User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make weight not such a gigantic factor in realized speed
Page:
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
No clue what you could mean by this. Speed is obviously locked at a set value until the ball is kicked.

These results don't seem perfectly logical because there are a number of factors out of our control, like I have mentioned numerous times.

This is also why I didn't engage you on your example: claiming you know there is a 2% difference between those two FBs, with a speed script that isn't even that granular, on seperate seasons, with a shitload of other factors that we can't account for, is silly. You can say there is a 2% difference +/- 5%, that would make much more sense.


No, the speed isn't locked at a set value... if anything there is a max speed limit, but as we're talking about 25 speed dots, I doubt it matters.

No. Logic would dictate that there is something going on behind the scenes... like the weight scale not being linear/static. I.E. a 30lb difference is not the same when you're talking about a 185lb player vs a 215lb player, as opposed to a 280lb player vs a 310lb player.

As for my FB example, it's data. I didn't say that I know it's 2%, I said that is what the data was telling me... big difference.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
pics or it didn't happen


http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y193/Darkzen2484/Random%20stuff/CBs.jpg?t=1265429083
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

No, the speed isn't locked at a set value... if anything there is a max speed limit, but as we're talking about 25 speed dots, I doubt it matters.


Are we watching the same replays? Anyone else wanna chime in here?

Originally posted by Warlock
No. Logic would dictate that there is something going on behind the scenes... like the weight scale not being linear/static. I.E. a 30lb difference is not the same when you're talking about a 185lb player vs a 215lb player, as opposed to a 280lb player vs a 310lb player.


No fucking shit. There is loads of stuff going on behind the scenes that we can't know. I highly doubt the formula is linear.

Originally posted by Warlock
As for my FB example, it's data. I didn't say that I know it's 2%, I said that is what the data was telling me... big difference.


The data wasn't telling you the difference was 2%, the data was telling you it was 2% plus or minus 5%. There is a big difference.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
The data wasn't telling you the difference was 2%, the data was telling you it was 2% plus or minus 5%. There is a big difference.


No, it would be more like between 1% and 25%, based on the data between the TE and CBs. The data from the FBs was showing ~2%.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by w_alloy

pics or it didn't happen


http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y193/Darkzen2484/Random%20stuff/CBs.jpg?t=1265429083


Need to see more of the field so we can tell which players these are and where they are on the field...
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Need to see more of the field so we can tell which players these are and where they are on the field...


I zoomed in close so you could see the ruler on the side, showing 4 pixels difference, it's the two CBs... if you didn't fail at photoshop, you wouldn't need me to post pics drawing you a fucking map.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by w_alloy

Need to see more of the field so we can tell which players these are and where they are on the field...


I zoomed in close so you could see the ruler on the side, showing 4 pixels difference, it's the two CBs... if you didn't fail at photoshop, you wouldn't need me to post pics drawing you a fucking map.


And now you are trolling...

This is why I did not engage you earlier in this thread. You are not worth my time.
Edited by w_alloy on Feb 5, 2010 21:24:32
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
And now you are trolling...

This is why I did not engage you earlier in this thread. You are not worth my time.


So I'm trolling because you asked for a pic and when I presented it, you started asking for more pics to prove the validity of the first pic... all of which could have been easily avoided, if you understood how to measure pixels in the first place.

I've proven you wrong numerous times in this thread, sorry if I ran out of patience explaining elementary concepts to you, but that's not trolling. I'm not jumping thru hoops for you, if you want to talk intelligently on a subject be well versed in it IMHO... you brought up pixels and measuring, but it's pretty obvious you're not well versed in the subject. I'm a novice with photoshop, I only use it to make textures and orthographic reference images for Maya, so I'm no master with it.
Edited by Warlock on Feb 5, 2010 21:42:35
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
You guys might have more luck with the page source rather than the graphics. You can compare everybody at the time when the ball and the kicker are last in the same position, to where everybody is at the time when the ball and the kick returner are first in the same position.

It is kind of wonky though because some guys are closer to max speed than others at kickoff.
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 5, 2010 21:40:11
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
You guys might have more luck with the page source rather than the graphics. You can compare everybody at the time when the ball and the kicker are last in the same position, to where everybody is at the time when the ball and the kick returner are first in the same position.

It is kind of wonky though because some guys are closer to max speed than others at kickoff.


Sounds like a fun Friday night...
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
The issue was not counting the pixels, which I would hope any 3rd grader could do as long as they know how to zoom in on a picture. The issue is that your pic obviously came at a different time in the play than my pic, which is the only reason I wanted you to post the thing in the first place. In fact it's clear from your picture that the CBs are on the left side of the field, which means that you are actually talking about the wrong play. I measured the difference at 2 pixels in the first kickoff, so congrats on arguing for my side.

And lol at thinking that you have "proven [me] wrong numerous times in this thread". You are seriously deluded.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
The issue was not counting the pixels, which I would hope any 3rd grader could do as long as they know how to zoom in on a picture. The issue is that your pic obviously came at a different time in the play than my pic, which is the only reason I wanted you to post the thing in the first place. In fact it's clear from your picture that the CBs are on the left side of the field, which means that you are actually talking about the wrong play. I measured the difference at 2 pixels in the first kickoff, so congrats on arguing for my side.

And lol at thinking that you have "proven [me] wrong numerous times in this thread". You are seriously deluded.


Dude, do you have any critical thinking ability what-so-ever? I said earlier that I did my calculations from the 20 to the 45, which is pretty much the point right before the players start to change directions (i.e. stop running in a straight line to chase after the ball-carrier). The larger white line in that frame is the 45 yard line, IIRC it's lined up with the trailing max weight SS.

Also, if counting pixels is something a 3rd grader can do... why do you fail at it? I seem to distinctly remember you giving the wrong number of pixels for 5 yards and it throwing off all of your other calculations.

As for proving you wrong...

A) players DO NOT move at the same speed before the ball is actually kicked.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1003248&pbp_id=2294390 notice how these players aren't ducks in a row as they run up field, before the ball is kicked.

B) You even admitted this one... the difference from player weight is not gigantic.

Originally posted by w_alloy
...Maybe calling it enourmous is a stretch, but that's a big difference...


Shall I continue pointing out where you've been wrong?

C) It's not 47 pixels for 5 yards and thus all data based on that number is wrong.

D) Being wrong about not being wrong.

E) This for obvious reasons...

Originally posted by w_alloy
The data wasn't telling you the difference was 2%, the data was telling you it was 2% plus or minus 5%. There is a big difference.


Etc...
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
I am going to crush all your arguments and then put you permanently on ignore with greasemonkey. You can have the last remarks and anyone reading this can decide for themselves.

I consider it a pretty huge fail on my part that I got into this with you in the first place. I would like to apologize to everyone reading this for how asinine this has gotten.

Originally posted by Warlock

A) players DO NOT move at the same speed before the ball is actually kicked.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1003248&pbp_id=2294390 notice how these players aren't ducks in a row as they run up field, before the ball is kicked.


That replay was not from this game.

I can prove I am right on this with the page source. Here is the link to the replay: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1010199&pbp_id=2411133

Below is the code for the tick before the ball is kicked. Notice the Z coordinate of the ball is 1. The player IDs of all the test players are 19595XX, The thing to look at here is the Y coordinate of each of these players. As you can see they are all at either 114.25 or 106.25.

[{id: 'ball',x: 80,y: 120,z: 1},{id: '1807783',x: 80,y: 330},{id: '1825567',x: 70,y: 268.5},{id: '1825571',x: 80,y: 268.5},{id: '1825573',x: 90,y: 268},{id: '1825555',x: 80,y: 189.75},{id: '1825515',x: 65,y: 189.75},{id: '1825564',x: 95,y: 194.5},{id: '1849438',x: 35,y: 166.25},{id: '1825576',x: 125,y: 195},{id: '1777780',x: 20,y: 186},{id: '1840331',x: 140,y: 165.5},{id: '1915222',x: 80,y: 120},{id: '1950521',x: 95,y: 106.25},{id: '1950524',x: 65,y: 114.25},{id: '1950539',x: 110,y: 106.25},{id: '1950530',x: 50,y: 114.25},{id: '1950536',x: 125,y: 106.25},{id: '1950531',x: 35,y: 114.25},{id: '1950510',x: 140,y: 106.25},{id: '1950515',x: 20,y: 114.25},{id: '1950504',x: 155,y: 106.25},{id: '1950517',x: 5,y: 114.25}]

Here is the next tick. Notice the Z coordinate of the ball is now rising. The players are still split into two groups.

[{id: 'ball',x: 79.75,y: 124.25,z: 7.5},{id: '1807783',x: 80,y: 329.75},{id: '1825567',x: 70,y: 267.75},{id: '1825571',x: 80,y: 267.75},{id: '1825573',x: 90,y: 267},{id: '1825555',x: 80,y: 192},{id: '1825515',x: 65,y: 192},{id: '1825564',x: 95,y: 196.75},{id: '1849438',x: 35,y: 167.25},{id: '1825576',x: 125,y: 197.25},{id: '1777780',x: 20,y: 187.75},{id: '1840331',x: 140,y: 166.5},{id: '1915222',x: 80,y: 121},{id: '1950521',x: 95,y: 107.5},{id: '1950524',x: 65,y: 115.75},{id: '1950539',x: 110,y: 107.5},{id: '1950530',x: 50,y: 115.75},{id: '1950536',x: 125,y: 107.5},{id: '1950531',x: 35,y: 115.75},{id: '1950510',x: 140,y: 107.5},{id: '1950515',x: 20,y: 115.75},{id: '1950504',x: 155,y: 107.5},{id: '1950517',x: 5,y: 115.75}]

They start to spread out on the next tick:

[{id: 'ball',x: 79.75,y: 128.5,z: 13.5},{id: '1807783',x: 80,y: 329.5},{id: '1825567',x: 70,y: 266.75},{id: '1825571',x: 80,y: 266.75},{id: '1825573',x: 90,y: 265.75},{id: '1825555',x: 80,y: 194.25},{id: '1825515',x: 65,y: 194.25},{id: '1825564',x: 95,y: 199},{id: '1849438',x: 35,y: 168.5},{id: '1825576',x: 125,y: 199.5},{id: '1777780',x: 20,y: 189.75},{id: '1840331',x: 140,y: 167.5},{id: '1915222',x: 80,y: 122},{id: '1950521',x: 95,y: 109},{id: '1950524',x: 65,y: 117.25},{id: '1950539',x: 110,y: 109},{id: '1950530',x: 50,y: 117.25},{id: '1950536',x: 125,y: 108.75},{id: '1950531',x: 35,y: 117.25},{id: '1950510',x: 140,y: 109},{id: '1950515',x: 20,y: 117.25},{id: '1950504',x: 155,y: 108.5},{id: '1950517',x: 5,y: 117.25}]

Originally posted by Warlock

B) You even admitted this one... the difference from player weight is not gigantic.

Originally posted by w_alloy

...Maybe calling it enourmous is a stretch, but that's a big difference...


Can it be gigantic and not enormous? You can never "prove" someone is wrong on a subjective semantics issue. The point is it's too big. Maybe I used some hyperbole, but I honestly think there is a case to be made for it being "gigantic", especially relative to what it should be.

Originally posted by Warlock

C) It's not 47 pixels for 5 yards and thus all data based on that number is wrong.


You gave a 5 pixel spread when you said what it was. I counted the same 5 yard stretch twice and came up with 47 both times (I was using paint with 8X zoom, I don't have photoshop on this laptop). Still, this number seemed weird, and I thought that maybe some fields or some 5 yard stretches are different, so admitted I wasn't totally sure about it. You can't "prove me wrong" when I say that I am just relating a measurement I took and I'm not 100% confident in it.

Here is the field that is default for me on this play: http://goallineblitz.com/images/game/fields/grass_baseball.jpg . It is 1160 pixels long and looks like it shows 3-4 yards extra after each endzone. 1160/126= 9.2, 1160/128=9.1, both much closer to my number than yours.

In this test, weight still averaged more than a 5% difference using your biggest pixel number anyways.

Booya.

Originally posted by Warlock

D) Being wrong about not being wrong.


See above.

Originally posted by Warlock

E) This for obvious reasons...

Originally posted by w_alloy

The data wasn't telling you the difference was 2%, the data was telling you it was 2% plus or minus 5%. There is a big difference.


Obvious reasons, huh? I said this to point out your fail when you kept asking an explanation and acting like your "data" disproved my OP.

You asked for an explanation, and I gave it to you. Even if we ignore the fact that the replays are over 40 days apart and from different seasons, and the fact that you are a self-admitted troll, how about the fact that there is a big margin for error. The measured weight-speed difference can vary position by position and player by player, and also the speed script isn't nearly accurate to exact percents because of the granularity of the coordinate and tick systems. All things this recent test has proven.



You are going up against the owner, OC, and DC of what is widely considered the best team in this game, and claiming I have no critical thinking ability when it comes to said game. It's a tough sell.

I will enjoy having your posts purged from the forum and having no further contact with you. I genuinely hope that you enjoy the rest of your life.
Edited by w_alloy on Feb 6, 2010 04:03:27
 
Link
 
makes sense....
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
I am going to crush all your arguments and then put you permanently on ignore with greasemonkey. You can have the last remarks and anyone reading this can decide for themselves.

I consider it a pretty huge fail on my part that I got into this with you in the first place. I would like to apologize to everyone reading this for how asinine this has gotten.


I love how people like to "take their ball and go home", once they lose. I would smash your feeble counter-argument, but why bother if you put me on ignore.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.