User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
-I referred someone who made a team; am I guilty of FP contracts if I sign a player onto his team?


No. That's not in the spirit of this rule and would mean, at most, you got 50 FP. On the flip side, if you say "come to my team and I'll make sure you get X referrals as a payment" that's not allowed.

Originally posted by oldskool
-I can give someone FP as long as it's not contract-related:
Originally posted by norsemanvike

Q: Can I give flex points to players already on my team?
A: As long as it's not tied to a condition of any contract; new, re-negotiated, or otherwise.

...how is this determined? If I give someone $1 via paypal for making a game-winning field goal, am I already breaking the rule? If they use that $1 towards buying flex did I break the rule at that point? What if they use the flex on another player that's not on my team? Is it against the rules to establish a "$1 for best play of the game" award on my team, or is that outside the realm of "condition of any contract"?


I'm actually not 100% sure how that would be handled. If another Mod doesn't have an answer for this one, I'll have to propose it to the Admins and see how they would like it handled. That's a bit of a gray area to me.

Originally posted by oldskool
And now, to actual contractual questions:

-If they re-sign with my team at some point after I give them the $1 game-winning kick bonus, did I break the rule?


Same as the last one in my mind, I'm not sure and would have to ask.

Originally posted by oldskool
-What's the designated "acceptable time limit" between when I can give someone money/FP and when they can sign/re-sign with me without it being viewed as illegal? Is it OK if I pay someone now and he re-signs during the offseason? Is it OK if he re-signed two days ago and I paid him today?


I don't think we're going to put a hard cap on that, because that's just asking for people to wait till the moment after the cap and do so, claiming to be in the right because they were outside of the time window. It'll be handled on a case-by-case basis.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by Hans Hammer

WILL IT ALLOWED FOR TO GIVING FLEX POINTS FOR TO ASK HUMAN REJECT CONTRACTING OFFER?


If you mean, "I will give you 100FP if you dont sign with X team" the answer is no, that is not allowed. I don't think that it is a problem that needs addressed though.


Yea, not allowed, but that is kinda funny. I never even thought of someone pulling that. I'd be quite pissed if that happened to me and I was the owner who lost the player!
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by Hans Hammer
WILL IT ALLOWED FOR TO GIVING FLEX POINTS FOR TO ASK HUMAN REJECT CONTRACTING OFFER?


If you mean, "I will give you 100FP if you dont sign with X team" the answer is no, that is not allowed. I don't think that it is a problem that needs addressed though.

It might as well be addressed while you're making the rule

More Jed goodness:
Originally posted by Jed
I don't think we're going to put a hard cap on that, because that's just asking for people to wait till the moment after the cap and do so, claiming to be in the right because they were outside of the time window. It'll be handled on a case-by-case basis.

If there's no cap, how do you outlaw it? How would one determine on a case-by-case basis how long is "long enough"? What criteria could you possibly use to decide between "That guy gave him cash to get him to sign that contract" and "He gave him cash, but the contract signing was completely separate"?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
You really want to have a definition of the term case-by-case basis or do you not think case-by-case is how it should be handled?

Regardless, that is how it will work. We'll take any and all evidence in the case and make a decision. If needed, we'll bring in other Mods/Admins to help analyze the evidence to do so. But we're not going to assign a length of time to that, or we're going to leave loopholes open to pay people outside of that arbitrary window.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
You really want to have a definition of the term case-by-case basis or do you not think case-by-case is how it should be handled?

When the punishment is a seven day forum suspension followed by banning with "No warnings, no debates, no questions.", I think you need to be a little more specific than "Uh, we'll figure something out when it comes up!"

Originally posted by Jed
Regardless, that is how it will work. We'll take any and all evidence in the case and make a decision. If needed, we'll bring in other Mods/Admins to help analyze the evidence to do so. But we're not going to assign a length of time to that, or we're going to leave loopholes open to pay people outside of that arbitrary window.


You don't have to assign a length of time publicly, but...you sort of need guidelines to enforce the rule if you're going to allow "You can give cash as long as it's not contract-related" loopholes to be embedded in the rule. You're trying to stamp out loopholes in the loophole you're allowing!

My issue is not what you're trying to stop, it's that you're trying to stop it by threatening week-long suspensions and bannings on people for doing something you can't even define and have no guidelines for defining. When you get those kinks worked out I'll consider not being so vocal an opponent of it
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
I'm sorry to have to post on this... but it appears the only ones complaining about this rule are the ones that use this practice to recruit because they can't come up with a more effective way of recruiting... which is just sad. guys get over it, stop having such crappy recruiting tactics and get better ones.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crzyblue
I'm sorry to have to post on this... but it appears the only ones complaining about this rule are the ones that use this practice to recruit because they can't come up with a more effective way of recruiting... which is just sad. guys get over it, stop having such crappy recruiting tactics and get better ones.

Thanks for your classless, unwarranted, and unfounded accusation.

It'll undoubtedly serve me well, as it gives me a great post to point to the next time I have to make the "See why I don't want the general GLB public deciding people's banning fates?" argument.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
@ Jed (although it's a catch all reply). My remark about Mods exploiting the game goes back to things like gutting, stacking in low leagues, stat padding and all the other BS that has historically gone on - ie exploiting loopholes/bugs in the game before/instead of reporting them like a normal tester would do. This then was taken as acceptable behaviour by (amongst others) some of the main detracors on this thread (and any other thread where rules are concerned) and the big problem is, despite lots of warnings, nothing gets done. WE know it, THEY know it - and all the other exploiting turds think they can get away with it too.....because a precedent has been set!

And now you set out a SIMPLE rule (ie NO FLEX POINTS AS PART OF ANY NEW CONTRACT) and yet you're continually getting dragged into debate by the very people who are looking for ANY angle to exploit this rule - because they'll use any chink of contradiction in your replies as the go ahead to cheat.

Keep the rule simple and act on it. Oh - and make sure that the rule applies NO MATTER WHO YOU HAPPEN TO BE FRIENDS/TEAMMATES/GMS WITH!!
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
...you're continually getting dragged into debate by the very people who are looking for ANY angle to exploit this rule - because they'll use any chink of contradiction in your replies as the go ahead to cheat.

Oh good, another post for me to point to. Thanks.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
oldskool - all you EVER seem to do is try to justify exploits in the game - I mean, a cynic might see your continual whining as a round-the-houses admission that you'd made use of these exploits??

Otherwise - why do you feel the need to have to have everything spelled out to you??

Please read this slowly so as not to get confused - FLEX POINTS OFFERED OR REQUESTED AS PART OF ANY NEW CONTRACT NEGOTIATION IS AGAINST THE RULES. ANYONE CAUGHT DOING THIS WILL BE BANNED WITHOUT FURTHER WARNING.

Personally, I'd have just banned you for being a prick - but that's just me..........
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
oldskool - all you EVER seem to do is try to justify exploits in the game - I mean, a cynic might see your continual whining as a round-the-houses admission that you'd made use of these exploits??

Otherwise - why do you feel the need to have to have everything spelled out to you??

Please read this slowly so as not to get confused - FLEX POINTS OFFERED OR REQUESTED AS PART OF ANY NEW CONTRACT NEGOTIATION IS AGAINST THE RULES. ANYONE CAUGHT DOING THIS WILL BE BANNED WITHOUT FURTHER WARNING.

Personally, I'd have just banned you for being a prick - but that's just me..........


Originally posted by norsemanvike
Q: Can I give flex points to players already on my team?
A: As long as it's not tied to a condition of any contract; new, re-negotiated, or otherwise.

Heaven forbid we stamp out ambiguity in a rule with strict unquestionable punishments...or worse yet, have a discussion where one side isn't accused of abusing, cheating, or exploiting when the argument isn't going their way.

Oh, and it gets so much better, oldskool fans:
Originally posted by you and your inability to read
FLEX POINTS OFFERED OR REQUESTED AS PART OF ANY NEW CONTRACT NEGOTIATION IS AGAINST THE RULES. ANYONE CAUGHT DOING THIS WILL BE BANNED WITHOUT FURTHER WARNING.

Originally posted by The actual rule
2) Will warrant an immediate - 7 day - suspension of forum posting privileges. No warnings, no debates, no questions.
3) If such a contract is offered - and - accepted, both parties will be subject to suspension.


Bans are only for repeat offenders, and they will be given out with warning, i.e. the forum suspension for breaking the rule the first time.

Maybe next time you should be the one slowing down and having things spelled out for you, instead of just making wild "You disagree, you must be a cheater!" accusations that do nothing but clutter the thread, make you look foolish, and hurt your own "Ban the cheaters" cause by diluting the definition of cheating to the point where the general GLB public cannot be trusted.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
If they re-sign with my team at some point after I give them the $1 game-winning kick bonus, did I break the rule?


I wouldn't see an issue with that if the 1$ was handed out mid-season and he re-signed later in the season. If he resigned within a day or two, we've got reasonable cause and suspicion.

Originally posted by oldskool
What's the designated "acceptable time limit" between when I can give someone money/FP and when they can sign/re-sign with me without it being viewed as illegal?


No because there is no time limit. If we tie it to a contract requirement/condition at any point, you're busted.

Originally posted by oldskool
Is it OK if I pay someone now and he re-signs during the offseason?


No.

Originally posted by oldskool
Is it OK if he re-signed two days ago and I paid him today?


No.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 17:33:52
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Originally posted by oldskool

If they re-sign with my team at some point after I give them the $1 game-winning kick bonus, did I break the rule?


I wouldn't see an issue with that.

Originally posted by oldskool

Is it OK if I pay someone now and he re-signs during the offseason?


No.

Originally posted by oldskool

Is it OK if he re-signed two days ago and I paid him today?


No.


Conflict? If I'm paying for an on-field performance it's ok if he resigns, but not if he resigns before or after I pay him?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by joecabezuela
Originally posted by TuNice

Originally posted by joecabezuela


rules are rules......................obey them or leave.
everyone can say "What about this"...or..."What about that"

where will it stop?


So what are you my parents now? My way or the highway? This is the way you would like to run a so called business? If that was the case there would be no need for a suggestion forum. Next the rules will tell me how often I can purchase FPs. Or they'll tell me what I can and cannot do with them.... oh wait.



Yeah bro....Bort is gonna start telling you when to brush your teeth and take a bath too......you probably think "THE MAN" is behind all of this too...relax.



It's a Freemasons conspiracy that's what it is!
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by norsemanvike

Originally posted by oldskool


If they re-sign with my team at some point after I give them the $1 game-winning kick bonus, did I break the rule?


I wouldn't see an issue with that.

Originally posted by oldskool


Is it OK if I pay someone now and he re-signs during the offseason?


No.

Originally posted by oldskool


Is it OK if he re-signed two days ago and I paid him today?


No.


Conflict? If I'm paying for an on-field performance it's ok if he resigns, but not if he resigns before or after I pay him?


I clarified my earlier response as follows: "I wouldn't see an issue with that if the 1$ was handed out mid-season and he re-signed later in the season. If he resigned within a day or two, we've got reasonable cause and suspicion."

Again, you're reading way too far into this and it seems as if you're fishing for a way or a "loophole" for you engage or continue the practice, which leads me to believe that you are one of the offenders.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.