User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > If X-Factor Theory is Legit, How Will You React?
Page:
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
Originally posted by Domer

It seems there are merits to the X-Factor exists argument. But we have very little data to back it up. A few these two players have nearly the same build yet etc... arguments doesn't hold water. For one, it's a very small sample. And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.

It's possible that the player's with so called X-factor simply have hit the sweet spot with their builds. They have perfect ratios between certain attrubutes, SA and VET's that make there player perform at optium levels. It's much more likely IMO, this is the case, than there being some random x-factor built into players. But who knows.

Domer


very little data to prove it doesn't exist imo.


This is also true.

Domer
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16


You do realize that that is the stupidest way possible to eliminate cookie cutter builds, right?


GLB Jail to anyone who copies someones build?
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
It seems there are merits to the X-Factor exists argument. But we have very little data to back it up. A few these two players have nearly the same build yet etc... arguments doesn't hold water. For one, it's a very small sample. And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.

It's possible that the player's with so called X-factor simply have hit the sweet spot with their builds. They have perfect ratios between certain attrubutes, SA and VET's that make there player perform at optium levels. It's much more likely IMO, this is the case, than there being some random x-factor built into players. But who knows.

Domer


I do because I built 2 OTs with identical size and rolls. Built them for 2 years exactly the same. They split playing time as best as I could get it set up and they alternated starts/backups. OT B out performed OT A 95% of the games.
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
I wrote up a suggestion on a more fair way to have the X factor work. Lemme know what you think.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3214080
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
Originally posted by Iceman16



You do realize that that is the stupidest way possible to eliminate cookie cutter builds, right?


GLB Jail to anyone who copies someones build?


Laggo would need to buy about 10,000 teams.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
This is very true.

Having higher attributes and SAs in all areas = Slower ldo


I really think it would be nice to know the energy hit for an SA firing.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
For one, it's a very small sample. And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.

First, it's not a small sample. We're talking about every route that each receiver has run in their career. If we were comparing one WR's performance in one game to another WR's performance in a different game, then that sample would be much too small to draw conclusions given the probabilistic nature of streaky. But we're talking about careers. The sample is mathematically inviolable. Secondly, the slower player is "superior" to the faster player in every single way.
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Has anyone here ever played Strat-O-matic sports? sportingnews has an online version of their baseball (they used to have football as well a long time ago) http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/

Reason I am bringing this up is because the game is essentially a dice game, using a RNG for the computer version. Each card has the probabilities in plain sight, the game doesn't have anything hidden, they even now (didn't used to) even show what rolls happened so really nothing is hidden anymore.

What am I getting at? Well say you have a Manny Ramirez card, one of the better hitting cards in the set. I've see him bat .340 for a season in a pitchers park, I've also seen an entire season where he ended up batting .240 at the end and was in a hitter's park. The RNG can be that cruel, and that is over 600 ab's per season. Now 16 games at 40 plays per game is even less, you don't think there could be a huge swing in stats if you got a lot of unlucky rolls??

RNG are just that random. I really think people here expect a dot with X speed and Y agility to ALWAYS = z. That isn't going to happen. They only expect say a .1% variable, instead of a much larger variable, say 5 or 10% (or even bigger). That larger variable to the RNG could cause a huge sway in the stats for the dots.

Even while playing SOM, sometimes luck just isn't on your side, even though you have what should be a perfect team. People here just can't see that here.

That being said I still believe in the X-Factor and the other thread seems to side with that 0_0. Transparency is the key, once sportingnews started giving the customers that transparency, all bitching subsided and everyone was happy. Here we have what 5%, maybe 10% transparency, the rest is a hidden mess we have to discover on our own.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
It seems there are merits to the X-Factor exists argument. But we have very little data to back it up. A few these two players have nearly the same build yet etc... arguments doesn't hold water. For one, it's a very small sample. And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.

It's possible that the player's with so called X-factor simply have hit the sweet spot with their builds. They have perfect ratios between certain attrubutes, SA and VET's that make there player perform at optium levels. It's much more likely IMO, this is the case, than there being some random x-factor built into players. But who knows.

Domer


So you think these x-factor players stay in that perfect ratio their entire career? It is more than two players, I've dealt with tens of thousands of player builds.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
I just figured out the answer. WOW, can't believe it took me this long all I gotta do is



Spend more money, and try to copy the x factor build
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Domer

And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.


This is very true.

Having higher attributes and SAs in all areas = Slower ldo


Yes, having higher attributes and SA in all areas could = slower. IF what's more important in a build is the ratio of the attributes and how the work together.

Just as an example, lets assume that because of the coding a player with a ratio of 1.25 - 1 (Speed to agility) will perfrom at 100% his speed potentional. A player with a 1.5 - 1 speed to agility will onbly peform at 80% of his speed potentional.

If the second player as 100 speed and 66 agility (that's roughly 1.5 speed for every 1 agility.) he would be running at 80 speed. (80% of his speed potentional)

The first player could have 85 speed and 60 agility and be faster running at a top speed of 85 because he's ratio of attributes is ideal.


This example is over simplified but it demonstrates the concept. It's entirely possible that players with the perfect ratio or balance of attributes perform much better than players with similiar, perhaps even higher attributes.

Domer
 
Ocho_CinCo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
you guys are stupid. you're supposed to say "it wouldn't matter and i'd probably buy more flex to keep creating players" that way bort would just admit it and THEN is when you flip out or do whatever it is you do.




Edited by OchO_CinCo on Aug 31, 2009 22:24:41
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OchO_CinCo
Originally posted by chronoaug

you guys are stupid. you're supposed to say "it wouldn't matter and i'd probably buy more flex to keep creating players" that way bort would just admit it and THEN is when you flip out or do whatever it is you do.


Even if bort said something about a decided randomness x factor type thing i don't think much would change




lol at kindergarten undercover secret agent tactics
Edited by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis on Aug 31, 2009 22:26:10
 
Handcuffed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Has anyone here ever played Strat-O-matic sports? sportingnews has an online version of their baseball (they used to have football as well a long time ago) http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/

Reason I am bringing this up is because the game is essentially a dice game, using a RNG for the computer version. Each card has the probabilities in plain sight, the game doesn't have anything hidden, they even now (didn't used to) even show what rolls happened so really nothing is hidden anymore.

What am I getting at? Well say you have a Manny Ramirez card, one of the better hitting cards in the set. I've see him bat .340 for a season in a pitchers park, I've also seen an entire season where he ended up batting .240 at the end and was in a hitter's park. The RNG can be that cruel, and that is over 600 ab's per season. Now 16 games at 40 plays per game is even less, you don't think there could be a huge swing in stats if you got a lot of unlucky rolls??

RNG are just that random. I really think people here expect a dot with X speed and Y agility to ALWAYS = z. That isn't going to happen. They only expect say a .1% variable, instead of a much larger variable, say 5 or 10% (or even bigger). That larger variable to the RNG could cause a huge sway in the stats for the dots.

Even while playing SOM, sometimes luck just isn't on your side, even though you have what should be a perfect team. People here just can't see that here.

That being said I still believe in the X-Factor and the other thread seems to side with that o_O. Transparency is the key, once sportingnews started giving the customers that transparency, all bitching subsided and everyone was happy. Here we have what 5%, maybe 10% transparency, the rest is a hidden mess we have to discover on our own.


The RNG would affect catching (say, one WR catches everything another drops everything).

BUT, why would it affect attributes? And if Bort has RNG regarding just running routes (beyond passing simple vision checks), than this game is coded worse than anything else out there...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
I just figured out the answer. WOW, can't believe it took me this long all I gotta do is



Spend more money, and try to copy the x factor build


actually i think it might be just spend more money then it increases your X-Factor
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.