User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add 10 season decline to the NEVER going to happen list
Page:
 
Teutonic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbartle3
decline after 10 seasons is the same as gaining no exp after 10 seasons. you get 10 seasons to build your guy. THEN, some stats drop off, you continue to level up and train, thereby replacing the ones you lost. i think its a good idea. its kind of like a maximum level, but more like a maximum TIME to reach whatever level you can get to.


Which is why I am done buying FP's.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric Scorpion
Without a decline, eventually the "Pro" leagues will just be a dice roll every game. Players will all have the exact same levels, exact same stats... it will be boring and pointless.


It would be BETTER. then it would mean the team with the better GAMEPLAN wins.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
Originally posted by Caledric Scorpion

Without a decline, eventually the "Pro" leagues will just be a dice roll every game. Players will all have the exact same levels, exact same stats... it will be boring and pointless.


It would be BETTER. then it would mean the team with the better GAMEPLAN wins.


That part may be true.

But without decline (which by the way the elimination of is on the never going to happen list) then those of us who got here first would have players that could never be surpassed talentwise.

There'd be no reason to create new players (especially bad for those new to the game), as they'd never have their chance to be the best.

Slightly longer plateau - yes. Endless plateau - no (and never going to happen).
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
While i have ZERO issue with the decline, in fact, I'm a sports guy before I'm an MMORPG guy, so when I joined without even looking I expected a career to last only so long, I do think this game should cater to the MMORPG in some way, some examples below:

Originally posted by SCACE

I think you could really bring in a lot of options.

My suggestions, quickly:
- First, have the decline come a little bit later, with a plateau and a decline that starts slow and speeds up exponentially.
- For those that would rather keep building like a MMORPG, they "retire" their players from the regular game (whatever records they have at that point for HOF) and rather than retire for 70% FP back, their player moves to a legacy league and keeps growing.
- For those that want to retire but not rebuild, they can become a coach in the regular game
- For those that want to retire and rebuild, 70% FP back when they choose to retire.
- For those that want to retire and rebuild a "son", less FP back and enhanced attributes to begin with as a son of a GLB veteran


I think these presented the best possible solutions to meeting the needs of both sides on this issue.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Yea I think I'd prefer your ideas Scace... Legacy here i come :-p
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
To add to this thread, I don't know that this has been mentioned or not...

Have all players automatically retire after 10 seasons, without a decline.

If not, let the decline be there.

I like the idea for many reasons. If you don't have this feature in the game, people will be maxed out in every possible stat, making players new to the game never have a chance to strut their stuff in the pros, etc.

I think when a player does get retire though, I'd like to see 100% FP points back, including custom equipment...otherwise you're virtually making people pay "rent" for the website.
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:26:00
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
While i have ZERO issue with the decline, in fact, I'm a sports guy before I'm an MMORPG guy, so when I joined without even looking I expected a career to last only so long, I do think this game should cater to the MMORPG in some way, some examples below:

Originally posted by SCACE


I think you could really bring in a lot of options.

My suggestions, quickly:
- First, have the decline come a little bit later, with a plateau and a decline that starts slow and speeds up exponentially.
- For those that would rather keep building like a MMORPG, they "retire" their players from the regular game (whatever records they have at that point for HOF) and rather than retire for 70% FP back, their player moves to a legacy league and keeps growing.
- For those that want to retire but not rebuild, they can become a coach in the regular game
- For those that want to retire and rebuild, 70% FP back when they choose to retire.
- For those that want to retire and rebuild a "son", less FP back and enhanced attributes to begin with as a son of a GLB veteran


I think these presented the best possible solutions to meeting the needs of both sides on this issue.


Very good ideas, IMO.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yea I think I'd prefer your ideas Scace... Legacy here i come :-p


I'm not taking credit for these, many other people hashed these out in great detail. I just tried to bring them all together in a neat, tidy list and hope the powers that be consider some or all of these options
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
To add to this thread, I don't know that this has been mentioned or not...

Have all players automatically retire after 10 seasons, without a decline.

If not, let the decline be there.

I like the idea for many reasons. If you don't have this feature in the game, people will be maxed out in every possible stat, making players new to the game never have a chance to strut their stuff in the pros, etc.

I think when a player does get retire though, I'd like to see 100% FP points back, including custom equipment...otherwise you're virtually making people pay "rent" for the website.


Not really...you're paying to enjoy the game, and all its features. If they gave 100% FP back in all cases (ngth btw) I would stop putting money in now and enjoy the game for the rest of its natural life. I have more than enough players and more than enough FP that I could retire them all and create new ones and have a lot of fun.

I personally think 70% FP refund on retirement is quite generous, to be honest. But maybe its because I'm not a teenager and I remember times when people didn't expect everything to be a handout.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by cwisler

To add to this thread, I don't know that this has been mentioned or not...

Have all players automatically retire after 10 seasons, without a decline.

If not, let the decline be there.

I like the idea for many reasons. If you don't have this feature in the game, people will be maxed out in every possible stat, making players new to the game never have a chance to strut their stuff in the pros, etc.

I think when a player does get retire though, I'd like to see 100% FP points back, including custom equipment...otherwise you're virtually making people pay "rent" for the website.


Not really...you're paying to enjoy the game, and all its features. If they gave 100% FP back in all cases (ngth btw) I would stop putting money in now and enjoy the game for the rest of its natural life. I have more than enough players and more than enough FP that I could retire them all and create new ones and have a lot of fun.

I personally think 70% FP refund on retirement is quite generous, to be honest. But maybe its because I'm not a teenager and I remember times when people didn't expect everything to be a handout.



I'm sure with, already, over 175,000 players currently created in the game, people will continue paying...and probably more if they know 100% of their FP will be refunded to them.
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:35:56
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Why would I put more money in if I got 100% back? Honestly, I wouldn't. And I'm sure there are MANY big spenders who would say the same. I already have more than enough money in the game that if they EVER considered this option, I'd never have to put a cent in again.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Why would I put more money in if I got 100% back? Honestly, I wouldn't. And I'm sure there are MANY big spenders who would say the same. I already have more than enough money in the game that if they EVER considered this option, I'd never have to put a cent in again.


When I said probably more, I meant more users would be willing to pay.

Not the users already paying would pay more.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by SCACE

Why would I put more money in if I got 100% back? Honestly, I wouldn't. And I'm sure there are MANY big spenders who would say the same. I already have more than enough money in the game that if they EVER considered this option, I'd never have to put a cent in again.


When I said probably more, I meant more users would be willing to pay.

Not the users already paying would pay more.


Maybe, but they would cap what they were willing to put in and then stop, no need to put money at X point when you can retire and make players at no cost. Sorry, not really a great continued revenue plan, if the game hopes to make enough money to improve over time, and the creators plan on earning over time.
 
mgbl3
offline
Link
 
I really think more about this topic needs to be listed in the FAQ. People start playing this game and invest plenty of time and money into it without realizing that at somepoint their characters will decline.

Then again I dont exactly know the details on what happens. Do you actually get worse? Or does the rate of you getting better level off?

I don't really see why players getting worse is necessary. Why can't there just be a level cap where progression stops?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
100% is a ridiculous thing to expect.

I do think that if you play a player into the decline phase, and retire him outright (without using any of the other options, from coaching to Seniors' Leagues to siring a "son" with a few extra points) you should be rewarded with 80% or so-- in other words, more than standard.

They can make up the lost revenue from that by giving less back if one of the other options are used.

Those who play in Seniors' Leagues would get 70% if/when they actually retired, but playing in them (for server usage) would cost a non-refundable fee per season.

Coaches may get just 60% back when retiring, and siring a son with extra stats only 50% or so-- as that's an in-game advantage and should be paid for.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.