User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Team Captain Feature:
Page:
 
rosenFAIL
offline
Link
 
BUMP
 
Link
 
Originally posted by colts rock
BUMP


Fail

It wasn't even close to off the first page, much less half way down it.
 
pimpkiller
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Flash83
Great point. That would be pretty easy to tell which owners weren't fair or unbiased. I think it actually places a lot of pressure on the owners who don't comprise more than 75% of the team. If they only own a handful of players on the team and pick their player, it better be a darn good build or you know everyone would think twice about resigning for that owner.

Bort could implement it where he puts it up for team vote - maybe having something on the team called a "Team Captain" poll, where players could cast their vote for anyone they choose. Most votes wins; so it would never be up to the owner.


I do agree with the idea of team captain, but a way for choosing a captain will need a little work. Here's my logic... say you aren't the owner or GM of a team and you knowing that a team captain gets a boost, who are you going to vote for? In most situations, probably yourself, just like everyone else more than likely will do. So how many people will get a vote for team captain, everyone.... and how many votes will everyone probably have.... 1. So which 3 people get team captain when there's a 50 person tie for 1st place.
 
joesox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
We have no ability to generate "official" polls anywhere on the site--only an admin can do that.

Again, this suggestion is just begging to be used poorly by bad owners.


signed
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
It would be nice to force a current team commitment of say 2 or 3 seasons in order to become a captain. Another possibility would be to use the age of the Captain compared to the rest of his teammmates.

The first example would be a Captain like Brian Urlacher, who's been with the Bears for a long enough time to develop his leadership skills. The second example would be more like Brett Favre. Although the Vikings rely on AP more, Brett Favre definitely inspires his teammates around him.
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pimpkiller
Originally posted by Flash83

Great point. That would be pretty easy to tell which owners weren't fair or unbiased. I think it actually places a lot of pressure on the owners who don't comprise more than 75% of the team. If they only own a handful of players on the team and pick their player, it better be a darn good build or you know everyone would think twice about resigning for that owner.

Bort could implement it where he puts it up for team vote - maybe having something on the team called a "Team Captain" poll, where players could cast their vote for anyone they choose. Most votes wins; so it would never be up to the owner.


I do agree with the idea of team captain, but a way for choosing a captain will need a little work. Here's my logic... say you aren't the owner or GM of a team and you knowing that a team captain gets a boost, who are you going to vote for? In most situations, probably yourself, just like everyone else more than likely will do. So how many people will get a vote for team captain, everyone.... and how many votes will everyone probably have.... 1. So which 3 people get team captain when there's a 50 person tie for 1st place.


I doubt I would be choosing my Left Guard or my Kicker to be Team Captain.
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't want the wrath of the agents who didn't get picked in the popularity contest. Its hard enough to keep them as it is.

I must -1 this as it is unnecessary and doesn't add a lot to the game. Just adds more pissy agents having a hissy because their CB didn't get team captain.

I can see the FA ads now:

Must pay for level 64 eq, must be WL, and must be team captain, max daily and bonus, and must get your first born child.
Edited by tuba_samurai on Oct 12, 2009 18:46:58
 
BUFFALOMATT23
offline
Link
 
Signed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tuba_samurai
I wouldn't want the wrath of the agents who didn't get picked in the popularity contest. Its hard enough to keep them as it is.

I must -1 this as it is unnecessary and doesn't add a lot to the game. Just adds more pissy agents having a hissy because their CB didn't get team captain.

I can see the FA ads now:

Must pay for level 64 eq, must be WL, and must be team captain, max daily and bonus, and must get your first born child.


 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Some sentiment against it, and quite a bit support for it. Seems like it'll need some rethinking if it's ever accepted. The few who are against it are definitely against it though. A few agents really want to push it and have been wanting it for a while. Most of the negative comments about it can be remedied fairly easily, in my opinion. As far as everyone voting for themselves, there should probably only be certain players eligible for the award, such as the top ten players who have been with the team the longest and have put up the best numbers, with everyone voting among those ten players.

I like the age factor required to be a team captain, though I wouldn't mind previous stats with the team to have some affect as well.
 
jedimster
offline
Link
 
+1. I have unofficial team captains on my team now.None of them are my guys either.It wouls be great to make it official.
 
Montyhawk
offline
Link
 
sign +1
 
shadowmane
offline
Link
 
+1, I like this idea.
 
chiefrocka6
offline
Link
 
here..."signed"...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Flash83
Some sentiment against it, and quite a bit support for it. Seems like it'll need some rethinking if it's ever accepted. The few who are against it are definitely against it though. A few agents really want to push it and have been wanting it for a while. Most of the negative comments about it can be remedied fairly easily, in my opinion. As far as everyone voting for themselves, there should probably only be certain players eligible for the award, such as the top ten players who have been with the team the longest and have put up the best numbers, with everyone voting among those ten players.

I like the age factor required to be a team captain, though I wouldn't mind previous stats with the team to have some affect as well.


You want Bort to spend his already limited time coding that crap? Do you realize how many of your "remedied fairly easily" items would require his time? Such as voting (we don't have the ability to create polls) and eligibility, to include "top ten player" calculations (based on...what?) as well as "with the team the longest" and "best numbers" (based on...what?). You're really suggesting that Bort spend his limited coding time on this clunker of an idea? Why not simply focus on the sim?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.