This would make me happier than a java/flash based team chat (...irc?).
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bring Back Forum Search
I did some testing on title searches and it was really slow, but they aren't indexed at the moment. I would need to apply an index to the title field, requiring some downtime, etc. User id search is fairly quick - there's an index on that.
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
martinwarnett
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
People who do put real names as their account name would thus have every forum post, however ridiculous, flippant, abusive eligible to be found in google searches as a consequence.
A big no, no, no from me. Not because I'd be personally affected too much by that, others who may be younger, maybe immature would then have potentially damaging posts they make easily searchable, gaining a high google rank against their name,
Any forum search has to be internal to the site.
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
People who do put real names as their account name would thus have every forum post, however ridiculous, flippant, abusive eligible to be found in google searches as a consequence.
A big no, no, no from me. Not because I'd be personally affected too much by that, others who may be younger, maybe immature would then have potentially damaging posts they make easily searchable, gaining a high google rank against their name,
Any forum search has to be internal to the site.
modred
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I did some testing on title searches and it was really slow, but they aren't indexed at the moment. I would need to apply an index to the title field, requiring some downtime, etc. User id search is fairly quick - there's an index on that.
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
Userid search would be great.
I'm on the fence about opening it up to google, wouldn't that greatly increase the load on the forum servers?
I did some testing on title searches and it was really slow, but they aren't indexed at the moment. I would need to apply an index to the title field, requiring some downtime, etc. User id search is fairly quick - there's an index on that.
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
Userid search would be great.
I'm on the fence about opening it up to google, wouldn't that greatly increase the load on the forum servers?
tsherr
offline
offline
Originally posted by martinwarnett
Originally posted by Bort
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
People who do put real names as their account name would thus have every forum post, however ridiculous, flippant, abusive eligible to be found in google searches as a consequence.
A big no, no, no from me. Not because I'd be personally affected too much by that, others who may be younger, maybe immature would then have potentially damaging posts they make easily searchable, gaining a high google rank against their name,
Any forum search has to be internal to the site.
Maybe that will keep people more polite. If it takes public shaming to make people practice good manners, then I'm all for it.
T
Originally posted by Bort
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
People who do put real names as their account name would thus have every forum post, however ridiculous, flippant, abusive eligible to be found in google searches as a consequence.
A big no, no, no from me. Not because I'd be personally affected too much by that, others who may be younger, maybe immature would then have potentially damaging posts they make easily searchable, gaining a high google rank against their name,
Any forum search has to be internal to the site.
Maybe that will keep people more polite. If it takes public shaming to make people practice good manners, then I'm all for it.
T
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by martinwarnett
Originally posted by Bort
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
People who do put real names as their account name would thus have every forum post, however ridiculous, flippant, abusive eligible to be found in google searches as a consequence.
A big no, no, no from me. Not because I'd be personally affected too much by that, others who may be younger, maybe immature would then have potentially damaging posts they make easily searchable, gaining a high google rank against their name,
Any forum search has to be internal to the site.
Maybe that will keep people more polite. If it takes public shaming to make people practice good manners, then I'm all for it.
T
agreed
Originally posted by martinwarnett
Originally posted by Bort
The more I think about it, though, I think opening forum access to public viewing to allow google to index it would probably be the best method to having a reasonable search without a whole lot of work other than the work of making the forum public.
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
People who do put real names as their account name would thus have every forum post, however ridiculous, flippant, abusive eligible to be found in google searches as a consequence.
A big no, no, no from me. Not because I'd be personally affected too much by that, others who may be younger, maybe immature would then have potentially damaging posts they make easily searchable, gaining a high google rank against their name,
Any forum search has to be internal to the site.
Maybe that will keep people more polite. If it takes public shaming to make people practice good manners, then I'm all for it.
T
agreed
Capaneus
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I did some testing on title searches and it was really slow, but they aren't indexed at the moment. I would need to apply an index to the title field, requiring some downtime, etc. User id search is fairly quick - there's an index on that.
I would rather have userid search sooner, and the rest later. Please?
I did some testing on title searches and it was really slow, but they aren't indexed at the moment. I would need to apply an index to the title field, requiring some downtime, etc. User id search is fairly quick - there's an index on that.
I would rather have userid search sooner, and the rest later. Please?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























