User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
I think the problem is still that Guards will not be able to come anywhere near the same speed that HBs have, and therefore the HB blows by them before they can get moving. Either that or the HB bumps them, and they back off to let the HB by.


The problem is they're 'delaying' before actually pulling. As soon as the ball is snapped, they should be getting out to the edge to lead block. Right now, they don't get going until the HB gets the pitch. By then it's too late and is a major reason why they get overrun by the back and beat to the edge by DE's and LB's. It's a two-part problem -- the delay before they actually pull and then rarely lead blocking downfield. Those are what need to be addressed by the devs.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
1st play, yeah that hurt. 2nd play he had a SS to block.

For some reason everyone seems to keep overlooking the fact that the HB runs into the RG, so the RG backs off to let him by.....it wasnt that there was no one to block. Watch enough of these replays and you'll see the pattern.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
The problem is they're 'delaying' before actually pulling. As soon as the ball is snapped, they should be getting out to the edge to lead block. Right now, they don't get going until the HB gets the pitch. By then it's too late and is a major reason why they get overrun by the back and beat to the edge by DE's and LB's. It's a two-part problem -- the delay before they actually pull and then rarely lead blocking downfield. Those are what need to be addressed by the devs.


They arent getting downfield to block because the HB gets there before they do. I understand the delay is there, but im sure if they had 30+ agi and 50+ speed(just a guess) it wouldnt exist. Obviously that isnt anywhere near a realistic expectation from a guard, which is why i suggest implementing a pulling skill to give them an initial boost to the edge, so they can turn upfield before the HB gets to them, and not get cut off behind the line by running into the HB.
 
taylonr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Originally posted by SAGA45

The problem is they're 'delaying' before actually pulling. As soon as the ball is snapped, they should be getting out to the edge to lead block. Right now, they don't get going until the HB gets the pitch. By then it's too late and is a major reason why they get overrun by the back and beat to the edge by DE's and LB's. It's a two-part problem -- the delay before they actually pull and then rarely lead blocking downfield. Those are what need to be addressed by the devs.


They arent getting downfield to block because the HB gets there before they do. I understand the delay is there, but im sure if they had 30+ agi and 50+ speed(just a guess) it wouldnt exist. Obviously that isnt anywhere near a realistic expectation from a guard, which is why i suggest implementing a pulling skill to give them an initial boost to the edge, so they can turn upfield before the HB gets to them, and not get cut off behind the line by running into the HB.


Not sure they need a "pulling skill" for the guard. It would be a nice thing to have, but really shouldn't be necessary. Part of it is that the guard isn't getting out there in time, but that's not necessarily speed. Because he is DROPPING IN TO PASS BLOCKING before he starts to pull. A guard should not drop 4 or 5 steps on a run unless it's some kind of draw play. Secondly, the reason some teams are good at pulling in real life is that they have a RB who waits for the blockers to get out in front. That doesn't mean standing still and getting killed, but it's not just the guard here. He's the most glaring problem, and maybe if he was pulling correctly the HB wouldn't have to wait.

Another reason that I don't think there needs to be a pulling skill is because if you think about the levels of football, even a HS guard CAN pull. He'll do it slower and not as well, but even he won't drop in to pass blocking first. As he progresses from JV to varsity, to college to pro he'll develop better and better, but I can almost guarantee that if you went to a HS game and saw a guard play like this, he'd be on the bench. So it's not a matter of lack of ability. It's a matter of a bug in the AI.

Even a level one should correctly pull on every play, if the level 5 HB beats him to the corner, THEN it becomes a matter of abilities (speed). Or if he pulls out there and misses a blitzing backer then that's a matter of ability (vision, or agility). If he gets to the corner and sees the right guy to block but misses his block, then it's an ability issue (blocking)

But when a pulling guard runs the wrong way (towards the QB instead of towards the end of the line) it's not an ability issue unless there is an ability which means "don't play like you're in pop-warner" and that had only 1 point.
Last edited May 27, 2008 17:46:26
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
I think the problem is still that Guards will not be able to come anywhere near the same speed that HBs have, and therefore the HB blows by them before they can get moving. Either that or the HB bumps them, and they back off to let the HB by.


This guard isn't the highest level guy, but he was built for special teams and actually had more Speed, Agility, and Vision than the runner at least at the time of the play. He can't pull to the hole either (seems like the TE gets in the way).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=4486888

Also, to prove he is not a sloth....For whatever reason he was on the outside of the KR formation and you can see him outrunning most of the other players (yes he had a level advantage and there are CPUs on the other team)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=4258710


Last edited May 27, 2008 18:05:17
 
jrg42
offline
Link
 
Still no answer on why LG's will no longer pull when they would at least attempt it earlier in the season.
 
taylonr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrg42
Still no answer on why LG's will no longer pull when they would at least attempt it earlier in the season.


They see how much heat the RGs are getting for doing it wrong and they've decided to stop

Actually, if I remember right, there was a bug where when the LG pulled, the NT always came through that hole and tackled the HB in the backfield. Could have something to do with it.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
I'm very curious about why the G's won't block down field. It seems like they get to the corner and stop.
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Pmub?
 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
I agree this is a big issue. When a linemen pulls (regardless of the technique used) the first step starts to take them down the line. One the 2nd step you are heading that direction and by the third step you should be past the tackle. The big problem I see is that (regardless of "the stop") the first step shouldn't be back, it should be out. A good puller would stay tight to the line, if the D gets penetration you may have to bubble a little bit, but you should be right on the back of the OT/TE butt for the most part. Also once you clear the last man (TE or OT) he should cut up right now...and find the first thing that shows (this is where vision would come in a lot) if the LB is there you get him, if he's not your find the DB. I don't think it's that the AI isn't working I just think the philosophy behind how the linemen pulling mechanics work is flawed.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
One issue I think this needs work on (the pull move is a given "not working") is the logic on the Offence for picking up who to block - particularly when the defence goes into zone with the DE's and such. On a play with the DE in zone, nobody picks him up and invariably your HB just ploughs straight into him.

Now I've seen the G pull successfully a couple of times - but only because we have the slowest HB in Christendom running the ball - and sometimes our fast back has stayed behind a sweep long enough to spot a hole, but the majority of the time the run "sweep right" play consists of half the O-Line going left, instead of trying to match-up to a man to the right of themselves. Invariably the TE ends up with the FB and Center giving a long DT a lovely frisk.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nithos
Yeah, something is messed up with the pulling logic. The Guards are afraid to cross the line of scrimmage.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2899123

I worked so hard on getting his speed and agility up so you could make it to the outside with the HB, just to have him stop before he can even be effective.


What is his vision?
 
taylonr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bolo_76
I agree this is a big issue. When a linemen pulls (regardless of the technique used) the first step starts to take them down the line. One the 2nd step you are heading that direction and by the third step you should be past the tackle. The big problem I see is that (regardless of "the stop") the first step shouldn't be back, it should be out. A good puller would stay tight to the line, if the D gets penetration you may have to bubble a little bit, but you should be right on the back of the OT/TE butt for the most part. Also once you clear the last man (TE or OT) he should cut up right now...and find the first thing that shows (this is where vision would come in a lot) if the LB is there you get him, if he's not your find the DB. I don't think it's that the AI isn't working I just think the philosophy behind how the linemen pulling mechanics work is flawed.


QFT
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bolo_76
I agree this is a big issue. When a linemen pulls (regardless of the technique used) the first step starts to take them down the line. One the 2nd step you are heading that direction and by the third step you should be past the tackle. The big problem I see is that (regardless of "the stop") the first step shouldn't be back, it should be out. A good puller would stay tight to the line, if the D gets penetration you may have to bubble a little bit, but you should be right on the back of the OT/TE butt for the most part. Also once you clear the last man (TE or OT) he should cut up right now...and find the first thing that shows (this is where vision would come in a lot) if the LB is there you get him, if he's not your find the DB. I don't think it's that the AI isn't working I just think the philosophy behind how the linemen pulling mechanics work is flawed.


Bingo!
 
Dave Fahrer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by nithos

Yeah, something is messed up with the pulling logic. The Guards are afraid to cross the line of scrimmage.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2899123

I worked so hard on getting his speed and agility up so you could make it to the outside with the HB, just to have him stop before he can even be effective.


What is his vision?


that is what i want to know. Vision comes into play alot with pulling. to see where the threat is coming from and then go to it.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.