User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
I like the idea, with one exception.

Don't penalize the guy who loses his team because it went in the red, at least not until a defined period has been set for this. I look at that as a learning experience.

A team shouldn't be taken from an owner in this case in the middle of the season anyway. Any team that goes in the red should have until the end of the following season to get back in black before losing a team. This will keep teams together and cause less gutting of teams.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Anyone who supports this thread...

Clearly has no idea what a pain in the ass it is for an uncapped team to start over with level one players.

It screws the entire conference that they are in.

GLB should encourage teams that are in the position to start over to sell their team and buy an expansion team.


They should no longer be in that conference at that point...thus the need for serious restructuring.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
I like the idea, with one exception.

Don't penalize the guy who loses his team because it went in the red, at least not until a defined period has been set for this. I look at that as a learning experience.

A team shouldn't be taken from an owner in this case in the middle of the season anyway. Any team that goes in the red should have until the end of the following season to get back in black before losing a team. This will keep teams together and cause less gutting of teams.


I see a valid and legit point in this and I agree with it.

The people that should get penalized are the guys that are having firesales every single season before they decide that they can no longer win and they sell there team.

In truth, I think the guys who are firesaling their teams EVERY SINGLE SEASON to get loads of money in and in and in, should also be penalized, and there is a lot of them, but that's another story for another thread
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
Originally posted by didymus

Anyone who supports this thread...

Clearly has no idea what a pain in the ass it is for an uncapped team to start over with level one players.

It screws the entire conference that they are in.

GLB should encourage teams that are in the position to start over to sell their team and buy an expansion team.


They should no longer be in that conference at that point...thus the need for serious restructuring.


I want to add, that GLB SHOULD NOT be encouraging, what this thread is discouraging.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by AuburnBlue

Originally posted by atom871



...

I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.

Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?



-1 (that's MINUS 1, negative, disagree)

Players in the NFL (or any other league) can go anywhere they want when their contact ends. Look at Warren Moon and Doug Flutie and Hershel Walker as perfect illustrations. Flutie AND Walker started out in the USFL, under your rule that's where their careers would have ended. Flutie next goes into the NFL where he bombed. He then went to the CFL and became a superstar. He threw for something like 45,000 yards and was an MVP 6(?) times! THEN he came back to the NFL and finished with a career winning record. Walker's USFL and NFL records speak for themselves. Warren Moon was a superstar in Canada and then became the highest paid player in the NFL and went tot he Pro Bowl 9 times. He also had something like 50,000 yards passing in just his NFL career.

Short answer, blocking where a player can go when their contract expires is a stupid suggestion and has no basis in reality.


As far as players go, there needs to be more incentive to signing long term deals imo.

When it comes to trades, how about a 'player veto option'? Give the Players an alert, and allow them to VETO the trade within 24 hr. of its existance. This DOES admittingly slow down the trade process, and probably calls for a slightly longer off season, but it allows the players some control over where they get traded. It also may encourage the majority of owners to go about trading people in the proper manner.

When it comes to contracts, implementing team captain ideas, among others, like jersey sales, etc. may help, little by little encourage long term deals.

What about changing up chemistry a little? Make it so when you sign a SOLID player, you get + chemistry, not just negative. Perhaps + overall but a - O or D chem. Just a thought.


As far as gutted teams, there's no way to completely eliminate them, but here's some thoughts..

Stop supporting farm teams, Put a VERY THIN limit on how many players one agent can have on a single team, and Make Penalties for selling your team.

These things, won't completely eliminate it, but give STRONG Discouragement toward it.



-100 on the VERY THIN limit idea. I should be able to have as many of my players on my team as I want...what does that have to do with anything.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by Raiders12

I like the idea, with one exception.

Don't penalize the guy who loses his team because it went in the red, at least not until a defined period has been set for this. I look at that as a learning experience.

A team shouldn't be taken from an owner in this case in the middle of the season anyway. Any team that goes in the red should have until the end of the following season to get back in black before losing a team. This will keep teams together and cause less gutting of teams.


I see a valid and legit point in this and I agree with it.

The people that should get penalized are the guys that are having firesales every single season before they decide that they can no longer win and they sell there team.

In truth, I think the guys who are firesaling their teams EVERY SINGLE SEASON to get loads of money in and in and in, should also be penalized, and there is a lot of them, but that's another story for another thread


Yes the "fire sale" guys should be banned for at least two seasons, maybe more.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
Originally posted by jackriley

Originally posted by AuburnBlue


Originally posted by atom871




...

I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.

Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?



-1 (that's MINUS 1, negative, disagree)

Players in the NFL (or any other league) can go anywhere they want when their contact ends. Look at Warren Moon and Doug Flutie and Hershel Walker as perfect illustrations. Flutie AND Walker started out in the USFL, under your rule that's where their careers would have ended. Flutie next goes into the NFL where he bombed. He then went to the CFL and became a superstar. He threw for something like 45,000 yards and was an MVP 6(?) times! THEN he came back to the NFL and finished with a career winning record. Walker's USFL and NFL records speak for themselves. Warren Moon was a superstar in Canada and then became the highest paid player in the NFL and went tot he Pro Bowl 9 times. He also had something like 50,000 yards passing in just his NFL career.

Short answer, blocking where a player can go when their contract expires is a stupid suggestion and has no basis in reality.


As far as players go, there needs to be more incentive to signing long term deals imo.

When it comes to trades, how about a 'player veto option'? Give the Players an alert, and allow them to VETO the trade within 24 hr. of its existance. This DOES admittingly slow down the trade process, and probably calls for a slightly longer off season, but it allows the players some control over where they get traded. It also may encourage the majority of owners to go about trading people in the proper manner.

When it comes to contracts, implementing team captain ideas, among others, like jersey sales, etc. may help, little by little encourage long term deals.

What about changing up chemistry a little? Make it so when you sign a SOLID player, you get + chemistry, not just negative. Perhaps + overall but a - O or D chem. Just a thought.


As far as gutted teams, there's no way to completely eliminate them, but here's some thoughts..

Stop supporting farm teams, Put a VERY THIN limit on how many players one agent can have on a single team, and Make Penalties for selling your team.

These things, won't completely eliminate it, but give STRONG Discouragement toward it.



-100 on the VERY THIN limit idea. I should be able to have as many of my players on my team as I want...what does that have to do with anything.


It has ALOT to do with everything. You should be allowed to own as many players as you want, but you should have to spread those guys out amongst GLB. You shouldn't be able to have them ALL one on team. Because, it leads to exploitations that GLB and Bort have worked very hard to get rid of and continue to try to get rid of. It's also the major reason that many of the ideas can never happen that have been suggested, because the way its set up right now, its' too easy to exploit by those who have nothing but their own guys on their team.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by Raiders12

I like the idea, with one exception.

Don't penalize the guy who loses his team because it went in the red, at least not until a defined period has been set for this. I look at that as a learning experience.

A team shouldn't be taken from an owner in this case in the middle of the season anyway. Any team that goes in the red should have until the end of the following season to get back in black before losing a team. This will keep teams together and cause less gutting of teams.


I see a valid and legit point in this and I agree with it.

The people that should get penalized are the guys that are having firesales every single season before they decide that they can no longer win and they sell there team.

In truth, I think the guys who are firesaling their teams EVERY SINGLE SEASON to get loads of money in and in and in, should also be penalized, and there is a lot of them, but that's another story for another thread


But out of the 1000s of owners in GLB how many actually do that?
 
Link
 
What? Firesaling each season? Look at the trading block.

Many of the current firesales are by the SAME owners who do it every year to get money for their team.
 
davidwest
offline
Link
 
I agree to disagree with the # of players an owner can have on a team. I bought my team in season 7 with no clue if it was going to work out or not, but I committed myself to seeing it through. I had no experience with OC or DC so I created an entire defense to I could experiment and try to learn how to DC. My partner in the venture created an entire Offense to learn how to OC. I don't see how what we have done in any way hurts the game. I know we are the exception to the rule, but I don't like the limits to # of player son a roster idea. By doing our team this way we have not wasted anyones time by screwing up their builds whiel we learned how to adjust the energy settings, no one is hurt by playig time, and if I screw up a build or have a better idea for a build I just do it, there are no worries, hastles, and no one is getting pissy. We sucked last season, we are doing better this season, but still kinda suck, and there is no one complaining about anything. I have no intention of selling the team, abandoning the team or anything else. If I ever feel comfortable enough with my skills running hte team I'll work on recruiting, and retire my players off, but for the learning experience, this team has been invaluable.

I don't know what circumstances cause owners to quit. I would guess not having the discipline to ride it out and take their lumps. I do know that every morning I logged into my team in season 7 I had at least one trade offer waiting for me of some poor level 12-13 player that some team had signed off of the D leagues just to try to get quick funds by selling his contract. This season every other morning I have trade offers for level 21 players that teams signed to shitty deals, short contracts and what not just to try to sell them off. Their are always going to be canerous owners out there that will look to gain the upper hand no matter what the concequences. Yeah it was frustrating as hell waiting to get my team after 3 seasons trying to learn how to even play the game, but I wanted my team, my way, so I didn't mind waiting. If these owners really are wanting a "do-over" then it shouldn't bother them to wait an extra season to get another team, in my opinion.

In summary:

Multiple players on a team = who cares

Owners that sell off every season just because they aren't winning chamionships = Gay
 
davidwest
offline
Link
 
I think you need to remember that teams can be bought by anyone old enough to log onto a computer and the ability to buy a debit card, so its hard to teach lessons to eight year olds.
 
Link
 
I see what you're saying David, but... there are Pee Wee teams now, if people are going to do this, pee wee teams should be used for this. Create a shit load of players, don't boost them (obviously) put them on a team, at the end of the season, retire them, rinse and repeat. I don't think doing this with Pee Wee teams is a MAJOR deal because its a 1 season thing.

But when it comes to actual teams, like i said, many of the options and features people want, like Team Captain Awarding, with bonuses, is absolutely exploited by those owners who choose to put nothing but their own players (or the players of 1-2 guys) on the same team.

As for Owners being inexperienced, be a GM, be a OC, be a DC before you get a team and learn a bit, read up on the guides, there is no reason at all what so ever and no excuse imo, for Owners stating 'i didn't know' everything is there for you to learn, so put forth the effort. If you're too lazy to do that, you shouldn't be owning a team in the first place, especially if you PAY to get the team...what's the point of paying to get a team if you're not really going to run the team effectively?

But, to answer your question

Multiple players on a team = Who Cares? More people than you obviously realize care about this issue. But those who DO IT are always the ones who refuse to see anything wrong with it.

The other major issue with it, imo, is that it takes the entire process of running, building, and owning a team, and flushes it down the toilet. You don't TRULY have to put any recruiting effort forth, because all you're doing is stocking your team with your own players, you don't have to worry about interacting with other people, unless you're talking to yourself in the mirror.. It honestly, imo, takes the point and the realism, of being an owner, completely out of the picture.

This needs to come to an end.


So does Teams being sold by the same owner over and over.

If you sell your team , you shouldn't be able to get right back on the waiting list. You should have to wait a few months before getting back on it. There's plenty of people who have never been owners that want a team. Those people deserve a shot. They shouldn't be penalized because you didn't do your homework, or you can't 'hack losing a few games.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
I could care less about things like the team captain thing. Its ideas like that and the Vet stuff that is killing this game now as it is.

I guess my issue with the own team players deal, is the use of "very thin". I have a team with 10-12 of my own players on it. That didn't stop me from recruiting a whole team. Some of my better players start and several are 2-3 string. It in no way causes any problems or gives me an unfair advantage over anyone. Where do you draw the line, I guess would be my issue?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
I could care less about things like the team captain thing. Its ideas like that and the Vet stuff that is killing this game now as it is.

I guess my issue with the own team players deal, is the use of "very thin". I have a team with 10-12 of my own players on it. That didn't stop me from recruiting a whole team. Some of my better players start and several are 2-3 string. It in no way causes any problems or gives me an unfair advantage over anyone. Where do you draw the line, I guess would be my issue?


And this is why we're suggesting limiting owners, such as yourself & david west (with all due respect, because i'm not saying your a bad owner), from having 30 players on one team. Because the ONLY REASON you think those are bad ideas, is because with it, comes limitations to 'exploit' the game.

Where do I draw what line? On limitations? Agents, myself included, should be allowed just 2 players on a single team. Its as simple as that really. It completely anihilates a LARGE portion of the exploitation that currently exists.

Farm teams, imo, are one of the other things that keep the 'competitive balance' from existing in this game. If you want a farm team find a baseball MMO. But, the real question is, how do you stop Farm teams? Perhaps limiting the # of teams that one person can be a GM of (that includes as an owner). That won't completely eliminate them, but again, it'll limit them.

Then you start penalizing Owners for constant selling of their teams. Like I said, I believe in second chances.

When someone sells there team, they should not be able to get back on the waiting list for a full season. But that should be their second chance. IF they sell again, that's it, no more teams for them.

If that person however, upon initially selling their team, is found, via legit and solid evidence, to have abused their priviledges as an owner, including the gutting process and the constant Fire Sales and 'abusive nature' toward players, it should be taken into consideration that this particular owner not be allowed to own another team.

The process to do this, would need to be taken seriously because, obviously, you'll get those 'Hot heads' wanting to get people banned because they're just cold hearted pieces of crap. So when Administration &/or support get an inquiry of Abuse of Ownership, it would need to be seriously looking into, in a very objective manner to determine whether banning the person is just or whether they deserve a second chance and the inquiry is just meaningless banter.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 12:49:07
 
davidwest
offline
Link
 
I think my point was, would you want me having no experience setting up an AI or running a defnse to have the reins for your team? I know my team is an exception because like I said I have ZERO intent to sell it. I just think my way of on the job training was safer for everyone involved.

I agreed that owners selling teams because they just want to start over was crap, at least I thought I made that point.

I don;t really agree tha tI am missing out on what the true "owning a team experience" is. The only thing I am missing out on is the recruiting process, which I will eventually have to do anyways, I kind of take exception to the claim of "flushing anything down the toilet", but I will conceed your point that you don't like multiple players on the same team. Trust me I have plenty of players on other teams to gain the "GLB experience".

Thanx
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.