User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Season 9 is fantastically better than Season 8 so far.


It's giving me headaches keeping up with all the defenses, but the diversity is excellent compared to last season.


Season 8 was a seaqson where if you had a very good powerback, very few teams could stop you. Scouting really didn't matter, nor did tactics really. Teams lined up and drove the ball down each other's throats. I'll give the Fins credit, they somehow managed to find a way to throw lasy season, when pretty much no-one else could.

This season is very difficult as a DC. We haven't run the same defense two games in a row now, and the amount of scouting is simply ugly. Offenses are running a much larger variety of plays and they are all pretty much doing it well, which makes setting up single defenses tricky. If you overload to stop a specific play, then there are a series of other plays that all attack different areas than the main play.

I understand some of the frustration, but the main problems I am seeing right now are the teams that can run a special teams unit specifically set up with the special teams VAs. As there are very few tactics available to counter that.

PinTBC
 
Falhawk
offline
Link
 
advanced AI ruined glb IMO. It was great at first but its become too ridiculous now, especially with bort's wild changes.

Basically the game was a lot more fun when it was about individual player builds and deciding "do we want to pass 60% of the time or 70%"
 
TheAn5wer11
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Falhawk
advanced AI ruined glb IMO. It was great at first but its become too ridiculous now, especially with bort's wild changes.

Basically the game was a lot more fun when it was about individual player builds and deciding "do we want to pass 60% of the time or 70%"


Exactly! Don't forget the VA mess..
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Falhawk
advanced AI ruined glb IMO. It was great at first but its become too ridiculous now, especially with bort's wild changes.

Basically the game was a lot more fun when it was about individual player builds and deciding "do we want to pass 60% of the time or 70%"


I would definitely prefer my team to be a basic AI team.

Honestly, I think a single 4-tiered Advanced AI region would be more than enough to quench the hardcore gamers, and the rest of the teams could all be basic.

Even better:

EVERY player gets onto a basic AI team where they earn their XP and get their money, and there is a simultaneous (and much smaller) Advanced AI league system where only the best players will be recruited to play and money/seats, salaries, and all that garbage don't come into play..
Last edited May 2, 2009 14:10:53
 
vladd148
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Falhawk

advanced AI ruined glb IMO. It was great at first but its become too ridiculous now, especially with bort's wild changes.

Basically the game was a lot more fun when it was about individual player builds and deciding "do we want to pass 60% of the time or 70%"


I would definitely prefer my team to be a basic AI team.

Honestly, I think a single 4-tiered Advanced AI region would be more than enough to quench the hardcore gamers, and the rest of the teams could all be basic.

Even better:

EVERY player gets onto a basic AI team where they earn their XP and get their money, and there is a simultaneous (and much smaller) Advanced AI league system where only the best players will be recruited to play and money/seats, salaries, and all that garbage don't come into play..


+100000
 
confidential
offline
Link
 
it went from a fun casual game where you could rile people up with a little trash talk to just way too complicated. basically became any other mmorpg and the wow/eve type nerds with time to waste will obviously do much better.
 
vladd148
offline
Link
 
Sim's been broken since season 6 IMO, and is no longer "casual" since only the hardcore people seem to win. Bort doesn't give a shit about it as long as he keeps wheeling in money.
 
Ladyzman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by confidential
it went from a fun casual game where you could rile people up with a little trash talk to just way too complicated. basically became any other mmorpg and the wow/eve type nerds with time to waste will obviously do much better.


Woah Woah Woah
I play WoW sir!
And this time thing you talk about isnt there.
Lets see, I raid 2 nights a week and maybe chill for a couple hours soooo, maybe 12 hours a week on it.
And complicated, lmao!
Not really that hard, but like any game, you have a lot of dumb fucks that dont understand the mechanics of the game and don't try to read up to understand so in turn whine when they suck at it or it isnt easy mode for everyone to just get free loot!

But i agree on this game, it has gotten more complicated to win. I tried to look at the defense AI and was like, "fuck that!" But im sure learning it wouldn't be that bad if i had a lower league team to test shit out and get decent enough to come here and do it. Time and learning are 2 factors i just don't have right now and i can understand that being a problem for ppl. Best thing i can say is find you some wow/eve nerds to come manage your shit till you get the time to learn how to do it yourself.

Oh, and if y'all think this game is fucked up and there is a lot of whining, you haven't played WoW, lmao! The shit they do sometimes is crazy, but hey, you just move on and learn to cope to the changes till they can get around to fixing them. No one is perfect, and the best thing i could tell Bort to do is to do it in small parts and just make weekly patches or bi-weekly to fix certain problems at a time.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Advanced AIs were fine. It's Bort's inability to produce balanced VAs that really crippled things - combined with doing nothing more but creating more work for coordinators and requiring them to spend more time doing it.

this season was the rl time/breaking point for me.


 
Veg
offline
Link
 
i love you islander
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Advanced AIs were fine. It's Bort's inability to produce balanced VAs that really crippled things - combined with doing nothing more but creating more work for coordinators and requiring them to spend more time doing it.

this season was the rl time/breaking point for me.




He really should have fixed the game mechanics before introducing something like VAs imo.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
I like this season.

GMs are relevant again.


...but, yeah, I'm sure a burnout is right around the corner for me...
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
When I started, this game was a very interesting excersize in player building with a fun SIM built around it. Both the player building and Sim were very raw, and needed to be fleshed out. Instead of beating the death out of the SIM and attribute system Bort decided to start implementing new features.

This is fun and interesting as the coder doesn't have to perform the drudge work of debugging and balancing the issues inherent in his code. Instead he applied patches to hide or cover some of the more objectionable bugs. The problem he is running into now is that instead of finding the root cause of problems, his first instinct is to patch the system.

For example, in season 6 the DEs really were too powerful. They were routinely destroying the OTs that were trying to block them. Some of the speed builds were simply cornerbacks playing defensive ends, and should have been pancaked every single running play, but somehow they weren't. The patch he put in artificially increased OT's abilities, while decreasing many of the speed/quickness abilities of the DE. Since season 6 DEs have been pretty much nothing more than a dot that on good teams could control the edge.

Had he really looked deep at the situation, he might have found some of the things he is trying to fix this season with offensive line stuns (a patch to reduce the effectiveness of the previous patch), quarterback vision checks etc..

Bort strikes me as a hell of a good idea guy, but not a very good designer, and a seriously bad debugger/tester.

PinTBC
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
The game was broke from inception, it just took a while for the brokenness to show up.

The fatal flaw was always having soft caps after which it cost more skill points to increase an attribute... but then not applying the caps to the free points you get upon leveling. I pointed this out in like season 2. Anybody with experience and a good eye for game design could see that. Many of the problems now are just snowballed from that initial mistake.

Of course it's almost impossible to fix now without a complete reset, which is why I suggested fixing it way back then when it was still possible.

That said, I think the sim this season is more fun than it's been in a long time. But it's getting REALLY crufty. At some point a complete reset will be required. I think Bort is just trying to ride the gravy train as long as possible before pulling the trigger.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
I too think this season is a lot more fun and a LOT more diverse as far as play calling goes. Heck, this is the first time in a long time I see one team leaning strongly toward the pass and another strongly toward the run and both can be successful. Season 8, not so much! If you didnt have a power back in season 8 you were considerably handicapped.

There is flaws in the Sim, but I think it has definitely moved in the right direction after a longgg offseason.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.