There really is no problem except for MILLIONS of shitty OTs out there. My team has zero problems with sacks because our OTs have lots of agility, speed, vision, and VERY high blocking.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Too many sacks - horrible blocking AI
Enkidu98
offline
offline
The Problem is that building a good OT is counter intuitive. Bort's early changes to Strength has completely neutered the attribute so that EVERY position should now have tons of Agility and Speed to succeed.
Thats not 'right' and makes for a poor modeling of football.
As has been said repeatedly. Most people wouldn't mind if Agility/Speed lead to sacks on passing plays if on a running play, the weak, low tackling high Agility Speed DE's would get run the hell over. But they don't.
There's no rock/paper/scissors thing here. It forces everyone to build the same way and thats going to damage the integrity of the game and its viability as a football simulation.
Thats not 'right' and makes for a poor modeling of football.
As has been said repeatedly. Most people wouldn't mind if Agility/Speed lead to sacks on passing plays if on a running play, the weak, low tackling high Agility Speed DE's would get run the hell over. But they don't.
There's no rock/paper/scissors thing here. It forces everyone to build the same way and thats going to damage the integrity of the game and its viability as a football simulation.
Blacksheep
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Here is a DE with 97 sacks.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=433515
Whats wrong with this picture
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3332
Here is a DE with 97 sacks.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=433515
Whats wrong with this picture
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3332
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Darkstrand
There really is no problem except for MILLIONS of shitty OTs out there. My team has zero problems with sacks because our OTs have lots of agility, speed, vision, and VERY high blocking.
No the problem is you have to build a shitty OT to stop the safeties playing DE. It isn't that hard to do, but like Enkidu98 stated it is counter intuitive.
There really is no problem except for MILLIONS of shitty OTs out there. My team has zero problems with sacks because our OTs have lots of agility, speed, vision, and VERY high blocking.
No the problem is you have to build a shitty OT to stop the safeties playing DE. It isn't that hard to do, but like Enkidu98 stated it is counter intuitive.
AnTiNiNjA
offline
offline
Shocker, another person complaining about DEs.
Learn to use your TE/FB/HB.
Also theres this thing called a pass blocking SA tree for OTs. Try it out some time, works rather nicely.
Learn to use your TE/FB/HB.
Also theres this thing called a pass blocking SA tree for OTs. Try it out some time, works rather nicely.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
Shocker, another person complaining about DEs.
Learn to use your TE/FB/HB.
Also theres this thing called a pass blocking SA tree for OTs. Try it out some time, works rather nicely.
The complaint is "sacks". DE's are just a portion of sacks.
Originally posted by Darkstrand
There really is no problem except for MILLIONS of shitty OTs out there. My team has zero problems with sacks because our OTs have lots of agility, speed, vision, and VERY high blocking.
Yada yada. Silly question, but have you met a DE yet who has 80 strength, 100 speed, 80 agility? Run up against a team playing C0 CB blitz on every down with a 100 80 agility speed CB? etc etc
I don't want to shatter the illusion that you might have won at the internets, but there's bigger fish in the sea and the curve for OT's is rather severe in GLB. If you're fractionally behind the advancement of DE's in your division (which you are for by the norm of them being able to stack purely speed/agility - whereas an OT has to stack Strength, Blocking, Speed, Agility, Confidence and Vision) you'll struggle to stop them.
Parity is achieved later on when the cost of a DE further improving their physical attributes becomes such that they start investing in their neglected skills - when at the same time an OT is just catching up with their fundamentals and may have soft capped all 6 by level 32.
There's an imbalance of development.
Shocker, another person complaining about DEs.
Learn to use your TE/FB/HB.
Also theres this thing called a pass blocking SA tree for OTs. Try it out some time, works rather nicely.
The complaint is "sacks". DE's are just a portion of sacks.
Originally posted by Darkstrand
There really is no problem except for MILLIONS of shitty OTs out there. My team has zero problems with sacks because our OTs have lots of agility, speed, vision, and VERY high blocking.
Yada yada. Silly question, but have you met a DE yet who has 80 strength, 100 speed, 80 agility? Run up against a team playing C0 CB blitz on every down with a 100 80 agility speed CB? etc etc
I don't want to shatter the illusion that you might have won at the internets, but there's bigger fish in the sea and the curve for OT's is rather severe in GLB. If you're fractionally behind the advancement of DE's in your division (which you are for by the norm of them being able to stack purely speed/agility - whereas an OT has to stack Strength, Blocking, Speed, Agility, Confidence and Vision) you'll struggle to stop them.
Parity is achieved later on when the cost of a DE further improving their physical attributes becomes such that they start investing in their neglected skills - when at the same time an OT is just catching up with their fundamentals and may have soft capped all 6 by level 32.
There's an imbalance of development.
oronis
offline
offline
Originally posted by turnerhero
Bullshit, a team I OC for matched up EVEN with the last two teams we faced, and in each game our OT's got slaughtered by their DEs...on BOTH sides. So my QB had enough time to hike the football, and take one step before he had either the LDE, the RDE, or both DEs sacking him...every pass play, almost.
Against equal competition, OTs get smoked...because they - for some UNKNOWN reason - now need speed to match up with a DE.
Hypocrites! You don't want Speed DEs to be effective only using 2 stats (speed and agi) but you want your OT to be effective using 2 stats (str and blocking).
This is a game. It's obvious an OT in GLB needs 40+ speed and 60+ agility in the 30s to be a good OT. It's that Fing simple. I just told you why your guys suck. If you refuse to fix it because you are harping over real life, that's your problem. Again, GLB is a game, not real life.
In real life, a lvl 40 wouldn't be allowed on a HS team (BBBs). In real life, we'd have injuries. Etc Etc.
Bullshit, a team I OC for matched up EVEN with the last two teams we faced, and in each game our OT's got slaughtered by their DEs...on BOTH sides. So my QB had enough time to hike the football, and take one step before he had either the LDE, the RDE, or both DEs sacking him...every pass play, almost.
Against equal competition, OTs get smoked...because they - for some UNKNOWN reason - now need speed to match up with a DE.
Hypocrites! You don't want Speed DEs to be effective only using 2 stats (speed and agi) but you want your OT to be effective using 2 stats (str and blocking).
This is a game. It's obvious an OT in GLB needs 40+ speed and 60+ agility in the 30s to be a good OT. It's that Fing simple. I just told you why your guys suck. If you refuse to fix it because you are harping over real life, that's your problem. Again, GLB is a game, not real life.
In real life, a lvl 40 wouldn't be allowed on a HS team (BBBs). In real life, we'd have injuries. Etc Etc.
Everybody has the same SPs to use. You don't like DEs getting sacks?! Do you not have DEs on your own team. Do they suck or something?? Several people have posted the answer to your OT problems yet there continues to be all this whining. You wanna have a player built to look like a overall 99 in Madden. Go ahead...and give up sacks while you're at it. You want your player to be good on THIS GAME...adjust your freakin' equipment.
Enkidu98
offline
offline
DE's get speed automatically per level. OT's dont. That's an advantage of several levels worth of SP's already by level 40.
Stregth based OT's DO NOT dominate on the running game. An Agility/Speed DE can neglect tackling and strength and still be highly successful. They should be pancaked every time the OT comes near.
Many of you are forgeting Bort nerfed the heck out of Strength as an attribute but never touched agiity so once speed/agility reached the levels people had strength at previously, its created a stupid imbalance.
No one is asking that DE's be made useless. I have some myself. The thing is an imbalanced DE who goes all speed/agility should be easy to exploit on the running game and they aren't.
You can have your advantage, but their needs to be the Rock to your Scissors. You go all for speed/cutting then when the offense rushes the ball they pound the hell out of your DE.
Stregth based OT's DO NOT dominate on the running game. An Agility/Speed DE can neglect tackling and strength and still be highly successful. They should be pancaked every time the OT comes near.
Many of you are forgeting Bort nerfed the heck out of Strength as an attribute but never touched agiity so once speed/agility reached the levels people had strength at previously, its created a stupid imbalance.
No one is asking that DE's be made useless. I have some myself. The thing is an imbalanced DE who goes all speed/agility should be easy to exploit on the running game and they aren't.
You can have your advantage, but their needs to be the Rock to your Scissors. You go all for speed/cutting then when the offense rushes the ball they pound the hell out of your DE.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Unfortunately there is an element of that currently with the prevalence and success of Off Tackle rushing offences.
I've not seen any teams running up an 80 strength defence against it to be able to tell you if it's any more effective against the rush, and any less effective against the pass - but it would be interesting to see anyway.
I've not seen any teams running up an 80 strength defence against it to be able to tell you if it's any more effective against the rush, and any less effective against the pass - but it would be interesting to see anyway.
HydrOshocK
offline
offline
what gets me is all the DE owners who were crying about DEs not being effective enough finally got their wish when Bort made his most recent changes, but as soon as they hear the same argument coming from the other side they are quick to point their fingers and shout "shitty build" and ridicule those that suggest there might be a problem here.
I own both DEs and OTs so I have studied the effects very closely on both sides of the ball. This season my LDE (who is built primarily to stop the run on the strong side) is on pace to shatter his single season sack record. On the flip we have given up 31 sacks already this season in just 12 games, which is MORE THAN EVERY PREVIOUS SEASON COMBINED. Therefor it has nothing to do with having bad builds because both of my OTs have been fantastic up until this season. My guys have been capped on every important attribute including agility and speed but obviously now the new bar has been raised to the 3:1 cap, which at Lvl 39 is no easy achievement.
Sure one short term fix would be to adjust equipment. That's fine for teams that have a ton of surplus cash to work with, but don't be naive to think that everyone has the luxury to do that right now. And just because things can be done to try and stop the bleeding does not mean that these guys don't have a legit argument because of the extreme nature of these UNANNOUNCED changes AFTER season 6 boosting was already done by most
So for those who sit there and point fingers, call names, and claim "shitty build" all the time you can suck it. The problem is not bad building, its the redefinition of what used to be considered a great build. The bar has been raised and it will take a lot of time and effort, as well as another season of boosting to completely correct the problem. In the mean time we all have to utilize whatever quick fixes we can but that does not discard this as a legitimate concern so please stop the childish bickering.
.02
I own both DEs and OTs so I have studied the effects very closely on both sides of the ball. This season my LDE (who is built primarily to stop the run on the strong side) is on pace to shatter his single season sack record. On the flip we have given up 31 sacks already this season in just 12 games, which is MORE THAN EVERY PREVIOUS SEASON COMBINED. Therefor it has nothing to do with having bad builds because both of my OTs have been fantastic up until this season. My guys have been capped on every important attribute including agility and speed but obviously now the new bar has been raised to the 3:1 cap, which at Lvl 39 is no easy achievement.
Sure one short term fix would be to adjust equipment. That's fine for teams that have a ton of surplus cash to work with, but don't be naive to think that everyone has the luxury to do that right now. And just because things can be done to try and stop the bleeding does not mean that these guys don't have a legit argument because of the extreme nature of these UNANNOUNCED changes AFTER season 6 boosting was already done by most
So for those who sit there and point fingers, call names, and claim "shitty build" all the time you can suck it. The problem is not bad building, its the redefinition of what used to be considered a great build. The bar has been raised and it will take a lot of time and effort, as well as another season of boosting to completely correct the problem. In the mean time we all have to utilize whatever quick fixes we can but that does not discard this as a legitimate concern so please stop the childish bickering.
.02
Last edited Dec 6, 2008 10:09:13
AnTiNiNjA
offline
offline
The only changes DEs have received were counter-fixes to DE nerfs/OT boosts. Every season there has been some kind of change to DEs to help the OTs stop them, be it a nerf to speed in general, blocking schemes, and now the vision deal.
Fact is there are a lot more good DE builds out there than OT build. Actually, there are a lot more DEs out there than OTs in general.
The only argument I see is OTs not being able to do the same with their SPs as DEs are. To be extremely effective we need essentially speed at the 3:1 cap and agility to the 4:1 cap, along with strength soft capped. Now we need vision soft capped as well and tackling in the 40 range.
Not to mention SAs. DEs are nearly useless without the pass rushing SA tree. TV needs to be 7+, and thats with a piece of upgraded advanced equipment. First step needs to be up now because of the snap delay. Shed block has always been important for primarily agility builds.
My question is, how many more pot shots are going to be taken at DEs before it stops? Hell, why don't we have anyone complaining about other positions? I see RBs putting up 70+ tds and QBs throwing for just as many.
There were no unannounced changes after the season 6 bonuses. they happened because OTs complained more, and then the DEs complained about it being too much. Everything that was done was listed in the change log.
Fact is there are a lot more good DE builds out there than OT build. Actually, there are a lot more DEs out there than OTs in general.
The only argument I see is OTs not being able to do the same with their SPs as DEs are. To be extremely effective we need essentially speed at the 3:1 cap and agility to the 4:1 cap, along with strength soft capped. Now we need vision soft capped as well and tackling in the 40 range.
Not to mention SAs. DEs are nearly useless without the pass rushing SA tree. TV needs to be 7+, and thats with a piece of upgraded advanced equipment. First step needs to be up now because of the snap delay. Shed block has always been important for primarily agility builds.
My question is, how many more pot shots are going to be taken at DEs before it stops? Hell, why don't we have anyone complaining about other positions? I see RBs putting up 70+ tds and QBs throwing for just as many.
There were no unannounced changes after the season 6 bonuses. they happened because OTs complained more, and then the DEs complained about it being too much. Everything that was done was listed in the change log.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Errr, there are also complaints about the HB's and the QB's. In most cases (and even for DE's) stats are padded with cupcake teams.
In evenly matched divisions there tend to be fewer run-away dominating players just because of how quickly they adapt.
One issue this year has been the re-organisation of divisions bringing more comparable (and talented) teams in direct competion with each other. Teams that went 10-6 last year and thought they were good are meeting teams who went 16-0 in the division below and are superior replacements for the CPU teams and cupcakes who dropped out.
In evenly matched divisions there tend to be fewer run-away dominating players just because of how quickly they adapt.
One issue this year has been the re-organisation of divisions bringing more comparable (and talented) teams in direct competion with each other. Teams that went 10-6 last year and thought they were good are meeting teams who went 16-0 in the division below and are superior replacements for the CPU teams and cupcakes who dropped out.
Mithra
offline
offline
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
The problem is not bad building, its the redefinition of what used to be considered a great build.
Bingo. And it's by far not the first time this has happened.
The problem is not bad building, its the redefinition of what used to be considered a great build.
Bingo. And it's by far not the first time this has happened.
Lohengrin
offline
offline
So if I understand correctly, if DEs don't get 3 sacks per game, they have been nerfed to uselessness; if OTs give up 3 sacks per game, it's because they all have crappy builds.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























