User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Fundamental sim illogic is fundamentally illogical.
Page:
 
odt
offline
Link
 
1. Brought up a bunch of times already. Fucked up from the start and I doubt it will change.
2. Assigning blockers is the biggest issue here. Blockers should occasionally miss a blitz pickup, but the ordering or something fundamental like that seems to be off. The blocking interaction code seems to be much more accurate this season though.
3. I would like to see CBs miss on routes more often. I've seen it happen to my CB before where he just stood there, but I don't know if it was a bug or him missing the comeback by the WR.
4 and 5. These good ideas for future development, but are not fundamental parts of the game, but can be integrated in future seasons. The fact that you can control the loft of a throw on a game-by-game basis means that it is possible to do so for a throw-by-throw basis. The route running after finishing a route is just another thing that can be added to the end of the route calculation and can also be implemented later.
6. I like the 8-100 idea because this isn't the NFL, there are tiers. The level 1s should be able to compete with other 1s and the 60s with other 60s like any other RPG. The problem comes in with the slow-building and hitting the caps ruins the balance of many of the player builds at lower levels as people are only worried about hitting the caps to become more successful later on in their careers and ignoring production for the first 20-30 levels.
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odt
1. Brought up a bunch of times already. Fucked up from the start and I doubt it will change.
2. Assigning blockers is the biggest issue here. Blockers should occasionally miss a blitz pickup, but the ordering or something fundamental like that seems to be off. The blocking interaction code seems to be much more accurate this season though.
3. I would like to see CBs miss on routes more often. I've seen it happen to my CB before where he just stood there, but I don't know if it was a bug or him missing the comeback by the WR.
4 and 5. These good ideas for future development, but are not fundamental parts of the game, but can be integrated in future seasons. The fact that you can control the loft of a throw on a game-by-game basis means that it is possible to do so for a throw-by-throw basis. The route running after finishing a route is just another thing that can be added to the end of the route calculation and can also be implemented later.
6. I like the 8-100 idea because this isn't the NFL, there are tiers. The level 1s should be able to compete with other 1s and the 60s with other 60s like any other RPG. The problem comes in with the slow-building and hitting the caps ruins the balance of many of the player builds at lower levels as people are only worried about hitting the caps to become more successful later on in their careers and ignoring production for the first 20-30 levels.


I hadn't seen it on any of my teams til this season. I'd seen OL get beat to the gap, but never a DL lined up straight on a OL and just go right through them with no visible slowdown.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odt
The blocking interaction code seems to be much more accurate this season though.


You haven't been watching the same sim I have.

Originally posted by
3. I would like to see CBs miss on routes more often. I've seen it happen to my CB before where he just stood there, but I don't know if it was a bug or him missing the comeback by the WR.


Me too.

Originally posted by
4 and 5. These good ideas for future development, but are not fundamental parts of the game, but can be integrated in future seasons. The fact that you can control the loft of a throw on a game-by-game basis means that it is possible to do so for a throw-by-throw basis. The route running after finishing a route is just another thing that can be added to the end of the route calculation and can also be implemented later.


No, they're not just pie-in-the-sky things. They are core problems with the sim. The reason WR's can't get open on routes out of power formations is because they are triple teamed, and once their route is run, they stand there, stupefied, with CB's and SS's and LB's buzzing around them like flies. INT's should only be happening when a CB really nails it. The fact that the QB can't comprehend a CB standing two yards in front of a WR creating a need for some loft on the ball to hit that WR instead of throwing it right to the CB (bullet vs. lofty) is beyond idiotic.

Originally posted by
6. I like the 8-100 idea because this isn't the NFL, there are tiers. The level 1s should be able to compete with other 1s and the 60s with other 60s like any other RPG. The problem comes in with the slow-building and hitting the caps ruins the balance of many of the player builds at lower levels as people are only worried about hitting the caps to become more successful later on in their careers and ignoring production for the first 20-30 levels.


Missed the whole point. Numbers people will always "ruin" a "perfectly good" (yet extremely exploitable) number system. It's a fact of life. Hell, back when I played D&D in high school, there were always min/maxers who built their characters in such a way to gain as much advantage from the numbers as possible, because (like GLB min/maxers), they wanted their toons to win. It's not nefarious, it's not evil, it's human nature.

 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner
I hadn't seen it on any of my teams til this season. I'd seen OL get beat to the gap, but never a DL lined up straight on a OL and just go right through them with no visible slowdown.


Or worse, a DL lined up straight on an OL and the OL ignores him to go block someone else, leaving him a clear gap to the QB.
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
Or worse, a DL lined up straight on an OL and the OL ignores him to go block someone else, leaving him a clear gap to the QB.


Even if he ignores him, his body should take up physical space. Here's a good example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=806891&pbp_id=2169676
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
You haven't been watching the same sim I have.



I'm talking about after they've engaged their blocks, not the blocking assignments. You're not getting people pinballing off O-linemen on their way to the QB anymore.

Originally posted by griffin8r

No, they're not just pie-in-the-sky things. They are core problems with the sim. The reason WR's can't get open on routes out of power formations is because they are triple teamed, and once their route is run, they stand there, stupefied, with CB's and SS's and LB's buzzing around them like flies. INT's should only be happening when a CB really nails it. The fact that the QB can't comprehend a CB standing two yards in front of a WR creating a need for some loft on the ball to hit that WR instead of throwing it right to the CB (bullet vs. lofty) is beyond idiotic.



They are issues with the sims, but the issues are not fundamental, basically that these functions can be added to the sim without starting some aspect of it over de novo like you would have to to fix the level up stuff.

Originally posted by griffin8r

Missed the whole point. Numbers people will always "ruin" a "perfectly good" (yet extremely exploitable) number system. It's a fact of life. Hell, back when I played D&D in high school, there were always min/maxers who built their characters in such a way to gain as much advantage from the numbers as possible, because (like GLB min/maxers), they wanted their toons to win. It's not nefarious, it's not evil, it's human nature.


So what you're saying is that the agents who realize how to maximize their builds and building as such is a bad thing?
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
+1 to the OP

It's a shame it's going to be ignored

Originally posted by tsherr
You want to talk about stupid settings, try the Pass/Run/No Focus block on o-linemen. I may be the only person who knows this, but when the offense huddles up, the QB actually tells the players what sort of play they are going to run. So when it's a passing play, the o-linemen are prepared for that and block according, and the same on a running play. The idea that the o-linemen should have one setting for an entire game is ridiculous.

And then there's defensive focus - same issue: pass/run/no focus. Ok, it's 3rd and 15 - probably going to be a pass, so switch to a passing attack. It's 4th and inches, probably going to be a run. No RL player actually goes into a game say "I'm going to attack the play as if it's a pass on every single play.


This, along with all the other sliders are my biggest pet peeve.Its mind bogglingly retarded.

Originally posted by California


As it stands right now, he's got about 200K people paying him who are somewhere in between bored and fed the fuck up and loathing him and only continue to play this game because they've already made the investment. I'd say about 90% of the vets on this site would walk away without looking back if we could get a refund check of even just 50% of what we've spent on the game.



fuck yes. I'm only still here because I have money tied up in this hell hole
 
Skullkrusher
offline
Link
 
My two biggest complaints is passing at lower levels and all sliders but especially the Lofty/Bullet slider.

But I pretty much agree with everything the OP said.
 
HueyK
offline
Link
 
Completely agree with the OP.

Too bad nothing will come of it.
 
andrew7taylor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
LMAO! Shows how much you know.


Why? It wouldn't need to be calculated for the older players, grandparent them, and install the corrected version for season 13 and beyond. I don't do programming, but I imagine that wouldn't be a hard thing to do, unlike changing the in-game interactions.
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Agreed on all accounts. Sorry you spent the time writing it because Bort will ignore it.
 
gameface25
offline
Link
 
+1 OP

Actually surprised at all the support in this thread tbh. Only a couple retards who felt the need to post "tl;dr, whine, dont pay if you dont like it" etc

Wake up Bort. I already have chosen not to spend another dime on this game (after spending upwards of $1k). I will systematically retire players for flex until out, then just retire them all and cut my losses and go find something that works

going on 2 years on a beta is absurd. If this was a game that you couldn't play for free, it wouldn't have lasted half this long. You can only use the "Its a free game, you chose to pay" crutch for so long

 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by California

As it stands right now, he's got about 200K people paying him who are somewhere in between bored and fed the fuck up and loathing him and only continue to play this game because they've already made the investment. I'd say about 90% of the vets on this site would walk away without looking back if we could get a refund check of even just 50% of what we've spent on the game.


You are dead on here. I've spoken to a lot of players who would walk if they didn't feel they were leaving money on the table. It's really too bad, because I can't believe that this game isn't fixable. Heck, Bort could hire one programmer to fix glaring bugs in current code and then hire two other guys to help him rewrite the game from scratch, selecting a group of hardcore players who were willing to do real testing and give him honest answers. Based on his current understanding of the sim, plus the extra programmers, I'd bet he could have a new sim up in a four to six months (while we play the current sim) and then move us to the new sim with a 70% flex refund.

T
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Agreed on all accounts. Sorry you spent the time writing it because Bort will ignore it.


In the old days, Bort would be in a thread like this, and post regularly. Not any longer. Perhaps he's losing interest at the same rate as the players?

T
 
lizrdgizrd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
In the old days, Bort would be in a thread like this, and post regularly. Not any longer. Perhaps he's losing interest at the same rate as the players?

T


Maybe he doesn't want to face how broken his sim is.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.