User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The fix for powerbacks.... without taking away from their abilities
Page:
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
There needs to be a bigger influence on balance when you make a 'missed' tackle. HBs can juke people off their feet and thats okay, but they do slow down quite a bit and also doesn't roll into a missed/broken tackle stat. Slow down the Power HBs more when they make their contact and also add more influence to their balance, and we're set. I have no problem in them breaking tons of tackles vs. speed defenses. It will happen, but some of the crap is just silly.

Defenses do need to adapt, but there is a flaw in how powerful powerbacks are right now. It just needs a bit more tweaking.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dianwei32
I would be fine with increaing the chance to be tackled from behind, so long as the HB gets a simlar increase in the chance to fight out extra yards against against the defender.


That's what I'm asking for... You should be able to tackle easily from behind, but every time, the ballcarrier would be able to fall forward for a yard or two... Not trying to remove power backs, just limit their unrealistic 80 yard runs, with 4 broken tackles after they've already cleared the pile, and gotten 15 yards deep.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Speed and Angle should matter.

105 speed Heading at 13 degrees against a 95 speed heading at 193 should have a 200 speed collission.

A 99 speed Heading at 13 degrees and a 114 speed heading at 35 degrees should result in a much lesser collission.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
this needs MUCH more love IMO
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
yet again with bort in the house
 
CocoaJayda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by Pitch Black

Originally posted by imnotthatstupid


Originally posted by jktooley



http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way


what about LB's putting SP's into Strength and tackling... the problem is solved


No it's not - because to do that then you need to sacrifice the very skills necessary to bring down the Power Backs alter ego - the Speed Back.

Defenders need at least 1 (usually more) attributes to do their jobs than the guys they are forced to tackle need to do theirs - especially LB's.

The answer isn't as simple as put more points into X and Y - because to do that those points almost always have to come from A, B and C to do that. A LB not only has to be able to tackle a Power Back, he need to be able to catch a HB in the flat, drop back in coverage, blitz and a couple other things that require other skills at high levels than just Strength/Tackling.

In the end - a LB can NEVER win the "Match the guy you are tackling statistically" battle - he needs the entire kitchen sink just to be able to do his job - which means doing more than just stopping Power Backs.





I don't have time to read the entire thread, so I hope this wasn't brought up yet...

But you do realize that one man isn't the entire defense? If the game is about reality.... in reality Brandon Jacobs would run over a CB trying to play LB (which is what the speed 'backers are), and IN REALITY a super strong 'backer will generally be slower. You can't have everything. That's the fun of the game, is making a linebacker that is alternately strong enough to take down a power back, yet fast enough to play some coverage.

Last I checked, you didn't need 80 speed to stick with an 80 speed TE. I don't know the exact number, but I imagine that some good vision, 60-70 speed, and good agility would take care of that.

If you are going to specialize AT ANY POSITION be prepared for some fall-out. If you want to be a speed backer... you will get to the play more often than not, but you will miss a few tackles here and there. if you want to be the surest tackler ever seen.... well you won't get many tackles because you're too slow to get into position.

Everything is a trade-off, people. You can't get it all, but you can either have the entire defense specialize at something (this is where gang tackles, etc, come into more play) or you yourself can be well-rounded with STRENGTHS, but not necessarily a specialized build.

 
dpell
offline
Link
 
It still seems like the system is set up so the HB makes a roll before each play as to how awesome his tackle-breaking is going to be that game. We had a combo/power back we played in a scrimmage tonight break only 6 tackles against us, but 3 of them came on one play one right after another where he ran through our LB with over 70 tackling and two of our DB's. I didn't see anyone being dragged, he just ran through it all. The next posession he was back to mortal.
 
ozzfan1317
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imnotthatstupid
Originally posted by jktooley

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way

I Agree +1

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CocoaJayda
Originally posted by greengoose

Originally posted by Pitch Black


Originally posted by imnotthatstupid



Originally posted by jktooley




http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way


what about LB's putting SP's into Strength and tackling... the problem is solved


No it's not - because to do that then you need to sacrifice the very skills necessary to bring down the Power Backs alter ego - the Speed Back.

Defenders need at least 1 (usually more) attributes to do their jobs than the guys they are forced to tackle need to do theirs - especially LB's.

The answer isn't as simple as put more points into X and Y - because to do that those points almost always have to come from A, B and C to do that. A LB not only has to be able to tackle a Power Back, he need to be able to catch a HB in the flat, drop back in coverage, blitz and a couple other things that require other skills at high levels than just Strength/Tackling.

In the end - a LB can NEVER win the "Match the guy you are tackling statistically" battle - he needs the entire kitchen sink just to be able to do his job - which means doing more than just stopping Power Backs.





I don't have time to read the entire thread, so I hope this wasn't brought up yet...

But you do realize that one man isn't the entire defense? If the game is about reality.... in reality Brandon Jacobs would run over a CB trying to play LB (which is what the speed 'backers are), and IN REALITY a super strong 'backer will generally be slower. You can't have everything. That's the fun of the game, is making a linebacker that is alternately strong enough to take down a power back, yet fast enough to play some coverage.

Last I checked, you didn't need 80 speed to stick with an 80 speed TE. I don't know the exact number, but I imagine that some good vision, 60-70 speed, and good agility would take care of that.

If you are going to specialize AT ANY POSITION be prepared for some fall-out. If you want to be a speed backer... you will get to the play more often than not, but you will miss a few tackles here and there. if you want to be the surest tackler ever seen.... well you won't get many tackles because you're too slow to get into position.

Everything is a trade-off, people. You can't get it all, but you can either have the entire defense specialize at something (this is where gang tackles, etc, come into more play) or you yourself can be well-rounded with STRENGTHS, but not necessarily a specialized build.



+100
 
MessorLord
offline
Link
 
i don't care should make people that have CB's and safties put stuff into tackling because mine are making tackles
 
oregonduck11
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley


I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.




then you havn't seen me play
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
No fix is needed.
 
Link
 
I have no problem with slowing powerbacks down, as long as Bort stops nerfing FB speed and allows them to gain some naturally each level. Otherwise , only nerf HB powerback speed / NOT FB's.... (HB's gain speed each level, FB's dont. )

As far as breaking tackles from behind , ever hear of a thing called "high-step" ?? ( tire drills,ect)

LB's aren't supposed to be "jacks-of-all-trades/ masters of none"... GM's and Owners just need to realize that this is changing from a game where you could play all game with no back-ups, to a game where depth in the core team of players is becoming more valuable... (maybe have two speed LB's, two power-tackler LB's, and one Defense General (well rounded) kinda thing...)
[ Instead of following the leaders and building ALL speed LB's ]
Last edited Jan 27, 2009 09:08:48
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1
I have no problem with slowing powerbacks down, as long as Bort stops nerfing FB speed and allows them to gain some naturally each level. Otherwise , only nerf HB powerback speed / NOT FB's.... (HB's gain speed each level, FB's dont. )

As far as breaking tackles from behind , ever hear of a thing called "high-step" ?? ( tire drills,ect)

LB's aren't supposed to be "jacks-of-all-trades/ masters of none"... GM's and Owners just need to realize that this is changing from a game where you could play all game with no back-ups, to a game where depth in the core team of players is becoming more valuable... (maybe have two speed LB's, two power-tackler LB's, and one Defense General (well rounded) kinda thing...)
[ Instead of following the leaders and building ALL speed LB's ]


You should see our well rounded Defense General MLB try to cover HB's in the flats... Pretty comical.

We actually lost a game this season to a team that torched us over and over again by playing a WR at HB and running him out on the HB pass focus plays from shotgun... Damn us for having that balanced player that everybody thinks is so great... Try that on the higher levels kid.


As for breaking tackles from behind... Yes, I know it happens. Please try to understand my point. I also know that when a player is trying to avoid a tackle from behind, he has to turn his head, stiff arm, high step, whatever... That causes him to break stride and slow down... Not on this game. They just keep going full tilt and the would-be tackler stops moving.

The point isn't to screw over power backs... it's to take away the unrealistic nature of a HB not slowing down period when avoiding a tackle from behind, and a power back rarely being tackled in these circumstances, when in reality, it is much harder to avoid a tackle from behind....
Last edited Jan 27, 2009 09:38:26
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.