User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > OL still not picking up blitzers who start far from the LOS
Page:
 
Track6Track7
offline
Link
 
In all seriousness, here's what I think is going on. Our blitz, and the one linked about for 5-man, are what I call "overload" blitzes, meaning you send more guys at the line or the segment of the line than there are blockers. The blockers commit to one guy, and someone is left unblocked. That may not seem apparent, because you think, "Hey, there's a RE and ROLB/FS, and there's a LT and LG, seems fair to me." But what is actually happening is the RE and blitzer are "overloading" the tackle 2 v 1, and the guard doesn't come into any of the pre-snap stuff. I am guessing that there is some sort of pre-snap determination for lineman where they "decide" who they are responsible for blocking based on proximity (you don't see lineman taking off after the CB or reacting cut off a potential CB blitz instead of going for the guy in front of them), and that the guard and tackle both decide that both the end and the blitzer "belong" to the tackle.

The key thing here is that the blitzer is "pathing" through the tackle, not the guard. The guard is not "watching" the blitzer, nor, and I think this is important, is the blitzer choosing his path based on the guard. They aren't "paired", if you will. The blitzer will choose his path based on how to beat the tackle, not the guard; but since the tackle gets pulled by the end, the best path for the blitzer is a straight line right through where the tackle was.

I can see how you think this is a bug if you're assuming the guard and blitzer are "paired"- if a blocker just stood there and let "his guy" run past him, that would he a "bug". Thing is though, the blitzer is not the guard's guy, he's the tackle's. Unfortunately, the tackle has to worry about the RE too here, and chooses the RE as the more immediate threat. The guard has to go through the normal rolls to say, "this blitzer got past the person that is supposed to take him and now he is the most immediate threat, I better engage him" but that comes too late most of the time. If the blitzer started closer to the guard than the tackle, I have a pretty good suspicion that the guard would behave exactly as you guys are demanding he react, sliding in front of the blitzer to engage him.

So yeah, this isn't a "bug", it's working as intended imo. This might be worthy of a suggestions thread to improve blocking assignments or something, but the guard isn't "bugged" or "glitching" or anything. Also, that 5 WR blitz is way, way closer to "unfair" than what we do (although neither is) but I bet you could torch it with quick slants.
Edited by Track6Track7 on Sep 3, 2009 07:45:20
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Track6Track7,

That's all fine and good, but when an OL has NO ONE TO BLOCK, they should be able to easily pick up blitzers that are even remotely close to them instead of sticking their thumb up their butt and just standing there while a FS/CB/LB zooms by within feet of them.
 
jstevens
offline
Link
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nT6iuMcBfCM

here is where the coding ideas for GLB blocking came from......
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
No man, it's like using 2 defensive backs in zone against 3 WR's, having THAT part work, and on the other side of the field where it is 2 defensive backs on 2 WR's, having a special placement of the 2nd WR force the 2nd DB to double cover a WR instead of cover the 1st WR 1 on 1.


Did you even look at the replay?

Yeah its 6 on 5.......

► but on the right side of the line, the RT and RG picked up all 3 of the MLB, SS, and LE. There went your numbers argument. I would expect this to get blocked everytime because you have blitzers all trying to shoot the same gap. Not that hard to block IRL.

► The C picked up the NT in the middle.

► The LT picked up the RE.

Leaving the LG free to do whatever he wanted. Instead of picking up the FS blitzer coming right at him, he *STEPPED FORWARD*, *BLOCKED NOBODY* , and let the FS shoot thru unmolested.

That part looks "working as intended" to you?


Nice!
Wonder why BORT does not come into any threads like this and just plain as day say "working as intended" or " working on a Fix"???
I think some people have never actually played RL football and do not realize that there is only so much space around a pocket in a pass play and that 5 Olineman can and DO indeed block out 6 rushers all the time. In the GLB lineman literally sit around doing nothing...thats BAD CODING period. No LG in any level of football would just stand there and watch a guy get a running start right in front of him and let him just zip on by to kill his QB, no level!

Bort, where are you and your answers
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NWWarrior
Nice!
Wonder why BORT does not come into any threads like this and just plain as day say "working as intended" or " working on a Fix"???
I think some people have never actually played RL football and do not realize that there is only so much space around a pocket in a pass play and that 5 Olineman can and DO indeed block out 6 rushers all the time. In the GLB lineman literally sit around doing nothing...thats BAD CODING period. No LG in any level of football would just stand there and watch a guy get a running start right in front of him and let him just zip on by to kill his QB, no level!

Bort, where are you and your answers


A bug mod will be a nice start. Then at least we can upgrade this to the "known bug, with no intention to fix list.

Track6Track7 - I could not describe better the blindness of the OL, thanks for helping.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Track6Track7


The key thing here is that the blitzer is "pathing" through the tackle, not the guard. The guard is not "watching" the blitzer, nor, and I think this is important, is the blitzer choosing his path based on the guard.


Wrong.

The LB clearly adjusts his path to get around the G, while the G is completely unaware the entire time:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712929&pbp_id=7175019
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Track6Track7
In all seriousness, here's what I think is going on. Our blitz, and the one linked about for 5-man, are what I call "overload" blitzes, meaning you send more guys at the line or the segment of the line than there are blockers. The blockers commit to one guy, and someone is left unblocked. That may not seem apparent, because you think, "Hey, there's a RE and ROLB/FS, and there's a LT and LG, seems fair to me." But what is actually happening is the RE and blitzer are "overloading" the tackle 2 v 1, and the guard doesn't come into any of the pre-snap stuff. I am guessing that there is some sort of pre-snap determination for lineman where they "decide" who they are responsible for blocking based on proximity (you don't see lineman taking off after the CB or reacting cut off a potential CB blitz instead of going for the guy in front of them), and that the guard and tackle both decide that both the end and the blitzer "belong" to the tackle.

The key thing here is that the blitzer is "pathing" through the tackle, not the guard. The guard is not "watching" the blitzer, nor, and I think this is important, is the blitzer choosing his path based on the guard. They aren't "paired", if you will. The blitzer will choose his path based on how to beat the tackle, not the guard; but since the tackle gets pulled by the end, the best path for the blitzer is a straight line right through where the tackle was.

I can see how you think this is a bug if you're assuming the guard and blitzer are "paired"- if a blocker just stood there and let "his guy" run past him, that would he a "bug". Thing is though, the blitzer is not the guard's guy, he's the tackle's. Unfortunately, the tackle has to worry about the RE too here, and chooses the RE as the more immediate threat. The guard has to go through the normal rolls to say, "this blitzer got past the person that is supposed to take him and now he is the most immediate threat, I better engage him" but that comes too late most of the time. If the blitzer started closer to the guard than the tackle, I have a pretty good suspicion that the guard would behave exactly as you guys are demanding he react, sliding in front of the blitzer to engage him.

So yeah, this isn't a "bug", it's working as intended imo. This might be worthy of a suggestions thread to improve blocking assignments or something, but the guard isn't "bugged" or "glitching" or anything. Also, that 5 WR blitz is way, way closer to "unfair" than what we do (although neither is) but I bet you could torch it with quick slants.


So you've boiled it down a semantics game of "bugged blocking code" against a strawman of "bugged guard". lol

Yes its buggy blocking code causing the guard on this play to do this. Whatever it is needs to be fixed.

An OL with no one directly in front of him for his pre-snap blocking read, should not default to "block no-one" as this guard obviously did. He didn't try to double the NT, he didn't try to double the LE, he didn't do anything except stand there and let the FS run through the spot he vacated.

I dont care if we want to call it a bugged guard or a bugged blocking code in general (<=-- what i think it is), it's not 'working as it should'.


Why is it do you think the actual overloaded part of the OL the right side actually handles the overload blitz?
 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Track6Track7
good/wordy explanation of what is happening


Thanks track, can't agree more with how you described the blockers as being committed to a guy before the snap even starts. The problem with that is... it's just a bad way to code. The issue (if you see it as one) seems to stem at linemen not picking an assignment when there are only three down linemen, or maybe picking an assignment and not being able to change it after the snap. Perhaps we just need more vision checks at the line. Something along the lines of...

1. Check: How many down linemen .................... Play starts
2. Check: Anyone getting badly beat, need assistance.............. yes/no.......... if no..
3. Check: Any one approaching the line aggressively directed at a gap you should control
4. Give up sack?

That said, I don't want to see the defenses ability to get pressure out of the quarter, 3-4 and 3-3-5 completely annihilated but it definitely shouldn't be as easy as finding the guy who isn't coded right and can be beat on a glitch. I think Zoblefu had an exceptional idea that should be implemented in all blocking situations.

Originally posted by Zoblefu


Almost no O-Line can hold a good D-Line back from a sack for more than a handful of seconds, and that happens all the time in GLB too. Something like every tick it should become easier for the D-Line to break free / harder for the O-Line to hold the block... or something.



Should apply to WR vs. CB, TE vs. LB.... etc, not just line men. Something along the lines of after x amount of ticks (somewhere in the 1.5-2 second range) it gets exponentially harder to hold a block. Vice-versa if a defender is outmatched, it should get harder to fend off being pancaked after x amount of time... even match ups favoring the defenders with this rule for the sake of realism.

To your other point.... The overload blitz argument is kind of null when there are only four attackers for the o-line to concentrate on.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712929&pbp_id=7175019
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712929&pbp_id=7174524
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712929&pbp_id=7175019
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712929&pbp_id=7175377
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712928&pbp_id=6314575 (MLB looks like he want to blitz here but doesn't, the O even has the TE and HB in to block... no help for that poor left guard)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712928&pbp_id=6316426
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712928&pbp_id=6317641
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712926&pbp_id=4584719
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712926&pbp_id=4584910
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712926&pbp_id=4586073

Actually, I'm just going to stop re-posting these plays. It's not a overload blitz that's doing it.... they're all three down lineman with one blitzer from the right of the defense.


Edited by Chop_Lobster on Sep 3, 2009 16:06:04
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=719607&pbp_id=9062142

Still there.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=726829&pbp_id=13666922

Ridiculous.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=726829&pbp_id=13666922

Ridiculous.


NT drops back in coverage and the Center and guards stand there with their thumbs up their butt.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.