User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
3 ideas:

VETO-vote / MOVE DOWN - request

A team flagged as moving up can veto to stay in their current league. The next team up the list will have the chance to move up. This prevents teams moving up too fast and loosing fun / have to make major roster moves.

A team not competetive in their current league (let's say 4-12-0 or worse) can move down a league. This prevents teams struggling for season after season.

Build-Up-League

Newly released teams are in a Build Up league for like 1 - 3 seasons. This league is a giant pyramid and serves the purposes of establishing the team and finding those new teams the proper spots in the existing leagues.

During the regular season, any team going CPU will instantly give a choice to the top team in the Build Up leage to jump in. The team doesn't have to, but can take over this spot. If it does, all remaining games of the replaced team will be counted 50-0 (so the established teams are not screwed up) and all remaining games are counted as scrimmages for the team jumping in. If the new team manages to end the scrimmages above an 0.333 average, they can choose to stay in the league. Otherwise they drop back to the Build Up league and instantly get back their top spot.

(So this is kind of "try out" for the team jumping in and provides the teams in the existing leagues a closer, competetive game than just playing a CPU team.)

At season end, the promotion out of a regular league (below AAA) works this way:

1. Winners move up
2. If additional spots need to be filled, the teams that won at least 2 playoff games are flagged (but can veto - see above)
3. If that doesn't fill all spots, the top 3 teams in Build-Up leage can "jump in"
4. If that doesn't fill all spots, ... (just like right now, but the teams can veto)

Naturally, there are quite a few spots to fill in the lowest leagues (single A or BBB, depending on region). So these leagues are filled (top to bottom) with teams out of the Build-Up - League.

This way, the teams moving into a established league are the best new teams and should be able to play competetive. On the other hand, no team owner is thrown into an established leage of average lv. 24s and has to build up from scratch.

Of course, the Build-Up league will naturally grow (more guys requesting new teams than owners selling back). So when the Build-Up league exceeds like 500 teams, Bort can expand an existing league and fill it with "The Best of Build Up" - which makes this league higly competetive and promotions no problem.


"forced" demotion

Any team doing 2-14 or worse will have to go down a league, even if another team is even worse. Any team doing 2-14 or worse in the lowest leage of their region is dropping out into the Build-Up league.

This will adress league parity, for highly incompetetive teams will move out faster - this creating spots for competetive teams to get promoted.
 
Link
 
txsteves was better in my opinion
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MikeV99
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?


Make it Real simple, The teams that are moving up b/c they are the best in the division, and replacing the two teams that are the worst in the division, REGARDLESS of who else is bought, sold, disbanded etc.....

Those two teams moving up, get the right to recruit at the new leagues level cap..

Other teams getting bumped up due to non-performance reasons (Sales, Dibanding, forgetting to renew, etc...) They do not get to recruit at a higher level..

I know it isn't perfect, but that way you can eliminate the problems with teams not having time to recruit or teams recruiting and then staying put....


 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

I have very little sympathy for owners in the situation described in the first half of the paragraph. As long as there's ample warning - for example, auto-send an alert to all owners with teams about to expire - there's no excuse not to re-ante on time. Come day 41 (or whatever day promotion/relegation happens), their team should be reset and dropped. If the alert mechanism for ownership running out is currently insufficient, such owners could be given a bit of extra time this coming off-season, but moving forward, this should become a non-issue.

Originally posted by Bort
2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

I'm inclined to agree with both sentiments. The earlier promotion / relegation is handled, the better for (almost) everyone. An extra day's freeze will be frustrating for (almost) everyone. For what it's worth, I would rather have promotion/relegation handled on day 41. Any team sold between days 41 and 45 should be listed somewhere and owners should be given a chance to request a swap with these teams and move up via a support request. This should minimize the number of CPU teams in higher leagues and provide an alternative for teams not flagged for promotion, but who feel they belong in a higher-tier league. It does generate more work for admins, but I think that's a reasonable price to pay. No owner should be unwillingly forced into an inferior recruiting situation by being forced into promotion - any teams sold after day 41 (or 42, or whatever day is decided on) should only be manually relegated if a trade partner is found. If the number of teams involved is too large, this solution can be re-considered heading into future seasons.

So, what I would like to see:
Day 35 - 39: Alerts sent to owners of expiring teams. On day 35, a regular alert. On day 38, bold red text on the owner's main page saying "YOU HAVE AN EXPIRING TEAM!".
Day 40: Last day of regular season.
Day 41: Promotion/Relegation is handled.
Day 41-44: Any team sold back to the CPU during this time frame is listed in a central location. Swap requests with human owners will be handled manually by admins. Relegated CPU teams can be assigned to new owners.
Day 45: Last day of off-season, no new transfer requests can be submitted. Last day to assign CPU teams to human owners.

This way, the off-season is reduced to the minimum possible time, and nobody is disadvantaged unless they either forgot to renew (which is entirely their fault) or they willingly asked for promotion via manual transfer / accepted a relegated CPU team after day 41. This also allows for what is hopefully a minimum of CPU teams, especially in higher-end leagues.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 08:38:20
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
3 ideas:

VETO-vote / MOVE DOWN - request

A team flagged as moving up can veto to stay in their current league. The next team up the list will have the chance to move up. This prevents teams moving up too fast and loosing fun / have to make major roster moves.

A team not competetive in their current league (let's say 4-12-0 or worse) can move down a league. This prevents teams struggling for season after season.

Build-Up-League

Newly released teams are in a Build Up league for like 1 - 3 seasons. This league is a giant pyramid and serves the purposes of establishing the team and finding those new teams the proper spots in the existing leagues.

During the regular season, any team going CPU will instantly give a choice to the top team in the Build Up leage to jump in. The team doesn't have to, but can take over this spot. If it does, all remaining games of the replaced team will be counted 50-0 (so the established teams are not screwed up) and all remaining games are counted as scrimmages for the team jumping in. If the new team manages to end the scrimmages above an 0.333 average, they can choose to stay in the league. Otherwise they drop back to the Build Up league and instantly get back their top spot.

(So this is kind of "try out" for the team jumping in and provides the teams in the existing leagues a closer, competetive game than just playing a CPU team.)

At season end, the promotion out of a regular league (below AAA) works this way:

1. Winners move up
2. If additional spots need to be filled, the teams that won at least 2 playoff games are flagged (but can veto - see above)
3. If that doesn't fill all spots, the top 3 teams in Build-Up leage can "jump in"
4. If that doesn't fill all spots, ... (just like right now, but the teams can veto)

Naturally, there are quite a few spots to fill in the lowest leagues (single A or BBB, depending on region). So these leagues are filled (top to bottom) with teams out of the Build-Up - League.

This way, the teams moving into a established league are the best new teams and should be able to play competetive. On the other hand, no team owner is thrown into an established leage of average lv. 24s and has to build up from scratch.

Of course, the Build-Up league will naturally grow (more guys requesting new teams than owners selling back). So when the Build-Up league exceeds like 500 teams, Bort can expand an existing league and fill it with "The Best of Build Up" - which makes this league higly competetive and promotions no problem.


"forced" demotion

Any team doing 2-14 or worse will have to go down a league, even if another team is even worse. Any team doing 2-14 or worse in the lowest leage of their region is dropping out into the Build-Up league.

This will adress league parity, for highly incompetetive teams will move out faster - this creating spots for competetive teams to get promoted.


Won't you need "partners" with all this movement. How will you regulate it if three teams want to move down, but only one wants to move up? Last season, teams could find their own partners to swtich with, and if you limit it to the same region, and only one level of movement, it can help league parity.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 08:43:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MikeV99
Originally posted by MikeV99

Originally posted by Bort


Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?


Make it Real simple, The teams that are moving up b/c they are the best in the division, and replacing the two teams that are the worst in the division, REGARDLESS of who else is bought, sold, disbanded etc.....

Those two teams moving up, get the right to recruit at the new leagues level cap..

Other teams getting bumped up due to non-performance reasons (Sales, Dibanding, forgetting to renew, etc...) They do not get to recruit at a higher level..

I know it isn't perfect, but that way you can eliminate the problems with teams not having time to recruit or teams recruiting and then staying put....




That is retarded. We're trying to get the leagues more competitive! Not hamper someone because they got moved to a tougher league.
 
REDAZZ
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
3 ideas:

VETO-vote / MOVE DOWN - request

A team flagged as moving up can veto to stay in their current league. The next team up the list will have the chance to move up. This prevents teams moving up too fast and loosing fun / have to make major roster moves.

A team not competetive in their current league (let's say 4-12-0 or worse) can move down a league. This prevents teams struggling for season after season.

Build-Up-League

Newly released teams are in a Build Up league for like 1 - 3 seasons. This league is a giant pyramid and serves the purposes of establishing the team and finding those new teams the proper spots in the existing leagues.

During the regular season, any team going CPU will instantly give a choice to the top team in the Build Up leage to jump in. The team doesn't have to, but can take over this spot. If it does, all remaining games of the replaced team will be counted 50-0 (so the established teams are not screwed up) and all remaining games are counted as scrimmages for the team jumping in. If the new team manages to end the scrimmages above an 0.333 average, they can choose to stay in the league. Otherwise they drop back to the Build Up league and instantly get back their top spot.

(So this is kind of "try out" for the team jumping in and provides the teams in the existing leagues a closer, competetive game than just playing a CPU team.)

At season end, the promotion out of a regular league (below AAA) works this way:

1. Winners move up
2. If additional spots need to be filled, the teams that won at least 2 playoff games are flagged (but can veto - see above)
3. If that doesn't fill all spots, the top 3 teams in Build-Up leage can "jump in"
4. If that doesn't fill all spots, ... (just like right now, but the teams can veto)

Naturally, there are quite a few spots to fill in the lowest leagues (single A or BBB, depending on region). So these leagues are filled (top to bottom) with teams out of the Build-Up - League.

This way, the teams moving into a established league are the best new teams and should be able to play competetive. On the other hand, no team owner is thrown into an established leage of average lv. 24s and has to build up from scratch.

Of course, the Build-Up league will naturally grow (more guys requesting new teams than owners selling back). So when the Build-Up league exceeds like 500 teams, Bort can expand an existing league and fill it with "The Best of Build Up" - which makes this league higly competetive and promotions no problem.


"forced" demotion

Any team doing 2-14 or worse will have to go down a league, even if another team is even worse. Any team doing 2-14 or worse in the lowest leage of their region is dropping out into the Build-Up league.

This will adress league parity, for highly incompetetive teams will move out faster - this creating spots for competetive teams to get promoted.


MAJOR +1 !!!!
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
Originally posted by MikeV99

Originally posted by MikeV99


Originally posted by Bort



Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?


Make it Real simple, The teams that are moving up b/c they are the best in the division, and replacing the two teams that are the worst in the division, REGARDLESS of who else is bought, sold, disbanded etc.....

Those two teams moving up, get the right to recruit at the new leagues level cap..

Other teams getting bumped up due to non-performance reasons (Sales, Dibanding, forgetting to renew, etc...) They do not get to recruit at a higher level..

I know it isn't perfect, but that way you can eliminate the problems with teams not having time to recruit or teams recruiting and then staying put....




That is retarded. We're trying to get the leagues more competitive! Not hamper someone because they got moved to a tougher league.


SteelCity, your killing all my ideas... I vow to find one you agree with..

and why is it retarded.. The whole point was to keep the idea simple.. too many variables to worry about multiple teams moving up and down, by helping the teams that earned it, how does that hurt anyone else??
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by Intimnasc

One idea that has come up in the past and I personnaly like is allow teams that promote to boost to the median level of the league. This way they are not thrown immediately into a league where they are giving up 3-6 levels. Being more competitive will keep more people interested.



The problem there is - I sign with a team about to be promoted to a non cap league; from a cap league - just to take advantage of the extra boosts...and then i get released; or traded; or whatever so i can go to the league of my choice...can be easily exploited (even though i like the concept)


While I agree with you there is little about the game in general that someone doesn't exploit. I see what your saying and the only thing I could say is that for each 3 extra boosts a player gets they lose 1 season on their lifetime.

For instance if player boosts normal 3 boosts then boosts 4 levels to median level of league player loses 1.3 seasons on this toon but gets to remain on the team with his friends.


edit::: I say this because there has to be some reward for promoting. In many cases promoting is a death sentence for teams of friends that wanna be competitive. No one wants to go into a league where you give up 3-6 levels in talent points to half the league. Nor do we want to cut our friends and the people that got us there.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 09:07:17
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MikeV99
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

Originally posted by MikeV99


Originally posted by MikeV99



Originally posted by Bort




Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?


Make it Real simple, The teams that are moving up b/c they are the best in the division, and replacing the two teams that are the worst in the division, REGARDLESS of who else is bought, sold, disbanded etc.....

Those two teams moving up, get the right to recruit at the new leagues level cap..

Other teams getting bumped up due to non-performance reasons (Sales, Dibanding, forgetting to renew, etc...) They do not get to recruit at a higher level..

I know it isn't perfect, but that way you can eliminate the problems with teams not having time to recruit or teams recruiting and then staying put....




That is retarded. We're trying to get the leagues more competitive! Not hamper someone because they got moved to a tougher league.


SteelCity, your killing all my ideas... I vow to find one you agree with..

and why is it retarded.. The whole point was to keep the idea simple.. too many variables to worry about multiple teams moving up and down, by helping the teams that earned it, how does that hurt anyone else??


The reason it's retarded is because this would hold teams back that didn't deserve to be held back (no team deserves to be held back, but have equal rights within their respective leagues). Say you lose in the conference championship, but you still get promoted because of all the sold teams, etc. Why should teams in the same league as you be able to do as they please (recruiting wise) and you're stuck with limitations? This would only cause more separation within leagues, and that's what we're trying to do away with. It's also another case of the rich get richer so to speak.
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

The reason it's retarded is because this would hold teams back that didn't deserve to be held back (no team deserves to be held back, but have equal rights within their respective leagues). Say you lose in the conference championship, but you still get promoted because of all the sold teams, etc. Why should teams in the same league as you be able to do as they please (recruiting wise) and you're stuck with limitations? This would only cause more separation within leagues, and that's what we're trying to do away with. It's also another case of the rich get richer so to speak.


OK, I see your point... I wasn't thinking about Rich get Richer or Holding Teams back, I was just trying to find an easy fix to early recruiting and didn't weigh the negatives.. Thanks

 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
When teams move up because of CPU team moving down, is it done by conference (ie only alpha move to alpha, etc). Or does the promotion go to the team that wins the tie breaker system, regardless of which conference they are in?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by ZachG650

Originally posted by jared


Originally posted by TxSteve



would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?


I really like this tx


yes me too


+1


Something like this is perfect. It'd make all BBBs similar, AAAs similar, and so on. Because once people start having to retire their guys, we're going to have older leagues suddenly decimated and not as many expansion teams being made.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
just bringing this one back up - since Bort started it...

AND

i've seen several other threads started to discuss this - so figure why not keep all ideas here (meaning - those of you with new posts - feel free to add your ideas here)
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
I am sure its not a new idea, and maybe over-simplistic, but...

Early notification of teams expiring (such as during the season) and a date certain (say by noon of the second day of the off-season) of when to renew should be all that is required. I too have no sympathy for the I forgot, because since you can renew at any time and you have had notification, then if you miss it, your not an active enough owner in the first place.

CPU teams should move out not up or down. If a team isn't renewed then it should be removed from a league and set aside (with all live players being given their release). I mean do we really need CPU owned teams with CPU players in an active league? I say put them in a CPU only owned league.

I liked the build-up league idea, and as teams are purchased, they would have to remain in the CPU league for the remainder of the season. This would allow the owner time to recruit for the next upcoming season. The owner should have a choice during this time of one of the following:

1. Play another season in the CPU league. (Although I am not sure why you would want to do this, except maybe to familiarize yourself with team operations before joining an active league.

2. Move into the Build-up league with the layout as described earlier.

3. Move into the Big leagues. These leagues should be tiered better than they are currently. There should be no reason for teams with players of say, 15-20 lvl or under in leagues against lvl 30+ players. This isn't really fun for either team, whether your winning by 100's or are the team getting walked on.

I would suggest that there should be a better way of ranking a team's overall level and then teams should be put in leagues accordingly, Then your promotion/demotion would be a much better tool for moving teams.

IMHO, the most important thing is for owners/players to have fun, and this would make teams more competitive which makes for a more fun experience.
Last edited Dec 19, 2008 08:45:25
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.