User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
- Opponent's last X # of games, with outcomes listed



TBH, I don't think this would really help much until we got more parity within the majority of the leagues. As of now, I wouldn't really care about their last 2 game or any other number since there is so many games going on where the opponents are outclassed, out leveled, and out teamed all around.
Maybe, where you could tag individual games (present, past, future) to show the win/loss and outcomes. When I do my scouting I look over teams and see which matchups/games I want to utilize for my scouting and then I'll post the links for the games (if they played already) or I will post the matchup link for future referance.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Don't go overboard with the scouting and tendencies.


And this as well. I do like to have scouting I would like to do myself. No sense in making it to easy and taking the work out of it
 
GosuPho
offline
Link
 
What about a different matchup where you see the advantages of stats, like passing, etc, that is by stats
Passing: ***|** (so 1st team is better in passing)
Could be out of 5 stars
 
Link
 
Definitely needs % of times run or pass from each formation as well as which position ran the ball. Passing would be good with distance 0-5, 5-15 and so on from each formation. I don't think you need which play was ran that's a little much. Also stats on QB passes such as thrown away, bad pass etc. would be nice and times sacked.
Edited by viking maniac 1 on Aug 11, 2009 15:52:21
Edited by viking maniac 1 on Aug 11, 2009 15:50:58
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
As a DC, I would love to have something like this:
http://img32.imageshack.us/img32/1482/passinggrid.jpg

My thinking is that you'd parse the plays like Monsterkill or PBR Game Scout, and than you can break this grid down by formation and by a customizable down and distance that matches your inputs in your defensive AI. Than, if you want, you can click or hover over a grid, like "Long Pass Right" for example, and it would give you a drop down list of each play that was recorded in that grid.

All of the percentage based things that people have talked about in this thread are kind of fluff. Sure, it is useful information somewhat, but the formations, the down and distance, and the plays they run based on the situation are what DC's need to level the playing field. In the real world you have interns, assistant coaches, student coaches, and so on who do all of this grunt work for the coaching staff with a pencil and clip board in the film room or by physically being at the game. Keep in mind, they have a week to prepare for a game as well.
 
ericb45696
offline
Link
 
at first I thought this was a horrible idea.

but the more I think about it... why not?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by Bort

- Opponent's last X # of games, with outcomes listed



TBH, I don't think this would really help much until we got more parity within the majority of the leagues. As of now, I wouldn't really care about their last 2 game or any other number since there is so many games going on where the opponents are outclassed, out leveled, and out teamed all around.
Maybe, where you could tag individual games (present, past, future) to show the win/loss and outcomes. When I do my scouting I look over teams and see which matchups/games I want to utilize for my scouting and then I'll post the links for the games (if they played already) or I will post the matchup link for future referance.


I was going to bring this up. Tendancies are hard to pick up on in "last 4 games" because if 2 of them are steamrolls. What would work better is to build PBR Scout into this page. It gives top level data, like "run left 50, run right 21, middle 30" and how often each WR is targeted and the like. And with it, you select which games to scout. Let us check off which games we want included, so that you're not giving us info for the game vs the team that gutted.

Oh, and some sort of notepad feature is needed on this page. Let the DC write something, that the scout can check on, then converse a bit back and forth there.
Edited by pottsman on Aug 11, 2009 17:04:39
 
MazzaL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

- A place for GM's and owners to enter notes about the opponent for future reference and collaboration


does this mean a place for me and my GM's or a place for me and mine and everyone elses in the league?
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Like the Greasemonkey script, I would prefer to:
a: pick X number of games to review (this would avoid the Gut-tastic games)
b: tendencies by period, 1st down, 2nd down, 3rd down, 4th down (chooser)

Other than that, whatever is deemed fair. Giving out formations sort of takes the joy of scouting a team out of it.
 
AD2K
offline
Link
 
Idea:Bort makes a HB and picks a random team
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Boy, I hope all of my ideas get read......:


For offense...
When you have a chart of their last 3-4 games,

*** have an option where you can filter by offensive formation ***

This is information available easily enough (monsterkill scout...), and is really the only RELEVANT information. 50/50 pass/run could be 100% run from strong I and 100% pass from singleback, 200 plays each. The way defense is set up, being able to select "by formation" after viewing the overall team tendencies would be huge.





For defense...
At least show like "weak spots." Like, opponent completion percentage from each formation, opponent YPC from each formation, opponent YPC on inside/outside/pitch/screen, average YAC, etc.

Once again, you could start with a big summary - opponent completion %, opponent YAC, YPC inside, YPC outside, YPC screen, YPC pitch, completion % to TE, WR, HB, FB, yards per catch TE WR HB FB, etc.

Then as in offense, you can filter "by formation."

Again this is all data that we can get anyway, and doesn't need to scan through their actual FORMATIONS but rather shows what other teams are successful with.





I recommend this "scout page" have multiple tabs

Summary
Offense
Defense
Players
Notes



Summary:
bars, recent games, top threats, maybe a few small charts about offense/defense

Offense:
as discussed in this topic, with options to filter by formation

Defense:
as discussed above, with options to filter by formation

Players:
as discussed in this topic, tagging players looking at player stats, etc.
this page could also include the "team leaders" that is currently available from their profile.

Notes:
this is where GMs can make notes, etc., to eachother. Almost like a little "bulliten board" sort of thing. Shows who posted the note, when, etc., and just lists them down in order almost like a topic on the forums but a bit easier to read interface, and you can title every post, etc.
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
This is great Bort. And nice additions ^^^
Edited by Gary_Hughes on Aug 11, 2009 19:10:20
 
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Originally posted by Bort


- Opponent's last X # of games, with outcomes listed



TBH, I don't think this would really help much until we got more parity within the majority of the leagues. As of now, I wouldn't really care about their last 2 game or any other number since there is so many games going on where the opponents are outclassed, out leveled, and out teamed all around.
Maybe, where you could tag individual games (present, past, future) to show the win/loss and outcomes. When I do my scouting I look over teams and see which matchups/games I want to utilize for my scouting and then I'll post the links for the games (if they played already) or I will post the matchup link for future referance.


I was going to bring this up. Tendancies are hard to pick up on in "last 4 games" because if 2 of them are steamrolls. What would work better is to build PBR Scout into this page. It gives top level data, like "run left 50, run right 21, middle 30" and how often each WR is targeted and the like. And with it, you select which games to scout. Let us check off which games we want included, so that you're not giving us info for the game vs the team that gutted.

Oh, and some sort of notepad feature is needed on this page. Let the DC write something, that the scout can check on, then converse a bit back and forth there.


Exactly my thoughts on it.
Pretty much, Pbr scout mixed with something along the lines of the monster scout script/and addon but with some enhanced features/functionality to it.
IE: being able to select pass/player and for it to pull up the plays that player was passed to in that game. That way you can browse through those select plays to see which ones were screens or routes, short or long. etcetc


 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sixx

Are you going to include the average level of players for offense and defense. Or did you miss my post?



I saw it. I could do that easily. Perhaps that should be included on the matchup page as well?


Yeah that would be cool but, how about firing bama also?
He is the one that derailed this thread.
Edited by Sixx on Aug 11, 2009 19:14:33
 
d-bo14
offline
Link
 
Got the wrong idea. This would be a nice thing to add.

Originally posted by Bort

- Opponent's last X # of games, with outcomes listed


Last 5 games or so would be nice
Edited by d-bo14 on Aug 11, 2009 21:30:43
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.