User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is Garbage, Just About Quit Today, FIX IT!!!!
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Why do people believe that a certain defensive AI setting will stop a play?

Just like: o.k. - I build my LBs as CBs and my lineman as safeties. But whenever I face a true running team, I expect my 11 player secondary to stop the run by having a blitz called.

Stupid. Doesn't work and shouldn't work. If you want to defend the run - get players build to defend the run. Otherwise suffer and enjoy beeing so great at pass defense.

Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.

/thread
 
JSeay5
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tbrew83
I am glad I am not alone with this issue. I demand ADMIN, address this issue. I want an answer.
stfu and leave.NO one cares about you

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 18:11:05
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tbrew83

I am glad I am not alone with this issue. I demand ADMIN, address this issue. I want an answer.


I can't say I agree with this at all, demanding won't get you anywhere at all.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tbrew83
I am glad I am not alone with this issue. I demand ADMIN, address this issue. I want an answer.


Learn to play better defense. Get a better DL, build better LBs.

Teams do this in real life. There are teams that run the same play over and over and win championships. Oklahoma ran the wishbone and won a championship. Nebraska ran the option with Frazier and won a title. Redskins destroyed the Broncos in the SB by running the counter trey.

This is another "oh my god, my team sucks, so someone please modify the code and nerf everyone so my team can win" thread. Stop looking for the easy way out, try to improve your build and tactics.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Why do people believe that a certain defensive AI setting will stop a play?

Just like: o.k. - I build my LBs as CBs and my lineman as safeties. But whenever I face a true running team, I expect my 11 player secondary to stop the run by having a blitz called.

Stupid. Doesn't work and shouldn't work. If you want to defend the run - get players build to defend the run. Otherwise suffer and enjoy beeing so great at pass defense.

Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.

/thread


+1
 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
I agree that some of the blame goes to defensive players. Many are built with too much Speed and not enough Strength/Tackling. I also agree that teams should be able to be pass/run heavy and be able to win. But the same play over and over and over again? That's just not fun. I can't think of any good reason to not implement some sort of offensive penalty or defensive boost when the same playcall keeps coming.
 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.


This is just not true. Watch a Steelers game sometime. Or the Ravens for that matter.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 21:27:20
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Why do people believe that a certain defensive AI setting will stop a play?

Just like: o.k. - I build my LBs as CBs and my lineman as safeties. But whenever I face a true running team, I expect my 11 player secondary to stop the run by having a blitz called.

Stupid. Doesn't work and shouldn't work. If you want to defend the run - get players build to defend the run. Otherwise suffer and enjoy beeing so great at pass defense.

Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.

/thread


I agree with the first part. Not the last comment though. We all know a 4 man front versus a 3 man front is a joke. Tackles are seldom made at the line of scrimmage. Not as long as 3 offensive lineman are continually allowed ot magically block 5 defenders of the front 7 at once.

Whether you use is a 3 man front or a 4 man front is pretty meaningless in many run situations - provided you provide the correct amount of back end pressure.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by McGrai37
Originally posted by RAPB


Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.


This is just not true. Watch a Steelers game sometime. Or the Ravens for that matter.



Steelers DE's are nothing like GLB DE's. They have no pass rushing ability at all.

Both rely heavily on NT's that DESTROY the C on every play. Usually they have a 50+ lb weight advantage. That simply doesn't exist in GLB either where all interior linemen generally are equal and just lock up for 5 seconds on every play.

I'm not siding with anyone either, I just wanted to explain how the Steelers and Ravens aren't anything like GLB...... I wish they were.

There should be a way to stop the run with 3 D-linemen, but that isn't possible since 5 o-linemen are always going to beat 3 equal D-linemen.
 
PRIME EVIL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tbrew83
Played a game today. Actually created a game plan, like real football. Our opponents ran the same play 71 times, power I. We planned for that, committed 7 and 8 in the box. Blitzed the RILB, LILB, LOLB, and SS consistently, while stacking the box.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=252272

This game is suppose to mirror real life football, this is flat out garbage!!! If this does not get fixed, I will no longer be a customer.


I assume you were on the losing side.
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boxcutter
You should check your AI. These D calls are wide open for the run and they are from the first drive.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552550
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552664
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552686
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552724

The new AI is very sensitive and if you have guys in med. or long coverage they evacuate. Blitzing isn't necessarily the answer either unless you blitzers are keying run with adequate vision.


That first defensive play looks like it was designed to open a big hole for the Strong I run. 6 closing in on D vs 7 blockers, and a wide lane for the RB.
 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Boxcutter

You should check your AI. These D calls are wide open for the run and they are from the first drive.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552550
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552664
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552686
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252272&pbp_id=8552724

The new AI is very sensitive and if you have guys in med. or long coverage they evacuate. Blitzing isn't necessarily the answer either unless you blitzers are keying run with adequate vision.


That first defensive play looks like it was designed to open a big hole for the Strong I run. 6 closing in on D vs 7 blockers, and a wide lane for the RB.


Those 3-4 plays would work if the DC blitz the LBs right.. Along with the SS. Try blitzing LOLB and ROLB or LILB and RILB.. Throw a few SS blitzes and see what happens.
 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by McGrai37

Originally posted by RAPB



Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.


This is just not true. Watch a Steelers game sometime. Or the Ravens for that matter.



Steelers DE's are nothing like GLB DE's. They have no pass rushing ability at all.

Both rely heavily on NT's that DESTROY the C on every play. Usually they have a 50+ lb weight advantage. That simply doesn't exist in GLB either where all interior linemen generally are equal and just lock up for 5 seconds on every play.

I'm not siding with anyone either, I just wanted to explain how the Steelers and Ravens aren't anything like GLB...... I wish they were.

There should be a way to stop the run with 3 D-linemen, but that isn't possible since 5 o-linemen are always going to beat 3 equal D-linemen.


GLB DEs could be like the Steeler DEs if they wanted to be, but no one wants them to be. And it wouldn't be 3 v 5 with blitzes, which are common. The NT may not be able to be as effective, but that doesn't change the fact that you can defend the run with 3 down linemen.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16
Originally posted by cdcollins

TBH, I think some of it was caused by your constant usage of 3-4 and 3-3-5, which in RL football, is MUCH more suspect against the run than a 4-3 set. Some of it, not all of it. Also, this should go under "Suggestions", as it's obviously not a bug, and I'd request this moved.

But, OTOH, if an offense ran the same play 71 straight times, a defense would eventually overload that side and stop it dead in its tracks. One cure to the "Strong-I" ailment would be to penalize an offense's morale/boost the defense's morale (or some other method) for running plays over, and over, and over, and over again.


If a play is run 2 times in a row, the defense should get a 50% boost to all stats. This should continue every time the play is run in sequence.

Example:

Strong I run - 0 boost
Same play - 50% boost
Same play - 100% boost
Same play - 150% boost
Different play- 0 boost
Strong I run again - 0 boost
Same play - 50% boost....


Therefore if the team ran the play 71 times IN A ROW, the defense would get a 3350% boost.




..if that makes sense. I know its EXTREME, but it would completely eliminate teams from exploiting the system.


The problem with the idea of limiting the play calls is that the playbook isn't very diverse. In this case the offense clearly was using just one play and always does...however if I am scouting another team and I see that they have a weak side of their D-line I'm going to run to that side of the line all day. And since there are only 1-2 run plays out of each formation if I may have multiple plays in a row that are the same, but until there are 4-5 run plays each direction out of each formation it seems unjust to penalize this.
 
spartans72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by McGrai37

Originally posted by RAPB



Honestly: 3 man line to defend the run? Shouldn't work and I'm glad it doesn't work.


This is just not true. Watch a Steelers game sometime. Or the Ravens for that matter.



Steelers DE's are nothing like GLB DE's. They have no pass rushing ability at all.

Both rely heavily on NT's that DESTROY the C on every play. Usually they have a 50+ lb weight advantage. That simply doesn't exist in GLB either where all interior linemen generally are equal and just lock up for 5 seconds on every play.

I'm not siding with anyone either, I just wanted to explain how the Steelers and Ravens aren't anything like GLB...... I wish they were.

There should be a way to stop the run with 3 D-linemen, but that isn't possible since 5 o-linemen are always going to beat 3 equal D-linemen.


We also lack the ability to cross blitz and zone blitz, which is typically key in the 3-4 and occasionally in the 3-3 defense.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.