Originally posted by TheInfinity
Seriously, tell me how this is different from someone spending a little more on strength or a little more on speed?
The Elusive Guy thats a bit faster but easier to tackle cause he's 160lbs.
The Elusive Guy thats a bit slower but harder to tackle cause he's 200lbs.
Where's the difference from:
The Elusive Guy thats a bit faster but easier to tackle cause he spent more on speed.
The Elusive Guy thats a bit slower but harder to tackle cause he spent more on strength.
It's different because it is an intrinsic quality that is factored in regardless of what stats you have spent SP's on. Plus, it would affect speed/breaknig tackles between HB types with an equal nominal speed/strength value. If a Power Back and an Elusive Back both have 80 Speed and 80 Strength, the Power Back is still slower and breaks more tackles.
Additionally, the introduction of weight classes would make it more difficult to make a lighter Elusive Back that won't put the ball on the ground when hit hard by a LB. The way things are now, if you pump up Carrying and train Strength a little bit as an Elusive Back, you have no more chance of fumbling than a Power Back with 80 Strength and 50 Carrying.
Finally, the weight classes will allow different builds to further augment abilities given by their weight class. Lightweight elusive HBs will be able to pump SP into Speed/Agility and reap the benefits of it more than a Heavyweight power HB that does the same thing.