User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
FWIW, I'll admit that the fumble distribution may have swung too far to the other side of reasonable behavior... seems like a lot of the time when the sim has a "minor" adjustment, some pretty big effects are seen in game results. I think a lot of that may just be because folks need to adjust (equipment, team AI, player tactics, long-term builds, etc) from previously extreme setups, which takes a few games to figure out -- typically 10-12 weeks of the season before the community as a whole figures out how to adapt.


Considering the brokeass nature of finance in this game, the concept of "adjusting" equipment on an annual basis (although I've taken part) at this point makes me want to punch people in the face.

Not as much as when I am seeing my QB throw the ball away with the game on the line on 3rd down and 16 in the 2 minute drill vs. a 3 man rush.....then following it up with a 4th down and 16 checkdown of 6 yards while the primary route receiver was up top in single coverage with no safety in sight...

That makes me want to punch people in the face more.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by jrry32


I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.


I agree with this, too, and it was the point I was trying to make in my first post. I think this situation is very similar to what happened with OTs, when Bort made changes to the sim to try and create the results he wanted when builds were already being adjusted. After the builds were properly adjusted, Bort's previous changes became overpowered. This is why the "fix your build" argument has some validity to me, but once Bort has already intervened, fixing the builds may require too much work and lead to a single path for builds where there should be at least a little variety.



I guess that's true but I don't want him to make fumbles non existant again.


I don't want to make them nonexistent either. Never said I did. All I want is for the game to be realistic. I've spent a lot of time and money on this game, and if this is what happens... well then there's going to be another gutted team in SEA Pro Garuda this season.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by jrry32


I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.


I agree with this, too, and it was the point I was trying to make in my first post. I think this situation is very similar to what happened with OTs, when Bort made changes to the sim to try and create the results he wanted when builds were already being adjusted. After the builds were properly adjusted, Bort's previous changes became overpowered. This is why the "fix your build" argument has some validity to me, but once Bort has already intervened, fixing the builds may require too much work and lead to a single path for builds where there should be at least a little variety.



I guess that's true but I don't want him to make fumbles non existant again.


Agreed. My view is that if power backs are going to try and run directly over defenders, then they should fumble more often (and, more importantly, they can fix their builds in ways that make their builds still realistic for what they're trying to do). Maybe there's a way to make fumbles less likely against players running on the elusive end of the tactical spectrum, b/c, theoretically, the defender will have a harder time squaring up on the runner, and more likely against players running on the power end of the spectrum. This should preserve, to some extent, elusive builds and still allow for a reasonable amount of fumbles.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
strength should not make as big a difference in fumbling as it appears to. and like poot said options for the running back to have a cover up or fight for yards option would be the most realistic solution.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Originally posted by jrry32



I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.


I agree with this, too, and it was the point I was trying to make in my first post. I think this situation is very similar to what happened with OTs, when Bort made changes to the sim to try and create the results he wanted when builds were already being adjusted. After the builds were properly adjusted, Bort's previous changes became overpowered. This is why the "fix your build" argument has some validity to me, but once Bort has already intervened, fixing the builds may require too much work and lead to a single path for builds where there should be at least a little variety.



I guess that's true but I don't want him to make fumbles non existant again.


Agreed. My view is that if power backs are going to try and run directly over defenders, then they should fumble more often (and, more importantly, they can fix their builds in ways that make their builds still realistic for what they're trying to do). Maybe there's a way to make fumbles less likely against players running on the elusive end of the tactical spectrum, b/c, theoretically, the defender will have a harder time squaring up on the runner, and more likely against players running on the power end of the spectrum. This should preserve, to some extent, elusive builds and still allow for a reasonable amount of fumbles.


Yea, like how it was easier to hit Earl Campbell straight on than Barry Sanders. With Sanders, you normally could get him a full on big hit because he was juking so often and was so quick. I definitely agree with that.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Yeah some defenses to play to strip the ball. I am out of here. Your team fumbled, I am trying to tell you how to fight back. You will still fumble if all you want to do is whine. It happened to us, we learned from it, applied what we learned on both sides of the ball. Things are getting much better on both sides of the ball for now. I am sure we will still have a few fumbles. GLB isn't just about speed anymore, it is now about strength.

I am out.


I just noticed that my non fumbling team beat one of your teams today.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

Yeah some defenses to play to strip the ball. I am out of here. Your team fumbled, I am trying to tell you how to fight back. You will still fumble if all you want to do is whine. It happened to us, we learned from it, applied what we learned on both sides of the ball. Things are getting much better on both sides of the ball for now. I am sure we will still have a few fumbles. GLB isn't just about speed anymore, it is now about strength.

I am out.


I just noticed that my non fumbling team beat one of your teams today.


Umm OK, you mean the team my center was traded to over the off-season?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
news flash people. 55-60 carrying is not the cure for no fumbles. It was last season because Bort broke fumbles. Not to mention those saety/linebackers turned into actual linebackers.

Adapt and improve.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by Gyuri1



Originally posted by jrry32




I think the biggest problem is when bort buffed the monster tackle, I don't think he could forsee that all those seasons of pumping strength and tackling would allow most Defenders to go to power tackling and kill RBs, KRs and PRs.


I agree with this, too, and it was the point I was trying to make in my first post. I think this situation is very similar to what happened with OTs, when Bort made changes to the sim to try and create the results he wanted when builds were already being adjusted. After the builds were properly adjusted, Bort's previous changes became overpowered. This is why the "fix your build" argument has some validity to me, but once Bort has already intervened, fixing the builds may require too much work and lead to a single path for builds where there should be at least a little variety.



I guess that's true but I don't want him to make fumbles non existant again.


Agreed. My view is that if power backs are going to try and run directly over defenders, then they should fumble more often (and, more importantly, they can fix their builds in ways that make their builds still realistic for what they're trying to do). Maybe there's a way to make fumbles less likely against players running on the elusive end of the tactical spectrum, b/c, theoretically, the defender will have a harder time squaring up on the runner, and more likely against players running on the power end of the spectrum. This should preserve, to some extent, elusive builds and still allow for a reasonable amount of fumbles.


Yea, like how it was easier to hit Earl Campbell straight on than Barry Sanders. With Sanders, you normally could get him a full on big hit because he was juking so often and was so quick. I definitely agree with that.



http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/S/SandBa00.htm

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/C/CampEa00.htm

lol proves poot and my point sanders 41 fumbles on 3062 carries, campbell 43 fumbles on 2187 carries. Strength should have little to do with fumbles.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Well like I was saying, Power HBs take more direct hits and are easier to strip when they are fighting for more yards but yes, strength shouldn't have the role in covering up the ball that it has, carrying should be by FAR the most important and it's not.
 
Demboyz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
news flash people. 55-60 carrying is not the cure for no fumbles. It was last season because Bort broke fumbles. Not to mention those saety/linebackers turned into actual linebackers.

Adapt and improve.


so true

ppl can we plz break the pattern plz

1.offense dominates in some type of way
2. def adjust
3. offense complains
4. bort nerfs the def

this is getting old
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Well like I was saying, Power HBs take more direct hits and are easier to strip when they are fighting for more yards but yes, strength shouldn't have the role in covering up the ball that it has, carrying should be by FAR the most important and it's not.


agreed an option for cover up the ball or fight for more yards would make it a better situation for GLB
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Demboyz
Originally posted by islander1

news flash people. 55-60 carrying is not the cure for no fumbles. It was last season because Bort broke fumbles. Not to mention those saety/linebackers turned into actual linebackers.

Adapt and improve.


so true

ppl can we plz break the pattern plz

1.offense dominates in some type of way
2. def adjust
3. offense complains
4. bort nerfs the def

this is getting old


it works both ways.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Well like I was saying, Power HBs take more direct hits and are easier to strip when they are fighting for more yards but yes, strength shouldn't have the role in covering up the ball that it has, carrying should be by FAR the most important and it's not.


+1



DMP

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Demboyz
Originally posted by islander1

news flash people. 55-60 carrying is not the cure for no fumbles. It was last season because Bort broke fumbles. Not to mention those saety/linebackers turned into actual linebackers.

Adapt and improve.


so true

ppl can we plz break the pattern plz

1.offense dominates in some type of way
2. def adjust
3. offense complains
4. bort nerfs the def

this is getting old


It gets old because nobody knows what the next problems going to be. This game is very shortsighted.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.