User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why "nerfs" and "berfs" are a bad idea (this is long, if you have ADD don't read it)
Page:
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Not everyone can pass for 70% completion rates....there has to be some shitty QB's in the league and his just happens to be one. Everyone thinks every player they own should be a superstar and that just can't happen. There are winners and losers. Teams that are good, teams that suck. Fix your builds and stop whining.


And Imthescientist comes in and spams his stupidity on another thread. Hey buddy - if any team needs to fix their builds, its Kai, who have been a piece of shit team for god knows how many seasons now. My team is successful, has always been, and will continue to be - and my build is fine. I am not arguing for bort to fuck with builds, if you could read. I am arguing for him to fix his sim mechanics. My point is a valid one, and as usual for any point made by you or your team, yours is an asinine one. Shut the fuck up, go find a trolling thread where you'll fit in, and stop attacking that which you don't understand.


I have never heard of you until I saw this post. You are asking him to fix the sim mechanics instead of just fixing things yourself. There is a reason that many of the QB's are not doing well. Obviously you have not figured this out yet....and its build related.

Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713

No drop in that guys play. He's a pro lvl QB and his numbers are right on par with his career totals. A little less crying/bitching would be appreciated. Again..not every QB can be Peyton Manning, its the nature of the beast.


Well, most have heard of me - and the reason I'm not as well known as you is that I don't make a gimmick out of making an ass of myself on forums. Nobody would ever have heard of you or your team if you didn't make a point of going on every thread and criticizing it and calling people idiots. Your posts are not worth the time it takes to read them, and they have no thought or actual care involved. You just post to be an ass because that's what spreads your reputation - nobody would ever hear of you based on the merits of your play. Those who do know me (and its a fair few) know me for what I contribute to the game, and not for my stupidity and forum whoring. I will take that kind of reknown over any that Kai has.

And, as for Porto's QB - you once again miss the point. Look at his game log - his games against equal competition, his percentages are far lower. His one game against 255-0 competition, his percentage is a whopping 88%, his yards account for more than half of his season total, and 28 of his 39 tds - all of these raise his overall numbers, and are not indicative of how good his build is relative to other QBs that play even competition. It is not a build thing, it is a passing mechanics thing - and if you guys ran more than 2 plays and actually watched film and tried to get better instead of spending your time being idiots on every forum you can get your hands on, you would notice this as well. However, reasoning with a moron like you isn't really worth my time - you are exactly the kind of person I was hoping to warn off with the title of this thread, so I wouldn't have to put up with you distracting a productive discussion.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Nerf nerfing.


Exactly. The OP has been saying what I've been thinking since season 5. The passing game does need to be fixed(especially since the entire defense moves toward the receiver before the ball is thrown). However, it's more of a sim thing and not a let's nerf something situation. stop nerfing things and let us adjust to the way things are going.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
While I agree with the sentiments of the OP, at this point I just don't see it happening. The more "fluff" (AE/VAs/endorsements) that get added on top of the real problems just serve to exacerbate the underlying issues and make them that much more difficult to resolve. Sort of like buying an old car that needs engine work, but instead of fixing the engine the buyer adds a whole bunch of chrome and then wonders why it's not running right. *sigh*


This is an excellent point - and I agree that with all those things convoluting matters, fixing stuff will be hard - but not impossible. Nerfing does not solve the problem though - it just adds to it.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xcoach2
needs bullets pts


 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414

This is an excellent point - and I agree that with all those things convoluting matters, fixing stuff will be hard - but not impossible. Nerfing does not solve the problem though - it just adds to it.


Nerfing isn't the answer, I agree. But, with how convoluted things have become it seems that quick fixes versus real sim code fixes are the only answer we have seen (will be seeing?) I don't expect that mind-set to change anytime soon. Just as I don't expect the sim code to be taken apart and fixed like it should be. There are now just too many new variables on top of it all (the fluff) to do it without first removing all the fluff and starting it from the foundation up.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TuNice
Originally posted by xcoach2

needs bullets pts




nevermind. was an easy read
 
PBer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Originally posted by rj414

Again, I'm not denying it - I even posted in the thread if you are 'offended' by people putting thought into posts and making an editorial, don't read the damn thing. Thanks for your valuable contributions to the discussion though. God, I love GLB public forums.


i think you screwed yourself with that massive text vomit above. You can easily make your points in a much easier to read and audience friendly manner. At least I think you can but i refuse to read that shit



Refuse to read . . . can't read. We understand.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by rj414


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Not everyone can pass for 70% completion rates....there has to be some shitty QB's in the league and his just happens to be one. Everyone thinks every player they own should be a superstar and that just can't happen. There are winners and losers. Teams that are good, teams that suck. Fix your builds and stop whining.


And Imthescientist comes in and spams his stupidity on another thread. Hey buddy - if any team needs to fix their builds, its Kai, who have been a piece of shit team for god knows how many seasons now. My team is successful, has always been, and will continue to be - and my build is fine. I am not arguing for bort to fuck with builds, if you could read. I am arguing for him to fix his sim mechanics. My point is a valid one, and as usual for any point made by you or your team, yours is an asinine one. Shut the fuck up, go find a trolling thread where you'll fit in, and stop attacking that which you don't understand.


I have never heard of you until I saw this post. You are asking him to fix the sim mechanics instead of just fixing things yourself. There is a reason that many of the QB's are not doing well. Obviously you have not figured this out yet....and its build related.

Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713

No drop in that guys play. He's a pro lvl QB and his numbers are right on par with his career totals. A little less crying/bitching would be appreciated. Again..not every QB can be Peyton Manning, its the nature of the beast.


Well, most have heard of me - and the reason I'm not as well known as you is that I don't make a gimmick out of making an ass of myself on forums. Nobody would ever have heard of you or your team if you didn't make a point of going on every thread and criticizing it and calling people idiots. Your posts are not worth the time it takes to read them, and they have no thought or actual care involved. You just post to be an ass because that's what spreads your reputation - nobody would ever hear of you based on the merits of your play. Those who do know me (and its a fair few) know me for what I contribute to the game, and not for my stupidity and forum whoring. I will take that kind of reknown over any that Kai has.

And, as for Porto's QB - you once again miss the point. Look at his game log - his games against equal competition, his percentages are far lower. His one game against 255-0 competition, his percentage is a whopping 88%, his yards account for more than half of his season total, and 28 of his 39 tds - all of these raise his overall numbers, and are not indicative of how good his build is relative to other QBs that play even competition. It is not a build thing, it is a passing mechanics thing - and if you guys ran more than 2 plays and actually watched film and tried to get better instead of spending your time being idiots on every forum you can get your hands on, you would notice this as well. However, reasoning with a moron like you isn't really worth my time - you are exactly the kind of person I was hoping to warn off with the title of this thread, so I wouldn't have to put up with you distracting a productive discussion.


1) I did not call you an idiot, so don't put words in my mouth.
2) Its ok to disagree, isn't that the point of a forum? A place for discussion.
3)Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713
He played the Krazy Monkeys 2 games ago and completed 62.5% which is ~3.5% lower than his career average. The Monkeys are SA Pro's second best team next to the Cobra Kai. You would expect that because his career numbers are an "Average" he would do better against bad teams and worse against good teams. He was only 3.5% of his career average against a great team.

Again, I don't agree with you at all. Its my opinion. I think that it should be up to the individual agent to fix their build, not up to bort. If something is wrong, analyze it and fix it....on your own. Your team is 2-2. Do you really expect to put up huge numbers when you have lost two games? It could be a number of things.

You had 20 PD's in your last game. Its not like your QB is off target. You also had 3 dropped balls. So of your 22 for 46 only 22 of 43 were your fault. You only threw 1 pass off target.

1) Either your WR's get no separation
2) Your QB has the arm of a high school QB playing in a Pro League

#2 would be my guess. You have not adjusted to the CB's which have now adjusted to the fact that vision is important to them in ball recognition. You are not getting away with the 30 yard jump balls that WR's were catching in triple coverage in previous seasons so your stats are suffering.

Boo-YA
 
PBer
offline
Link
 
By the way, I totally agree that the constant "nerfing" of specific positions and certain builds just SUCKS. You spend 3-4 season slow building a player because you think it will work, then it does work, but a bit too well, and then they get nerfed all to hell and you have to "re-create" them somehow by shifting equipment, etc. Basically killing all the work you put in for the first 3-4 seasons.

It does get tiresome.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by rj414



Originally posted by ImTheScientist




Not everyone can pass for 70% completion rates....there has to be some shitty QB's in the league and his just happens to be one. Everyone thinks every player they own should be a superstar and that just can't happen. There are winners and losers. Teams that are good, teams that suck. Fix your builds and stop whining.


And Imthescientist comes in and spams his stupidity on another thread. Hey buddy - if any team needs to fix their builds, its Kai, who have been a piece of shit team for god knows how many seasons now. My team is successful, has always been, and will continue to be - and my build is fine. I am not arguing for bort to fuck with builds, if you could read. I am arguing for him to fix his sim mechanics. My point is a valid one, and as usual for any point made by you or your team, yours is an asinine one. Shut the fuck up, go find a trolling thread where you'll fit in, and stop attacking that which you don't understand.


I have never heard of you until I saw this post. You are asking him to fix the sim mechanics instead of just fixing things yourself. There is a reason that many of the QB's are not doing well. Obviously you have not figured this out yet....and its build related.

Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713

No drop in that guys play. He's a pro lvl QB and his numbers are right on par with his career totals. A little less crying/bitching would be appreciated. Again..not every QB can be Peyton Manning, its the nature of the beast.


Well, most have heard of me - and the reason I'm not as well known as you is that I don't make a gimmick out of making an ass of myself on forums. Nobody would ever have heard of you or your team if you didn't make a point of going on every thread and criticizing it and calling people idiots. Your posts are not worth the time it takes to read them, and they have no thought or actual care involved. You just post to be an ass because that's what spreads your reputation - nobody would ever hear of you based on the merits of your play. Those who do know me (and its a fair few) know me for what I contribute to the game, and not for my stupidity and forum whoring. I will take that kind of reknown over any that Kai has.

And, as for Porto's QB - you once again miss the point. Look at his game log - his games against equal competition, his percentages are far lower. His one game against 255-0 competition, his percentage is a whopping 88%, his yards account for more than half of his season total, and 28 of his 39 tds - all of these raise his overall numbers, and are not indicative of how good his build is relative to other QBs that play even competition. It is not a build thing, it is a passing mechanics thing - and if you guys ran more than 2 plays and actually watched film and tried to get better instead of spending your time being idiots on every forum you can get your hands on, you would notice this as well. However, reasoning with a moron like you isn't really worth my time - you are exactly the kind of person I was hoping to warn off with the title of this thread, so I wouldn't have to put up with you distracting a productive discussion.


1) I did not call you an idiot, so don't put words in my mouth.
2) Its ok to disagree, isn't that the point of a forum? A place for discussion.
3)Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713
He played the Krazy Monkeys 2 games ago and completed 62.5% which is ~3.5% lower than his career average. The Monkeys are SA Pro's second best team next to the Cobra Kai. You would expect that because his career numbers are an "Average" he would do better against bad teams and worse against good teams. He was only 3.5% of his career average against a great team.

Again, I don't agree with you at all. Its my opinion. I think that it should be up to the individual agent to fix their build, not up to bort. If something is wrong, analyze it and fix it....on your own. Your team is 2-2. Do you really expect to put up huge numbers when you have lost two games? It could be a number of things.

You had 20 PD's in your last game. Its not like your QB is off target. You also had 3 dropped balls. So of your 22 for 46 only 22 of 43 were your fault. You only threw 1 pass off target.

1) Either your WR's get no separation
2) Your QB has the arm of a high school QB playing in a Pro League

#2 would be my guess. You have not adjusted to the CB's which have now adjusted to the fact that vision is important to them in ball recognition. You are not getting away with the 30 yard jump balls that WR's were catching in triple coverage in previous seasons so your stats are suffering.

Boo-YA


And I am saying that you are clueless - it has nothing to do with my team in particular - the whole point of the OP isn't even about the fact that he's nerfed this position or that - it's that his entire approach to fixing his sim is not correct. As you saw - the point I made in the freakin OP is that while he's considering a nerf of the CBs - he SHOULDNT be. This is why I say, in short, that your posts on this subject are pointless. If you had read the OP, you would not have come on here bitching that I'm 'whining' and I need to 'fix my builds', because I did no such thing. Read the whole damn post, get the point of it, and then speak - or don't speak at all.

As for the Monkeys - yeah, I know very well who they are. They, unlike you, have got their reputation through winning. If one of THEM comes on here and says my OP is nonsense, I will be happy to give their opinion the due respect. However, my acceptance of any of your opinions, whether I agree with them or not, will be handicapped heavily by your past conduct on forums and the fact that, in general you don't seem to like to contribute as much as you like to stir up shit and attack. This conclusion and label of you is further supported by the fact that you are attacking me and calling me a whiner, without reading that in fact about all I did was tell Bort NOT to nerf the defense and in fact to address the actual mechanics of a pass, which I believe are the core of the problem. I'm not here complaining about my passing game being broken - that isn't the point of the post. The point of the post is that if he IS going to fuck with the passing game, he shouldn't do it by nerfing CBs, or any other position.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 14:49:52
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Very well written post, RJ, and something I agree entirely with. The sim is very lacking for any kinda of higher level "anticipation" or decision making AI for the dots. QBs utterly fail to anticipate routes vs. coverage and instead just knee-jerk throw to the open guy. Runners don't really know where the endzone is (kinda silly that a runner is locked into 1 style of running). Blockers don't understand what the purpose of the run/pass is.

I'm afraid that might just remain the nature of the sim - a bunch of cellular automata running around operating under a fairly simple set of interaction codes.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by rj414


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by rj414




Originally posted by ImTheScientist





Not everyone can pass for 70% completion rates....there has to be some shitty QB's in the league and his just happens to be one. Everyone thinks every player they own should be a superstar and that just can't happen. There are winners and losers. Teams that are good, teams that suck. Fix your builds and stop whining.


And Imthescientist comes in and spams his stupidity on another thread. Hey buddy - if any team needs to fix their builds, its Kai, who have been a piece of shit team for god knows how many seasons now. My team is successful, has always been, and will continue to be - and my build is fine. I am not arguing for bort to fuck with builds, if you could read. I am arguing for him to fix his sim mechanics. My point is a valid one, and as usual for any point made by you or your team, yours is an asinine one. Shut the fuck up, go find a trolling thread where you'll fit in, and stop attacking that which you don't understand.


I have never heard of you until I saw this post. You are asking him to fix the sim mechanics instead of just fixing things yourself. There is a reason that many of the QB's are not doing well. Obviously you have not figured this out yet....and its build related.

Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713

No drop in that guys play. He's a pro lvl QB and his numbers are right on par with his career totals. A little less crying/bitching would be appreciated. Again..not every QB can be Peyton Manning, its the nature of the beast.


Well, most have heard of me - and the reason I'm not as well known as you is that I don't make a gimmick out of making an ass of myself on forums. Nobody would ever have heard of you or your team if you didn't make a point of going on every thread and criticizing it and calling people idiots. Your posts are not worth the time it takes to read them, and they have no thought or actual care involved. You just post to be an ass because that's what spreads your reputation - nobody would ever hear of you based on the merits of your play. Those who do know me (and its a fair few) know me for what I contribute to the game, and not for my stupidity and forum whoring. I will take that kind of reknown over any that Kai has.

And, as for Porto's QB - you once again miss the point. Look at his game log - his games against equal competition, his percentages are far lower. His one game against 255-0 competition, his percentage is a whopping 88%, his yards account for more than half of his season total, and 28 of his 39 tds - all of these raise his overall numbers, and are not indicative of how good his build is relative to other QBs that play even competition. It is not a build thing, it is a passing mechanics thing - and if you guys ran more than 2 plays and actually watched film and tried to get better instead of spending your time being idiots on every forum you can get your hands on, you would notice this as well. However, reasoning with a moron like you isn't really worth my time - you are exactly the kind of person I was hoping to warn off with the title of this thread, so I wouldn't have to put up with you distracting a productive discussion.


1) I did not call you an idiot, so don't put words in my mouth.
2) Its ok to disagree, isn't that the point of a forum? A place for discussion.
3)Grim Blackwood
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67713
He played the Krazy Monkeys 2 games ago and completed 62.5% which is ~3.5% lower than his career average. The Monkeys are SA Pro's second best team next to the Cobra Kai. You would expect that because his career numbers are an "Average" he would do better against bad teams and worse against good teams. He was only 3.5% of his career average against a great team.

Again, I don't agree with you at all. Its my opinion. I think that it should be up to the individual agent to fix their build, not up to bort. If something is wrong, analyze it and fix it....on your own. Your team is 2-2. Do you really expect to put up huge numbers when you have lost two games? It could be a number of things.

You had 20 PD's in your last game. Its not like your QB is off target. You also had 3 dropped balls. So of your 22 for 46 only 22 of 43 were your fault. You only threw 1 pass off target.

1) Either your WR's get no separation
2) Your QB has the arm of a high school QB playing in a Pro League

#2 would be my guess. You have not adjusted to the CB's which have now adjusted to the fact that vision is important to them in ball recognition. You are not getting away with the 30 yard jump balls that WR's were catching in triple coverage in previous seasons so your stats are suffering.

Boo-YA


And I am saying that you are clueless - it has nothing to do with my team in particular - the whole point of the OP isn't even about the fact that he's nerfed this position or that - it's that his entire post to fixing his sim is not correct. As you saw - the point I made in the freakin OP is that while he's considering a nerf of the CBs - he SHOULDNT be. This is why I say, in short, that your posts on this subject are pointless. If you had read the OP, you would not have come on here bitching that I'm 'whining' and I need to 'fix my builds', because I did no such thing. Read the whole damn post, get the point of it, and then speak - or don't speak at all.

As for the Monkeys - yeah, I know very well who they are. They, unlike you, have got their reputation through winning. If one of THEM comes on here and says my OP is nonsense, I will be happy to give their opinion the due respect. However, my acceptance of any of your opinions, whether I agree with them or not, will be handicapped heavily by your past conduct on forums and the fact that, in general you don't seem to like to contribute as much as you like to stir up shit and attack. This conclusion and label of you is further supported by the fact that you are attacking me and calling me a whiner, without reading that in fact about all I did was tell Bort NOT to nerf the defense and in fact to address the actual mechanics of a pass, which I believe are the core of the problem. I'm not here complaining about my passing game being broken - that isn't the point of the post. The point of the post is that if he IS going to fuck with the passing game, he shouldn't do it by nerfing CBs, or any other position.


Perhaps you should have listened to Skanker Irl and myself on GLB radio
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/stations/fantasysportschannel/GoalLine-Blitz-Radio/2009/03/04/Rookie-Blitz-with-Esen
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 14:55:18
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Perhaps you should have listened to Skanker Irl and myself on GLB radio
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/stations/fantasysportschannel/GoalLine-Blitz-Radio/2009/03/04/Rookie-Blitz-with-Esen


Perhaps you shouldn't evade the fact that you called me a whiner when the point of my post wasn't even that he should address the passing game, but HOW he should if he did try to do so. Read 6 words and attack - the Kai mentality.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 14:55:01
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514 - catch up.

Originally posted by rj414

Bort, the passing game is struggling this season, I agree. As an offensive coordinator, a passing game guru, and somebody who would very much benefit from the passing game being a little easier in this case because my team is built to throw the ball


I'd choose a new job title


You're a tester? I would too.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 14:54:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.