User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kwill-bot
I like it.


I like what Kwill-bot likes.

*Looks at eyeshield picture* yup.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The bonus would have to be worth it to lure people away from pwning n00bs.


Does this really happen? I would think that everyone is trying to move up to the highest level of competition (and its accompanying prestige, monetary advantages and recruiting advantages). Besides which, football being a team sport then noob pwnage won't happen unless a team is predominantly higher-level, in which case I'd expect them to move up anyway.

Unless instances are actually occurring in which teams are throwing their conference championships to stay in the lower-level league, this may just be a solution in search of a problem. And yes, I know of the one high-profile disaster in which a team did throw a conference championship but iirc they knew in advance that they were being moved to a league two levels higher anyway.



My recommendations for implementation: keeping the impact low (say, 2%-5% benefit from level differences) would keep people from throwing 'normal' league dynamics out of whack by trying to exploit the new XP system. For a similar reason, I'd also endorse making the XP bonus have the most significant impact in cases where the lower level team beats the higher level team with the least impact in games where they weren't competitive in the first place (as discussed earlier).
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by rbedgood


I realize that the point of this is to avoid having the lv15 player that wants to drop to BBB so he can XP up and dominate a league. I think 1-4 should pretty much handle this, especially if it is done on a sliding scale. The actual implementation of the program should not be revealed so as to reduce the loopholes...don't say what players are going to determine the average level of your team. It could be the entire roster, could be the starting line-up, could be 'best possible' line-up to remove advantage of dropping top players in the depth chart...

Additionally this helps the new owner of a gutted team recover. Or a team like ours (Ottawa Chiefs Canada AAA#2) that played all last season outmatched...we were 3-13...we beat the two teams that were relegated and our inter-conference matchup. So essentially every team that stayed beat us last season. This would give us hope of making up a bit of the 3-4 level deficit we face on average.

I think we'll be a bit more competitive than last season, but this gives us a bit more hope.



Instead of making the rest of the league play down to your level, how about dropping down to a lower level league. Do you realize that you are punishing the whole league to make your team "competitive"?


We've tried to move down...we missed out on relegation and haven't been able to find a trade partner that wants to move up...any suggestions, or do you just want to flame indiscriminately?


I'm not trying to flame anyone here. I understand your situation, but what I am saying is that just because you are in a tough position, you should not punish everyone else in your league for it. Your team might have to tough it out another year, and if you improve and avoid relegation, then great, you are improving. If you still have a hard time competing, then you will be relegated next season. The system already in place is working, maybe just not as fast as some people would like.

If you put yourself in the position of the other 15 teams in your league, why should they be punished in their player development when they play against your team?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justafish2002
The problem is teams like Utopia in USA Pro will get pounded because they sold their team. So the cycle takes even longer


Can we speed up the process by promoting/relegating more teams each season?
 
Kaiserfarrow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by justafish2002

The problem is teams like Utopia in USA Pro will get pounded because they sold their team. So the cycle takes even longer


Can we speed up the process by promoting/relegating more teams each season?


Bingo - I'd vouch for that!! 2 go up from each conference, 4 go down!
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Serenity

Also with getting a penalty for playing teams with lower levels

Since teams are able to bring in players so a team could add say level 21's to replace level 13's during the season. But the teams that had to play them at the start of the year get penalized for playing them early.


Not if it's based on league level, as opposed to opponent's level.




This I like - it also protects entire leagues from the negative impact of one guy trying to game the XP system.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by datongw

Hey Bort, are there a lot of people doing this? If there is only a minority of people that are doing this, then the changes really should not have an effect on everyone. For my experience in the BBB league, everyone is trying to win and move up. No one is trying to stay around or move to a lower level so that they can keep "dominating". I'm just curious how many of the people in the GLB actually think this is a problem.


It comes up at least once every couple of days with some sort of "cheating" accusation witch hunt.

This idea has been discussed before. I just thought I would bring it up again after all the recent complaining about Africa and "stacking" teams.


This is going to come up every time new teams are released. NO ONE wants to be told that a new team that they purchased will be level capped or it will prohibit people from purchasing teams. The only unfair case I saw in Africa was a team that got transfered to Africa AA with players AND stadium upgrades which was totally unfair. If anything that team should have never been moved or it should have at least been put in Africa Pro.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by datongw


Hey Bort, are there a lot of people doing this? If there is only a minority of people that are doing this, then the changes really should not have an effect on everyone. For my experience in the BBB league, everyone is trying to win and move up. No one is trying to stay around or move to a lower level so that they can keep "dominating". I'm just curious how many of the people in the GLB actually think this is a problem.


It comes up at least once every couple of days with some sort of "cheating" accusation witch hunt.

This idea has been discussed before. I just thought I would bring it up again after all the recent complaining about Africa and "stacking" teams.


This is going to come up every time new teams are released. NO ONE wants to be told that a new team that they purchased will be level capped or it will prohibit people from purchasing teams. The only unfair case I saw in Africa was a team that got transfered to Africa AA with players AND stadium upgrades which was totally unfair. If anything that team should have never been moved or it should have at least been put in Africa Pro.


Stadium upgrades? How'd they do that?
 
Kaiserfarrow
offline
Link
 
Being honest - new teams that recruit higher levels recruit them fair and square. Teams full of lower level friends will suffer short term, but longterm benefit from a better financial situation and greater chemistry. Plus after a few seasons, the level variances will be negligible, and the other teams will be losing FAs every season as the market changes and guys want something different.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker

Does this really happen? I would think that everyone is trying to move up to the highest level of competition (and its accompanying prestige, monetary advantages and recruiting advantages). Besides which, football being a team sport then noob pwnage won't happen unless a team is predominantly higher-level, in which case I'd expect them to move up anyway.


You underestimate internet denizens.

People have started it with Africa, and I'm sure they'll do the same in Oceania, SE Asia, etc when I add the leagues: AA level teams with lv 18/19's that should head to Pro, but they don't have a friend up there so they'll just pwn some n00bs for a while until they can move up or the team runs out of cash.

I dunno, maybe that's not a problem, but lots of people sure like to whine about it.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw

I'm not trying to flame anyone here. I understand your situation, but what I am saying is that just because you are in a tough position, you should not punish everyone else in your league for it. Your team might have to tough it out another year, and if you improve and avoid relegation, then great, you are improving. If you still have a hard time competing, then you will be relegated next season. The system already in place is working, maybe just not as fast as some people would like.

If you put yourself in the position of the other 15 teams in your league, why should they be punished in their player development when they play against your team?


Cool enough...but the way I'm reading this proposal, Bort wouldn't make the XP differential be based on that particular game matchup, but rather each player's level compared to the league average...so if the league average is 13.4207 (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=324473) and we have half our line-up at or around level 10, then we'd get a significant bonus. The only players that would be penalized are the lv 17&18 guys on one or two teams that frankly signed at the wrong league level. The entire team wouldn't be punished, just the few players that are playing high school football at 23 years old...
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I don't think it is a problem, but of all the ideas, this one is the best and actually makes football sense.

BTW, Bort, I think you should be spending this time doing something more productive, like adding exactly 164 new teams?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Instead of whole team v. whole team for averages, why not the higher of the sum levels of the top few offensive & defensive players (five, maybe)? Take the top five offensive players, the top five defensive players, add their levels together to get a number and that number's the one you use to determine average team quality.

Eliminates the ability to create & sign a bunch of level 1s to sit on the bench for minimum salaries to drop your average level to within tolerances.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
how about different XP earned by league level?

BBB = normal

A = +2%

AA = +4%

AAA = +6%

At least this way, leagues won't be forced into 32 identical teams, and owners that gut their teams and fill them with their own level 1 guys won't see supernatural growth.

This should be enough to encourage guys that are good enough to start at higher levels to go there.
 
xxedge72x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Painmaker


Does this really happen? I would think that everyone is trying to move up to the highest level of competition (and its accompanying prestige, monetary advantages and recruiting advantages). Besides which, football being a team sport then noob pwnage won't happen unless a team is predominantly higher-level, in which case I'd expect them to move up anyway.


You underestimate internet denizens.

People have started it with Africa, and I'm sure they'll do the same in Oceania, SE Asia, etc when I add the leagues: AA level teams with lv 18/19's that should head to Pro, but they don't have a friend up there so they'll just pwn some n00bs for a while until they can move up or the team runs out of cash.

I dunno, maybe that's not a problem, but lots of people sure like to whine about it.


See the part about a team running out of cash I think is key in this conversation, because in a sense the team that is harboring the ultra high level player, while getting the benefit of that player, is also in a way being punished for paying for something that they can't afford. If you're a college student without a job you're not going to go out and buy a BMW. The same concept should apply to the teams that go out and sign these players.

I don't think any of these suggestions should be implemented. I understand the purpose of them and feel for people who could use that boost right now... but I really feel like this is all a short term solution. I agree with the posters on here who feel that relegation will work itself out after a few seasons.

As it's been pointed out, currently there isn't much of a level gap since the game is still so new (BETA is flashed just about everywhere on this site, so that should be a good indicator)... but as time goes on and seasons pass, the XP gap will start to open up, and when that happens relegation will become more and more important, because teams will be put where they should be.

I think the best long term solution for this game is to just make sure that there are enough leagues / teams to accommodate the amount of players, and to make sure teams keep getting moved up and down appropriately. Right around the 10th season, when the XP degradation kicks in, is when everything should really be balanced and the game running at full steam.

Just my opinion.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.