User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Ie, they're probably saying, like they always say, when they see these threads, "dont worry let them talk it out, they'll get tired talking to themselves and eventually the thread will drop to page 180".

Bort/admin/mods have seen many many threads like this.....and they're not all "GG" created. There's plenty of threads like this in the GLB Board, in team forums, in League forums, and in here. A lot of people are afraid to say how they really feel. A lot of people think people like me going off in a thread is making an ass of oneself and so they rather show the class instead to just not say anything, but secretly agree. A lot of people dont agree. Etc. In the end, nothing will get done whilever Bort/admin avoid these threads.

They kinda already did reply to Flames54's thread about wiping the game, but it was all head in the sand and denying theres a problem. In the end, all that will happen is more and more people will in their own time stop boosting and buying FPs and slowly bit by bit leave whilever this game continues on its current path (no overhaul only band-aids). Even all those maddenite franchise-mode types will tire of the game being so cookie-cutter and bereft of fun.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 03:32:24
 
yoshi_yoshi
offline
Link
 
I think it's hard for Bort to do an overhaul because it's really pretty damn difficult to write a good sim. He could overhaul the system and come up w/ something just as imbalanced, but in a different way.

I'm not sure it's reasonable to expect a single programmer to write a great & balanced football sim (even w/ dots) in a span of several months, or ever. Just look at all the crappy football games out there who have orders of magnitude more man-hours put into them.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Removing all the multipliers and bonuses and extra bonuses (as found in SAs, VAs, EQT) and bringing it back to an attribute vs attribute game, would greatly help this sim. (Season 1/2 had that). That would just be one step.

A new more detailed attribute system which allows for multi-builds would be another step.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 03:47:14
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Things have gotten a lot of support here, so I'll just clarify the goal of the OP again. Attributes and whatnot are done and over so I'm going to imagine that they have to stay. The big change is to the mechanics, allowing for the differentiation of a lot of different things (Pass Blocking/Run Blocking) so that different types of players excel at them.

Its basically to cure the imbalances created by super builds without nerfing them. Speed DEs would be good against the Pass but decent/bad against the Run. Elusive Backs would have to face Fast Linebackers, while Power Backs would face Strong Linebackers (with the Depth Charting changes). This would add an element of a need for good recruiting (cause you need players of all types), balanced builds (the higher level players especially would have the ability to play multiple roles while taking up one roster spot), and game planning around both tactics and personnel (having to adapt to a Power Back or an Elusive Back that a team may have).

All I'm proposing is a full mechanics overhaul. The attribute system can remain as it is in order to preserve the game. If I'm correct about programming time the outcome of this would be that we move into Season 8 with a whole new set of mechanics without a hiccup, it'd be just like every other move from one season to another, only when we get to Season 8 we'd have a bunch of new Depth Chart options and the game logic would be better.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
What this game should do is overhaul, and REMOVE all the BS like bonus-applied SAs, VAs, EQT, etc. Just make it attribute vs attribute. Create more attributes, deepen that whole attribute system. And when you include something like SAs, they have to be only SKILL-specific things. Like giving you the ability to take a one-handed catch. Not giving you a percentage chance to take a one-handed catch, and then boosting the percentage chance of that by stacking it with more SPs. The SAs being free-form, and all just skill-specific, would make the journey of that first created player more real as they learn and acquire new skills (SAs).

You place an emphasis on tactics, not levels. You implement more interactive features for players and owners.....players---training modules that are actually interactive, you have to do wonderlic tests and click the mouse to catch balls etc. While for owners they have like socio-economic RPG elements that affect their team and finances. While for coaches they have play creation modules that is completely customizable.

And as the whole point of GLB is to be a 10 season decline, then by the 10th season, all that stuff should be more than enough for a players lifetime and an agents sense of interactivity with GLB. Enough for them to come back and play more and more BECAUSE every game is parity-driven, real-like dynamics and stats, scores, etc. And bringing back the "watch the live game" mode that was fun for groups of people to enjoy.

Removing all the tedium too of a thousand mouse-clicks to have to do anything. And all the laborious AI interface percentages. And the website has all the basic forum and PM/email/chat tools that a lot still havent been implemented during season 1 suggestions.


this post gg is amazing, you shuold create your own thread about this stuff, the training modules...brilliant, the social economics for owners...brilliant, play creation modules brilliant... and again brilliant, your like three times a fucking guiness commercial! I would love all of these things regardless of an overhaul(on the fence, I like this game regardless of whether or not it's broken, and will continue to play until it stops being fun)
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
imho...we should go back to the Sim as we had it at the end of season 6. Then, we need a complete re-working of the league set-up. This would stop a lot of the 100+-0 games by not having teams with level 35-40 players playing teams with level 20 and below players.

These two simple steps would make the game as a whole much more entertaining to everyone.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
+1 to the OP.

The list of changes is way to small, but game mechanics should be addressed as a priority. Once it's done better it will be possible to add a more versatile playbooks (offense and defense) and make the game a coordinator heaven.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense.


And involves making a completely new game...


Which is why it shouldn't be done.

Even if you preserve players as they are, it resets Beta and we'd have bugs and new things that needed much bigger nerfing than we see now.

I remember playing in Season 2, and I've seen how far the game has progressed. I don't want to see the progress lost. Oh, and we wouldn't all agree on what to do if the game were redone.

I'd want him to make sure that Speed wasn't a part of any trench blocking. Run blocking would be mainly Blocking and Strength, whereas pass blocking would be Blocking and Agility with Strength also mattering a small amount. Breaking blocks would involve Agility and Strength and mostly a new Break Block ability (as opposed to just having it as an SA).

Everyone would do it his own way, and many people wouldn't like that way. Better to keep all the great progress we've seen.
 
yomama17
offline
Link
 
This is a dumb idea. I doubt that any of you have actual programming knowledge and why should he take the time to completely rewrite the game to fix a lot of the stuff that is not broken. Everyone is making assumptions which are likely not true. Nobody can be completely sure how the game works.

EDIT: Besides, a wipe of the game would lead to new bugs.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 14:13:25
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yomama17
This is a dumb idea. I doubt that any of you have actual programming knowledge and why should he take the time to completely rewrite the game to fix a lot of the stuff that is not broken. Everyone is making assumptions which are likely not true. Nobody can be completely sure how the game works.


Thank you for your input!
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by TheInfinity


Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense.


And involves making a completely new game...


Which is why it shouldn't be done.

Even if you preserve players as they are, it resets Beta and we'd have bugs and new things that needed much bigger nerfing than we see now.

I remember playing in Season 2, and I've seen how far the game has progressed. I don't want to see the progress lost. Oh, and we wouldn't all agree on what to do if the game were redone.

I'd want him to make sure that Speed wasn't a part of any trench blocking. Run blocking would be mainly Blocking and Strength, whereas pass blocking would be Blocking and Agility with Strength also mattering a small amount. Breaking blocks would involve Agility and Strength and mostly a new Break Block ability (as opposed to just having it as an SA).

Everyone would do it his own way, and many people wouldn't like that way. Better to keep all the great progress we've seen.


I disagree, because the game is handicapped in the long-term. Like I said we're bubble gum and shoe-string fixing the over-all mechanics of the game. The longer we band-aid this whole thing, the less and less it's going to work.

Instead Bort has to just put his head down, take some criticism, and do everything he's wanted to do that he thought would make the game better. I'd rather see a full wipe and reset myself.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by TheInfinity



Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense.


And involves making a completely new game...


Which is why it shouldn't be done.

Even if you preserve players as they are, it resets Beta and we'd have bugs and new things that needed much bigger nerfing than we see now.

I remember playing in Season 2, and I've seen how far the game has progressed. I don't want to see the progress lost. Oh, and we wouldn't all agree on what to do if the game were redone.

I'd want him to make sure that Speed wasn't a part of any trench blocking. Run blocking would be mainly Blocking and Strength, whereas pass blocking would be Blocking and Agility with Strength also mattering a small amount. Breaking blocks would involve Agility and Strength and mostly a new Break Block ability (as opposed to just having it as an SA).

Everyone would do it his own way, and many people wouldn't like that way. Better to keep all the great progress we've seen.


I disagree, because the game is handicapped in the long-term. Like I said we're bubble gum and shoe-string fixing the over-all mechanics of the game. The longer we band-aid this whole thing, the less and less it's going to work.

Instead Bort has to just put his head down, take some criticism, and do everything he's wanted to do that he thought would make the game better. I'd rather see a full wipe and reset myself.


I wouldn't, regardless of whether players were kept (and if it were done, it would likely require a re-spec-- bad, but not as bad as a wipe-- but that is only one of the reasons not to do it). The big reason is all the problems of Beta as in Season 1 would be back, and it would take 7 more seasons to reach the level we're at in terms of sophistication without bugs.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 14:52:44
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.