User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Not enough fumbling?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr.Zoidberg
Needs moar fumbles


Needs moar tackling ability
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
So are these people saying it's "unrealistic" for a specially built defensive player to average 1 FF per game the same people who think it's OK for running backs to average 200 yards per game because it's "fun"? Unrealistic stats are only fun for offensive players?
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Just an observation based on the league I'm in. If I feel so inclined, I may compare to other leagues as well, but I've noticed that the number of turnovers this season seems to be exceptionally low. At first I figured it was just in my head, but my curiosity got the best of me, so I figured I would take a look at some numbers.

In my league, USA AA 2, through 5 games, these are the following turnover stats (fumbles lost + interceptions)
180 total turnovers
38 fumbles lost
142 interceptions

I decided to compare the stats to what you see in the NFL (Douchebag disclaimer: I realize that GLB is not the NFL, so by posting that GLB != NFL, you fully admit you have no reading comprehension and are merely posting such because you want to be first in line to expose your sandy vagina and need to OD on midol), because after all, we're trying to get the simulation as close to realism as possible, and it made sense to compare it to the highest level of professional football.

This season, in the NFL:
793 total turnovers
328 fumbles lost
465 interceptions

If you convert it to turnovers per game, it doesn't look as bad, because you get:
2.25 turnovers/game in USA AA 2
3.13 turnovers/game in NFL

OK, so maybe another oopsie mistake a game would help out, but looking a little more into the numbers, the fumble to interception ratio is what sticks out the most:
0.27 fum/int ratio in USA AA 2
0.71 fum/int ratio in NFL

What are we seeing? That while the number of interceptions seems about accurate (The USA AA 2 number extrapolates to 454 picks over a 16 game season, in line with what the NFL's got), the number of fumbles is incredibly low. We're only seeing about 1/3 the number of fumbles in GLB (USA AA 2 extrapolates to 122 fumbles over a 16 game season).

Having pointed this out, let's get some insight into this as opposed to turning the thread into a "GLB is not the NFL" douchebag pissing match. Some things for you to consider:
* Why is the number of fumbles so low?
* What can be done to make the occurrence of fumbles more likely?

Start up the discussion and let's see what comes up!



did you consider that almost every single player in your league is set on wrap up?
 
FatLoad
offline
Link
 
We don't have NFL level players in GLB. The pro level teams are just getting there now. Don't expect NFL performance from high school players.

GLB is different, just like international basketball is different from the NBA and international hockey is different from the NHL. The stats will be different. Players haven't developed their builds to create the sme types od matchups as the NFL.

The code could be changed. Plenty more changes are coming. The balances have not been found yet. Many formulas need to be at least tweaked if not overhauled. There will never be an exact match.
 
WearyWarrior
offline
Link
 
I have a player who was intended to hit hard and occasionally force fumbles. What i got was someone who rarely forces fumbles. I dont play on wrap up, he can survive without it since ive invested enough in his tackling skills to allow him to play on balanced tackling. Hes got 9 in big hit and has 55+ tackling and str. Now how can this build not be getting more FF on the WR's around the game who dont bother investing more than a couple points in carrying (most of this players fumbles are on HBs)
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
you put 9 in Big Hit? ouch.
 
WearyWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
you put 9 in Big Hit? ouch.


Yeah, sure why not. Hes a season 1 player and ive always been on board with SA's when i liked the description. I mean big hit says it forces more fumbles the more you invest in it and thats the direction i wanted to go in. Im still really happy with the player's build otherwise too so im not that bothered by it.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I wouldn't mind seeing a few more fumbles overall, tbh, especially since a lot of people have gimpy carrying ability. I don't think right now is the best time to toy with it though, because honestly I think if more defenders had higher tackling skill (and I don't mean ~50), we'd see more fumbles anyway. That would be the point to getting tackling skill near 100, imo.


which is all nice and good to say....but how do you get to 100 tackling? take away from SPD/AGI which means you will never catch a speed back and even some power backs will be too fast. In the meta game, 100 tackling will lose. The only way it doesn't is if carrying has to be near tackling to avoid a significant fumble rate.

If a 100 tackling guy pops a 50 carrying guy, it needs to be a very high fumble rate to make the risk not worth the reward.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WTFPILLOWSHIRT
Guys, open your eyes.

What has been a huge issue this season? DEFENSIVE PLAYERS BUILT FOR SPEED, NOT STRENGTH AND TACKLING.

There is your answer.


+1000

LBs with 40 strength, safeties with 20 strength...it goes on and on - speed has been rewarded so heavily that no one has bothered putting points into the attributes that lead to fumbles.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WearyWarrior
I have a player who was intended to hit hard and occasionally force fumbles. What i got was someone who rarely forces fumbles. I dont play on wrap up, he can survive without it since ive invested enough in his tackling skills to allow him to play on balanced tackling. Hes got 9 in big hit and has 55+ tackling and str. Now how can this build not be getting more FF on the WR's around the game who dont bother investing more than a couple points in carrying (most of this players fumbles are on HBs)


Agreed...while lack of strength on defence is surely an issue, there hasn't been incentive for ball carriers to put points into strength or carrying, either. Fumbles seem pretty random and it doesn't seem to take a lot of str/carry for offensive players to be able to hang onto the ball.

 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Originally posted by WTFPILLOWSHIRT

Guys, open your eyes.

What has been a huge issue this season? DEFENSIVE PLAYERS BUILT FOR SPEED, NOT STRENGTH AND TACKLING.

There is your answer.


+1000

LBs with 40 strength, safeties with 20 strength...it goes on and on - speed has been rewarded so heavily that no one has bothered putting points into the attributes that lead to fumbles.


Well, you have to get to the ball before you can make a play. It doesn't matter if you have a gazillion in tackling, if you can never get to the ball carrier, you are never gonna force a fumble.

A 60 speed LBer is never gonna be able to catch a 100 speed elusive back, or even a 70 speed power back. As running backs have no reason to invest in anything other than speed (for the most part)....defense has to counter that speed with more speed.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Originally posted by WTFPILLOWSHIRT


Guys, open your eyes.

What has been a huge issue this season? DEFENSIVE PLAYERS BUILT FOR SPEED, NOT STRENGTH AND TACKLING.

There is your answer.


+1000

LBs with 40 strength, safeties with 20 strength...it goes on and on - speed has been rewarded so heavily that no one has bothered putting points into the attributes that lead to fumbles.


Well, you have to get to the ball before you can make a play. It doesn't matter if you have a gazillion in tackling, if you can never get to the ball carrier, you are never gonna force a fumble.

A 60 speed LBer is never gonna be able to catch a 100 speed elusive back, or even a 70 speed power back. As running backs have no reason to invest in anything other than speed (for the most part)....defense has to counter that speed with more speed.


on an outside run yes, inside run - with the slowdown through the line - maybe not so much.

Not arguing, just sayin'
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
on an outside run yes, inside run - with the slowdown through the line - maybe not so much.

Not arguing, just sayin'


True. Would be nice to see ILB builds diverge from OLB.
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
I would like to see the WRs, QBs, TEs with low carrying, like less than 30 (hell even the HBs that are all speed and no carrying) cough up the ball more when hit by player with over 55+ strength and tackling, Over 6 in both Big Hit and Monster Hit and using balanced tackling, especially when the SAs fire.

What Bort said about Jukes and cuts tipping the "balance" scale should come into play as well.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 09:19:01
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by islander1

on an outside run yes, inside run - with the slowdown through the line - maybe not so much.

Not arguing, just sayin'


True. Would be nice to see ILB builds diverge from OLB.


My ILB has diverged, to a degree.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.