User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Official Proof the DPC is NOT working as intended
Page:
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Robb can you do me and favor and create a mirrored test on a higher leveled team? I have an inkling it could be vision related, as the LB essentially has to make the read if his coverage option is running a route or staying in to block.

I'm not quite positive this is a bug.


This seems to be the norm for bugs forum. "Needs more vision"
Well hell I'm going to start building all my players with 100 vision and when they act the same way then what is everyone going to blame it on?

Give me a freaking break with the vision crap.
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rat9771
This seems to be the norm for bugs forum. "Needs more vision"
Well hell I'm going to start building all my players with 100 vision and when they act the same way then what is everyone going to blame it on?

Give me a freaking break with the vision crap.


Coders not players need more vision.

 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by rat9771

This seems to be the norm for bugs forum. "Needs more vision"
Well hell I'm going to start building all my players with 100 vision and when they act the same way then what is everyone going to blame it on?

Give me a freaking break with the vision crap.


Coders not players need more vision.




 
Himura
offline
Link
 
I don't see this as being a vision issue. The players are going freelance and that defeats the purpose of the DPC as a whole or at least the "Or do this" function. Variables can be tricky i imagine with the sim but it really makes alot of peoples job's harder if they have to doubt their defensive settings for reasons other then the normal game warrants.

A test on this would be simple just blitz everyone on Defense and set a MLB to cover say...the FB OR blitz and put it vs Singleback offense. And do one more play Blitzing everyone and setting the LOLB to cover the TE OR do Zone or something and use it vs 5 WR. I think that might give a somewhat clear view of a issue.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rat9771
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

Robb can you do me and favor and create a mirrored test on a higher leveled team? I have an inkling it could be vision related, as the LB essentially has to make the read if his coverage option is running a route or staying in to block.

I'm not quite positive this is a bug.


This seems to be the norm for bugs forum. "Needs more vision"
Well hell I'm going to start building all my players with 100 vision and when they act the same way then what is everyone going to blame it on?

Give me a freaking break with the vision crap.


The OP's replays in question were level 20s. Most low level defenders won't touch vision until after the usual speed/agility.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Exactly what I stated, if everything is vision then get it to 100 first and then what is everyone going to blame it on?

I see the "needs more vision" crap, stated when guys have 60-70 vision.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by rat9771

Originally posted by Mat McBriar


Robb can you do me and favor and create a mirrored test on a higher leveled team? I have an inkling it could be vision related, as the LB essentially has to make the read if his coverage option is running a route or staying in to block.

I'm not quite positive this is a bug.


This seems to be the norm for bugs forum. "Needs more vision"
Well hell I'm going to start building all my players with 100 vision and when they act the same way then what is everyone going to blame it on?

Give me a freaking break with the vision crap.


The OP's replays in question were level 20s. Most low level defenders won't touch vision until after the usual speed/agility.


but the point is other teams with high level players have had issues also

AND despite low vision, that does not tell a man to ignore what the AI has set.

all of this needs moar vision is a farse, my guy can see a wr from across the field and make a run after him, yet he can see 5 yards in front of him that the HB is not running a route?

that is basically what all of these needs moar vision comments basically say.

anyway ZZ is the man and will test it out on the test server tomorrow and if he comes back and says it is not a vision issue you can shove that comment and ban any other user who uses it.

if he comes back and says working as intended and needs moar vision, than I will come in here and apologize and then run the same test on higher level team to prove to myself
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Robb I'm merely working directly off your OP here. I'm pretty sure w/ "coverage progressions" that they are run through quicker w/ higher vision. I therefore concluded that a player could incorrectly judge if a player was running a route/staying in to block.

No one else has posted proper evidence regarding their own experience w/ the 'bug', so until then I'm trying to come up with logical reasoning for your OP. You posted the necessary evidence, now we're working with it as best we can. As I stated earlier I've directed alex2544 to step in when logs on as well.

I know the 'moarrr vision' comments can get on people's nerves, but generally a lot of false positives for bugs are build related. It may not be vision, but a lot of times players in question are lacking or are deficient in a key attribute(s).

It very well may be a bug, but for now I'm leaning towards it being reasoned as a build deficiency. And I completely agree, trying to understand some of the effects of vision and general mechanics surrounding it can give you a headache.
Edited by Mat McBriar on Jun 30, 2009 20:03:01
 
Jazzpelli
offline
Link
 
I would agree. I'm seeing plays in the DPC where the players are not covering their assignment or they are not heading for their assigned zone. Kills the defense some times.
 
billbillson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

I know the 'moarrr vision' comments can get on people's nerves, but generally a lot of false positives for bugs are build related. It may not be vision, but a lot of times players in question are lacking or are deficient in a key attribute(s).


This has basically been turned into a copout for anything that appears wonky or doesn't work as intended. It's pretty ridiculous when all you see to every issue in this forum is "needs more vision."
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I've never seen a missed coverage but the blitz/zone option seems to be wonky at times
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by billbillson
Originally posted by Mat McBriar


I know the 'moarrr vision' comments can get on people's nerves, but generally a lot of false positives for bugs are build related. It may not be vision, but a lot of times players in question are lacking or are deficient in a key attribute(s).


This has basically been turned into a copout for anything that appears wonky or doesn't work as intended. It's pretty ridiculous when all you see to every issue in this forum is "needs more vision."


It's not a copout it is a reason. By calling it a copout you seem to be assuming that there is an imaginary state where vision checks are never failed for any reason. And in this state, your player will do as exactly as you have told him to do, and always make the correct choice when presented with a quandary. I am pretty sure that because of the random number generator, that state will never exist, and your player will make mistakes.

If all the players did exactly what they were supposed to do in college or pro football, there would be a lot less scoring. Ever hear the term "Broken Coverage", "Missed Assignment", or "out of position"? They usually come after a big play either on offense or defense. In GLB our rough equivalent of a players "football sense" is Vision.

The exact numbers you need to reach to pass a given vision test are unknown, as are the factors that go into the making the roll. So when someone comes i here and his player does something unusual, the first thing we ask ourselfs is what was he supposed to be doing, then we compare it to what he did. Most of the time its's a pretty clear case that a better vision check roll looked like it would have helped. would have helped.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by billbillson

Originally posted by Mat McBriar



I know the 'moarrr vision' comments can get on people's nerves, but generally a lot of false positives for bugs are build related. It may not be vision, but a lot of times players in question are lacking or are deficient in a key attribute(s).


This has basically been turned into a copout for anything that appears wonky or doesn't work as intended. It's pretty ridiculous when all you see to every issue in this forum is "needs more vision."


It's not a copout it is a reason. By calling it a copout you seem to be assuming that there is an imaginary state where vision checks are never failed for any reason. And in this state, your player will do as exactly as you have told him to do, and always make the correct choice when presented with a quandary. I am pretty sure that because of the random number generator, that state will never exist, and your player will make mistakes.

If all the players did exactly what they were supposed to do in college or pro football, there would be a lot less scoring. Ever hear the term "Broken Coverage", "Missed Assignment", or "out of position"? They usually come after a big play either on offense or defense. In GLB our rough equivalent of a players "football sense" is Vision.

The exact numbers you need to reach to pass a given vision test are unknown, as are the factors that go into the making the roll. So when someone comes i here and his player does something unusual, the first thing we ask ourselfs is what was he supposed to be doing, then we compare it to what he did. Most of the time its's a pretty clear case that a better vision check roll looked like it would have helped. would have helped.


Mind if I borrow this?
 
frankiebee
offline
Link
 
RILB isn't going to cover a FB that stays in to pass block. In the first replay the RILB does the right thing and tries to cover the TE that was running wide open in the middle of the field
 
Demboyz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by frankiebee
RILB isn't going to cover a FB that stays in to pass block. In the first replay the RILB does the right thing and tries to cover the TE that was running wide open in the middle of the field


buts thats not his assignment. his job for that play was to cover the FB or blitz. theres no audibles yet so he should of follow the play to a "T"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.