User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Um, isn't it against the rules to gut a team?
Page:
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tigerbait0307
I think i'm more or a blind bat just looking for blood. Yeah I dont wander pastures I wander the night.


Hey when you get off the soap box can I use it.


No, I'm goinge to race it.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
This is the same as in fantasy football where a player dumps all their good guys into Free Agency and gives up mid-season. It destroys the balance of the league. And there are only two reasons to explain it:
a) absolute and stupid ignorance; if you don't have time to run the team find a GM who does (easy to do by posting on the public forums) or SELL the team to someone who does have the time and interest.
b) What you really wanted was to get your good players off of this team and to other teams that you own or GM or have players and you decided it was cheaper and easier to buy the team and then move everyone (and let everyone else go, which of course they would want to do). This avoids the need to offer a comparable trade value and saves your team the need to give players or money to get your guys. For the cost of 1000 FP if there are quite a few players involved it is a good deal.

Congratulations--you jobbed the system but please don't act like we are bad for calling you on it.


Go look in the forum history. I looked and even found assistants to the coordinators. Only 1 of them actually really did his job, but he left after the first game as the OC. I asked within the organization no one stepped up, instead of ignoring the team of time that is needed to properly run it, I found a new owner.

All the players that were part of the Highlanders have found different teams found in different leagues. Its not like 1 team was made into a super team.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Ug, this got much worse since I posted.


3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread



Sorry, but you're simply wrong in point 3 above. Using your analogy, the NFL would NEVER let the Chargers SELL the team and GUT its roster DURING the season. Moves like this DURING an active season are crap, pure and simple.

 
TundaKlap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Ug, this got much worse since I posted.

1) STOP USING NESTED QUOTES. Take the time to delete some stuff out of your quotes.

2) I don't care what your thoughts are on people selling teams, on people releasing players just before selling teams, or how any of this relates to a board game. If you don't have anything related to this topic: that being the potential of any sort of cheating and any info that can help solve this issue one way or the other, DO NOT POST.

If you want to talk about those other topics, go to another thread or, if one doesn't exist, create one and debate away.

3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread


If I may say one last thing here. I don't get where people are saying we moved people to the team I own, or intentionally to other teams.

You can go find posts in Players Looking for Teams where we offered up players as packages to any team. We didn't move anyone to any specific team, and players not owned by myself or Icespyder were allowed to do what they wanted.

I hear this place called Salem has witches, you may want to start the hunt there.
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Jed

Ug, this got much worse since I posted.


3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread



Sorry, but you're simply wrong in point 3 above. Using your analogy, the NFL would NEVER let the Chargers SELL the team and GUT its roster DURING the season. Moves like this DURING an active season are crap, pure and simple.



Jed, he called you out. He questioned your authority, you gunna take that? I demand you two duel,pistols, thirty paces high noon out in the corn field.
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TundaKlap
Originally posted by Jed

Ug, this got much worse since I posted.

1) STOP USING NESTED QUOTES. Take the time to delete some stuff out of your quotes.

2) I don't care what your thoughts are on people selling teams, on people releasing players just before selling teams, or how any of this relates to a board game. If you don't have anything related to this topic: that being the potential of any sort of cheating and any info that can help solve this issue one way or the other, DO NOT POST.

If you want to talk about those other topics, go to another thread or, if one doesn't exist, create one and debate away.

3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread


If I may say one last thing here. I don't get where people are saying we moved people to the team I own, or intentionally to other teams.

You can go find posts in Players Looking for Teams where we offered up players as packages to any team. We didn't move anyone to any specific team, and players not owned by myself or Icespyder were allowed to do what they wanted.

I hear this place called Salem has witches, you may want to start the hunt there.


Witches float, that should help in your hunt.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Jed

Ug, this got much worse since I posted.


3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread



Sorry, but you're simply wrong in point 3 above. Using your analogy, the NFL would NEVER let the Chargers SELL the team and GUT its roster DURING the season. Moves like this DURING an active season are crap, pure and simple.



This is not the NFL that needs to be understood, and it needs to stop being compared to it. If that is what you are expecting, you are best finding another game.
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Jed


Ug, this got much worse since I posted.


3) Owners are not obligated to keep a team for one second longer than they would like, whether it throws the balance of the league a bit out of whack or not. It's no worse than if LdT got injured 7 games into the season after averaging close to 200 yards and 2 TDs a game. The NFL isn't going to say "wait, we have to keep things balanced, no more games till he gets better or it's not fair to the teams the Chargers already played!" Things happen, teams/leagues change.

In conclusion, cut it out or I'm locking the thread



Sorry, but you're simply wrong in point 3 above. Using your analogy, the NFL would NEVER let the Chargers SELL the team and GUT its roster DURING the season. Moves like this DURING an active season are crap, pure and simple.



This is not the NFL that needs to be understood, and it needs to stop being compared to it. If that is what you are expecting, you are best finding another game.


I heard something about this maddness game, or maddened or something like that... maybe thats soccer...
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=175644
Originally posted by Bort
'Gutting' - Buying a team, stripping it of its resources and then selling the team back for the next poor sucker to buy.


Does ANYONE dispute that this is what happened? There's responsibility to the players, sure, but there's also responsibility to the next owner and that's what is ignored/neglected by gutting.

And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?
 
TundaKlap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=175644
Originally posted by Bort

'Gutting' - Buying a team, stripping it of its resources and then selling the team back for the next poor sucker to buy.


Does ANYONE dispute that this is what happened? There's responsibility to the players, sure, but there's also responsibility to the next owner and that's what is ignored/neglected by gutting.

And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?


Problem: He is talking about specifically buying a team that is ownerless with decent players, gutting it by trading to your own team, and leaving it go.

This is not what happened in this situation. Also, the person who will be owning the team was informed up-front what would happen.
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=175644
Originally posted by Bort

'Gutting' - Buying a team, stripping it of its resources and then selling the team back for the next poor sucker to buy.


Does ANYONE dispute that this is what happened? There's responsibility to the players, sure, but there's also responsibility to the next owner and that's what is ignored/neglected by gutting.

And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?


Did you see that one movie, I think it was called the replacements? It was a good movie, the guards were my favorites.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=175644
Originally posted by Bort

'Gutting' - Buying a team, stripping it of its resources and then selling the team back for the next poor sucker to buy.


Does ANYONE dispute that this is what happened? There's responsibility to the players, sure, but there's also responsibility to the next owner and that's what is ignored/neglected by gutting.

And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?


No resources have been stripped. Players wanted off the team and they were not held against there wishes. The new owner was made aware that many of the players would not want to stay for the duration of the season.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
Originally posted by oldskool

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=175644
Originally posted by Bort


'Gutting' - Buying a team, stripping it of its resources and then selling the team back for the next poor sucker to buy.


Does ANYONE dispute that this is what happened? There's responsibility to the players, sure, but there's also responsibility to the next owner and that's what is ignored/neglected by gutting.

And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?


No resources have been stripped. Players wanted off the team and they were not held against there wishes. The new owner was made aware that many of the players would not want to stay for the duration of the season.



In a word, "bullshit".
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TundaKlap
Originally posted by oldskool

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=175644
Originally posted by Bort


'Gutting' - Buying a team, stripping it of its resources and then selling the team back for the next poor sucker to buy.


Does ANYONE dispute that this is what happened? There's responsibility to the players, sure, but there's also responsibility to the next owner and that's what is ignored/neglected by gutting.

And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?


Problem: He is talking about specifically buying a team that is ownerless with decent players, gutting it by trading to your own team, and leaving it go.

This is not what happened in this situation. Also, the person who will be owning the team was informed up-front what would happen.


That, Tunda, doesn't matter. You're a bad person. You shouldn't be allowed to smile, or play with puppies anymore. You puppy hater. Go club some more baby seals while you're at it.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Sorry, but you're simply wrong in point 3 above. Using your analogy, the NFL would NEVER let the Chargers SELL the team and GUT its roster DURING the season. Moves like this DURING an active season are crap, pure and simple.


Wow, that's impressively dumb right there. I specifically said to take that debate to its' own thread and you quoted me to keep it going. Hell, you could have quoted me from here to start the new thread and I would have responded backing up my point.

Consider this an official warning, do something stupid like that again and you'll lose posting privileges.

Originally posted by TundaKlap
If I may say one last thing here. I don't get where people are saying we moved people to the team I own, or intentionally to other teams.

You can go find posts in Players Looking for Teams where we offered up players as packages to any team. We didn't move anyone to any specific team, and players not owned by myself or Icespyder were allowed to do what they wanted.

I hear this place called Salem has witches, you may want to start the hunt there.


Ya know, you were doing so well until that last line. Regardless, this is at least on-topic. If you notice, I said nothing saying you guys did anything wrong. I just said that if there's a serious accusation, it should be looked into.

Originally posted by oldskool
And Jed, surely you realize there's a huge difference between one player getting injured for part of the season, and an entire team dumping their roster so they could instead play a bunch of nobodies taken out of the parking lot (regardless of what level of football is being considered, unless you count the "Guys we found in a parking lot" league)?


What did I just say above? How does this relate to the topic? Consider this an official warning for you as well, oldskool.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.