User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
Page:
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Normally I side with Bort but I agree with everyone else on this one, the pct was working fine before... the only time you would see 80% completion rates was when a team was throwing a lot of short routes against a much worse team. If I took my level 9 QB and threw him into USA Pro, he would probably throw for 30-40%, the 63% (in mainly a short to intermediate passing game) against the same level of competition seems about right... maybe a SMALL tweak downwards, but not to where people are completing 30%.

If it stays the way it is, I'm just going to run way more than I probably should.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Bort can you explain to why when my teams lvl 8 QB threw to my lvl 8 WR he got the ball to him nearly every time he was tripled covered but when he was wide open he threw way to long or way behind him.

My WR caught all of one pass in what I will say was a horrible and very shitty game by a our QB and non-reflective of how he should of played. The QB played worse then when he was only a lvl 4, by a fair margin.

Not complaining or bitching just adding to the information that something is very wrong with a majority of the game yesterday as it seems most QBs played as a lvl 1 not the lvl they were.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Using Bort's logic that QBs are really very low level right now, should the same be true for running backs? We should all be running for 2 yards a carry if things are going to be equal.
 
Nevstar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.

I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.


Shenanigans. Peyton Manning is also playing against CBs that are a bit higher than lv 10.

I can't see how you can say it's expected for completion pct to drop 35%
 
Boble
offline
Link
 
yep, plus Defenders are also very low in level, and f..., you can just complete passes easily playin high school kids, this drives me crazy, I guess I have to turn off the PC, or I'll get even crazier and risk being banned!
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
I don't really think that is true. If we're thinking we are all Pop Warner level, running is the easiest thing to do when you have a good team. Running would be consider pee wee leagues bread and butter.

At least every pee wee game I've seen or apart of it was.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Which does happen when you take a level 4 RB up against a level 10 defense.

Honestly, I thought the pass/run part of the game was working pretty well, what needs tweaking is situational play calling, more flexibility in the types of play calling we can do... as far as how the actual sim was running in terms of realism when teams are equal levels, I thought it was very realistic.
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by Bort

QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.

I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.


That is a seriously flawed analysis. These leagues are set up as weighted leagues It is pefectly reasonable to expect a lvl 6 QB to have a decent completion rate when he is throwing against lvl 4 DB's and no pass rush.

Should a lvl 6 QB be a monster in AAA or Pro? Heck no, but A Qb's performance depend a lot on the level of his competition. I have seen pop warner or High School QB's with outrageous stats, but it is always because they are superior to their competition. I have seen High School QB's throw for 300 + yards and 60% or 70% plus passing against weaker schools. They'd get killed against college Defenses. It's all relative.

We can't all be wrong with our concerns can we?



Very well said. I really think it was perfect the way it was. I don't think I have seen a lvl 6 QB throw for 80+% against an equally talented team. And my guess is the changes were accidentally downgraded a little too much, I wouldn't worry too much about that.
 
Abulia
offline
Link
 
Did I miss the announcement on this?

Even worse, the stupid "follow my gameplan" bug still exists. So, in order to compensate for the low completion percentage you shift your gameplan to 100% run and turn auto-adjust "OFF" you're still going to pass for 40+ times.

"Beta" I can forgive a lot, but the reality is that many people are actually paying money. This week has been a comedy of errors.

Regards,
Abulia

 
Boble
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Which does happen when you take a level 4 RB up against a level 10 defense.

Honestly, I thought the pass/run part of the game was working pretty well, what needs tweaking is situational play calling, more flexibility in the types of play calling we can do... as far as how the actual sim was running in terms of realism when teams are equal levels, I thought it was very realistic.



Fully agreed, reverse that stupid change, run/pass worked perfectly, now passing is like a mistery in the making and can just be forgotten about, should we all play WR and TEs just as blockers for our RBs?????
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Normally I side with Bort but I agree with everyone else on this one, the pct was working fine before...


I have to agree.

I found the passing percentages to be quite good. Maybe a slight adjustment (very, very slight) downward is warranted, but I think the system already in place was good. QBs that were good for their level, playing against even competition, did well. Poorly built QBs or ones playing against much better secondaries, usually were the worse for it.

Part of the beauty of GLB is that the competition is scaled, but players have to progress quickly and properly to keep up, so there's incentive to improve. In the passing game, part of that incentive was to keep developing so that longer routes/throws would become viable, unlocked, so to speak.

In that scaling, it mirrors real life. A QB in high school can dominate the competition, but they have to develop to do the same in college. Likewise for the jump to the pros.

I'd understand the tweak if level 1s were popping up in USA Pro, throwing for 80%+, but that isn't happening. Lower levels still suck, as they should, but not so much that they don't have fun while sucking.

Trust the sim, Bort. It's already very good. Some things may need tweaking, I won't deny that. But I strongly disagree that this is one of those things.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Abulia
This week has been a comedy of errors.



Ah, my friend. If this qualifies as a comedy of errors, then the words "start of Season 5" mean nothing to you

 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
I have to agree that it looks like Bort second-guessed himself a little too much this time.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
I think this depends on what Bort and DD vision what level represent what in real life. If 1-10 are consider pee wee (5-6 year olds) then pass completions are right on now for most real life pee wee teams. And those teams usually have running as their bread and butter.

But then again we are getting paid to play so it would have to pro leagues through out and the pass completion should be tweaked back up a little bit.
Last edited May 2, 2008 15:49:55
 
dead_poet
offline
Link
 
I'd like to hear more from an admin on this (unless they're diligently at work fixing the issue). This is the first I've been upset/frustrated/confused with the GLB higher-ups.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.