Originally posted by rj414
If the Big 12 had handled it like the SEC or ACC - the other two leagues with conference championships - would have handled it, then Texas would have been in, despite your asinine Stanford metaphor, which is so completely and utterly stupid that I won't even elaborate on it.
The SEC and ACC have clauses in their tiebreakers that state that the highest ranked team in the BCS goes - UNLESS the top 2 teams are within 5 places of each other. In which case the winner of that head to head goes.
I've said it once and I'll say it again - there is no argument that Oklahoma was clearly better that can hold water. They lost on a neutral field, and they played tech at home - Texas Tech outside the city of Lubbock plays 1 step above Duke. Put them in a hostile environment and their sissy quarterback suddenly comes under pressure because his offensive line with the 8 mile splits suddenly can't communicate and his defense doesn't have an army of rabid Tech fans making noise for them.
I've got another Pac-10 reference for you. Is Penn State clearly better than USC because they annihilated the Oregon State team at home that USC lost to on the road?
The SEC and ACC rules make little sense to me, to be honest. I'm not saying that the Big 12 method is right or wrong, it just makes more sense. You would think that a conference would want to send its best teams to the championship games just because it would get them in the title game more often, which is why the Big 12 did it. Really, the problem is this stupid system of 6 team divisions with unbalanced schedules and championship games. I really like how the Pac-10 does it with a true round robin. It's far more unlikely to get into this kind of a tie-breaking situation. Everyone plays the same schedule, and you can compare things down the line (who did best against the 4th place team... then the 5th...etc...). The Big 10 has stupid rules about "co-champions" as well. Penn State beats Ohio State, but has the same record, and is only a Co-Champion. Then add in the rule about who goes to the Rose Bowl based on who was the team that went there the least recently.
Why was Texas Tech undeserving of going to the Big 12 title game? I mean they did beat Texas! That means they are better than them, right? I'm just asking what a good procedure would be that's fair (and doesn't use the BCS at all). It makes sense that it would be something like Division Record, Conference Record, Overall Record, Record against common teams, and then Point Differentials. Maybe the Big 12, SEC, and ACC would just learn from this and scrap the joke division system. Na, they wouldn't make things better if it cost them money.
It's all for nothing at this point, the Big 12 was exposed as complete frauds this year. Oklahoma's "unstoppable offense" is held to 14 points. Texas sneaks a win against a very mediocre Ohio State team. Texas Tech gets blown out by Ole Miss. Cowboy State loses to Oregon. Missouri has to go to OT against a terrible Northwestern team (a team that gave Indiana its only conference win). The top 5 teams are 2 plays away from being 0-5.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by corruptone
I hate the BCS and have always backed a playoff...and I don't really want to get too involved in this argument/discussion. All I have to say though, is if you believe Utah would have drilled Ohio State OR possibly even beaten Texas..then you should just go watch the Utah/TCU game. Utah was extremely lucky to win that one as TCU missed two 4th quarter field goals.
I don't think anyone said Utah would "drill" anyone. But they won every game, and a lot of people think they deserved a shot at the championship. They would definitely make for a better game than OSU-Florida a couple of seasons ago.
As far as margin of victory being relevant in any way, there's really no argument for it. Some teams win with offense and some teams win with defense. A team that shuts everyone down and wins by small margins is not somehow worse than a team that wins by big margins in shootouts (or uses their effective offense as a form of defense by keeping the other team off of the field). I'd actually tend to argue that the defensive team is better, because a great defense almost always beats a great offense.
You make a good point about margin of victory, and I think it is pretty valid. An analysis system that accounted for how a team does offensively and defensively vs. what their opponents did, etc... Systems that use margin of victory will still be better to predict winners than systems that don't look at scores at all. Your system that uses scores, but not just a 14 point win is a 14 point win. A system that weights things differently is probably better than just raw MOV (IMO, YPP gained and YPP allowed are probably the best measures that are easily calculated, and comparing that against teams averages and how good they are).