User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > Season 7 Power Rankings
Page:
 
Rixen
offline
Link
 
Understandable how the maulers are above us....wait....wait....nope totally confused.

P.S. I know this is a computation and not up to the poster. I am just drunk and felt like posting some shit.
 
4th Quarter
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to explain how retarded these rankings are. Whatever the formulas are, they need to be revisited. They're absolutely mind bottling and I'm not going to pay any attention to them.
 
Slayer4099
offline
Link
 
Not only does it bottle your mind, it boggles mine as well. Just so you know, in scrabble boggle would be worth 2 more points due to the "g" being worth an extra point a piece.
 
FUPA
offline
Link
 
Splittin hairs Donnie
Last edited Jan 15, 2009 04:34:51
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
I approve the most recent ratings.
 
dan rules
offline
Link
 
Do you guys understand how RPI works?? SOS is one of the biggest and most important parts...and ours has been the toughest so far
 
4th Quarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dan rules
Do you guys understand how RPI works?? SOS is one of the biggest and most important parts...and ours has been the toughest so far


It's not about understanding how RPI works, it's that the results are giving rankings that just dont make any sense so the RPI is worthless.

You have a tough SOS, but you have lost 3 games head to head, and you're ranked above all 3 of the teams that beat you. You cant tell me that makes any sense. The equations need to be revised if these rankings are going to be valuable at all.
Last edited Jan 15, 2009 10:50:51
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4th Quarter
Originally posted by dan rules

Do you guys understand how RPI works?? SOS is one of the biggest and most important parts...and ours has been the toughest so far


It's not about understanding how RPI works, it's that the results are giving rankings that just dont make any sense so the RPI is worthless.

You have a tough SOS, but you have lost 3 games head to head, and you're ranked above all 3 of the teams that beat you. You cant tell me that makes any sense. The equations need to be revised if these rankings are going to be valuable at all.


its not even half way through the season...... give it 5 more games and it will be dead accurate..... if you expect rpi to be good at this point in the season, after 7 games....... you're ridiculously confused
 
Mooser
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4th Quarter
I'm not going to explain how retarded these rankings are. Whatever the formulas are, they need to be revisited. They're absolutely mind bottling and I'm not going to pay any attention to them.


I think the formulas should stay the same. I think it is funny that people are getting all worked up about a made up ranking that has no barring on whether or not they make the playoffs. If you dislike it that much make your own, and use what ever means you like.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mooser
Originally posted by 4th Quarter

I'm not going to explain how retarded these rankings are. Whatever the formulas are, they need to be revisited. They're absolutely mind bottling and I'm not going to pay any attention to them.


I think the formulas should stay the same. I think it is funny that people are getting all worked up about a made up ranking that has no barring on whether or not they make the playoffs. If you dislike it that much make your own, and use what ever means you like.


I reran the numbers with my own special calculations.

Yaks were #1 in mine too.

Coincidence? I think not.
 
4th Quarter
offline
Link
 
I'm not at all worked up about this at all. I'm just saying that this system isnt providing any useful results, so the whole thing is a waste of time.

By the end of the season we'll have played nearly all of the teams in our conference, so the conference standing will give a very accurate representation of the power rankings. So if we have to wait for the end of the season for the RPI to become accurate, then it's conference rankings arent anything the standings wont tell us, and its only real benefit is that it provides a way to compare teams between the 2 conferences and get comprehensive rankings for the entire 32 team league. Unfortunately, we only have one week of inter-conference games, so that's very little data for the system to use to compare conferences. If this system cant get the western conference standings right after 6 weeks of conference play (48 games) then how is it going to have enough information to integrate teams from the 2 conferences with only 16 inter conference games to use as data?
Last edited Jan 15, 2009 14:18:58
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4th Quarter
I'm not at all worked up about this at all. I'm just saying that this system isnt providing any useful results, so the whole thing is a waste of time.

By the end of the season we'll have played nearly all of the teams in our conference, so the conference standing will give a very accurate representation of the power rankings. So if we have to wait for the end of the season for the RPI to become accurate, then it's conference rankings arent anything the standings wont tell us, and its only real benefit is that it provides a way to compare teams between the 2 conferences and get comprehensive rankings for the entire 32 team league. Unfortunately, we only have one week of inter-conference games, so that's very little data for the system to use to compare conferences. If this system cant get the western conference standings right after 6 weeks of conference play (48 games) then how is it going to have enough information to integrate teams from the 2 conferences with only 16 inter conference games to use as data?


i mean.... all this really is is something for us to smack each other around and argue about during the season, and its serving its purpose. its true that nothing matters other than the records, but it doesnt hurt to have these rankings. and if uclabob doesnt mind doing it, then why not have them?
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Atleast it gives us a basic "feel" for the lvl compitition everyone has faced so far. Im pretty sure nobody thinks too much about what a spreadsheet says when there gameplanning but its nice to look at and argue over I suppose
 
voltageaav
offline
Link
 
The most recent rankings are pretty bogus, but it's the same argument you hear about the BCS and unfortunately in college football, that does determine the postseason. We're just lucky it doesn't work that way here. That's the problem with the formulas though, sometimes they come out with results that make no sense whatsoever.
 
Slayer4099
offline
Link
 
Hey uncle Bob... where are the rankings? You can't spoil us and then take them away mid-season!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.