Originally posted by Bort
I'm going to bump this myself because I was thinking about it recently, and had the thought come up:
What would you do with teams who dropped down from above? Let's say a former AAA teams wants to load up with lv 24 players and head down to a 26 league. Where do we place them? Silver? Figuring out the number of leagues and how to split them becomes harder when you have teams who have no past record at a lower tier.
I'd say silver is the default league provided they have the roster for it. If they are demoting and taking on all level 1s they'd be placed in copper. If they (as in your example) were all level 24s and in a 26 cap league, they'd be defaulted to silver and adjusted next season.
Originally posted by Bort
Where do newly purchased teams start?
Again default into silver, if they don't get the recruiting done and have a terrible roster they could be placed in copper.
Originally posted by Bort
Also, couldn't we accomplish a very similar goal if we simply sorted all teams by past season's record, and fill the next tier's leagues in that order, starting at league 1? League 1 basically becomes the "Gold" league, leagues 2,3,4 etc become "Silver" and the rest get filtered into 5,6,7, etc with CPU teams to fill remaining holes. It might be hard to figure out designations, but you'd tend to end up with all the good teams together, while the non-trying teams get lumped together at the end as well.
The main problem I see is that people that get a bad record in the #1, #2 etc leagues get a huge demotion. I sort of worked in another thing to my idea which was to keep people in the same # silver league as much as possible (provided they aren't promoted / demoted). Which kept the leagues less fluid and made it much easier for rivalries to develop (more of a A, BBB type feel to it).
shuffling the leagues based on numbers would make them much more fluid, which doesn't promote rivalries because you don't see them.
That is, unless I"m not understanding your idea, if you plan it to be a 1 time shuffle than it would work, but as teams sell and new teams come into the cap it would be a bit harder to get them placed correctly
I'm going to bump this myself because I was thinking about it recently, and had the thought come up:
What would you do with teams who dropped down from above? Let's say a former AAA teams wants to load up with lv 24 players and head down to a 26 league. Where do we place them? Silver? Figuring out the number of leagues and how to split them becomes harder when you have teams who have no past record at a lower tier.
I'd say silver is the default league provided they have the roster for it. If they are demoting and taking on all level 1s they'd be placed in copper. If they (as in your example) were all level 24s and in a 26 cap league, they'd be defaulted to silver and adjusted next season.
Originally posted by Bort
Where do newly purchased teams start?
Again default into silver, if they don't get the recruiting done and have a terrible roster they could be placed in copper.
Originally posted by Bort
Also, couldn't we accomplish a very similar goal if we simply sorted all teams by past season's record, and fill the next tier's leagues in that order, starting at league 1? League 1 basically becomes the "Gold" league, leagues 2,3,4 etc become "Silver" and the rest get filtered into 5,6,7, etc with CPU teams to fill remaining holes. It might be hard to figure out designations, but you'd tend to end up with all the good teams together, while the non-trying teams get lumped together at the end as well.
The main problem I see is that people that get a bad record in the #1, #2 etc leagues get a huge demotion. I sort of worked in another thing to my idea which was to keep people in the same # silver league as much as possible (provided they aren't promoted / demoted). Which kept the leagues less fluid and made it much easier for rivalries to develop (more of a A, BBB type feel to it).
shuffling the leagues based on numbers would make them much more fluid, which doesn't promote rivalries because you don't see them.
That is, unless I"m not understanding your idea, if you plan it to be a 1 time shuffle than it would work, but as teams sell and new teams come into the cap it would be a bit harder to get them placed correctly






























