i like the idea but the prices are to high
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
offline
dislike this one alot. Rich get richer scenario. As i'm not one of the rich I'm very anti this idea. No owner would want to sign any non-pro or non all-star players, and why should they? If this were to happen I would say the cost to create should be roughly 1000 points and CE costs should be increased, but then the boosting costs stay the same as if those players were regular players of that type. Far more feasible. They cost more, but not so much more to the point that no 1 wants to buy them.
Edited for clarification
Edited for clarification
Last edited Nov 29, 2008 16:50:38
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
offline
another varied idea, a separate league for all pros and superstars...this way it doesn't mess with the current balance between the haves and the have nots...the haves can go have their little superstars and whatnot, and the havenots can keep playing the same game we've enjoyed thusfar.
nflcardholder
offline
offline
I don't like the All-Pro end of the idea. But the SS is fine with a few tweaks.
The All-Pro with no limits simply makes a normal player absolutely worthless.
As for the SS's, I agree that the limit per account would open up a lot of multi-abuse. But why make a limit? Just limit the ammount allowed per team to like 3 and then on the player creation screen list how many SS slots are still available. If someone wants to make 10 SS's let them, but they'll have a hard time gettng them all signed.
The idea isn't perfect but it does open up a whole new avenue of strategy for the game. I've thought about it for 10 minutes now and I'm still not sure which positions I'd like to sign SS's for my team (although with the FA market, I'd probably just sign whatever I could get)
The biggest problem this idea faces is finding a way to make current players into superstars. If only new players could start off with level 1 SS's it would take many seasons before they got to the levels (with retirements of the current pro starters) that the Pro leagues would have any superstars at all.
I could also see it being tough for young SS's to level at all, as it wouldn't be easy to find a low level team to get your SS to play for since there would surely be a huge influx of SSs as soon as the idea was added.
Another thought, signing/cutting/trading a SS should be at least double the regular chemistry hit.
The All-Pro with no limits simply makes a normal player absolutely worthless.
As for the SS's, I agree that the limit per account would open up a lot of multi-abuse. But why make a limit? Just limit the ammount allowed per team to like 3 and then on the player creation screen list how many SS slots are still available. If someone wants to make 10 SS's let them, but they'll have a hard time gettng them all signed.
The idea isn't perfect but it does open up a whole new avenue of strategy for the game. I've thought about it for 10 minutes now and I'm still not sure which positions I'd like to sign SS's for my team (although with the FA market, I'd probably just sign whatever I could get)
The biggest problem this idea faces is finding a way to make current players into superstars. If only new players could start off with level 1 SS's it would take many seasons before they got to the levels (with retirements of the current pro starters) that the Pro leagues would have any superstars at all.
I could also see it being tough for young SS's to level at all, as it wouldn't be easy to find a low level team to get your SS to play for since there would surely be a huge influx of SSs as soon as the idea was added.
Another thought, signing/cutting/trading a SS should be at least double the regular chemistry hit.
SCACE
offline
offline
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
This is a much better way to go about something like this, IMO.
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
This is a much better way to go about something like this, IMO.
nflcardholder
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
The only problem I see is that teams that all start off together at pre-16 levels can potentially end up having to cut some of their own due to having too many SS's
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
The only problem I see is that teams that all start off together at pre-16 levels can potentially end up having to cut some of their own due to having too many SS's
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
offline
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
nflcardholder
offline
offline
Originally posted by SikoraP13
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
If your SS gets +7 instead of +5 per level but only levels half as often, he's going to be worse than the normal players.
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
If your SS gets +7 instead of +5 per level but only levels half as often, he's going to be worse than the normal players.
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by nflcardholder
Originally posted by SCACE
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
The only problem I see is that teams that all start off together at pre-16 levels can potentially end up having to cut some of their own due to having too many SS's
Good point -- I had thought of that, but it didn't come through in the suggestion for some reason
I'll try to think about how you deal with that
Originally posted by SCACE
I like the idea...I'm not sure increased cost is the way to go about it.
While putting a cost on this ensures that only so many Superstars and All-Pro's will be created, it squarely puts a further advantage to those who can afford to spend money on this game (yes, I'm one of those users...I'm not complaining because I can't afford to play the game).
For those of us who can afford to pay for an entire team, while it would be more expensive, I could build a team with 5 superstars and 30-35 all-pro's and thus, assuming I build my toons alright, have a distinct advantage.
Here is my suggestion, on this note:
1. Create players as normal. Upon creation, there is a hidden "list" which determines if your player has the chance to be a Superstar, All-Pro or just a regular joe in the game.
2. You don't find anything out right away. In fact, you don't find out until you hit lvl 16 (lvls 1-15 are your initial growth years). At level 16, your find out whether your player has the potential to be a Superstar, All-Pro, or will continue on as a regular player in the game.
3. At this point, your player starts to get more SP per level and/or a training bonus. Maybe their gain per level increases, or it decreases at a slower rate.
4. Teams can only carry, as mentioned, so many superstars and all-pro's -- these numbers can be determined through discussion. There needs to be a demand for all types of players (superstar through regular joe) so that there is a reason not to retire your average joe and keep trying again.
This way, everyone has an equal chance of getting a Superstar, All-Pro or Regular Joe.
Something to chew on.
The only problem I see is that teams that all start off together at pre-16 levels can potentially end up having to cut some of their own due to having too many SS's
Good point -- I had thought of that, but it didn't come through in the suggestion for some reason

I'll try to think about how you deal with that

SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by nflcardholder
Originally posted by SikoraP13
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
If your SS gets +7 instead of +5 per level but only levels half as often, he's going to be worse than the normal players.
yeah, I was going to post this.
Originally posted by SikoraP13
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
If your SS gets +7 instead of +5 per level but only levels half as often, he's going to be worse than the normal players.
yeah, I was going to post this.
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
offline
Originally posted by nflcardholder
Originally posted by SikoraP13
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
If your SS gets +7 instead of +5 per level but only levels half as often, he's going to be worse than the normal players.
double was just a number...say 1.5x as much, and you also didn't take into account the training bonuses. All I'm saying was that it would increase parity (scary word, I know) between the Superstars and the non-superstars. This way, a regular joe would still have the chance to sack a Superstar QB.
Originally posted by SikoraP13
another idea, instead of having them cost more to boost or w/e...have them require a greater amount of xp (let's say double?) to level up. that way, while they get bonuses, they also have their drawbacks as far as actual gameplay goes, not only as pricing.
If your SS gets +7 instead of +5 per level but only levels half as often, he's going to be worse than the normal players.
double was just a number...say 1.5x as much, and you also didn't take into account the training bonuses. All I'm saying was that it would increase parity (scary word, I know) between the Superstars and the non-superstars. This way, a regular joe would still have the chance to sack a Superstar QB.
SoxPhan21
offline
offline
I like the idea but what happens if a user has 10 superstars and they are on his own team?? I think it would be unfair to limit him form having his own players on his own team.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























