Originally posted by Snickerling
Okay... I just had a game where we set the FG distance to 20... and it punted the ball on the FREAKING 10 YARD LINE!
We've tried everything...
Set it at 40 and it attempts 59.5 yard FGs.
Set it at 35 and it attempts 58 yard FGs
Set it at Auto and it attempts 55 yard FGs
Set it at 10 and it does not attempt any FGs
Set it at 20 and it PUNTS the ball on the 10 yard line.
I haven't read through this thread entirely, but I would just like confirmation on what that number means. I've seen people insist they've been told by bort that it's a hard number... if you set it at 40... he won't kick anything over 40 yards. I've also seen people insist bort has said it's a +17 number. Set it at 40 and it will kick from 57 and under.
Which is it? I wish someone would confirm one way or another. If it's a hard number, why did it punt from the 10? If it's a +17 number, why would it attempt field goals from 58 when it's set at 35?
VERY frustrating.
Depends on when these things happened. Prior to the 24th the distance you set in the basic AI was pretty much ignored as the according database field was disabled along with the advanced AI. In games played since that point this is supposed to be fixed, and you should not longer attempt any FGs from a distance greater than what you put into the distance field.
Although that punt from the 10 might seem ridiculous, it is actually an indication that the fix works as intended, as it would have been a 27 yard FG when the ball is at the 10 yard line, which is outside the 20 yard range you set for the game. Working as intended, although of course it should probably be discussed whether the basic AI should not ratehr go for it than punt in such a situation.
Setting it at 10 not leading to any FGs is rather logical as well, as the line of scrimmage and hence the ball would have to be at the -7 for such an attempt. The lowest range that would be logical to use would be 18, as that would allow you to kick FGs when the ball is at the 1 yard line. Again, it might be worth to discuss whether this should be the minimum distance allowed to put into that field, but anything below 18 yards just does not make any sense.
Okay... I just had a game where we set the FG distance to 20... and it punted the ball on the FREAKING 10 YARD LINE!
We've tried everything...
Set it at 40 and it attempts 59.5 yard FGs.
Set it at 35 and it attempts 58 yard FGs
Set it at Auto and it attempts 55 yard FGs
Set it at 10 and it does not attempt any FGs
Set it at 20 and it PUNTS the ball on the 10 yard line.
I haven't read through this thread entirely, but I would just like confirmation on what that number means. I've seen people insist they've been told by bort that it's a hard number... if you set it at 40... he won't kick anything over 40 yards. I've also seen people insist bort has said it's a +17 number. Set it at 40 and it will kick from 57 and under.
Which is it? I wish someone would confirm one way or another. If it's a hard number, why did it punt from the 10? If it's a +17 number, why would it attempt field goals from 58 when it's set at 35?
VERY frustrating.
Depends on when these things happened. Prior to the 24th the distance you set in the basic AI was pretty much ignored as the according database field was disabled along with the advanced AI. In games played since that point this is supposed to be fixed, and you should not longer attempt any FGs from a distance greater than what you put into the distance field.
Although that punt from the 10 might seem ridiculous, it is actually an indication that the fix works as intended, as it would have been a 27 yard FG when the ball is at the 10 yard line, which is outside the 20 yard range you set for the game. Working as intended, although of course it should probably be discussed whether the basic AI should not ratehr go for it than punt in such a situation.
Setting it at 10 not leading to any FGs is rather logical as well, as the line of scrimmage and hence the ball would have to be at the -7 for such an attempt. The lowest range that would be logical to use would be 18, as that would allow you to kick FGs when the ball is at the 1 yard line. Again, it might be worth to discuss whether this should be the minimum distance allowed to put into that field, but anything below 18 yards just does not make any sense.






























