Gotcha, thanks.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Gameplan doesnt run in playoff game WTF?
Cryptotich
offline
offline
Sorry it took so long to get to this thread. It took me about 5 hours just to catch back up from the weekend. I tried to start at the oldest and work my way forward.
To be honest this is going to be one hard bug to pin down.
Right now this is a "needle in a haystack" situation. Or to make a car analogy it's like taking your car to the mechanic and saying "Somethings wrong with my engine"
The mechanic replies: "Whats wrong?"
You reply: "I don't know, but it isn't working like I expected it to."
The mechanic says: "OK"... takes the car, gives it back to you in 2 weeks, with a bill that says $900 for diagnostics, but your car works the same, as it did before you took it to the mechanic.
The moral of the story, is that if I can not hand Bort a bug report telling him, at the very least, where in his code to look, the issue will likely not get resolved.
Right now, with the information available in this thread, I really don't even have a place to start looking.
To be honest this is going to be one hard bug to pin down.
Right now this is a "needle in a haystack" situation. Or to make a car analogy it's like taking your car to the mechanic and saying "Somethings wrong with my engine"
The mechanic replies: "Whats wrong?"
You reply: "I don't know, but it isn't working like I expected it to."
The mechanic says: "OK"... takes the car, gives it back to you in 2 weeks, with a bill that says $900 for diagnostics, but your car works the same, as it did before you took it to the mechanic.
The moral of the story, is that if I can not hand Bort a bug report telling him, at the very least, where in his code to look, the issue will likely not get resolved.
Right now, with the information available in this thread, I really don't even have a place to start looking.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Sorry it took so long to get to this thread. It took me about 5 hours just to catch back up from the weekend. I tried to start at the oldest and work my way forward.
To be honest this is going to be one hard bug to pin down.
Right now this is a "needle in a haystack" situation. Or to make a car analogy it's like taking your car to the mechanic and saying "Somethings wrong with my engine"
The mechanic replies: "Whats wrong?"
You reply: "I don't know, but it isn't working like I expected it to."
The mechanic says: "OK"... takes the car, gives it back to you in 2 weeks, with a bill that says $900 for diagnostics, but your car works the same, as it did before you took it to the mechanic.
The moral of the story, is that if I can not hand Bort a bug report telling him, at the very least, where in his code to look, the issue will likely not get resolved.
Right now, with the information available in this thread, I really don't even have a place to start looking.
Yeah I really don't expect much to be done about it because we still don't even know WTF happened. Like the gameplan was there...it was all set, but obviously it didn't use our gameplan. This has never happened to me in the 6 or 7 seasons of offense AI, and if somebody posted this in bugs I would probably not believe them either. But hey...it happened to us lol.
I don't know, I really don't want to beat a dead horse. Just hope other teams don't get screwed by the same thing. Sucks the season had to end on this note.
Sorry it took so long to get to this thread. It took me about 5 hours just to catch back up from the weekend. I tried to start at the oldest and work my way forward.
To be honest this is going to be one hard bug to pin down.
Right now this is a "needle in a haystack" situation. Or to make a car analogy it's like taking your car to the mechanic and saying "Somethings wrong with my engine"
The mechanic replies: "Whats wrong?"
You reply: "I don't know, but it isn't working like I expected it to."
The mechanic says: "OK"... takes the car, gives it back to you in 2 weeks, with a bill that says $900 for diagnostics, but your car works the same, as it did before you took it to the mechanic.
The moral of the story, is that if I can not hand Bort a bug report telling him, at the very least, where in his code to look, the issue will likely not get resolved.
Right now, with the information available in this thread, I really don't even have a place to start looking.
Yeah I really don't expect much to be done about it because we still don't even know WTF happened. Like the gameplan was there...it was all set, but obviously it didn't use our gameplan. This has never happened to me in the 6 or 7 seasons of offense AI, and if somebody posted this in bugs I would probably not believe them either. But hey...it happened to us lol.
I don't know, I really don't want to beat a dead horse. Just hope other teams don't get screwed by the same thing. Sucks the season had to end on this note.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by guzzdude
Also something I've noticed is when I save AI settings that have things set from 0 - 3.5 yards or any .5 yard the AI rounds it up later to a whole number. Then, in a game where the scenario occurs, that half yard is not covered and it defaults to basic settings.
Yeah every OC worth his weight in salt knows that though.
Also just the examples I looked at were 1st & 10 where that would never be a problem.
Also something I've noticed is when I save AI settings that have things set from 0 - 3.5 yards or any .5 yard the AI rounds it up later to a whole number. Then, in a game where the scenario occurs, that half yard is not covered and it defaults to basic settings.
Yeah every OC worth his weight in salt knows that though.
Also just the examples I looked at were 1st & 10 where that would never be a problem.
Craw33
offline
offline
This is just a guess,
In this image http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/2243/picture2oqe.png The pick a play is HB Sweep Strong, The drop boxes show Pass Short HB can't see the formation.
In this image http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png Two Plays look odd to me. HB Sweep Strong (pass)
and TE Quick Hit (outside run pitch)
I know it says that the pick a play overrides all other settings, but I am going to guess that when a play is picked and drop down boxes are used in the same play it throws the AI off and just picks a play at random.
In this image http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/2243/picture2oqe.png The pick a play is HB Sweep Strong, The drop boxes show Pass Short HB can't see the formation.
In this image http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png Two Plays look odd to me. HB Sweep Strong (pass)
and TE Quick Hit (outside run pitch)
I know it says that the pick a play overrides all other settings, but I am going to guess that when a play is picked and drop down boxes are used in the same play it throws the AI off and just picks a play at random.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by Signalsgt
If anyone can find it Mat can.
He's probably pretty good at finding errors, but I don't see how our 1st & 10 input would all the sudden stop registering when all we changed were the outputs.
I would let him look at the AI, but that is up to ddingo, and he never really expressed interest in looking into the problem, so we're just going to move on.
If anyone can find it Mat can.
He's probably pretty good at finding errors, but I don't see how our 1st & 10 input would all the sudden stop registering when all we changed were the outputs.
I would let him look at the AI, but that is up to ddingo, and he never really expressed interest in looking into the problem, so we're just going to move on.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by Craw33
This is just a guess,
In this image http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/2243/picture2oqe.png The pick a play is HB Sweep Strong, The drop boxes show Pass Short HB can't see the formation.
In this image http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png Two Plays look odd to me. HB Sweep Strong (pass)
and TE Quick Hit (outside run pitch)
I know it says that the pick a play overrides all other settings, but I am going to guess that when a play is picked and drop down boxes are used in the same play it throws the AI off and just picks a play at random.
Yeah I also had my doubts about that. I don't really know how bhall has been setting it up all season, but logic would say he's just been using the select play feature and ignoring everything else besides the custom slots.
This is just a guess,
In this image http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/2243/picture2oqe.png The pick a play is HB Sweep Strong, The drop boxes show Pass Short HB can't see the formation.
In this image http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png Two Plays look odd to me. HB Sweep Strong (pass)
and TE Quick Hit (outside run pitch)
I know it says that the pick a play overrides all other settings, but I am going to guess that when a play is picked and drop down boxes are used in the same play it throws the AI off and just picks a play at random.
Yeah I also had my doubts about that. I don't really know how bhall has been setting it up all season, but logic would say he's just been using the select play feature and ignoring everything else besides the custom slots.
Cryptotich
offline
offline
Well since the pick a play was one of the major things added this season, it seems like a likely place to start looking. Unfortunately I can't do that on the test server, as there are some changes there that would interfere with that issue, (or possibly fix it).
As much as I hate to say it, unless lightning strikes, I don't think this will get fixed until the off season.
As much as I hate to say it, unless lightning strikes, I don't think this will get fixed until the off season.
Thunder66
offline
offline
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
Cryptotich
offline
offline
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
I use the pick a play extensively, and have never had a problem with it,
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
I use the pick a play extensively, and have never had a problem with it,
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
I use it almost exclusively, and have never had a problem. I make sure to leave all the other fields blank though except for the custom slots and things like TE/HB/FB pass block/run route though. They could be conflicting I guess. It's an idea.
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
I use it almost exclusively, and have never had a problem. I make sure to leave all the other fields blank though except for the custom slots and things like TE/HB/FB pass block/run route though. They could be conflicting I guess. It's an idea.
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
I use it almost exclusively, and have never had a problem. I make sure to leave all the other fields blank though except for the custom slots and things like TE/HB/FB pass block/run route though. They could be conflicting I guess. It's an idea.
Same here pretty much.
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Thunder66
If it helps, I made a new AI using the 'pick a play' option as the outputs in the game we experienced problems. I dare say it might be there (but I've had others run with no issue this season?).
I'm concerned about the rest of my playoff games (do I run with old AI's which don't use pick a play???).
I personally do not use the pick a play, mostly because I just don't have time to fine tune my offense that much. Having said that, I also have not had a problem with my OAI that I didn't create all by my own.
Thanks for the input by the way, even narrowing it down to the pick a play cuts the possible issues by more than half.
I use it almost exclusively, and have never had a problem. I make sure to leave all the other fields blank though except for the custom slots and things like TE/HB/FB pass block/run route though. They could be conflicting I guess. It's an idea.
Same here pretty much.
Headbutt
offline
offline
What the fuck is going on with all the AI fuck ups in the playoffs and why the fuck isn't Bort doing something about it RIGHT NOW?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























