User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League? Poll the Audience.
Page:
 
HULK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachviking
Originally posted by Ravenwood

Originally posted by coachviking


The best of the best should all be in one place. This is purely my opinion but it just seems right to me.



There is a place for that already - it's the tournaments. Really, you can have your cake and eat it too.


We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs. So Every scrim didn't matter. Basically to be among the best of the best in this game, you need to play EVERY DAY. 2 Tourneys and a USA PRO regular season sched is freaking brutal.


Yeah, its overload. OFG is in 3 tourneys on top of USA PRO. Scheduling is insane, several times we've had a tourney scrim on the same day as a USA game. A World Pro League would solve this. Wouldn't need the tournys at all, maybe could do 1 for fun. It would be great to actually have the free time to schedule some scrimms just to experiment and whatnot.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
A decent alternative IMO would be to have a tournament of pro champions days 42/44/46 with the games counting as official playoff games. Otherwise, we definately need a Pro World League.

I say lock the rosters of all the teams that make it to that championship playoff run until they lose. Fuck their possible complaining, they made it to the WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP PLAYOFFS they should be happy with that.
Edited by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis on Jul 8, 2009 21:46:54
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachviking
We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs.

Again, it comes down to whether Goal Line Blitz is seeking to maximize the enjoyment of a few select players, agents and teams who are already at the top of the pyramid (by helping them stay there), or if, instead, it wants to encourage more teams to try making it to the top.

Don't forget the other arguments against a world league - the gutting of the various regional communities and identities; the homogenization of the game (as the tournaments outside the usual schedules are made redundant); and the effective emasculation of the current Pro leagues, which will for all intents and purposes become no better than AAA leagues.

Really, is it worth it?
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
I like it. Let the cream rise to the top. I think most of the resistance will come from pro teams who are used to dominating in their league and don't want the competition.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by coachviking

We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs.

Again, it comes down to whether Goal Line Blitz is seeking to maximize the enjoyment of a few select players, agents and teams who are already at the top of the pyramid (by helping them stay there), or if, instead, it wants to encourage more teams to try making it to the top.

Don't forget the other arguments against a world league - the gutting of the various regional communities and identities; the homogenization of the game (as the tournaments outside the usual schedules are made redundant); and the effective emasculation of the current Pro leagues, which will for all intents and purposes become no better than AAA leagues.

Really, is it worth it?


You guys act like teams don't gut now. Have you looked at SAPL lately? It's only midseason. Last season, there were 5 or 6 guts in USAPL.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Some people are stating they are against this but not giving any reason why...I would love to hear some reasons why someone would be against this....

I am all for it...screw polls and tournaments where everyone always seems to have an excuse. Let the best of the best fight it out in a real league.

 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by coachviking

We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs.

Again, it comes down to whether Goal Line Blitz is seeking to maximize the enjoyment of a few select players, agents and teams who are already at the top of the pyramid (by helping them stay there), or if, instead, it wants to encourage more teams to try making it to the top.

Don't forget the other arguments against a world league - the gutting of the various regional communities and identities; the homogenization of the game (as the tournaments outside the usual schedules are made redundant); and the effective emasculation of the current Pro leagues, which will for all intents and purposes become no better than AAA leagues.

Really, is it worth it?


If there was a Pro World League I would think they would need something special set up. Maybe remove roster limits and have 100 man teams all duking it out or maybe have it be a 128 team league and start the playoffs 2 games early.
Edited by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis on Jul 8, 2009 21:50:38
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HULK
Originally posted by coachviking

Originally posted by Ravenwood


Originally posted by coachviking



The best of the best should all be in one place. This is purely my opinion but it just seems right to me.



There is a place for that already - it's the tournaments. Really, you can have your cake and eat it too.


We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs. So Every scrim didn't matter. Basically to be among the best of the best in this game, you need to play EVERY DAY. 2 Tourneys and a USA PRO regular season sched is freaking brutal.


Yeah, its overload. OFG is in 3 tourneys on top of USA PRO. Scheduling is insane, several times we've had a tourney scrim on the same day as a USA game. A World Pro League would solve this. Wouldn't need the tournys at all, maybe could do 1 for fun. It would be great to actually have the free time to schedule some scrimms just to experiment and whatnot.


What you're not considering is, in a World League, every game would be even more intense than what you're used to now. If you think the game planning is bad now, imagine playing against championship teams every week.

With a tournament (as opposed to a regular 16-week league format) the drain on game planners is actually much more manageable. Especially since, if you're feeling burnt out, you can simply opt not to participate in any given tournament.

As far as I can tell, the "too much game planning" argument is a moot point.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by HULK

Originally posted by coachviking


Originally posted by Ravenwood



Originally posted by coachviking




The best of the best should all be in one place. This is purely my opinion but it just seems right to me.



There is a place for that already - it's the tournaments. Really, you can have your cake and eat it too.


We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs. So Every scrim didn't matter. Basically to be among the best of the best in this game, you need to play EVERY DAY. 2 Tourneys and a USA PRO regular season sched is freaking brutal.


Yeah, its overload. OFG is in 3 tourneys on top of USA PRO. Scheduling is insane, several times we've had a tourney scrim on the same day as a USA game. A World Pro League would solve this. Wouldn't need the tournys at all, maybe could do 1 for fun. It would be great to actually have the free time to schedule some scrimms just to experiment and whatnot.


What you're not considering is, in a World League, every game would be even more intense than what you're used to now. If you think the game planning is bad now, imagine playing against championship teams every week.

With a tournament (as opposed to a regular 16-week league format) the drain on game planners is actually much more manageable. Especially since, if you're feeling burnt out, you can simply opt not to participate in any given tournament.

As far as I can tell, the "too much game planning" argument is a moot point.


I think you're streching your argument. I think Hulk would agree it's better to have 48 hours to gameplan for anyone than have to gameplan for 4 different teams in those 48 hours even if every single one is worse.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Some people are stating they are against this but not giving any reason why...I would love to hear some reasons why someone would be against this....


Originally posted by Ravenwood
Recap of the arguments against:

1. A world league erodes the identities and communities of the regions
2. A world league belittles the current pro leagues, which will basically become the equivalent of AAAs
3. A world league takes away the need for a tournament of champions - a tournament which adds a ton of flavour and an element of variety to the game
4. A world league, added at this point, after 10 seasons, gives the impression that GLB is all about keeping a certain few teams, players and agents at the very top of the pyramid, and be damned to everyone else.

 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by HULK

Originally posted by coachviking


Originally posted by Ravenwood



Originally posted by coachviking




The best of the best should all be in one place. This is purely my opinion but it just seems right to me.



There is a place for that already - it's the tournaments. Really, you can have your cake and eat it too.


We do them both USA PRO and PWT as well as Hazy's. BUT it would make life a lot easier if we didn't have to. Hell put the best 32 of us in one place and let us slug it out for 16 games and playoffs. So Every scrim didn't matter. Basically to be among the best of the best in this game, you need to play EVERY DAY. 2 Tourneys and a USA PRO regular season sched is freaking brutal.


Yeah, its overload. OFG is in 3 tourneys on top of USA PRO. Scheduling is insane, several times we've had a tourney scrim on the same day as a USA game. A World Pro League would solve this. Wouldn't need the tournys at all, maybe could do 1 for fun. It would be great to actually have the free time to schedule some scrimms just to experiment and whatnot.


What you're not considering is, in a World League, every game would be even more intense than what you're used to now. If you think the game planning is bad now, imagine playing against championship teams every week.

With a tournament (as opposed to a regular 16-week league format) the drain on game planners is actually much more manageable. Especially since, if you're feeling burnt out, you can simply opt not to participate in any given tournament.

As far as I can tell, the "too much game planning" argument is a moot point.


Seriously? Playing in usapl pretty much means no easy games (lost to the .500 woodys and had 5 losses last season) and playing against the best of the best in tourneys. No way that's easier to plan for than 16 wpl games.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Some people are stating they are against this but not giving any reason why...I would love to hear some reasons why someone would be against this....

I am all for it...screw polls and tournaments where everyone always seems to have an excuse. Let the best of the best fight it out in a real league.



because since i owned my team in season 3 the goal was to get to South America Pro league- a goal that was emphasized w/ the big sense of South America pride and burning desire for what was then the puny team of mine to compete w/ the giants of the santiago benitos and cobra kai. And now your telling me the best teams in our league are leaving and there's very little hope to ever play them again? TBH, this would feel like all those seasons simply got me in AAAA ball. TBH the best solution would be to add 7 days to the season and have an 8 team playoff of all the league winners.

I was originally for the world pro league but when you think of the implications its not so hot :/
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Ravenwood

Originally posted by dpride59


Because 95% of glb won't be able to participate. This should be a decision based on Bort, and the 50 or so candidates for the WPL.

So you're suggesting the entire game experience should be based on the interests of a select few?


How would your game experience be worse by seeing the 32 best run teams getting a chance to slug it out? You still get to compete with teams at your level, and if you are at that level of the best you get to go slug it out with the best.

I don't understand how the best of GLB in one league will make your gaming experience, or any ones gaming experience worse, other than jealousy.


Exactly. The only "change" would be top Pro teams would be playing all top pro teams. If anything it improves the gaming experience of every other team in GLB since the championship teams would not be around to dominate the league again the next season making room for another team to step up.
Edited by Second Goalie on Jul 8, 2009 22:26:44
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

Some people are stating they are against this but not giving any reason why...I would love to hear some reasons why someone would be against this....

I am all for it...screw polls and tournaments where everyone always seems to have an excuse. Let the best of the best fight it out in a real league.



because since i owned my team in season 3 the goal was to get to South America Pro league- a goal that was emphasized w/ the big sense of South America pride and burning desire for what was then the puny team of mine to compete w/ the giants of the santiago benitos and cobra kai. And now your telling me the best teams in our league are leaving and there's very little hope to ever play them again? TBH, this would feel like all those seasons simply got me in AAAA ball. TBH the best solution would be to add 7 days to the season and have an 8 team playoff of all the league winners.

I was originally for the world pro league but when you think of the implications its not so hot :/


This might be the gayest thing i've ever read
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 8, 2009 22:29:50
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by Ravenwood


Originally posted by dpride59



Because 95% of glb won't be able to participate. This should be a decision based on Bort, and the 50 or so candidates for the WPL.

So you're suggesting the entire game experience should be based on the interests of a select few?


How would your game experience be worse by seeing the 32 best run teams getting a chance to slug it out? You still get to compete with teams at your level, and if you are at that level of the best you get to go slug it out with the best.

I don't understand how the best of GLB in one league will make your gaming experience, or any ones gaming experience worse, other than jealousy.


Exactly. The only "change" would be top Pro teams would be playing all top pro teams. If anything it improves the gaming experience of every other team in GLB since the championship teams would not be around to dominate the league again the next season making room for another team to step up.


and get an empty win. A gold trophy in SLAP is not gold unless you take down the benitos
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.