User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > More clarification from Bort re: Promotions
Page:
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4favre
to help the mess of cap 14 they should just add another cap which is level 1 cap and then it goes to 14 automatically the next season.

This would eliminate all the requests for teams to stay in cap 14 and it would make cap 14 a little more competitive. There are way too many cap 14 teams made up of level 1 players.


+1
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
So....

Cap 14 conference winner with completely empty roster will be denied demotion request back to 14?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5847

Will the team land in cap 18 then?

Or would this constitute and "exception"?

 
TerryDK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
you do realize this whole thing was over level 1 teams making the playoffs because they beat a bunch of CPU teams right?


It does show how diluted everything is when a CPU team makes the playoffs!
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4favre
to help the mess of cap 14 they should just add another cap which is level 1 cap and then it goes to 14 automatically the next season.

This would eliminate all the requests for teams to stay in cap 14 and it would make cap 14 a little more competitive. There are way too many cap 14 teams made up of level 1 players.


+1
 
kyxoan
offline
Link
 
that is exactly why I want a demotion, I don't plan on demoting again in the future, but I just started out as a team of all level 1 players (all 11 now and not boosting) and I want to stay in cap 14, after that I will take promotions as they come.
 
vinman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
I would like some clarifications from Catch

the current confusion is over level 38 trophy winners, level 42 playoff teams and all level 46 teams

1. Are uncapped minors going away like promised?

2. Does every team have to play in the level 46-capped leagues for a season before moving to AA?
2a. When a level 42 team makes the playoffs and finishes the season with players over level 46, does it still go to level 46 even though it is in violation of the rule where a playoff team can only promote 1 level if they have no one over the new cap?


Good questions
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4favre
to help the mess of cap 14 they should just add another cap which is level 1 cap and then it goes to 14 automatically the next season.

This would eliminate all the requests for teams to stay in cap 14 and it would make cap 14 a little more competitive. There are way too many cap 14 teams made up of level 1 players.


this, omg, this.

Cut out half of the ass pain.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
So....

Cap 14 conference winner with completely empty roster will be denied demotion request back to 14?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5847

Will the team land in cap 18 then?

Or would this constitute and "exception"?



same with http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5627

We won with like half a CPU roster, but still.
 
Mindor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
Originally posted by Mindor

I hate this rule,I have 1 player on my team lvl 30 the rest are all 26-28 and because we went to the championship game this season we have to get bumped up to cap 34?When the reality of it is we should only be cap 30.

Explain to me why you cant have it so that the highest lvl player on the team, come promotion time, determines where you will be?


You have jizz-enducingly awesome players coming in, you'll be fine. Honestly we'll be in the upper half of the playoff race next season. Four levels is nothing with builds and gameplanning ability which you already know your team a shit load of.

SSSSSB players TBH.Yeah those new players I have coming in next season will look good getting everyone Gatorade and passing out towels during time outs. I might bring Momma home with me though...

Edited by Mindor on Jan 20, 2010 14:13:39
Edited by Mindor on Jan 20, 2010 14:11:50
 
Dadd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
Originally posted by Shart

I'm curious as to why you would want to do this... We have the option of moving up 3 since we won our league but we can't imagine why anyone would want to do so? Is there an advantage to this? Will it help you down the road in the pros?


Personally i wanted to get out of the cloud as soon as i could. The faster you move up, the faster you can get your team into a position of competing at AA and above. That's where the money is for those ridiculous equipment costs and it could save you a season in trying to be promoted from a lower league. There's isn't really a wrong way to do it, just preference.


I did this with my team last season. Skipped the Cloud and went to AA right away.
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dadd
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom

Originally posted by Shart


I'm curious as to why you would want to do this... We have the option of moving up 3 since we won our league but we can't imagine why anyone would want to do so? Is there an advantage to this? Will it help you down the road in the pros?


Personally i wanted to get out of the cloud as soon as i could. The faster you move up, the faster you can get your team into a position of competing at AA and above. That's where the money is for those ridiculous equipment costs and it could save you a season in trying to be promoted from a lower league. There's isn't really a wrong way to do it, just preference.


I did this with my team last season. Skipped the Cloud and went to AA right away.


Good move imo.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vinman
Good questions


Facts:

Assuming 6 cap 38 leagues (same as today) and 6 cap 42 leagues (same as today), if cap 42 playoff teams and cap 46 non-playoff teams do not promote to AA, that means every season, there are 288 new teams in Cap 46. If you only promote the cap 46 playoff teams to AA, you will need 18 cap 46 leagues before the number of teams going to AA from cap 46 is equal to the number of teams coming into cap 46. That is more than half of the total number of AA leagues (which have a ton of CPUs as it is).

We might as well not have AA leagues if we are going to keep the stated AA promotion rule that you have to go thru one season in cap 46 to get there.
Edited by Plankton on Jan 20, 2010 14:19:11
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
A) There needs to be a 1 cap. That would help so much, I don't know why you guys refuse to add it.

B) What's going on with upper cap to AA promotion? Only 46 goes up, does everyone, can 42 winners request, etc?
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4favre
to help the mess of cap 14 they should just add another cap which is level 1 cap and then it goes to 14 automatically the next season.

This would eliminate all the requests for teams to stay in cap 14 and it would make cap 14 a little more competitive. There are way too many cap 14 teams made up of level 1 players.


Absolutely. Cap-14 is currently choked at both extremes: CPU teams on the bottom, SSB-laden superteams at the top. If you are somewhere in between, you are in one crappy feast-or-famine situation.
 
ljsefton
offline
Link
 
I was going to post a complaint about the current promotion system before I came here and found others had already done that and pretty much voiced my objections already. However, as usual for these forums, the general idea of the original poster's complaint has been either twisted or completely paved over and the primary points seem to be missed entirely by many of the responders.

My complaint resides in that as a minor team or a casual team owner in their first seasons of ownership, we have to build our stadium if we want to continue to remain competitive in higher cap levels later thus we have to build our stadiums with our money that could have gone only to salaries and signing bonuses. Apparently, while this design is not completely taken into consideration by most posters that have never owned a team, we should just suck it up, be the losing teams for the first 1 to 4 seasons while we build our stadiums regardless of whatever cap level they toss us into, then once we have our stadiums completely capped out with all available seating, we can then do what everyone else is doing and request as demotion back to cap14 and use all our money to offer unrealistic salaries and signing bonuses to human players so that the new team owners that season face what we faced initially, this does not promote change for the better only continues the cycle as it is already in place.

Had I known when I bought my team in Season 13, that all I had to do was screw tactics so that I loose more than I win so I could only be promoted 1 cap level each season I would have, but no, I put together what I could from the marketplace, then filled my team with level 1 players from myself and friends to fill out my roster where I only had to keep 2-3 CPU players by day 1. Then between myself and a friend scout every team and actually try to win every game to be more competitive to all the human owned teams, how foolish of us, we should have just tried to loose instead. Now my roster for my team for season 14 while diminished, is comprised mostly of players level 9 to a few 18s, and our position monitor states that our likely cap level for season 14 will be 22. Which means many of my players will be coming into Season 14 in a cap level 22, 12 levels behind the cap to start with. Yes, I can sign and fill my open slots from the marketplace in hopes I can sign people closer to the cap level, but again because I have to allocate most of my monies to stadium construction, I cannot offer competitive signing bonuses when compared to the teams that stepped down from whatever cap level they were with fully completed stadiums.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.