User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

And if you don't think sacks can happen that quickly, I think you should watch the Colts-Steelers playoff game from 2005. Porter had a couple sacks where he just ran straight at Manning and was untouched (the OG picked up the wrong guy). Immediate sack. Polamalu had one also if I recall and there were about 5 as a result of an overload on the left side and countless other hurries.


I specified in my initial post in this thread that I was talking about non-blitz situations. If it's a blitz, all bets are off. I wouldn't be surprised to see a sack in that situation. The link that I quoted showed a 4 man rush. If an offensive guard is missing an assignment, that's a heck of a lot different than circling an OT to make a speed sack. Plus, Pitt is known for their ability to bring pressure from all angles with their blitz packages, which is additionally why it wouldn't surprise me to see quick sacks from that type of pressure. But a 4 man rush?
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
It can't be easy.


Agree 100% with this. And I'm not really trying to call Bort out on this, but while he's tuning, OT's who are built realistically are getting beaten like a drum, and it frustrates people, especially the agents of the offended.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by CoachBradley

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


The problem is that there is only 1 man programming the entire game and he can't simulate NFL action perfectly in a few months for hundreds of different plays. He's doing the best he can. I'd like to see anyone else do better. If you could do better, you would make your own site and be making $50K a month also.


Of course I would. But I couldn't do better...I don't know syntax from income tax (well, actually I do, I am a senior accountant, but you get my point )

But this isn't exactly a new issue; by the same token, I don't know how he prioritizes which bugs get fixed first.



I'm telling you the bug is in that the high strength OT isn't pummeling the low strength DE in the running game. I'm sure he is working on it. But he is probably dealing with changing 1 variable from 0.0125 to 0.0123 and then making sure that adjustment doesn't cause other problems, etc etc. It has to be alot of fine tuning. Plus he has to make sure it doesn't cause problems for all players from level 1 to level 44. It can't be easy.


Yeah, I think this is the problem. The problem isn't that speed DEs get tons of sacks (although I do think it's a bit unrealistic and could use a bit of fine tuning), the problem is that speed DEs can still suck up an OT and TE/FB in the running game. The high STR OTs should be able to flatten them immediately and both the TE and the OT move on to take out a LB/SS. That's not happening. If it did - you would see it affect the passing game as well, due to morale loss.

I also think that part of the problem is O-line and D-line have the same "jump" on the ball. There's no interplay in the snap. IRL, if a D-lineman correctly jumps the snap, there's almost nothing an O-lineman can do to keep him from disrupting the play. However, if he jumps early it's offsides, guesses late it can lead to him getting pancaked.

One solution to this could be to implement this and have it as a jump snap advanced tactic D-linemen.

Based on vision - players can set to aggressive, normal, or conservative. Aggressive leads to more jumped snaps, but also to more offsides and pancakes. Normal creates a slight pause to simulate waiting til the defender "sees" the ball snapped, then he reacts. Conservative elongates the pause, but gives a bonus to not being pancaked and standing ground in the running game.

DEs can keep getting these sacks, but they might also run the risk of keeping a drive alive. I'm sure this idea is full of holes, but it might start to balance things out better, while still allowing superior DEs to be superior.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 10:18:05
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
the botton line is teams need to start bringing the FB, HB and TE over to the left side to block
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 10:17:17
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

In real life, if a OT was that bad, he would be cut and out of the NFL forever.


Then it should come back to what the ratings mean. Does an OT with 80 blocking, 50 agility, and 30-something speed mean that he is in the 80th, 50th, and 30th percentile of those attributes? Or are we using a zero based system to measure attributes, in that the numbers are what they are?

If that's the case, how much faster is a 70 speed guy than a 30-something speed guy? What is the difference between a 75 agility guy and a 50 agility guy?

I think this is one of the problems with the game...guys are now building OT's to respond to the epidemic of speed DE's, while those who have the OT's built to realistic specifications are now getting torched. If/as soon as Bort installs a fix, all those new OT's who have been created now have to scamper to get points into Strength and blocking (blocking probably not so much) to counter the DE's that now become the dominant force (the guys who dumped points into strength). It's a slippery slope, and it's tough because everyone is paying their own money and trying to get the same enjoyment, and you can't always please everyone.



Just realize that you have to match the attributes of the player opposite of you. If they have high strength, then you probably have to have high strength. If they are really fast, then you are probably going to have to be really fast. In all the dynamics between CB/WR, DT/OG, DE/OT, TE/SS, that is the case. Even LB/HB. If you think of it like that, then you will be fine.

If you see that the successful WR's are 140 speed, don't even think about it, get your CB to the same speed. If the most successful WR's are 130 agility, then get your CB to 130 agility.

What YOU think is realism isn't what someone else thinks is realism.

Broncos fans could say that fat O-linemen are stupid and that the best O-linemen are the fastest, quickest ones. Cowboys fans could say, if you want REALISTIC O-linemen, then they have to be huge monsters who maul people. So who is right??

You find out who is right from watching the sims.

Eventually Bort is trying to have a way for all builds to succeed, but that will take time. So either build to what is working (speedy OT's) or take a wild chance and build something different and hope the sim changes.

The guys who made speedy QB's have been waiting for 5 seasons for their build to even be somewhat useful. They are going to be paid off this year.



 
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
the botton line is teams need to start bringing the FB and TE over to the left side to block


exactly. Bort gave a way to cover for bad builds at OT now. Use it.
 
Club America
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwrujosh
30 SPD and 50 AGL and you wonder why you are getting owned by the DE.

It's quite simple. He's got 60 SPD and 80-90 AGL.

Get your SPD and AGL up and you'll start seeing better results.



thats complete garbage.

Im getting tired of nefs happening every season and completely destroying a quality build.

its happening in al the games now.

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148004

if the FB was set to pass block left this would have never been a sack, instead he is standing there doing nothing productive
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 10:19:08
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by CoachBradley


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



The problem is that there is only 1 man programming the entire game and he can't simulate NFL action perfectly in a few months for hundreds of different plays. He's doing the best he can. I'd like to see anyone else do better. If you could do better, you would make your own site and be making $50K a month also.


Of course I would. But I couldn't do better...I don't know syntax from income tax (well, actually I do, I am a senior accountant, but you get my point )

But this isn't exactly a new issue; by the same token, I don't know how he prioritizes which bugs get fixed first.



I'm telling you the bug is in that the high strength OT isn't pummeling the low strength DE in the running game. I'm sure he is working on it. But he is probably dealing with changing 1 variable from 0.0125 to 0.0123 and then making sure that adjustment doesn't cause other problems, etc etc. It has to be alot of fine tuning. Plus he has to make sure it doesn't cause problems for all players from level 1 to level 44. It can't be easy.


Yeah, I think this is the problem. The problem isn't that speed DEs get tons of sacks (although I do think it's a bit unrealistic and could use a bit of fine tuning), the problem is that speed DEs can still suck up an OT and TE/FB in the running game. The high STR OTs should be able to flatten them immediately and both the TE and the OT move on to take out a LB/SS. That's not happening. If it did - you would see it affect the passing game as well, due to morale loss.



Exactly. If that happened, then alot less people would build their DE's all speed because they want them to be good against the run also.

Even right now, we all know this change is coming, but few are preparing for it. If anyone has a super high strength DE (100 strength with equipment), let me know. I'll take you now in advance of the coming changes that will surely happen.



 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Just realize that you have to match the attributes of the player opposite of you. If they have high strength, then you probably have to have high strength. If they are really fast, then you are probably going to have to be really fast. In all the dynamics between CB/WR, DT/OG, DE/OT, TE/SS, that is the case. Even LB/HB. If you think of it like that, then you will be fine.


This part is true. But if you have a strength LT going up against a speed DE, you would expect the LT to bury the DE a few times, and also the DE would probably get around the LT a few times, just not in the same way that the links showed.

Originally posted by SteelersInsider
If you see that the successful WR's are 140 speed, don't even think about it, get your CB to the same speed. If the most successful WR's are 130 agility, then get your CB to 130 agility.

What YOU think is realism isn't what someone else thinks is realism.

Broncos fans could say that fat O-linemen are stupid and that the best O-linemen are the fastest, quickest ones. Cowboys fans could say, if you want REALISTIC O-linemen, then they have to be huge monsters who maul people. So who is right??

You find out who is right from watching the sims.

Eventually Bort is trying to have a way for all builds to succeed, but that will take time. So either build to what is working (speedy OT's) or take a wild chance and build something different and hope the sim changes.

The guys who made speedy QB's have been waiting for 5 seasons for their build to even be somewhat useful. They are going to be paid off this year.


The Cowboys and Broncos are two good examples of polar opposites when it comes to lineman. But it doesn't mean that the Broncos were terrible at blocking the power guys, or the Cowboys couldn't block the speed guys. They just don't match up AS WELL, but they do match up somewhat evenly. The speed DE's right now are violating Tackles, and it doesn't seem very even.
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
the botton line is teams need to start bringing the FB, HB and TE over to the left side to block


I didn't think that you could flip the TE? I thought you could only change the run direction?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by Robbnva

the botton line is teams need to start bringing the FB, HB and TE over to the left side to block


I didn't think that you could flip the TE? I thought you could only change the run direction?


if TE is not primary receiver he can be pulled to block the left side.

works like this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=264581&pbp_id=738510
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by CoachBradley

Originally posted by Robbnva


the botton line is teams need to start bringing the FB, HB and TE over to the left side to block


I didn't think that you could flip the TE? I thought you could only change the run direction?


if TE is not primary receiver he can be pulled to block the left side.

works like this
Originally posted by Robbnva

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=264581&pbp_id=738510


the more I watch that play the more i fall in love with it. I never noticed the FB on the right side blocking also.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 10:23:55
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
if TE is not primary receiver he can be pulled to block the left side.

works like this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=264581&pbp_id=738510

the more I watch that play the more i fall in love with it. I never noticed the FB on the right side blocking also.


Ah, I see the setting now. Good deal.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
still bullshit
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.