User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > Ask Catch > Questions and Answers about the new changes
Page:
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula


I agree with j10er, and if the math is right (I haven't done it myself) there are two extreme approaches:
1) Rounded build with 2 AEQs. Using multiple training late in the career to help the minor.
2) Extreme build with 4 AEQs, very high majors and a bit low minors.

And there likely a spectrum of options in between


Now that catch just updated the BT values again, you can do 4 AEQ if you train on primary normal(= old normal train + 2 BT) as you'll get 100+BT/season which will get you 4 pieces.

However, the multiple training is also improved so you will be giving up a lot of training to get there. All multiple training will only get you one AE though.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
it's hard to find an exact balance. Basically it's going to come down to players choosing whether they want higher base values through training or if they want the AEQ. It's their choice. With the removal of AEQ stacking I don't see it as being a huge issue if a player wants to sacrifice max training gains to get AEQ.

 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
If your desired build includes a few SAs really high, probably worth 4AEQ and lower training...

Taking an SA to 4 instead of 10 saves you 23 SP for each one. That 23 SP (each AEQ) would probably more than make up for the stats not trained as much.
Edited by Zoblefu on Apr 20, 2010 13:05:47
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
yea but see the problem (and I was playing around with this earlier just to see if the numbers worked) if I went:

Intense 0 BT
Normal 1 BT
Light 2 BT

2 Attrib +1 BT
3 Attrib +2 BT
4 Attrib +3 BT

Then we're actually only creating one option that has an actual BT gain over the current system (Light) and everything requires BT's now - we have to make BT's easier to earn then in the past.

Maybe the better thing is to say there is a limit of three pieces of AEQ that a player can equip at any one time? This would force balance a bit.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
I can't imagine too many people would cry at only being able to use 3 AEQ, since that's pretty much the reasonable limit now.

I thought it was 1/2/3 not 0/1/2 BTs for 1 attribute training?
 
sbjnyc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
it's hard to find an exact balance. Basically it's going to come down to players choosing whether they want higher base values through training or if they want the AEQ. It's their choice. With the removal of AEQ stacking I don't see it as being a huge issue if a player wants to sacrifice max training gains to get AEQ.


I assume by AEQ stacking you still mean just the +% part and not SAs. Because this allows a player to take 2 major SAs to 10 for no SP. And adding in the attribute bonus you are talking about maybe up to or over 150 SPs saved, which probably trumps the lost training.

Edited by sbjnyc on Apr 20, 2010 13:18:30
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
I can't imagine too many people would cry at only being able to use 3 AEQ, since that's pretty much the reasonable limit now.

I thought it was 1/2/3 not 0/1/2 BTs for 1 attribute training?


It is - I was trying to show an alternative idea I was looking at. Didn't really work.
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22


Maybe the better thing is to say there is a limit of three pieces of AEQ that a player can equip at any one time? This would force balance a bit.


tbh, I don't think 4 is necessarily going to be overpowered if you're giving up a lot of training benefit but I haven't run the nums.

I'd say to test it, build a player who does normal train every day and one who does the 4 attributes at level 5 for the mega stacked training and see how they compare.

My guess is the stacked training will probably get you the 3 better points in your main attributes that you would get from the AE (since you can cap earlier) and you'll have more SP available to buy SAs (because the stack means it's easier to train things to 40 before capping instead of 35).

It may still be that 4 is overpowered, but it wouldn't shock me if 4 is underpowered vs. stacked training either because of what you're giving up in the core build.

Let's at least run the nums before deciding, imo.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
well that's what we'll do obviously - if it turns out it's too easy to get 4 pieces of AEQ and making it OP, then we'll put a limitation at 3.

Definitely on my testing list though.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lucky_eagle_13
i know jp already asked about the training combinations a bit but what does each upgrade allow you to do? does it allow you to just add more things to train at once or just for more effective training?


need some clarity on this for players if it isn't the same as coaches.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
not sure exactly what your question is?

If it's what does training more than one attribute do - the answer is it allows you to train multiple attributes at once (thus giving them both gains) and it provides a training bonus depending on how many attributes you are training.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
well that's what we'll do obviously - if it turns out it's too easy to get 4 pieces of AEQ and making it OP, then we'll put a limitation at 3.

Definitely on my testing list though.


What BT cost is in selling AEQ ? If you cannot really use AEQ as a BT bank that will likely make the 4 AEQ a not too strong option.

You can 'fight' 4 AEQ builds by making it hard to get 4 good ones at Lv 30. That will give people to options:
- Settle for mediocre AEQs
- Pay high BT cost for getting good AEQs (and as a result more training cost).

Definitely this is a calculation that can be done today.

 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
1. My player has 1 piece of equipment for each body part upgraded fully. I go in and buy another piece for each body part and don't upgrade at all. Will those pieces be upgraded fully or only 2 levels?

2. When will we be able to see the average salaries for positions?
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Hmm... when did the changes occur?

It's no longer possible to frontload Intense training and still get 4 AEQ. Well, it is, but you seriously gimp your Season 4-5 training, which still matters.

Looks like the changes balanced this out nicely. Back to the drawing board to see what is the optimal number of AEQ
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
well that's what we'll do obviously - if it turns out it's too easy to get 4 pieces of AEQ and making it OP, then we'll put a limitation at 3.

Definitely on my testing list though.


it's easy to get 4 AE. The issue is whether that's overpowered vs. stacked training.

My first run says the stacked training build should be based on using a lot of lvl 2 & 3 effective training in a 4 way train rather than 1 lvl 5 and the rest lvl 1. The sweet spot seems to be going to level 2 or 3 from what I've done so far (compounding of several 20-30% bonuses > one 50% bonus and 10% bonuses).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.