User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
...there should not be teams full of lvl. 23+ players in USA BBB.


Either way, we have good ideas. My proposal tackles the issue of friend teams. Yours might too. Here is an example. A group of friends owns 10 level 20 players. They all sign to a BBB level team.

Under my idea, they would have to fill out the rest of the roster with level 1's depending on the team level cap. The level cap would go up as team cultivated talent.

Your idea would work as well, allowing the 10 level 20's to sign. However, teams can take out loans to fill the rest of the roster with other high level players. GLB players for the most part are front runners. When they see the team has a good foundation of players, they will certainly want on board as well. Thus you open the door (via loan) the ability to stack a team regardless of fiances. The team dominates and attendance/demand will be high. High ticket prices can be charged. Team has an unfair advantage and the league suffers.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
I think they both accomplish mostly the same goal. My method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because the team will be restricted by its income. Your method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because of an average level cap.

Because there are minimum salary requirements, I think the system is already in place for this. We don't need level caps, we need more appropriate economic caps. Make it more like real life. Minor league teams don't make that much money. The money comes as you advance up the leagues. If you manage your team right, you advance and get more money to pay your current players as they level up and to get better players to compete in the new league. If you don't advance, it would be because you are a poor manager, and thus you will still be limited in funds to only be able to afford the type of players that are appropriate for the league that you are currently in.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
I think they both accomplish mostly the same goal. My method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because the team will be restricted by its income. Your method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because of an average level cap.

Because there are minimum salary requirements, I think the system is already in place for this. We don't need level caps, we need more appropriate economic caps. Make it more like real life. Minor league teams don't make that much money. The money comes as you advance up the leagues. If you manage your team right, you advance and get more money to pay your current players as they level up and to get better players to compete in the new league. If you don't advance, it would be because you are a poor manager, and thus you will still be limited in funds to only be able to afford the type of players that are appropriate for the league that you are currently in.


Two considerations:

1. Loans enable teams to quickly circumvent your proposed restrictions. Even if the teams make less money: A) Friend teams take minimum $$$ anyway. B) Loans allow a stacked team to get further stacked.

2. If a friend team is stuck in a low league because of poor builds/management, then eventually you method will require them to break up because the salaries will cost too much. The friend leagues then sour on GLB and quit.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by awesome

I think they both accomplish mostly the same goal. My method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because the team will be restricted by its income. Your method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because of an average level cap.

Because there are minimum salary requirements, I think the system is already in place for this. We don't need level caps, we need more appropriate economic caps. Make it more like real life. Minor league teams don't make that much money. The money comes as you advance up the leagues. If you manage your team right, you advance and get more money to pay your current players as they level up and to get better players to compete in the new league. If you don't advance, it would be because you are a poor manager, and thus you will still be limited in funds to only be able to afford the type of players that are appropriate for the league that you are currently in.


Two considerations:

1. Loans enable teams to quickly circumvent your proposed restrictions. Even if the teams make less money: A) Friend teams take minimum $$$ anyway. B) Loans allow a stacked team to get further stacked.

2. If a friend team is stuck in a low league because of poor builds/management, then eventually you method will require them to break up because the salaries will cost too much. The friend leagues then sour on GLB and quit.


1. I don't know anything about the loans. However, why not just do away with them? When a new owner acquires a team, give the new owner seed money.

2. That is the risk you run if you don't know how to manage a team. The salary levels should give them plenty of time to make it work, especially considering the high turnover of other owners in the higher league tiers. Lots of teams will get moved up as the gutted/abandoned teams are moved to the bottom. If you can't be successful enough to survive in this environment, it's time for someone else to have the team.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome

1. I don't know anything about the loans. However, why not just do away with them? When a new owner acquires a team, give the new owner seed money.

2. That is the risk you run if you don't know how to manage a team. The salary levels should give them plenty of time to make it work, especially considering the high turnover of other owners in the higher league tiers. Lots of teams will get moved up as the gutted/abandoned teams are moved to the bottom. If you can't be successful enough to survive in this environment, it's time for someone else to have the team.


Well, I think I now agree with you. If you give the new teams less money, it is virtually impossible to fill up the team with ringers.

Also, I believe you when you say that the new gutting rules will allow fresh, new, rookie teams into an already weak division.

So I guess what our suggestion boils down to is:

1. Do away with loans.
2. Start teams with less money.

Enact those with a "gutted teams relegated to lowest levels" rule and I think you might have a winner.
 
AAflyboys2
offline
Link
 
I think Teams shouldn't be sent to the bottom Rung until after the season is over. If they have a Winning Percentage Higher then say 40 percent they stay in the league there in the new owner could be trying to compete and may have brought in appropriate level players to help his new squad compete. If it's Between 30 and 40 they move down one leauge and the next best team in the lower division moves up. If the winning percentage dips below 30 send them to the bottom rung and move the next best team up from that rung. I/E one of the losers of the conference championship game. Also once/if one of these teams get's sent to the bottom rung, forgive all debts and make them start like a new expansion team basic starting stadium basic starting money. Then they would have to move out a majority there higher priced veterans. Sure they could keeps some but your not going to be able to afford a bunch of lvl 20 + players with starter money. So that should fix most of the higher level in lower league issue Allow them the offseason to get there finances straight and move guys/sell or trade players.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AAflyboys2
I think Teams shouldn't be sent to the bottom Rung until after the season is over. If they have a Winning Percentage Higher then say 40 percent they stay in the league there in the new owner could be trying to compete and may have brought in appropriate level players to help his new squad compete. If it's Between 30 and 40 they move down one leauge and the next best team in the lower division moves up. If the winning percentage dips below 30 send them to the bottom rung and move the next best team up from that rung. I/E one of the losers of the conference championship game. Also once/if one of these teams get's sent to the bottom rung, forgive all debts and make them start like a new expansion team basic starting stadium basic starting money. Then they would have to move out a majority there higher priced veterans. Sure they could keeps some but your not going to be able to afford a bunch of lvl 20 + players with starter money. So that should fix most of the higher level in lower league issue Allow them the offseason to get there finances straight and move guys/sell or trade players.


I don't agree with this. Why in the world would one brand new owner deserve to inherit a higher level team than another brand new owner? They both paid the same amount of cash. They should both get the same thing. All new teams should have to start at the bottom.
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 05:45:52
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome

I don't agree with this. Why in the world would one brand new owner deserve to inherit a higher level team than another brand new owner? They both paid the same amount of cash. They should both get the same thing. All new teams should have to start at the bottom.


I agree with awesome. If you don't make exceptions for anyone - then there is no problems with borderline cases. Resetting a team should be exactly that - reset to the bottom with no players, that way all owners start out from exactly the same circumstances.

 
AAflyboys2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by AAflyboys2

I think Teams shouldn't be sent to the bottom Rung until after the season is over. If they have a Winning Percentage Higher then say 40 percent they stay in the league there in the new owner could be trying to compete and may have brought in appropriate level players to help his new squad compete. If it's Between 30 and 40 they move down one leauge and the next best team in the lower division moves up. If the winning percentage dips below 30 send them to the bottom rung and move the next best team up from that rung. I/E one of the losers of the conference championship game. Also once/if one of these teams get's sent to the bottom rung, forgive all debts and make them start like a new expansion team basic starting stadium basic starting money. Then they would have to move out a majority there higher priced veterans. Sure they could keeps some but your not going to be able to afford a bunch of lvl 20 + players with starter money. So that should fix most of the higher level in lower league issue Allow them the offseason to get there finances straight and move guys/sell or trade players.


I don't agree with this. Why in the world would one brand new owner deserve to inherit a higher level team than another brand new owner? They both paid the same amount of cash. They should both get the same thing. All new teams should have to start at the bottom.


That is your opinon. There is no way completely fair way of doing it. And if you want all sold teams relagated and moved back down it have to be done at the end of the year. I woulnd't say any one deserves a leg up (but lives not fair), but you have to keep in mind the competivie balance aspect. Unless you want all teams sold during the year to cut all players and go to CPU rosters and move them down at then end of the season. It was just an idea.
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 05:58:44
 
AAflyboys2
offline
Link
 
You guys if we all buy established franchises like a Wendy's franchise. We are not going to all inherit the same thing. The franchise fee will be the same for all of us though. You might inherit great employee's with great management, I might inherit terrible employee's with terrible management. And if you want a sold team to fill out w/ all CPU's and be sent to the bottom rung at the end of the year your affecting competivie balance. Why not give the new owner at least a chance to compete in the league his team currently resides in. If you want a new team and not one you have to rebuild make one of the new leagues that doesn't exsist yet your preference.
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 06:13:55
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
I'm going to switch these around a bit:

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

This is bad, and should not happen automatically. New owners should have the chance to get people to stay or not.



5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

The new owner should get the chance to present themselves to the team and organise their own players/friends to come in. A team should never be disbanded. Imagine if the Bengals were sold to a new owner, they wouldn't fire the playing staff first (though with the Bengals.....)

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

Team sales should be allowed but gutting should not. Once an owner decides to sell the players should have a grace period in which to decide to stay or try to get a trade before & after the team is taken over.



4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

If a team is moved down to the bottom, this is an awkward problem however there hsould be enough grace period given that owners can buy the need players and the team relocated correctly at the end of that period. As in "Ok, you have a new team & 5 days (or whatever) to fix the roster at which point we'll take an average sounding and move your team down to a league with a corresponding level of difficulty"



1. Who moves up?

Ah! Pass! That's up for you to decide!


 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
My method would require the BBB team to fill out the roster with extremely low players because the team will be restricted by its income.


I don't know if this is similar to the discussion we had earlier, but I do agree with how this works at first, but again you can't continue to limit income for very long.
Example:
A NEW team starts out with limited cash and therefore can only sign limited players. Now after the first year they aren't very good, but players get better, same for the next year. Now I have a team of pretty good players in the third year and we are doing well (maybe well enough to win the conference, maybe we just miss it either way) now I am getting a pretty good payroll, if I can't earn more money then they can't keep a team and you really are nothing more than a minor league team for the big boys. I didn't buy a team to make good players for others.

Now if we are just talking about the start of a team I'm all for this, set it up so that guys in low level leagues can't make major upgrades until season 3 or something. Eventually though you are going to have BBB leagues with level 20+ players and there is no way around that. If you force new low level teams to have low level players they will be stuck in there with some teams that have grown there and will still be at a disadvantage.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bolo_76

I don't know if this is similar to the discussion we had earlier, but I do agree with how this works at first, but again you can't continue to limit income for very long.


Team level cap for new teams would allow that. Everyone must start on the same level, but you can raise your level cap by retaining players and not churning your roster. With this idea, you will never have to get rid of players due to their level, since you did all the hard work and raised them.

This idea works with the current monetary system.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
My first question is why are we giving new owners existing teams? They should have a clean slate start at the bottom with a completely new team. Basically at the end of a season where a owner is done... just end all contracts at the end of the year (with cpu owner) and have that team no longer exist. As well when the CPU takes over treat the team like the D leagues... player can stay to the end for XP or leave for another human team if they so choose.

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

Just have a system of choosing by stats and record of teams in lower leagues...

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

Just have a CPU owner and allow GM's (if any) to run out the team. Basically the team will be gone and players released at the end of the year (this is for the good of the league... some players might feel pissed...)

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

Bad to leave players out of a job... maybe make the team like a D league and people can stay for XP or leave by their own choice for a human team.

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

Build a strong team and get beyond level caps to be able to sign your own players... being an owner should be a "game" in itself in that you should be forced to start at the bottom and work your way up. Like most MMO's those that came before you have an advantage, but you can catch-up if your willing to put in the work.
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
1. Who moves up. - Its simple, whichever confrence it was from, the loser of the confrence championship.

2. Not allowing team sales mid-season. - I don't like the idea and I also dont like the idea of a GM taking over. Most likely if the team fell apart or was just plain lowsy it was the owners and the GMs fault. So giving temporary ownership isnt a good idea.

3. Allow teams to be sold whenever, keep them in the league until the season ends, but definately have some way that players can get out. Some people have 20 players, some people have 2. If your stuck on a team and you only have a player or two, your not happy. Who cares if there is a cup cake game for the rest of the season, most likely they wernt competitive all season, so its not much of an advantage for teams who havnt played the team yet. No temporary D-league, then your missing a team in a league, and you cant move up a team mid-season, that would not be fair.

4. Every new team that wasnt sold is a new team that has caps, so new owner who have high level players will just have to wait. There might be already, but if not, there should be a seperate waiting list for players who want teams that are sold and not a new team. This way they can bring whatever players they want.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.