User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > Something about the Bible I honestly want to know
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
What I mean is aside from the parables we take it pretty literal


yes, but in the sense of biblical literalism, not raw literalism/constructivism.

further, there is a significant population of liberal christians (especially in europe) that follow neo-augustinian heuristics for interpreting the bible -- meaning, there may be a literal meaning that requires digging into the original language and fully understanding it's context... but the real spiritual meaning is found through a higher interpretation.

since the 'fourth great awakening' in the US, the charismatic/evangelical wing has veered back towards a more literal approach... but still not as far as the early constructivists, and thus still somewhat liberal.
 
Link
 
This must be stuff going on in different denominations
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious
Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.

not a non sequitur.
also, i'm quite obviously speaking of the general non-trinitarian position (would you prefer "arianism" instead?) that jesus was not divine.

Arianism is not the only non-trinitarian viewpoint, but:

uh... which is why i started with "non-trinitarianism". it was you who wanted to quibble.

Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by
Arius had a simple formula for explaining how Jesus Christ could be divine—and therefore worthy of worship along with God the Father—even though there is only one God.
http://christianodyssey.com/god/jesusgod.htm

okay, but now you're conflating two radically different senses of the word "divine".

in theology, the word "divinity" is kept within the bounds of its latin etymology and is roughly synonymous with deity (i say roughly, because there are some qualitative distinctions with notions of godhead and atavism, especially in eastern religions).

if you mean jesus was divine in the sense that he was a special dude with some connections to heaven, then fine... although the majority of muslims and even some jews feel the same way. but if you're talking about the divinity of jesus in the theological sense, then i'll once again point you to the non-trinitarians (among others).
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
What verse(s), chapter, book were her comments?


well, i'm running out of time to go pull up verses, but i'm referring to the comments she made that prompted abraham to get it on with hagar in the first place.

also, how does your interpretation account for the abram/sarai → abraham/sarah conversion?

probably the easiest thing here is for you to just spell out the narrative...
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Sureal
Captobvious,
Please give me a reference of the objective definition of a Christian that "we" have.

Sure. It's called a dictionary.


?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
This must be stuff going on in different denominations


which stuff?
 
Ted Buckland
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
Originally posted by ddriver80

all this blasphemy makes me want to pray....








Our spaghetti
Who art in the colander
Hallowed be thy sauce
Thy serving come
Thy strands be wrung
On forks as they are on spoons
Give us this day our daily meatball
And forgive us our starchiness
As we forgive those who are starchy against us
And lead us not into Kraft parmessan
But deliver us from Chef Boy Ardee
For thine is the garlic
And the onion and the bay leaves
For ever and ever.
Ramen


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

I couldn't stop laughing


don't laugh at my religions prayer please, don't be disrespectful like that
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious

Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by captobvious

Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.

not a non sequitur.
also, i'm quite obviously speaking of the general non-trinitarian position (would you prefer "arianism" instead?) that jesus was not divine.

Arianism is not the only non-trinitarian viewpoint, but:

uh... which is why i started with "non-trinitarianism". it was you who wanted to quibble.


No, you did. I gave a universally-accepted definition of the word "Christian." You're the one who is quibbling.

There are plenty of other non-trinitarian Christian viewpoints, but they all agree that Jesus is divine. Argue about one or argue about many, the point still remains.
Originally posted by

Originally posted by captobvious

Originally posted by

Arius had a simple formula for explaining how Jesus Christ could be divine—and therefore worthy of worship along with God the Father—even though there is only one God.
http://christianodyssey.com/god/jesusgod.htm

okay, but now you're conflating two radically different senses of the word "divine".

in theology, the word "divinity" is kept within the bounds of its latin etymology and is roughly synonymous with deity (i say roughly, because there are some qualitative distinctions with notions of godhead and atavism, especially in eastern religions).

if you mean jesus was divine in the sense that he was a special dude with some connections to heaven, then fine... although the majority of muslims and even some jews feel the same way. but if you're talking about the divinity of jesus in the theological sense, then i'll once again point you to the non-trinitarians (among others).


I'm not conflating anything. The notion of higher/lower gods is not unique to Arianism. Whether the gods are equal or one outranks the other, they're both divine.
Edited by captobvious on Jun 9, 2009 14:54:38
Edited by captobvious on Jun 9, 2009 14:54:16
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious
Non sequiter. Whether Jesus is seen as part of the Trinity, the son of God, or an embodiment of God, he remains divine.

not a non sequitur.
also, i'm quite obviously speaking of the general non-trinitarian position (would you prefer "arianism" instead?) that jesus was not divine.

Arianism is not the only non-trinitarian viewpoint, but:

uh... which is why i started with "non-trinitarianism". it was you who wanted to quibble.

No, you did. I gave a universally-accepted definition of the word "Christian." You're the one who is quibbling.
There are plenty of other non-trinitarian Christian viewpoints, but they all agree that Jesus is divine. Argue about one or argue about many, the point still remains.

false.

for starters, that most certainly wasn't a "universally-accepted" definition. not even close... hence my rejoinder about non-trinitarians. not only are you now pulling a self-sealing fallacy here yourself, but you're quite nicely proving my original point about how all these definitions are actually subjective.

theologically speaking, anti-trinitarians deny the divinity of jesus and non-trinitarians (almost by definition) do roughly the same. trust me, you're flat-out wrong here.

Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by
Arius had a simple formula for explaining how Jesus Christ could be divine—and therefore worthy of worship along with God the Father—even though there is only one God.
http://christianodyssey.com/god/jesusgod.htm

okay, but now you're conflating two radically different senses of the word "divine".
in theology, the word "divinity" is kept within the bounds of its latin etymology and is roughly synonymous with deity (i say roughly, because there are some qualitative distinctions with notions of godhead and atavism, especially in eastern religions).
if you mean jesus was divine in the sense that he was a special dude with some connections to heaven, then fine... although the majority of muslims and even some jews feel the same way. but if you're talking about the divinity of jesus in the theological sense, then i'll once again point you to the non-trinitarians (among others).

I'm not conflating anything. The notion of higher/lower gods is not unique to Arianism. Whether the gods are equal or one outranks the other, they're both divine.


is there a reason why you're suddenly talking about "higher/lower gods"?!? and what on earth does that have to do with arianism?

and you're still not properly parsing the different usages of "divinity" here. i was quite obviously speaking within a theological context -- why go about furiously slaying strawmen that don't even exist?
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
for starters, that most certainly wasn't a "universally-accepted" definition. not even close... hence my rejoinder about non-trinitarians. not only are you now pulling a self-sealing fallacy here yourself, but you're quite nicely proving my original point about how all these definitions are actually subjective.


If you have a better definition of Christian, then, I'd be happy to hear it.

Originally posted by

theologically speaking, anti-trinitarians deny the divinity of jesus and non-trinitarians (almost by definition) do roughly the same. trust me, you're flat-out wrong here.


Epic fail.

1) You're absolutely wrong.
2) You're making a statement while producing no evidence to back it up. One Christian sect which does not believe in the divinity of Jesus would be sufficient.

Originally posted by captobvious

is there a reason why you're suddenly talking about "higher/lower gods"?!? and what on earth does that have to do with arianism?


Yes. It's because I understand Arianism. Arius saw Jesus as separate from God, and subordinate to him, but still divine.

Honestly, if you don't even know the basics of Arianism, why do you keep arguing from it? A casual acquaintance with Arianism discredits your argument and proves mine.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arianism

Originally posted by
and you're still not properly parsing the different usages of "divinity" here. i was quite obviously speaking within a theological context -- why go about furiously slaying strawmen that don't even exist?


There are no usages of the word "divinity" that are invalid when used in a theological context.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.