User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Solution to Test Server Issue - Please do not Delete/Lock - Serious Idea
Page:
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985

Fine then....

For the topic of this thread....NO!! WAY!!



You wanna put any reasoning or thought behind that?
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 23:33:24
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wrian Bestbrook
TEST SERVERS ARE FOR PEOPLE WHO REGULATE THIS GAME, NOT EVERY IDIOT THAT WANTS TO MAKE A "PLAYER" THAT WILL DOMINATE A RPG. THIS IS HOW THEY MAKE MONEY, THEY NEED TO TEST THINGS SO MOST OF THE GLITCHS GET ERASED. STOP WHINING, I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY PEOPLE THINK THEY'RE SO POWERFUL THAT THEY CAN REQUEST USING THE TESTERS. IT'S FOR ADMINS AND MODS AND BORT AND DD ONLY!!!


Well you are probably right, especially people that can't figure out caps lock....

 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Personally, I don't think it is necessary to give every user access to all of the functionality of the test server as long as every user gets access to all the information on the test server. Meaning: the general population of GLB doesn't need to be able to actually run the tests, as long as they can see all of the results of all of the tests.


I can see the logic behind this...the problem is how do we get to see all of this information fairly...

Maybe if anyone could see all of the builds on the test server (you cant have closed builds on test) and all of the AI was open (you could see everyone's tactics on the test server as well, including the AI of every team)..
SO you could look at any game, any player, and any AI and have all of the testing information, at your fingertips.

Complete 100% transparency would be fine with me as a second best option. (as opposed to everyone having access)

But In my eyes it has to be one of those 2 options...anything else will not do.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 23:41:17
 
The Tempest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7


As for banning testers, I don't think that is a very good solution. There have been people who want that to happen, they want testers to be a seperate community....But I think that is wrong...No one is as qualified to test this game as the people who play it, so having a rule that stated something like 'if you are a tester, you cant own/gm a team' etc would be the wrong way to do it IMHO...I Think my solution of allowing Everyone some kind of limited access (everyone with equal access) is a much more elegant, and superior solution.




It's not really a suggestion, it is part of the rules of the game. Read the TOS, if you are caught exploiting the game you can be banned without warning. I never said they couldn't GM or Own a team, that is your own imagination at work. I merely read the rules of the game before playing. Since I realize the difficulty of that concept and the ability to retain that information, I will give you a moment.........

The whole pompous attitude while screaming it's not fair everyone should have the same access is absurd. It won't happen, it might as well be a thread about leprechauns, because the pot of gold your following is fantasy.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
I'm sorry I do not know how to explain it to you any more clearly...

What you are saying is that having access to the test server is not an unfair advantage, and many people disagree...There is a thread with over 2000 posts in it that is the right place to debate that.

If you want to argue over whether or not allowing some people to have access to test servers, and not allowing others the same access is unfair, then the proper thread is here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2071720

You still have not given one single reason why allowing everyone equal access to test servers is a bad idea...You seem angry and seem to be confusing facts (like saying I screamed at you, when I have never even PM'd you or chatted with you before)...

If having access to the test server does not give an unfair advantage (your opinion) why are you against it? you have not given any coherent argument...Your posts seem rambling and disjointed.

If you have a logical, on topic argument, I will be happy to discuss it with you...If you want to discuss other aspects of the test servers then the above thread is a better place.

Good luck.
Last edited Feb 16, 2009 02:09:36
 
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
The solution is very simple...

If a test server is needed (which I am going to assume that it is needed)...

Give everyone fair access to it. Yes, give everyone free and fair access to the test server...

Wouldn't too many people use it? Well if that is the case, then have a 'queue' for sims or somehow regulate how often people can test things....

But if anyone is going to have access to test info, then everyone should.....This is not a unique or new concept..In the MMORPG that I play, the test server is for everyone...not just a select few....and very few people use it....

I think Bort and crew could prevent/stop a lot of this whining if they simply opened up this test server to everyone...maybe at 1st it would be crowded....and there might be longer waits for sims....but after a while I bet you that it wouldn't be that bad of a wait and the issue would become a non- issue.




I think the owners of the teams in the league where the testers Own/OC/DC should get the first chance since they are the ones who will be most negatively affected.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I think the owners of the teams in the league where the testers Own/OC/DC should get the first chance since they are the ones who will be most negatively affected.


I was kind of thinking that everyone should get a limited amount of access to the server, the same amount as everyone else...

For example...being able to make a few players, own a team, and have x amount of hours per season of test server time....if there was too much demand...Lower X, but keep X the same for everyone.

And, in conjunction with this, make everything completely visibile...Open all the player's builds....Allow everyone to see the ai of the teams, and the play-by-play of all the games...(on the test server only of course)

100% transparency if there are going to be test servers.
Last edited Feb 16, 2009 02:13:28
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7


Maybe if anyone could see all of the builds on the test server (you cant have closed builds on test) and all of the AI was open (you could see everyone's tactics on the test server as well, including the AI of every team)..
SO you could look at any game, any player, and any AI and have all of the testing information, at your fingertips.


Yes, that is what I was getting at.
Last edited Feb 16, 2009 02:32:24
 
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I think the owners of the teams in the league where the testers Own/OC/DC should get the first chance since they are the ones who will be most negatively affected.


I was kind of thinking that everyone should get a limited amount of access to the server, the same amount as everyone else...

For example...being able to make a few players, own a team, and have x amount of hours per season of test server time....if there was too much demand...Lower X, but keep X the same for everyone.

And, in conjunction with this, make everything completely visibile...Open all the player's builds....Allow everyone to see the ai of the teams, and the play-by-play of all the games...(on the test server only of course)

100% transparency if there are going to be test servers.



There is a cost to the sims. That is why Bort charges FP's for scrimmages. Allowing free sims for everyone doesn't seem like it is cost effective. I assume that is why he worked with a limited group in the first place.


Either move all the tester's teams to 1 league or allow teams to move out of the leagues that the testers were in.

I don't think allowing access to everyone is a possible solution.
 
Link
 
^^^^ this solution has many many holes.


The only good solution was to keep the formula to the sim hidden. Now that Bort has basically given the sim formula to 30 testers, I don't know if there is a good fix.
 
nakedpanic
offline
Link
 
Owners = can't be testers
Agents = can't be testers
GMs = can't be testers
Anyone who's been a part of GLB = can't be testers
3rd party company with no individual ties to GLB and are being paid as such = testers
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nakedpanic
Owners = can't be testers
Agents = can't be testers
GMs = can't be testers
Anyone who's been a part of GLB = can't be testers
3rd party company with no individual ties to GLB and are being paid as such = testers


it's either everyone tests or as you outlined there....as the way to go.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by James1985


Fine then....

For the topic of this thread....NO!! WAY!!



You wanna put any reasoning or thought behind that?


Nope I posted a reason and you said it was the wrong tread.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Here is another solution:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2095700
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Too much is being made out of being on the test server. I happen to know of at least 2 guys who are on this 'server' and their teams didn't even make the playoffs. Both are great members of the community, and I can nearly guarantee you they aren't attempting in any way to cheat. They both just want to help make the game better.

I do think that allowing teams to do a certain number of 'practice games' against their own squad would (maybe 4-5 per real-life week) would allow everyone to better gauge this and even out whatever advantage could be gained from being on the test server. Additionally all test server data should be reported in announcement periodically.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.