User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
addddddum
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by doubletree
Originally posted by addddddum

Originally posted by MadcatWillie


I would think that the best rusher would be the one who leads his team to a championship win. What good is 5,000 yards if you don't get the ring?


So Willie Parker > Adrian Peterson?


While its obvious AP>WP. who was the better rusher last year, Michael Turner or DeAngelo Williams?


That's irrelevant. My RB has put up amazing numbers versus good and bad teams and sits atop both rushing categories as a RB.

So.. my statement is true.

Originally posted by addddddum
Originally posted by AngryDragon

Bump for the leagues best RB

 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Actually we have the best TWO RBs of the league.
 
Valenski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshinzen
Actually we have the best TWO RBs of the league.


Thats questionable....
 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Really? Because when I look at the top 10 players in Rushing Yds & TDs I see our RBs on top of the list (J. Young excluded since is not a HB).
Last edited Mar 12, 2009 07:38:29
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshinzen
Really? Because when I look at the top 10 players in Rushing Yds & TDs I see our RBs on top of the list (J. Young excluded since is not a HB).


True, but look at your league rank in passing offense...30th. All you do is run. As a matter of fact, you lead the league in rushes per game...the next team has 10 less attempts per game than you. What RB wouldn't excel in that system?!?
 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Our passing offense is there when we need them, take a look at our QB rating and pass completion. We try to win games depending upon matchups, not to promote our players stats.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by gatorfan
Originally posted by Kenshinzen

Really? Because when I look at the top 10 players in Rushing Yds & TDs I see our RBs on top of the list (J. Young excluded since is not a HB).


True, but look at your league rank in passing offense...30th. All you do is run. As a matter of fact, you lead the league in rushes per game...the next team has 10 less attempts per game than you. What RB wouldn't excel in that system?!?


So are you saying that Derrick Ward was the best RB in the NFL last year because he lead the league in yards per carry?
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derek McFadden
So are you saying that Derrick Ward was the best RB in the NFL last year because he lead the league in yards per carry?


What? Where did that come from?!?

I'm saying that you guys have a good offensive line and you carry the ball 69.3 times per game. It's like Emmitt Smith when he was with the Cowboys - any back would have dominated behind that line, and could you imagine the stats if they had run the ball 69 times per game?!?

Originally posted by Kenshinzen
Our passing offense is there when we need them, take a look at our QB rating and pass completion. We try to win games depending upon matchups, not to promote our players stats.


Really? Your starting QB has thrown the ball 46 times....all season. That's an average of 6.1 attempts per game.

Not trying to promote your player's stats, huh? What about this:

Originally posted by Kenshinzen
Really? Because when I look at the top 10 players in Rushing Yds & TDs I see our RBs on top of the list (J. Young excluded since is not a HB).


I could keep pasting and copying if you'd like.

Our point here is that "best" running back is relative and you can spin the stats however you want. It's difficult to say how good your backs are without putting them behind a worse offensive line.

IMO it's more fair to say that the best running back has broken or caused the most missed tackles. Check out HB Dark Violence of the Borgholm Bearcats - 108 broken tackles on only 23.1 carries per game. Or HB Heath "Thick Thighs" Peters of the Tjernobyl Nuclear Mutants - 101 broken tackles on only 14.6 carries per game!

Now THOSE are good running backs - no disputing it.

 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Dude, all I care is my team winning. Honestly don't care what Dark Violence did since his team lost to us 55-10. This discussion is getting boring, I'll talk to you in the playoffs!

EDIT: Did I mentioned that this great HB against a real D-Line like ours had only 2.9ypc (total 52yds)?
Last edited Mar 12, 2009 12:00:57
 
zomgmike
offline
Link
 
i think its funny that you gatorfan is looking at missed tackles to determine the best RB. seriously?
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshinzen
Dude, all I care is my team winning. Honestly don't care what Dark Violence did since his team lost to us 55-10. This discussion is getting boring, I'll talk to you in the playoffs!

EDIT: Did I mentioned that this great HB against a real D-Line like ours had only 2.9ypc (total 52yds)?


Are you implying that great players never have bad games? Isn't coaching a variable too? Maybe his offensive line isn't as good as yours?

Are you going to say your backs aren't good if they have a bad game?

No matter how you spin it, 108 broken tackles in 7 games is phenomenal.

I never said that your HB's aren't good - they obviously are, but there are way too many variables (as I've pointed out) to consider when deciding who is truly the 'best' HB....and obviously your backs' stats will be skewed simply due to the fact that they never stop carrying the ball...that and you have a very good offensive line.




 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zomgmike
i think its funny that you gatorfan is looking at missed tackles to determine the best RB. seriously?


OK...you guys are starting to get silly. Please point out where I said that missed tackles should determine the best RB.

I said that it would be more fair. What I meant was that it would be more fair than determining it with inflated stats.

EDIT: At least broken and missed tackles take the offensive line out of the equation. It shouldn't be the only determination, but it should weigh heavily.

Last edited Mar 12, 2009 12:52:14
 
Valenski
offline
Link
 
This happens every season when a team starts the season off good and starts talking smack implying they are the best.....Who has the trophy at the end of the season will tell who the best team really is!!!
 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshinzen
This discussion is getting boring, I'll talk to you in the playoffs!

 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
That's what I thought
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.