User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > Simple question.... " Should Ron Mexico EVER be allowed to play in the NFL again?"
Page:
 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

Not exactly. The opportunity is more than just a chance encounter. The more control asserted in a situation, the less of a choice there is.


How does one force the dog to fight though? You can put two dogs in a ring, but you can't make them fight.

Originally posted by
Not exactly. There's far more than a couple of factors involved. In today's day and age, most domestic animals are reliant on Humans for food.


Reliant if they are confined or restrained in such a manner where they cannot obtain food. Let them run loose and they will find food.

Originally posted by
There's a reason, that we do not understand, behind those situations. I'm willing to bet that a hungry dog would eat said cat or hungry cat would eat said mouse. They hunt and kill said animals because they're hunters... they do not eat said animals because they're not hungry. Animals will fight and kill for reasons other than food as well, like territory.


The "reasons that we do not understand" are irrelevant to your original claim which was: 3. Killing for reasons other than survival is not something that goes on in Nature, only in the world of man.

Now you admit that animals will kill other animals for something other than survival.

Originally posted by
Newsflash, hunting is sport, unless you kill the animal for the sake of survival... I.E. to eat or to protect yourself (or territory).


Dog fighting is a sport as well.

Originally posted by
Yup.


You would prefer to inflict pain or cause death upon a person who doesn't want to fight. Difference between the person and the dog, the person can understand that if they don't fight to your standards you will kill them.

Originally posted by
The legal system isn't perfect, but man is flawed. Either way, it's their job to police us. Don't like it, use the system or revolt.


At least from the get-go you recognize this nation has a legal system, not a justice system.

Like the ever-increasing militarization of the police to be used against the citizenry it is supposedly there to protect but the courts have determined that the police have no obligation or duty to protect any person unless there is a special relationship between the person and the police.

Huffing and puffing and blow your house in, huffing and puffing and blow your house in...

Originally posted by
Not really. Your points are all over the place, why should I take you seriously? Bottom line, we're the master of our domain. Animals are tools to be used by us. There's no gray area, either you're for protecting animals (ALL ANIMALS) or you're a hypocrite.


WHOO-HOO! Somebody understands, but where are my points all over the place? The premise is pretty simple.

Last point. My animals are my property. Means that I can protect my property even if they are animals because the rights that I afford my animals are merely an extension of my property rights which cannot violate your rights outside of my property.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Festus
How does one force the dog to fight though? You can put two dogs in a ring, but you can't make them fight.

By manipulating the circumstances to take away a real choice. Put the animal in a certain state of mind and more than likely it'll act accordingly.

Reliant if they are confined or restrained in such a manner where they cannot obtain food. Let them run loose and they will find food.

Not true. Some may find food and flourish, but many won't last long. Their parents didn't teach them to hunt and their instincts are diluted from generations upon generations of domestication. Hell, look at how much trouble wildlife workers have re-introducing orphaned animals back into the wild.

The "reasons that we do not understand" are irrelevant to your original claim which was: 3. Killing for reasons other than survival is not something that goes on in Nature, only in the world of man.

Now you admit that animals will kill other animals for something other than survival.

No. I'm merely pointing out that survival entails more than just the quest for food. If you look closely, you'll also see how the connection to man has also warped domesticated animals... who now mimic man's killing for reasons other than survival. If an animal kills another animal in the wild, it's for some reason linked to survival... that's how Nature works.

Dog fighting is a sport as well.

So if you condone hunting for sport, why don't you condone dog fighting? Both are identical IMHO, death for entertainment. Both also help control the animal populations.

You would prefer to inflict pain or cause death upon a person who doesn't want to fight. Difference between the person and the dog, the person can understand that if they don't fight to your standards you will kill them.

Yes, but I'm a bit of a sociopath. Plus, I generally dislike people. What difference does the person understanding this fact make?

At least from the get-go you recognize this nation has a legal system, not a justice system.

Well anyone with half a brain should realize this, so thanks... I guess.

WHOO-HOO! Somebody understands, but where are my points all over the place? The premise is pretty simple.

You're weaving a fine line between both sides of the argument. Some of your points contradict others.

Last point. My animals are my property. Means that I can protect my property even if they are animals because the rights that I afford my animals are merely an extension of my property rights which cannot violate your rights outside of my property.

How is that relevant to the discussion? Unless we somehow shifted the topic to talking about people seizing your animals to use in dog fighting. Wouldn't the same concept apply in reverse? Meaning that I can destroy my property as I see fit.

I don't condone dog fighting and I love my own dog, but if my dog died... I'd do just like everyone else, go get a new one. I also love my 42" LCD monitor, I would be sad if it broke, but it's an object... just like my dog, replaceable. My immediate family is the only thing in this world that is irreplaceable to me.


 
backstop
offline
Link
 
This thread is retarded.

Vick committed a crime, and did his time, it's a moot point after that. He should be able to play. In fact he would have legal precedence on his side and could probably win a lawsuit against the league and force them to let him play. Now if no one will offer him that's another story.

If he was smart he'd play a year or 2 in that new league that's kicking off this fall and move back into the NFL after that. They'd suck him off to have him play for them.

As for dog fighting it's not the fighting that was reprehensible (though it's not my cup of tea) it was the torturous way he treated the animals in general that was fucked up. Anyone who does the things he did to those dogs has some screws loose. All this moral relativism is asinine.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by backstop
As for dog fighting it's not the fighting that was reprehensible (though it's not my cup of tea) it was the torturous way he treated the animals in general that was fucked up. Anyone who does the things he did to those dogs has some screws loose. All this moral relativism is asinine.


Obviously you feel that the "torture" was wrong. My entire point is either you have a little conviction and fight to protect all animals or you view them as instruments to be used and abused. Anything less is hypocrisy.

Moral relativism is a part of life. Morals are perspective based. There's no absolute right and no absolute wrong. Right and/or wrong are subjective to the individual. I'm merely trying to show people that their hypocrites... sitting their eating a cheeseburger, while petting their dog, then getting upset that Michael Vick killed a few dogs... ignorance is bliss, right.

How many animals are each of us responsible for killing? Thousands would be my guess. We just ignore the fact that animals are breed and raised, before being slaughtered, just so that we can merrily over eat our fat asses into bliss. God forbid some guy kills a few dogs. You may call it torture, but I call it killing... since it is generally brutal. When you get a lethal injection, you can tell me how painless it is. I'm not going to try and speak like I know whether it's painful or not. Taking a life is brutal, regardless of how much you dress it up.

Think about that the next time you order a big mac. I'll savor every bite, because I'm not deluding myself into some gray area nonsense.
 
backstop
offline
Link
 
You're a narcissistic blowhard who likes to read his own writing and fancies himself an intellectual. Everyone is a hypocrite at some point, as every parent can attest, however if your trying to equate what was done to those dogs to the slaughter of livestock then you're just being disingenuous to flex your obviously superior intellect.

It's ludicrous to say one must "protect all animals" or none at all. What does that mean anyway? However to use your criteria to not be a hypocrite I offer this: I don't believe my burger should be shocked, beaten, and hung/strangled before I put cheese and bacon on it either. And before you even go there, no, domesticated livestock are not on the same level as a dog in my opinion. There are many animals that I feel deserve to be considered in a higher category than merely an animal. Dogs would be one, whales and dolphins (and most of the higher sea mammals), many parrot species, elephants, among others. That being said I don't think any animal deserves to be killed in such a manner.

Contrary to your opinion there are many ways to cleanly and humanely kill something, just as there are ways to make it protracted and painful. Think about this if there was no difference in the way something is killed (because it's generally brutal right?) then why did he kill them in such a manner. Why didn't he just put a bullet in the brain and call it a day? I'll tell you why. Because there is a difference. He was gonna show that fucking dog what's up. That bitch is gonna pay for costing him.....whatever. He wanted the animal to suffer for it's insolence and feel maximum pain before expiring. Additionally by killing them in that way he makes a statement a clean kill doesn't. That he's a bad ass, that his dogs have to be only the toughest, only the best. The more brutal and torturous the better when it comes to street cred. Those 2 examples couldn't be more different, and if you can't see the difference your damaged goods.

In any case this isn't about that at all. It's about whether Vick should be able to play in the NFL again, and again I say yes he should. He's a disturbed scumbag but he's done his time. Now stop psychoanalyzing the forum.
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by backstop
This thread is retarded.


 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by backstop
You're a narcissistic blowhard who likes to read his own writing and fancies himself an intellectual. Everyone is a hypocrite at some point, as every parent can attest, however if your trying to equate what was done to those dogs to the slaughter of livestock then you're just being disingenuous to flex your obviously superior intellect.

Thanks. I love it when people try and refer to being intellectual as a bad trait to possess... as for being disingenuous, I'm talking in absolutes... not trying to twist something to suit my views.

It's ludicrous to say one must "protect all animals" or none at all. What does that mean anyway? However to use your criteria to not be a hypocrite I offer this: I don't believe my burger should be shocked, beaten, and hung/strangled before I put cheese and bacon on it either. And before you even go there, no, domesticated livestock are not on the same level as a dog in my opinion. There are many animals that I feel deserve to be considered in a higher category than merely an animal. Dogs would be one, whales and dolphins (and most of the higher sea mammals), many parrot species, elephants, among others. That being said I don't think any animal deserves to be killed in such a manner.

Why is it ludicrous? You're basically saying that it's ok to steal, as long as you don't steal too much. Killing is killing, mankind is the only one who puts a sliding scale on the act. I do appreciate you making my case for me though... you twist your logic to suit your own agenda/beliefs/opinions. Guessing by your avatar, you have some affiliation with the Marine Corps. Maybe you should reflect on the values that they teach. Then again, I got out of the Military because it's full of double standards, you're probably a good example why.

Contrary to your opinion there are many ways to cleanly and humanely kill something, just as there are ways to make it protracted and painful. Think about this if there was no difference in the way something is killed (because it's generally brutal right?) then why did he kill them in such a manner. Why didn't he just put a bullet in the brain and call it a day? I'll tell you why. Because there is a difference. He was gonna show that fucking dog what's up. That bitch is gonna pay for costing him.....whatever. He wanted the animal to suffer for it's insolence and feel maximum pain before expiring. Additionally by killing them in that way he makes a statement a clean kill doesn't. That he's a bad ass, that his dogs have to be only the toughest, only the best. The more brutal and torturous the better when it comes to street cred. Those 2 examples couldn't be more different, and if you can't see the difference your damaged goods.

So I'm "damaged goods" because I don't buy the bullshit that you shovel? Sorry, maybe you just don't like being called out as a hypocrite... yet you lack the ability to defend your opinions, instead you attempt to attack my credibility. See, unlike you, I know full well what my issues are and readily admit them (no matter the consequences). That's called strength of character.

In any case this isn't about that at all. It's about whether Vick should be able to play in the NFL again, and again I say yes he should. He's a disturbed scumbag but he's done his time. Now stop psychoanalyzing the forum.

Sure it is. People want to cast stones from their glass houses. This ties right into the topic of the OP. I'm merely showing how hypocritical it is of them to take their stance.


 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

By manipulating the circumstances to take away a real choice. Put the animal in a certain state of mind and more than likely it'll act accordingly.


Not when you have two dogs that possess gameness. Take my current dog for example. He'll shy away from a fight in heartbeat. My previous dog would fight the second he perceived the other dog was trying to be dominant over him.

Put two dogs in the ring, if they want to fight, they'll fight. If they don't want to fight, they won't. Why they have rules within the ring when the dog turns away or disengages or attempts to escape from the fight.

Originally posted by
Not true. Some may find food and flourish, but many won't last long. Their parents didn't teach them to hunt and their instincts are diluted from generations upon generations of domestication. Hell, look at how much trouble wildlife workers have re-introducing orphaned animals back into the wild.


Hunting is instinctual. It's also survival of the fittest. Ever read the reports of starving cougars or bears that have attacked people? These animals were born and raised in the wild and yet they were going without food. It doesn't take long for a domesticated animal to return to it's feral roots and a prime example are feral cats.

Originally posted by
No. I'm merely pointing out that survival entails more than just the quest for food. If you look closely, you'll also see how the connection to man has also warped domesticated animals... who now mimic man's killing for reasons other than survival. If an animal kills another animal in the wild, it's for some reason linked to survival... that's how Nature works.


The same survival argument can be linked to the actions of man when they kill an animal.

Originally posted by
So if you condone hunting for sport, why don't you condone dog fighting? Both are identical IMHO, death for entertainment. Both also help control the animal populations.


Dog fighting is something I will not participate in. I'm not required to financially support an activity that I find disagreeable. But I will defend the activity with a couple of caveats. Additionally, I don't hunt for sport. I hunt to kill the animal with the intention of either eating it or selling the products of the animal. I could really care less how the animal dies or what I kill it with, 'cept in most cases I prefer a quick, clean kill (for those that I eat) because adrenalin tends to give the meat a very game flavor. One of the points I'm getting at here is that the state refers to hunting and fishing as a sport, a sport that entails the use of animals by people that generally results in the death of the animal. How is the death of a deer via gunshot or arrow morally superior to the death of a dog in a fighting ring? They're both sports, correct?

When we're discussing the aspects of dogfighting Vick was performing, which was of a professional level, yes, the fight is entertainment, but the goal is to improve the breed to their standards. It's no different than horse racing.

A person who condemns one use of animals while declaring their use of animals to be morally superior is a hypocrite.

Originally posted by
Yes, but I'm a bit of a sociopath. Plus, I generally dislike people. What difference does the person understanding this fact make?


The dog doesn't understand that if it turns from the fight that it's death is more than likely imminent. The dog is also not forced to fight. When it comes to people, you're willing to coerce them with the threat of death to watch them fight for your entertainment. It's not voluntary on the person's part and it contradicts your statement that animals are tools and can be used as the owner sees fit. It's slavery.

Originally posted by
You're weaving a fine line between both sides of the argument. Some of your points contradict others.


Nope. Being honest. Showing the hypocrisy of others.

Originally posted by
How is that relevant to the discussion? Unless we somehow shifted the topic to talking about people seizing your animals to use in dog fighting. Wouldn't the same concept apply in reverse? Meaning that I can destroy my property as I see fit.


Relevant due to the fact that the dogs Vick was fighting were his dogs. He can fight his dogs all he wants so long as he isn't fighting mine. I'm still not required to associate or conduct business with him if I find his actions disagreeable or unacceptable.

Everything revolves around property rights. What right do I have to walk onto your property and under the threat of force dictate that you treat your property in accordance with my ideals?

Originally posted by
I don't condone dog fighting and I love my own dog, but if my dog died... I'd do just like everyone else, go get a new one. I also love my 42" LCD monitor, I would be sad if it broke, but it's an object... just like my dog, replaceable. My immediate family is the only thing in this world that is irreplaceable to me.


Agreed.



 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Festus
Not when you have two dogs that possess gameness. Take my current dog for example. He'll shy away from a fight in heartbeat. My previous dog would fight the second he perceived the other dog was trying to be dominant over him.

Put two dogs in the ring, if they want to fight, they'll fight. If they don't want to fight, they won't. Why they have rules within the ring when the dog turns away or disengages or attempts to escape from the fight.

You can manipulate anything that you have control over and understand. Put a dog in a certain state of mind and it will want to fight. As for knowing the rules of a dogfight, I wouldn't have the slightest clue.

Hunting is instinctual. It's also survival of the fittest. Ever read the reports of starving cougars or bears that have attacked people? These animals were born and raised in the wild and yet they were going without food. It doesn't take long for a domesticated animal to return to it's feral roots and a prime example are feral cats.

Not entirely true. Like I said before, there's examples of both situations in Nature. Animals adapting and animals failing to adapt (even with man's assistance). Also, for every feral cat that does succeed, there's just as many that cannot. Plus many of the feral cats that do survive get assistance from men.

The same survival argument can be linked to the actions of man when they kill an animal.

Unlike animals, man doesn't need to feed on animals to survive. At the very least, we don't need to kill as many as we do. Animals do not kill without a specific reason (or actual necessity)... be it food, defense or territory.

Dog fighting is something I will not participate in. I'm not required to financially support an activity that I find disagreeable. But I will defend the activity with a couple of caveats. Additionally, I don't hunt for sport. I hunt to kill the animal with the intention of either eating it or selling the products of the animal. I could really care less how the animal dies or what I kill it with, 'cept in most cases I prefer a quick, clean kill (for those that I eat) because adrenalin tends to give the meat a very game flavor. One of the points I'm getting at here is that the state refers to hunting and fishing as a sport, a sport that entails the use of animals by people that generally results in the death of the animal. How is the death of a deer via gunshot or arrow morally superior to the death of a dog in a fighting ring? They're both sports, correct?

When we're discussing the aspects of dogfighting Vick was performing, which was of a professional level, yes, the fight is entertainment, but the goal is to improve the breed to their standards. It's no different than horse racing.

A person who condemns one use of animals while declaring their use of animals to be morally superior is a hypocrite.

So, I'm a little confused... you're agreeing with my stance... why are we arguing?

The dog doesn't understand that if it turns from the fight that it's death is more than likely imminent. The dog is also not forced to fight. When it comes to people, you're willing to coerce them with the threat of death to watch them fight for your entertainment. It's not voluntary on the person's part and it contradicts your statement that animals are tools and can be used as the owner sees fit. It's slavery.

Slavery is another of those subjective topics. It's existed through-out the history of men, only recently it's changed to be more of an illusion/veil. It still exists, most people just delude themselves into thinking that they have a "real" choice. We're still puppets, the strings have changed though. Instead of whips and threats of force, it's now policies and laws which manipulate us. The manipulation still exists, it's merely less blatant and less complete.

Nope. Being honest. Showing the hypocrisy of others.

Then you merely fail at debate. No need to argue on both sides of a discussion to make a point. It only causes confusion and makes people unsure of what you're trying to convey.

Relevant due to the fact that the dogs Vick was fighting were his dogs. He can fight his dogs all he wants so long as he isn't fighting mine. I'm still not required to associate or conduct business with him if I find his actions disagreeable or unacceptable.

Everything revolves around property rights. What right do I have to walk onto your property and under the threat of force dictate that you treat your property in accordance with my ideals?

You're free to make that decision. Again, what does that have to do with the topic? The NFL will make a decision on the situation... you as a fan then can make a decision whether you still want to support the NFL (based on their decision). The guy did the crime and he did his time, you're attempting to impose additional punishment on him by going out of your way to prevent him from playing in the NFL again. If you feel that his punishment wasn't fitting the crime, put that energy into trying to change the system... not trying to just change this single instance.


 
ANumber1Roy
offline
Link
 
I can't believe this thread is still going.
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Originally posted by backstop

This thread is retarded.




 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Um yes he should. My QB agrees! At the end of the day it's goddamn pitbulls. He broke the law, he did his time, now let him go on with his life. And to your point...So if I kill an adult by driving drunk, I should be allowed back in the NFL because they had a voice? (btw, this has happened already) But animal cruelty = lifetime ban? Meanwhile, pedos are winning grammy awards and still playing pro sports. Our country has logic backwards.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt

Originally posted by backstop


This thread is retarded.






 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kmart
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt

Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt


Originally posted by backstop



This thread is retarded.








 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.