User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
Page:
 
Granted86
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Still think a flat increase to attributes is a dumb way to go about it.


maybe not an increase to attributes, maybe just significant bonus on the rolls
the bonus to the rolls would get bigger if a team runs a play over and over
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
A vision bonus makes sense to me. Unfortunately I don't think it'll help much vs the run.

edit: vision bonus to the defense. I don't like the idea of penalizing an offense for running the same play, but some bonus to defense makes sense. Not a flat % boost to all skills, but anticipation/vision/etc type stuff.
Last edited Mar 21, 2009 18:59:54
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I am testing out this idea right now, though I don't know how well it'll really work as far as stopping an overpowered play. A recognition boost still won't help you break blocks or make tackles. It will just get you to the block or missed tackle quicker.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
The only explanations I can come up with for why it isn't in the game, is a coding issue that would take too long to pull off anytime in the near future, or he thinks some people think it's fun to play like that and he wants to appeal to them.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I am testing out this idea right now, though I don't know how well it'll really work as far as stopping an overpowered play. A recognition boost still won't help you break blocks or make tackles. It will just get you to the block or missed tackle quicker.


Looks like my first possible explanation was correct.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Solve it by forcing teams to expand the playbook with their play % in some formations?
 
Padre
offline
Link
 
I am sure this idea has already been offered up. But can't Bort put in some type of system that the more a certain play in ran in a game the less effective it becomes by some degree. Like in football the more an offense runs a play; the more awareness the defense gains for recognizing and defending the play.
 
Padre
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Padre97
I am sure this idea has already been offered up. But can't Bort put in some type of system that the more a certain play in ran in a game the less effective it becomes by some degree. Like in football the more an offense runs a play; the more awareness the defense gains for recognizing and defending the play.


Of course after I type this I read up top.
 
Granted86
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
This came from jrry's old thread...not saying I agree with any of it, but yeah.

Originally posted by jrry32
We all know that there are some exploits and hear many people complaining so my thought is...why not have players adapt to plays run over and over again? Say a team runs the Strong I Offtackle 6 times in a row...well then players will start to see it coming and will gamble to stop it. Like they will get in position pre play to stop the play. They will also know exactly where the play is going. Another example is say the WR screen gets run 8 times in a row well the next time both CBs know it's coming and sprint into the backfield for a TFL, int or PD.

Now, how fast you realize that a play has been run over and over again is based on your players vision. The higher the vision, the faster they can recognize plays coming. Please don't flame...just give thoughts?

Here are more great ideas that could go hand in hand with this suggestion:
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

I'm all for it ... as long as you give a minus to vision whenever the offense uses the same formation but a different Play. Say I run HB Slam 3x in a row and your guys would get a +1 to vision if I run it the next snap... shouldn't you guys get a -1 to vision if I use the same formation but call a different play?

If you anticipate something, and are right - great! But if you anticipate something, and you are wrong.. consider that as well.


Originally posted by palmer_garnett_95

Here's the other side of the coin. If a defense only runs one thing against any formation, the offense should also be able to adjust if that same play is run over and over. So, if a team like to shift to the strong side and blitz the LOLB and MLB every time against the strong I, then the offense will adjust. Maybe if those LBs are getting to the QB, he looks to dump off the pass sooner. Maybe the running back looks to cut outside. The point is that this could work both ways. I definitely believe that a defense needs to be able to adjust to a play if that's all that is run, but I think the same is true for the offense.


Originally posted by bmedders

Yeah I wasn't necessarily saying that was your idea, I just hate the idea that it should solely be a "vision boost".

IMO, it should be a vision check in two ways -

1) Players with higher vision recognize the play after fewer repeats and
2) Players with higher vision should go back to their original assignments faster once the recognize it's not the same play.


Originally posted by SAGA45

I'd like to see some auto-adjust option for every individual player tactic and using the player's vision as a modifier to how quickly and effectively they adjust.

For example, a QB might have his tactics originally set to not 'Favor long passes' but, as the game progresses, it shifts to 'yes, favor long passes' after he realizes he's having a lot of success on the deeper throws. A RT who's getting repeatedly beaten on passing downs my shift his blocking focus from 'run' to 'pass' to better compensate. A CB set to 'aggressive' might shift to 'semi-aggressive' if he's being beaten.

But again, the player's vision ultimately determines how quickly and effectively they make these shifts in focus and tendency. IMO, this best mimicks the player being coached on the sidelines and being told what adjustments they need to make both as units and in 1-on-1 matchups.


 
STG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
If a team runs 2 plays over and over all game, the defense should be given a bonus to adapting and stopping the play.

No one in real football runs 2 plays and wins.


+1
 
strikes369
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShannontheGuy
Originally posted by jamz

If a team runs 2 plays over and over all game, the defense should be given a bonus to adapting and stopping the play.

No one in real football runs 2 plays and wins.

+1


Great idea, but until we get a BUNCH more plays, then by default some plays will be used over and over and over again. Now, if you made it like if was used 10+ times a game for now, I can totally agree with it.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
What's wrong with running the same play over and over again if a team gives you the same defense?



legitimate point
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Best way to go about this imo is...give defenses bonuses to their rolls.

More likely to break their block, more likely to make tackles, more likely to get a PD or Int, less likely to fail vision checks, less likely to get faked...all that good stuff.

It seems like it would actually get the job done, and it would be more realistic than say, 5% bonus to all attributes or something.

The % modifiers would be dependent on several factors. Obviously, the more that a team runs a play, the higher it will be. I think it should also increase at a rate relative to vision. Higher vision = higher % modifiers per consecutive play, lower vision = lower % modifiers.


still like this idea the best
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I just got hit by this bus today. Something needs to be done. Power I off tackle again and again. Pretty lame that we couldn't stop it...better scouting bars for our team and a real AI put in place.

No way we should have been destroyed by the same play run again and again.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.