User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Players adapting to overused plays
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I'm all for it ... as long as you give a minus to vision whenever the offense uses the same formation but a different Play. Say I run HB Slam 3x in a row and your guys would get a +1 to vision if I run it the next snap... shouldn't you guys get a -1 to vision if I use the same formation but call a different play?

If you anticipate something, and are right - great! But if you anticipate something, and you are wrong.. consider that as well.


instead of a direct bonus to vision, or a direct penalty to vision, it should be a success rate multiplier that affects the vision roll in either direction based partly on the DAI
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
I've been in support of this for ages, but it really only makes sense with either a custom play creator for offense, or a vastly expanded playbook. Too many useless plays for this to do much good now. Defense would have an incredible advantage.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
I've been in support of this for ages, but it really only makes sense with either a custom play creator for offense, or a vastly expanded playbook. Too many useless plays for this to do much good now. Defense would have an incredible advantage.


I can see that happening
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
I do agree, but I must add...I remember last season a team dominating our A division...they did it by getting a high level powerback and speed back and running the same formation for 16 weeks.

You might wonder why I am telling you this, but once theyu moved up to AA, they were 0 and 6 and team was firesaled and restarted.

What does that have to do with this suggestion??? Even if GLB does nothing, a team that is a one trick wonder, will crash and burn when they move up a division.

Just a little hope for you all when nothing is done about this suggestion
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
I've been in support of this for ages, but it really only makes sense with either a custom play creator for offense, or a vastly expanded playbook. Too many useless plays for this to do much good now. Defense would have an incredible advantage.


 
Link
 
Something really needs to be done with this. I've seen several teams just spam exploitable plays all game long. We really need something that Allows players to recognize and react to plays that are run constantly. Also, I think this shouldn't be something that you can only recognize one play if it's ran often because then teams would just set to run one exploitable play on first, another on second, and another on third(or something similar). Maybe something like Madden's Smart QB/CB/LB where after the play is run a certain number of times, they pick up on the play.

I think someone mentioned this before, but maybe it should be progressive. If the play is run 5 times in a half, the defense will remember that the play has been run, but not necessarily change so the way they play, but rather that they know it could be run(so maybe vision+1). If the play is run 5 times in a quarter, then the defense starts anticipating the play(so maybe a +3 or +5 to vision or you could start having the defense shift to counter that play). If the play is run 5 times in a series, the defense should be ready for the play and have either shifted or get something like a +10 bonus to vision against that play.

Allowing the defense to shift, would allow for running a quick pitch to the weak side after running to the strong side for 3 quarters, play action passing after the running heavy, using screens and short passes to make the defense focus on shorter routes before hitting them deep. That might be too deep for now, but the main thing is that we need some way to fix this now. This and WRs not having a vision check on long passes are the two biggest problems with the sim I see right now. Fix those and we can get on to finding the problems that will arise with the new Custom D-Play creator. I forsee exploitable plays being run from it all day just like with the offense, so setting both sides of the ball to adapt would be a great idea and way to prevent problems rather than waiting until they pop up to fix them.
 
Link
 
What if you ran fifty plays in a half all out of the same formation, but different plays. How would a defense know what play is coming? I would think a middle linebacker with a high whatever that SA is, would be the key to predicting a play, since I thought that they are the ones that usually calls the defensive plays.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
I've been in support of this for ages, but it really only makes sense with either a custom play creator for offense, or a vastly expanded playbook.

But then what's to stop a team from making the same passing play 6 different times, just with different names and maybe changing the route that the QBs 4th option runs?
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Just give a bonus to vision once a play has been ran a certain amount of times in a quarter. Simple, yet effective.


Or create another skill, called anticipation. That should address both issues like Oline picking up blitzes, QB's checking down, DB's breaking early on a pass play, or coming up to stop a run.


Frankly, I don't see this problem really changing until both the offensive and defensive playbooks are expanded to the point we can create our own plays.

And then that will make this a moot point.
Last edited Jan 29, 2009 11:30:29
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
I was thinking about this the other day and came up with an idea on how to implement it. Have an 'auto-adjust' for defense just like there is for offense. This can be a slider for how sensitive you want your defense to be in reacting to the same plays. If you have it at 100, they will adjust after 2 or 3 of the same plays, if you set it lower it will take them more time to catch on and change. Obviously it has the drawback of a higher auto-adjust meaning that a different play out of the same formation will catch them out, but its all a case of risk/reward right?
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kingdan23
I was thinking about this the other day and came up with an idea on how to implement it. Have an 'auto-adjust' for defense just like there is for offense. This can be a slider for how sensitive you want your defense to be in reacting to the same plays. If you have it at 100, they will adjust after 2 or 3 of the same plays, if you set it lower it will take them more time to catch on and change. Obviously it has the drawback of a higher auto-adjust meaning that a different play out of the same formation will catch them out, but its all a case of risk/reward right?


I like this too.
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
lol just seen someone has already suggested it in the OP...

Free bump
 
bsgilani
offline
Link
 
+1 Reacting to what the offense calls is great
 
Landry Skins
Skinny Laundry
offline
Link
 
very good suggestion
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
It's funny... OP quotes me - but I was being sarcastic.

Well, partially sarcastic. If you really wanted to penalize defenses purely because an offense used a playbook which didn't call plays multiple times in a row - go for it.. but my guess is that the same agents which are calling for this change would come right back and cry that the change is actually a nerf to Defenses.

Really I'd hate to see this kind of change. There aren't nearly enough offensive Plays to allow for the kind of variety at the same time as actually having a game plan.... and if Bort implements an offensive playmaker - this idea completely fails because offenses would be able to clone the same Play dozens of times, and just give it a different name. Once that happens - the defense would never get any bonus even if the Offense ran the same routes every snap of the game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.