I am happy my team got promoted. I just wished I could be in WE but AA is fine. I think getting promoted is the top goal or should be. Thats why I say 1 more AA league. It should also water it down to make it less competitive to prevent the fear factor you speak of.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort answered Questions/Concerns about restructure here (after a few pages of complaints about thread-locking)
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Originally posted by Nyr3270
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I would suggest filling each AA league with one more league taken from the uncapped cloud. It would be possible to have 5 AA leagues in each region and then only 2 AAA leagues. I know it would look funny but it may reduce lots of complaints as higher leveled uncapped teams will be in AA and some may actually get to be in the region of choice.
I only took playoff teams when doing promotions to AA, and I think that there ended up not being enough of those. Not sure if want to promote non-playoff teams (who are likely not ready to play up there!)
But a playoff team who goes 9-7 and got destroyed by a team in the first round as an 8-seed and definitely has improvement to do is promotion-wortthy? http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1250
You mean, if I wanted to stay in a fair league, I gotta throw my last game?
That's a symptom of the promotion system itself.
The problem:
People in higher leagues want teams to move up so they don't have to play CPU's. Ok, sounds great, to them. People in lower leagues don't want to move up because they aren't "ready" for whatever reason. Now, some would say "sack up" and often they would be right. Sometimes, though, I agree that there just aren't enough teams ready to move up. I don't know what the solution is, though...you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the upper levels have to play CPU's, or the lower levels have to move up. One or the other; what's it gonna be?
Teams at the top earned it tbh... It's a hard decision to make, but I think you've made the right ones. The top teams have paid the flex and have the hardest time recruiting, etc. You have to reward those at the top.
Their "reward" is often a promotion into a league they have no prayer of competing in though. Except by cutting all the players that made them a good team and re-recruiting.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I would suggest filling each AA league with one more league taken from the uncapped cloud. It would be possible to have 5 AA leagues in each region and then only 2 AAA leagues. I know it would look funny but it may reduce lots of complaints as higher leveled uncapped teams will be in AA and some may actually get to be in the region of choice.
I only took playoff teams when doing promotions to AA, and I think that there ended up not being enough of those. Not sure if want to promote non-playoff teams (who are likely not ready to play up there!)
But a playoff team who goes 9-7 and got destroyed by a team in the first round as an 8-seed and definitely has improvement to do is promotion-wortthy? http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1250
You mean, if I wanted to stay in a fair league, I gotta throw my last game?
That's a symptom of the promotion system itself.
The problem:
People in higher leagues want teams to move up so they don't have to play CPU's. Ok, sounds great, to them. People in lower leagues don't want to move up because they aren't "ready" for whatever reason. Now, some would say "sack up" and often they would be right. Sometimes, though, I agree that there just aren't enough teams ready to move up. I don't know what the solution is, though...you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the upper levels have to play CPU's, or the lower levels have to move up. One or the other; what's it gonna be?
Teams at the top earned it tbh... It's a hard decision to make, but I think you've made the right ones. The top teams have paid the flex and have the hardest time recruiting, etc. You have to reward those at the top.
Their "reward" is often a promotion into a league they have no prayer of competing in though. Except by cutting all the players that made them a good team and re-recruiting.
RWCol2011
offline
offline
Soooo Bort since appearantley my support pm was read is anyone gonna respond to it or help now or what? Sorry to bother you but ive been waiting to hear back for a week.
headsigh
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I would suggest filling each AA league with one more league taken from the uncapped cloud. It would be possible to have 5 AA leagues in each region and then only 2 AAA leagues. I know it would look funny but it may reduce lots of complaints as higher leveled uncapped teams will be in AA and some may actually get to be in the region of choice.
I only took playoff teams when doing promotions to AA, and I think that there ended up not being enough of those. Not sure if want to promote non-playoff teams (who are likely not ready to play up there!)
But a playoff team who goes 9-7 and got destroyed by a team in the first round as an 8-seed and definitely has improvement to do is promotion-wortthy? http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1250
You mean, if I wanted to stay in a fair league, I gotta throw my last game?
That's a symptom of the promotion system itself.
The problem:
People in higher leagues want teams to move up so they don't have to play CPU's. Ok, sounds great, to them. People in lower leagues don't want to move up because they aren't "ready" for whatever reason. Now, some would say "sack up" and often they would be right. Sometimes, though, I agree that there just aren't enough teams ready to move up. I don't know what the solution is, though...you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the upper levels have to play CPU's, or the lower levels have to move up. One or the other; what's it gonna be?
If these lower level guys move up and get murdered early and often, what's the point?
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I would suggest filling each AA league with one more league taken from the uncapped cloud. It would be possible to have 5 AA leagues in each region and then only 2 AAA leagues. I know it would look funny but it may reduce lots of complaints as higher leveled uncapped teams will be in AA and some may actually get to be in the region of choice.
I only took playoff teams when doing promotions to AA, and I think that there ended up not being enough of those. Not sure if want to promote non-playoff teams (who are likely not ready to play up there!)
But a playoff team who goes 9-7 and got destroyed by a team in the first round as an 8-seed and definitely has improvement to do is promotion-wortthy? http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1250
You mean, if I wanted to stay in a fair league, I gotta throw my last game?
That's a symptom of the promotion system itself.
The problem:
People in higher leagues want teams to move up so they don't have to play CPU's. Ok, sounds great, to them. People in lower leagues don't want to move up because they aren't "ready" for whatever reason. Now, some would say "sack up" and often they would be right. Sometimes, though, I agree that there just aren't enough teams ready to move up. I don't know what the solution is, though...you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the upper levels have to play CPU's, or the lower levels have to move up. One or the other; what's it gonna be?
If these lower level guys move up and get murdered early and often, what's the point?
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
That's a symptom of the promotion system itself.
The problem:
People in higher leagues want teams to move up so they don't have to play CPU's. Ok, sounds great, to them. People in lower leagues don't want to move up because they aren't "ready" for whatever reason. Now, some would say "sack up" and often they would be right. Sometimes, though, I agree that there just aren't enough teams ready to move up. I don't know what the solution is, though...you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the upper levels have to play CPU's, or the lower levels have to move up. One or the other; what's it gonna be?
Bort, one thing that would help is if you actually enforced suggested levels. This would be a tremendous step.
That's a symptom of the promotion system itself.
The problem:
People in higher leagues want teams to move up so they don't have to play CPU's. Ok, sounds great, to them. People in lower leagues don't want to move up because they aren't "ready" for whatever reason. Now, some would say "sack up" and often they would be right. Sometimes, though, I agree that there just aren't enough teams ready to move up. I don't know what the solution is, though...you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the upper levels have to play CPU's, or the lower levels have to move up. One or the other; what's it gonna be?
Bort, one thing that would help is if you actually enforced suggested levels. This would be a tremendous step.
Originally posted by Nyr3270
Teams at the top earned it tbh... It's a hard decision to make, but I think you've made the right ones. The top teams have paid the flex and have the hardest time recruiting, etc. You have to reward those at the top.
It seems to make sense, yes, but also there are also 1000's more teams at the bottom than there are at the top, so that must be taken into account. I mean, generally, enough lowbie teams move up together that they play each other and do fine, but there always seems to be that juggernaut team looming over everyone.
Teams at the top earned it tbh... It's a hard decision to make, but I think you've made the right ones. The top teams have paid the flex and have the hardest time recruiting, etc. You have to reward those at the top.
It seems to make sense, yes, but also there are also 1000's more teams at the bottom than there are at the top, so that must be taken into account. I mean, generally, enough lowbie teams move up together that they play each other and do fine, but there always seems to be that juggernaut team looming over everyone.
Originally posted by RWCol2011
Soooo Bort since appearantley my support pm was read is anyone gonna respond to it or help now or what? Sorry to bother you but ive been waiting to hear back for a week.
The one you sent yesteday? I'm sure it's in the queue to be answered. I didn't look too closely at the particular team in question, but CPU teams have been pushed all over the place at this point, and may not even belong to a league any more.
Soooo Bort since appearantley my support pm was read is anyone gonna respond to it or help now or what? Sorry to bother you but ive been waiting to hear back for a week.
The one you sent yesteday? I'm sure it's in the queue to be answered. I didn't look too closely at the particular team in question, but CPU teams have been pushed all over the place at this point, and may not even belong to a league any more.
Adderfist
offline
offline
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'. Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
Edited by Adderfist on Jun 5, 2009 16:55:00
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Bort, one thing that would help is if you actually enforced suggested levels. This would be a tremendous step.
Do you mean force players off a team when they are too high of a level? That doesn't sound like a good plan, really.
Bort, one thing that would help is if you actually enforced suggested levels. This would be a tremendous step.
Do you mean force players off a team when they are too high of a level? That doesn't sound like a good plan, really.
Originally posted by Adderfist
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
I think it just happened to be the one with a lot of posts; not sure, I was asleep when it got moved around. Agree, it's a bad title.
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
I think it just happened to be the one with a lot of posts; not sure, I was asleep when it got moved around. Agree, it's a bad title.
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Originally posted by Adderfist
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
That is a function of Jed being a horrible mod. And the people above him are covering for him.
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
That is a function of Jed being a horrible mod. And the people above him are covering for him.
RWCol2011
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by RWCol2011
Soooo Bort since appearantley my support pm was read is anyone gonna respond to it or help now or what? Sorry to bother you but ive been waiting to hear back for a week.
The one you sent yesteday? I'm sure it's in the queue to be answered. I didn't look too closely at the particular team in question, but CPU teams have been pushed all over the place at this point, and may not even belong to a league any more.
Actually the first pm I sent was over a week ago, I got one response, and havent heard back to solve the problem in I think 4 maybe 5 days now. If someone would have replied then we could easily have solved it by now but since no one replied I sent in my question again last night hoping it would have gotten solved, but it didnt obvi.
If you would open your inbox to me this would be easier
Originally posted by RWCol2011
Soooo Bort since appearantley my support pm was read is anyone gonna respond to it or help now or what? Sorry to bother you but ive been waiting to hear back for a week.
The one you sent yesteday? I'm sure it's in the queue to be answered. I didn't look too closely at the particular team in question, but CPU teams have been pushed all over the place at this point, and may not even belong to a league any more.
Actually the first pm I sent was over a week ago, I got one response, and havent heard back to solve the problem in I think 4 maybe 5 days now. If someone would have replied then we could easily have solved it by now but since no one replied I sent in my question again last night hoping it would have gotten solved, but it didnt obvi.
If you would open your inbox to me this would be easier
AngryDragon
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Adderfist
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
I think it just happened to be the one with a lot of posts; not sure, I was asleep when it got moved around. Agree, it's a bad title.
I compiled the complaints from page 1-14 for easy reading.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2765508&page=14
scroll down.
Originally posted by Adderfist
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
I think it just happened to be the one with a lot of posts; not sure, I was asleep when it got moved around. Agree, it's a bad title.
I compiled the complaints from page 1-14 for easy reading.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2765508&page=14
scroll down.
Edited by AngryDragon on Jun 5, 2009 16:57:22
Adderfist
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Adderfist
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
I think it just happened to be the one with a lot of posts; not sure, I was asleep when it got moved around. Agree, it's a bad title.
Create a new thread, Call it something like... "Issues with the cloud reorganization"
Use the merge command, Merge that thread into it.
Sticky new thread
Profit?
Originally posted by Adderfist
My major concern is, the excuse has always been 'we don't have the tools for that'.
Well. You have the tools now, and a merge is the only correct answer when dealing with this.
Also, Why on earth would you make the 'official' thread on this, with the title "The Official Complaint Thread - Because lord knows there'll be a lot of crying today". Don't you feel that's more then just a little insulting to someone with a legitimate complaint?
I think it just happened to be the one with a lot of posts; not sure, I was asleep when it got moved around. Agree, it's a bad title.
Create a new thread, Call it something like... "Issues with the cloud reorganization"
Use the merge command, Merge that thread into it.
Sticky new thread
Profit?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























