User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by aerophil
Beachsand is worried because although he's got an awesome team, he just had not only 4 of the teams that finished ahead of him last season but also a bunch of really good teams from the opposite side of the league all get squashed into one conference leaving them 14th overall in rating in the conference. Effective level underrates them but he may still end up a 7 or 8 seed (again) without the benefit of a home promo in the playoffs leading to a quick exit and no chance of going Pro whereas his team has the talent to get to the championship game if they'd been placed in the other conference in our own league.


I just want all the leagues to be equal.............and to have an equal chance of making to the pros......


There really should be no easy way to get directly to the Pros......
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD
Originally posted by aerophil

Beachsand is worried because although he's got an awesome team, he just had not only 4 of the teams that finished ahead of him last season but also a bunch of really good teams from the opposite side of the league all get squashed into one conference leaving them 14th overall in rating in the conference. Effective level underrates them but he may still end up a 7 or 8 seed (again) without the benefit of a home promo in the playoffs leading to a quick exit and no chance of going Pro whereas his team has the talent to get to the championship game if they'd been placed in the other conference in our own league.


I just want all the leagues to be equal.............and to have an equal chance of making to the pros......


There really should be no easy way to get directly to the Pros......


This. And even more importantly the best of the AAA leagues should end up in Pro so that we end up with top competition up there. Promoting a team that isn't ready for the Pros is damaging to the other teams in the Pro league and the team sent up who end up harshly over matched and end up back down just one season later.
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Just do the tournament World Cup style for AAA...

Top 8 teams from each conference go to the top Championship Tournament. #1 seeds play #8 seeds (and so forth) in the first round but from different leagues (AAA1 #1 seed plays AAA4 #8 seed for example). There would be a cutoff point in this elimination tournament where all teams would promote. Basically, it would allow the strongest AAA teams to promote (there might be a AAA league where no teams promote),

You could even do this for 8 teams from each conference that dont make the playoffs (Toilet Bowl). Only difference is they are playing to stay in AAA. There would be the potential for a AAA league to not have an demotions.

It would certainly increase the parity across the AAA league much quicker than anything else.


Best idea so far. It could be quick, and would tell us (outside of RNG type stuff) which AAA teams are ready to move up.

Forget the AAA playoffs, and put the top 16 teams from each of the 11 AAA leagues in a single elimination tournament as described above. It would take 7-8 days, depending on the scheduling, and could be done easily. Games every day that matter for those who want to advance, and then just drop the losers in a scrimmage system like is done for the playoffs now.

 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nthomas
Best idea so far. It could be quick, and would tell us (outside of RNG type stuff) which AAA teams are ready to move up.

Forget the AAA playoffs, and put the top 16 teams from each of the 11 AAA leagues in a single elimination tournament as described above. It would take 7-8 days, depending on the scheduling, and could be done easily. Games every day that matter for those who want to advance, and then just drop the losers in a scrimmage system like is done for the playoffs now.



Sounds fun. However, Catch said the solution would be simple, so I doubt this gets done, at least not this season.
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
This is very simple.

176 team single elimination tournament, with games every day, will take 8 days to complete. Free bracket makers available online means it would be set up within an hour.

Instead of each AAA league playing a playoff bracket, the entire AAA league plays in one, with the final seeds being the teams who advance.

Seems pretty simple to me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nthomas
This is very simple.

176 team single elimination tournament, with games every day, will take 8 days to complete. Free bracket makers available online means it would be set up within an hour.

Instead of each AAA league playing a playoff bracket, the entire AAA league plays in one, with the final seeds being the teams who advance.

Seems pretty simple to me.


What sounds simple to us is not always easy to Bort & Co.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
At least 32 Pro slots per season plus any demotions and sell backs.

After first round, you would have 88 teams. After the second round, you would have 44 teams. Thus if there are 12 sellback/demotions, then all a team would need to do to go pro is to be top 8 and win two games in a row? With the randomness of the sim, that hardly seems like it would ensure the best teams go. What if 13 teams sellback/demote? How do you pick which of the 44 teams that only won their first round game should get in?
Edited by Plankton on Jul 15, 2010 10:28:42
Edited by Plankton on Jul 15, 2010 10:24:13
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
How do you pick which of the 44 teams that only won their first round game should get in?

I figure seeding would be the biggest problem with this idea. Gonna be hard to come up with a method everyone agrees on.

*And if you do come up with a method of seeding teams, why not use that same method for promotion?

Edited by MeauxJeaux on Jul 15, 2010 11:21:42
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
And here I thought the new league structure was well thought out, since my concerns regarding this very topic, before it was implemented were ignored.

I'd link to it, but it seems the thread was moved.

P.S. tourney is exploitable teams that wanted to stay in AAA could easily do so, while pushing teams not quite ready yet up.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
And here I thought the new league structure was well thought out, since my concerns regarding this very topic, before it was implemented were ignored.

I'd link to it, but it seems the thread was moved.

P.S. tourney is exploitable teams that wanted to stay in AAA could easily do so, while pushing teams not quite ready yet up.


Good point....

I say we play the season and the champs automatically get in. Then Catch and/or a committee choose the rest of the AAA teams for promotion. Case closed.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC

And here I thought the new league structure was well thought out, since my concerns regarding this very topic, before it was implemented were ignored.

I'd link to it, but it seems the thread was moved.

P.S. tourney is exploitable teams that wanted to stay in AAA could easily do so, while pushing teams not quite ready yet up.


Good point....

I say we play the season and the champs automatically get in. Then Catch and/or a committee choose the rest of the AAA teams for promotion. Case closed.


It would be case closed if someone was actually willing to do that, but they won't.
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
lolAAA tbh
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
lol Casual Pro
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
lolAAA tbh


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1276247
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Didn't read the whole thread but I did read the OP in full.

This is the polar opposite of the "there needs to be league parity within the leagues" complaint, and that is why everything is complicated. On the one hand, people wanted coherent rivalries and competitive balance within the tiers, and on the other hand people want the best teams in AAA to promote to pro. Should AAA be dominated by the best teams across the board or should each AAA have it's own competitive balance? If you go to some non-standard promotion technique then you invalidate the regular season and playoffs of the AAA leagues - who cares if you won AAA if it has no bearing on anything? People will only try in the tournament or whatever and the playoffs become meaningless lolplayoffs. Why even have them then?

There aren't easy answers to this and at the end of the day compromises are going to end up being made and some group or another WILL be unhappy with the outcome.

Personally, I think making an Elite AAA and adding some preferred promotion to that league into pro after all the conference champs of AAA are promoted might be one of the better solutions. I'd have to review the league promotion rules but I suspect that if there is a way to tank games to try to "fast track" your team to the Pros by ending up in a weaker AAA in that system, it's probably a fine line to walk to avoid spending extra seasons in the minors just getting to the weaker AAA in the first place.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.