User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Stealth nerfing of the WR Screen?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Toriq


All you Wr screen abusers are just whiners. Competent DCs have learned to combat it and now yu say Bort "stealth nerfed" it. That's just major BS. DCs have simply learned how to nullify it's effectiveness. Supposed stealth nerfs are just your abusers excuse. Sad and tired. *shrug*


I'm glad that the WR screen can be an effective play and can also be effectively countered like any other play.

I'm just not glad that even when the defense calls the right play, the pathing/blocking bugs can often nullify the defense's strategy.

People like jrry32 seem to think that defense should be about trying to counter the game's bugs rather than countering the offense...


I think INSTEAD of nerfing plays, you should at least try to figure out how to stop it because this is a play that can be stopped and isn't usually run successfully in the elite leagues.


Please listen for once.

I never once said "nerf the WR screen". Other people have said that, but not me.

The only thing you heard me say is "fix the bugs"!

Yet despite this, you continue to not listen and distort my position.

Why not try listening?
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury

I'm glad that the WR screen can be an effective play and can also be effectively countered like any other play.

I'm just not glad that even when the defense calls the right play, the pathing/blocking bugs can often nullify the defense's strategy.

People like jrry32 seem to think that defense should be about trying to counter the game's bugs rather than countering the offense...


Lately I've been successful in nullifying it's overall effectiveness. Nothing to do with a "stealth nerf". And I've said all along the pathing is broken and needs fixing, but that didn't stop me from setting up effective D's to can it either. Took a while but it is doable so I hope the nezt team we face relies in it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kanaan
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Originally posted by tigerbait22




It is such a simple play to stop... I don't understand the whining.. So are the DE's. Its tactics and builds. The Sim seems to be running pretty well right now IMO.


Because you look at things through the lens of your 15-1 championship-winning AAA team with a defense that hasn't seen the play much at all this year?


No, because his players have the builds needed to stop it and he probably came up with plays to stop it instead of sitting around and whining at/antagonizing others.



No, seriously, go look at his games. There's hardly a WR screen at all.

So if there's one thing he did NOT do, it's come up with a play to stop it. Since there was no "it".


fallingmercury, you are on a team i gm, i had a playoff game whith the original poster of thread, he ran that play like 20 times and only had 1 long gainer, it doesnt need to be nerfed, and here is the game
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=286714


Yeah you can play to the bugs and stack four guys over there, knowing that at best the bug will allow the WR to only net three defenders.

Sooo... Yeah... pathing/blocking is bugged, which is my (our) point.

And you can just hope that you're lucky enough that the pathing bug doesn't show up (much).
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 23:59:28
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Negative.. I don't like to give away tactics but you are way off base.. this one is incomplete, but the defense works. Tactics are vital. Playoffs are over so here you go

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11693015
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11693223
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11695597

These are against one of the best teams in the game.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Another

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11696088

So tired of everyone screaming about nerfs.. learn the game better. Put effort into your defensive AI.. Try "Thinking"

As you can see its a cover one 3-2-6 that puts 3 Defensive backs on that side to cover the TWO WR's, so you have ONE WR trying to block THREE defenders from making the tackle.
Last edited Dec 21, 2008 00:05:42
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Toriq



All you Wr screen abusers are just whiners. Competent DCs have learned to combat it and now yu say Bort "stealth nerfed" it. That's just major BS. DCs have simply learned how to nullify it's effectiveness. Supposed stealth nerfs are just your abusers excuse. Sad and tired. *shrug*


I'm glad that the WR screen can be an effective play and can also be effectively countered like any other play.

I'm just not glad that even when the defense calls the right play, the pathing/blocking bugs can often nullify the defense's strategy.

People like jrry32 seem to think that defense should be about trying to counter the game's bugs rather than countering the offense...


I think INSTEAD of nerfing plays, you should at least try to figure out how to stop it because this is a play that can be stopped and isn't usually run successfully in the elite leagues.


Please listen for once.

I never once said "nerf the WR screen". Other people have said that, but not me.

The only thing you heard me say is "fix the bugs"!

Yet despite this, you continue to not listen and distort my position.

Why not try listening?


I have no problem fixing the bugs but your constant whining has influenced this play to be nerfed when EVEN WITH THE BUGS it can be stopped.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11693223


This one is the lame inside route that always fails.

Yes, I know that if you stack 3-4 guys on top of the WR screen, it gets stuffed. Although occasionally one WR can single-handedly block all three defenders and it's a long gain.

And yes, I've posted 10-20 plays where starting level 40-42 players from winning Pro-league squads have ended up in the triple block. So it does happen.

Regardless, why do you have to game plan for the bugged pathing? Wouldn't it nice if you just had to game plan for the offense?
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by tigerbait22

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11693223


This one is the lame inside route that always fails.

Yes, I know that if you stack 3-4 guys on top of the WR screen, it gets stuffed. Although occasionally one WR can single-handedly block all three defenders and it's a long gain.

And yes, I've posted 10-20 plays where starting level 40-42 players from winning Pro-league squads have ended up in the triple block. So it does happen.

Regardless, why do you have to game plan for the bugged pathing? Wouldn't it nice if you just had to game plan for the offense?


See.. there lies the difference.. We are not GAME PLANNING for a BUGGED play.. We are game planning to simply stop a very EFFECTIVE play.

Game planning for PLAYS and Formations is what GAME PLANNING means..
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


I have no problem fixing the bugs but your constant whining has influenced this play to be nerfed when EVEN WITH THE BUGS it can be stopped.



No, you and others constantly responding to my posts about bug fixes by saying "shutup nerfmonkey" - and completely missing the point because you don't listen - has led me to try to drive my point further.

I've even tried suggesting that we agree on fixing the bugs, but it hasn't worked. You've always taken it a step further with your distortions and putting words into my mouth.

Instead, just read.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by tigerbait22


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=274204&pbp_id=11693223


This one is the lame inside route that always fails.

Yes, I know that if you stack 3-4 guys on top of the WR screen, it gets stuffed. Although occasionally one WR can single-handedly block all three defenders and it's a long gain.

And yes, I've posted 10-20 plays where starting level 40-42 players from winning Pro-league squads have ended up in the triple block. So it does happen.

Regardless, why do you have to game plan for the bugged pathing? Wouldn't it nice if you just had to game plan for the offense?


See.. there lies the difference.. We are not GAME PLANNING for a BUGGED play.. We are game planning to simply stop a very EFFECTIVE play.

Game planning for PLAYS and Formations is what GAME PLANNING means..


I have no problem with it being effective (or very effective). I just have a problem when it ends up being effective due to a single WR blocking 2-3 players.

And yes, even though double/triple blocking happens only a minority of the time, it can very easily lead to game-changing TDs so it's a big deal.

You did a good job of scouting and countering the WR screen on that play, and you deserve credit for it. Pat yourself on the back.

If the other team got lucky enough to spring a few multi-blocks on you and walk away with an extra couple TDs because of it (despite your perfect playcalling), I would say they didn't deserve credit for it. Would you agree?
Last edited Dec 21, 2008 00:13:12
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jrry32



I have no problem fixing the bugs but your constant whining has influenced this play to be nerfed when EVEN WITH THE BUGS it can be stopped.



No, you and others constantly responding to my posts about bug fixes by saying "shutup nerfmonkey" - and completely missing the point because you don't listen - has led me to try to drive my point further.

I've even tried suggesting that we agree on fixing the bugs, but it hasn't worked. You've always taken it a step further with your distortions and putting words into my mouth.

Instead, just read.


So fix it how? Where the play NEVER works? Whats the solution.. They ran that play against us 6 times.. the biggest gain was 3 1/2 yards..
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by jrry32




I have no problem fixing the bugs but your constant whining has influenced this play to be nerfed when EVEN WITH THE BUGS it can be stopped.



No, you and others constantly responding to my posts about bug fixes by saying "shutup nerfmonkey" - and completely missing the point because you don't listen - has led me to try to drive my point further.

I've even tried suggesting that we agree on fixing the bugs, but it hasn't worked. You've always taken it a step further with your distortions and putting words into my mouth.

Instead, just read.


So fix it how? Where the play NEVER works? Whats the solution.. They ran that play against us 6 times.. the biggest gain was 3 1/2 yards..


(See above post which came in a millisecond before yours)

Please don't say the play NEVER works. There are probably literally 100+ links on this forum from this past week alone where the play springs long gains after bugged pathing/blocking. One dude even posted half a dozen plays where the WR blocked two CBs and a FS alone, leading to a long TD. The links were from either Canada AAA or Pro, where guys up to level 41 were caught in the bugged pathing.

And no, I'm not going to go dig up those posts for you, but see for yourself.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jrry32



I have no problem fixing the bugs but your constant whining has influenced this play to be nerfed when EVEN WITH THE BUGS it can be stopped.



No, you and others constantly responding to my posts about bug fixes by saying "shutup nerfmonkey" - and completely missing the point because you don't listen - has led me to try to drive my point further.

I've even tried suggesting that we agree on fixing the bugs, but it hasn't worked. You've always taken it a step further with your distortions and putting words into my mouth.

Instead, just read.


Yes, I have said shut up nerfmonkey. In most of my posts, I have told you to stop worrying about the play being fixed and just to FIND WAYS TO STOP IT.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.