User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin69
Originally posted by Dr. E

There are several of these threads now. Be nice if a Mod would combine them.


Yes I agree.


Maybe if everyone started there own thread someone will notice
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
bumping for season 18 whines
 
Smokey1913
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin.

Either promote the whole team to a cap where there highest level player is under OR
simply cut the player that is over the cap.


We give the owners selection to move up 2 or 3 cap levels, why not add this as a selectable option. They are notified which cap their team will be before day 40. Owners need to manage this and control their players.

When good men do nothing, evil triumphs (Edmund Burke).


Let's stop perpetuating the cycle and address this issue. More important than coaches IMO.

 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
bumping for season 18 whines


yeah that is the proper attitude for a mod to have

Originally posted by Smokey1913
We give the owners selection to move up 2 or 3 cap levels, why not add this as a selectable option. They are notified which cap their team will be before day 40. Owners need to manage this and control their players.

When good men do nothing, evil triumphs (Edmund Burke).


Let's stop perpetuating the cycle and address this issue. More important than coaches IMO.



What you mean make the owners and agents work together to make sure things work out properly.. if not they have to suffer consequences.. what a novel idea.
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
+1 to level caps being hard-enforced.

The suggestions I've seen for changing the basic advancement system, however, seem short sighted to me.

Changing the way new level caps are assigned is more complex than just moving a team to the best cap for their players. People tend to think of it like Admin has a bottomless bag of teams they can just reach into for assigning advancements, but that's not the case. If it was treated this way, it would mean the addition of a lot more computer teams to make sure everyone has a place to go, since you can't predict in advance which cap will be best for a team in the next season.

The only way "team roster specific" advancement could happen without making 1/3 of the teams CPU is with someone manually setting down and figuring it out. There are too many teams, however, for advancement to be processed "by hand" without the use of heavy automation. With a set number of teams in a set number of leagues, the computer needs to know that for each team moved out of a league, another team is ready to move in and take its place, in a formulaic way.

The advancement system definitely needs to be rethought and improved, but there's not going to be any simple way of doing it effectively.

Edited by charwh on Sep 9, 2010 16:08:21
Edited by charwh on Sep 9, 2010 16:07:33
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
Originally posted by Chysil

bumping for season 18 whines


yeah that is the proper attitude for a mod to have


Ya... I supported the thread in the previous pages. I had to bump it, so I thought I'd do a little ripping on myself and the others in this thread. It was really pretty mild in my opinion
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
I think the most practical solution may be to give enough advantage to incumbent teams that buying a new team at an appropriate cap, if you've been advanced higher than you can compete, isn't considered an unfair advantage.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
IMHO the only fix that is still needed is some sort of "safety valve" to insure teams don't promote so fast they end up in leagues with dots simply too high to defeat. It's been my experience that is about 80 effective points, I think that is about 7 or so levels. You would have to scale back the levels the lower you go of course, but effective levels would work no matter the league level.
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
IMHO the only fix that is still needed is some sort of "safety valve" to insure teams don't promote so fast they end up in leagues with dots simply too high to defeat. It's been my experience that is about 80 effective points, I think that is about 7 or so levels. You would have to scale back the levels the lower you go of course, but effective levels would work no matter the league level.


Under the current system, really, only about 1 out of 8 teams should end up in this boat. Others may get into inconvenient situations, but I don't think anybody should expect their team to be a likely championship contender every season.

My team is likely to end up one of those 1 out of 8, however, but I'm willing to give Admin the benefit of the doubt that they will deal with those minorities on a case by case basis, when the problem happens.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
To be honest....there needs to a be REASON teams AND players want to struggle to go 8-8 instead of go 16-0 in a lesser league. Either a punishment for being too good in a bad league, or a nice reward for struggling in a good league.

You can come up with systems all you want, but the first solution is to make sure that 99% of the teams out there WANT to be in the highest possible league.

That's the first solution to this problem.

I would say you could do a few things to solve the problem....These are just wild ideas off the top of my head and not necessarily good ideas...just to get out the type of things I'm thinking about

* Make fame worth something. Not sure about this one.

* Restrict EQ upgrades and/or AEQ in leagues. Elite 2+ AEQ. Competitive 1 AEQ. Normal 0 AEQ

* Restrict stadium upgrades. Elite unlimited upgrades. Competitive 2-3 sections/season. Normal 1 section/season.

* Perhaps you could tie any of the above to a team having an effective level much higher than the leagues average? exempting elite leagues of course.

* Elite leagues get more endorsements, normal get less.

* Elite teams get more players that can have endorsements per game, normal teams get less

What I'm getting at is right now players and teams have no reason to want to play with the best competition, other than the World League.
Edited by PackMan97 on Sep 10, 2010 10:52:52
Edited by PackMan97 on Sep 10, 2010 10:47:46
 
Link
 
I would love to hear the intelligent reason on this team then. Undefeated last season and only jumped 1 cap and is basically over the league cap.


Sep 9, 2010 13:18:04
ReportLinkQuote

How can this team be in a capped 26 league??? Kinda makes playing the whole season useless...thanks again!!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=6530
OC for Moai Droogs
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Morbid Da Clown
I would love to hear the intelligent reason on this team then. Undefeated last season and only jumped 1 cap and is basically over the league cap.


Sep 9, 2010 13:18:04
ReportLinkQuote

How can this team be in a capped 26 league??? Kinda makes playing the whole season useless...thanks again!!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=6530
OC for Moai Droogs


They got bumped 2 caps. They must have been over cap in the 18 league.

Edited by charwh on Sep 10, 2010 11:27:33
 
Link
 
they should have gone 3 caps then. they have more players over cap then they do under. At those levels thats a pretty much guaranteed championship season even with mediocre GM's (not saying there mediocre) if they boost.

I'm not blaming the team, I'm blaming the lvl cap system
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Morbid Da Clown
they should have gone 3 caps then. they have more players over cap then they do under. At those levels thats a pretty much guaranteed championship season even with mediocre GM's (not saying there mediocre) if they boost.

I'm not blaming the team, I'm blaming the lvl cap system


I took a look, they aren't the highest leveled team in the conference, there are several higher. There are also a couple others just one level lower and..........they went from competitive to Elite. That last is the big jump. The only issue I saw was the poor teams in that conference that are averaging lvl 23, but then they might of asked for a demotion or promoted 3 times.
 
Brewster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
IMHO the only fix that is still needed is some sort of "safety valve" to insure teams don't promote so fast they end up in leagues with dots simply too high to defeat. It's been my experience that is about 80 effective points, I think that is about 7 or so levels. You would have to scale back the levels the lower you go of course, but effective levels would work no matter the league level.


Plus one

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.