Wow, I step out for a little bit and a discussion erupts!
I think there definitely is value in this kind of objective approach as well as in a subjective one like Haplos' work. Neither of the methods wil be able to capture the full picture, but coming at it from a few different angles is going to give us a better look than just choosing one or the other. And it's fun too.
Sure, we could tear the numbers apart further and further and add many, many other things to it (believe me, there's plenty of other stuff I'd like to include in the formula that I think would make it even more accurate if free time weren't an issue), but the foundation for these rankings is simply "How good are the teams you've beaten and how good are the teams that beat you?" I think, to that end, this method is rather elegant ... you get big points for beating a good team, fewer points for beating a lesser team, you lose big points for getting beat by a bad team and lose fewer points by getting beat by a powerhouse. By including DSF's stuff and my simple team tallies, we add a smoothing effect that still gives you some credit even if you beat a team that is winless on the year - if you rack up yards and points the way you should in those games. I think the most important thing that shutd0wn said was "... every game matters."
Ultimately, I think it would be awesome to combine the objective analysis with some subjective commentary - maybe that's the future of these rankings. I've thought to include notes along with the final S.C.O.R.E. each "week" and may do so in the future, but that, of course, is largely a time-dependent issue.
Anyway, as it stands, while the oddities in team movement from week-to-week are some of the more interesting things to note about this system, I think the big picture it produces is reasonable. I don't think Haplos was challenging the validity of the method, but instead was just pointing to one of those movement moments that looked a bit strange.
Good job in week 9 everyone - we're past the half-way mark now. Time to start thinking about the playoff races.
I think there definitely is value in this kind of objective approach as well as in a subjective one like Haplos' work. Neither of the methods wil be able to capture the full picture, but coming at it from a few different angles is going to give us a better look than just choosing one or the other. And it's fun too.
Sure, we could tear the numbers apart further and further and add many, many other things to it (believe me, there's plenty of other stuff I'd like to include in the formula that I think would make it even more accurate if free time weren't an issue), but the foundation for these rankings is simply "How good are the teams you've beaten and how good are the teams that beat you?" I think, to that end, this method is rather elegant ... you get big points for beating a good team, fewer points for beating a lesser team, you lose big points for getting beat by a bad team and lose fewer points by getting beat by a powerhouse. By including DSF's stuff and my simple team tallies, we add a smoothing effect that still gives you some credit even if you beat a team that is winless on the year - if you rack up yards and points the way you should in those games. I think the most important thing that shutd0wn said was "... every game matters."
Ultimately, I think it would be awesome to combine the objective analysis with some subjective commentary - maybe that's the future of these rankings. I've thought to include notes along with the final S.C.O.R.E. each "week" and may do so in the future, but that, of course, is largely a time-dependent issue.
Anyway, as it stands, while the oddities in team movement from week-to-week are some of the more interesting things to note about this system, I think the big picture it produces is reasonable. I don't think Haplos was challenging the validity of the method, but instead was just pointing to one of those movement moments that looked a bit strange.
Good job in week 9 everyone - we're past the half-way mark now. Time to start thinking about the playoff races.
Last edited May 12, 2008 21:16:42






























