User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add Gold / Silver / Copper Leagues For Each Level Cap And Change Promotion System
Page:
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm going to bump this myself because I was thinking about it recently, and had the thought come up:

What would you do with teams who dropped down from above? Let's say a former AAA teams wants to load up with lv 24 players and head down to a 26 league. Where do we place them? Silver? Figuring out the number of leagues and how to split them becomes harder when you have teams who have no past record at a lower tier.


I'd say silver is the default league provided they have the roster for it. If they are demoting and taking on all level 1s they'd be placed in copper. If they (as in your example) were all level 24s and in a 26 cap league, they'd be defaulted to silver and adjusted next season.

Originally posted by Bort

Where do newly purchased teams start?


Again default into silver, if they don't get the recruiting done and have a terrible roster they could be placed in copper.

Originally posted by Bort

Also, couldn't we accomplish a very similar goal if we simply sorted all teams by past season's record, and fill the next tier's leagues in that order, starting at league 1? League 1 basically becomes the "Gold" league, leagues 2,3,4 etc become "Silver" and the rest get filtered into 5,6,7, etc with CPU teams to fill remaining holes. It might be hard to figure out designations, but you'd tend to end up with all the good teams together, while the non-trying teams get lumped together at the end as well.


The main problem I see is that people that get a bad record in the #1, #2 etc leagues get a huge demotion. I sort of worked in another thing to my idea which was to keep people in the same # silver league as much as possible (provided they aren't promoted / demoted). Which kept the leagues less fluid and made it much easier for rivalries to develop (more of a A, BBB type feel to it).

shuffling the leagues based on numbers would make them much more fluid, which doesn't promote rivalries because you don't see them.

That is, unless I"m not understanding your idea, if you plan it to be a 1 time shuffle than it would work, but as teams sell and new teams come into the cap it would be a bit harder to get them placed correctly

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I just realized the sort all idea wouldn't work for future movement, but it would probably actually work very well to get something like this started, as the initial setup foundation.

Other problems to be addressed:

- What if there are only 2 leagues needed at a particular tier?
A. You can't really have a copper league
B. When the next season rolls around, you're not going to have enough silver winners to fill in the next tier's gold. How do you fill it out?

- What if you need 20 leagues or some high number at a particular tier? You'd end up with too many silver promotions the next season for a single Gold league. Do some miss out? Do you create more than one gold league?

- How do you keep teams together in the various silvers? By definition, silver is going to expand and contract as teams promote or fold. You're going to have some spillover somewhere.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I have an idea about keeping the teams together, but it's not simple:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3663284
 
Peshawar
offline
Link
 
I know I'm an utter noob, but in addition to the "rivalry" scheme - which I think is great btw - how about figuring out a way to promote and relegate from the newest of the new, lowest of the low in the "regular" leagues all the way to the World League? A similar structure might be started in the PeeWee Leagues, cap raised to - just to throw out a # - L5. Those who aren't interested could stay in what is in the PeeWee now. Same for all the others, Casual, etc. I see the idea being started in the Casuals, but the level caps seem too high to me. I guess that's 'cause I'm new, eh?

 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Peshawar
I know I'm an utter noob, but in addition to the "rivalry" scheme - which I think is great btw - how about figuring out a way to promote and relegate from the newest of the new, lowest of the low in the "regular" leagues all the way to the World League? A similar structure might be started in the PeeWee Leagues, cap raised to - just to throw out a # - L5. Those who aren't interested could stay in what is in the PeeWee now. Same for all the others, Casual, etc. I see the idea being started in the Casuals, but the level caps seem too high to me. I guess that's 'cause I'm new, eh?



As it stands right now, winning the championship in your league will promote your team three levels. So, a 14 cap team could reach the World League in like four or five seasons if they were perfect.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
As it stands right now, winning the championship in your league will promote your team three levels. So, a 14 cap team could reach the World League in like four or five seasons if they were perfect.


Two, with the ability to choose to go up 3
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Yea I just picked the max to illustrate the absolute fastest it could be done. Though I didn't do the math so I'm not sure exactly how many seasons are required.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Other problems to be addressed:

- What if there are only 2 leagues needed at a particular tier?
A. You can't really have a copper league
B. When the next season rolls around, you're not going to have enough silver winners to fill in the next tier's gold. How do you fill it out?


Ya the best thing to do for these caps would be to have 1 silver and 1 gold league. As for the next cap, just reduce the number of gold teams demoting. If you have 4 silver leagues, 8 of the golds would demote (aka the bottom 4 gold teams).

You could even mix in the rivalry points in this system as well. I'd say something like this (instead of all silver teams stay in same # league):

Each regular season (or playoff) game with a team yields 1 rivalry point
teams are given an additional 1 rivalry point if:
-the game is a conference game (not for playoff games obviously)
-the game is within 10 or less points score differential

then when shuffling, leagues, the teams with high rivalry points would be placed together in the same conference. It would be much more complicated (while having them stay in the same # league as best as possible would be a easier, but more bandaid like) or you could kind of combine both ideas (see below).


Originally posted by Bort

- What if you need 20 leagues or some high number at a particular tier? You'd end up with too many silver promotions the next season for a single Gold league. Do some miss out? Do you create more than one gold league?


There are two possible solutions for something like this (however looking at current league sizes I'm not sure how needed it is)

1 - make 2 gold leagues, add an additional game between both the champs for a "cap champion"

2 - prevent people from advancing by means of lowest regular season record between the non winning conference champs.

Originally posted by Bort

- How do you keep teams together in the various silvers? By definition, silver is going to expand and contract as teams promote or fold. You're going to have some spillover somewhere.


Basically I would think that each team would be assigned a specific "primary silver league number" that would be assigned. Then you would try to keep the most like number teams together. As for the "spillover teams" you could remove the most record teams from the league that has too many (make it more of a privilege to get in a league with rivals). Exactly which league they spill into could be decided by rivalry points (each league would get the team that had the most rivalry points with the league).

You will always have spillover no matter the system, so I think just make the teams with the worst records be the spillover teams (however, you give the gold teams precedence over silver since they played harder teams)

 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
+1

I came in here to post the same thing. I am about to start a new crop of Season 1 players, but am wondering if it is worth the effort when they will be 5+ seasons in crappy leagues with little enjoyment.
 
Peshawar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Originally posted by Peshawar

I know I'm an utter noob, but in addition to the "rivalry" scheme - which I think is great btw - how about figuring out a way to promote and relegate from the newest of the new, lowest of the low in the "regular" leagues all the way to the World League? A similar structure might be started in the PeeWee Leagues, cap raised to - just to throw out a # - L5. Those who aren't interested could stay in what is in the PeeWee now. Same for all the others, Casual, etc. I see the idea being started in the Casuals, but the level caps seem too high to me. I guess that's 'cause I'm new, eh?



As it stands right now, winning the championship in your league will promote your team three levels. So, a 14 cap team could reach the World League in like four or five seasons if they were perfect.


Great! Thanks for the clarification. I still haven't quite figured out how the leagues interact; can you tell?
 
Link
 
+1
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
i'd love to see this for season 14, but 15 is probably our best bet
 
Red Sox
offline
Link
 
Wow plus 100
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redsoxboy34
Wow plus 100


thanks... but... this thread was made like 9 months ago. Let's not necro bump stuff

that and the elite / competitive / regular league structure was taken from this. If you want to follow the same style promotional system go to this thread: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4198933
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.