Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I'm not trying to discourage your test. I'm trying to help you out by pointing out things that your test doesn't appear to be considering. If you'd like me to stop, I will do so - just say the word.
That's just it. This isn't really a test. This a basically a simple spread sheet that uses real numbers taken from actual players.
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Do you have actual examples of a specific roll at a specific position where training on Normal results in being able to hit the first cap 1-2 levels sooner?
no but using the data I have I could easily find some, for normal training. I've never seen a list of numbers laid out for intense training. Maybe that will be the next "test".
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I could possibly see this happening 1 level sooner, at most, and only in specific instances where 1 or 2 SP make the difference in being able to level up at level 3 or level 4 (this is a rare occurrence).
That "rare ocurrance" is what I am calling a magic number. For some players if they get thier initial roll high enough they could cap at least 1 level sooner, if they do focused training every day.
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
The part in an earlier post you made about assuming max XP is something I've thought about before but never spent much time on. When I was comparing build strategies I had to keep XP fixed across the strategies, otherwise the comparison would be bogus. For my own interest I ran the Intense vs Normal Comparison for a punter at 75% max XP, which results in a level 9 punter with 779 XP toward level 10. This run actually resulted in 2 additional SP for the Intense training player vs. the Normal training player. If you care you can view here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeUf1hD8Zve-dQ
Both finished with 80+% in their punting training bar, which will provide an additional 4 SP bonus when trained up during season 2.
The methodology is sound for a hypothetical experiment. What I am doing is taking 3 players with 3 different values of automatic progression (1, .67, .4) and showing what happens when normal training is used. While making this basic list I'm seeing trends, and getting ideas. I'm just passing on what I'm seeing.
For the long term, my basic premise is that by usuing normal training early certain players can hit thier cap at least 1 level sooner. Then they could switch attributes and hit that cap at least 1 level sooner. The switch again, and again as they see fit. Then after they've capped everything they want to cap, switch to intense training, and start collecting those free SPs from bonus tokens.
Given the fact that it takes 10 days to get 1 Free SP, then in theory if the player can make more than 1 SP by training on normal -- and then switch to intense training on or before Day 10 -- then they will have made a net profit.
This part of that greater expirement is just getting real data for comparison sake. Now in all fairness I didn't fully realize that is what I was doing when I started this. I was just tired of reading everyone else opinion on what at how to build as a player. I just wanted a data set to use to make my own decisions with instead of relying on some random jackhole who is spouting off what he "thinks" is the best thing to do, and may or may not have any kind of sound basis for that opinion. There are a lot of threads out there giving advice on how to build a player. There is a very small percentage of good threads out there, and it's really hard sometimes to get the good ones. Some players go so far as to spread misinformation so that they will be the ones with the advatage. The use realy neat looking charts and use big words to make it look and sound like they know what they are talking about.
That's why I wanted to do a simple list. If your attribute is X and you train on normal, you can expect Y. If you continue to train on normal, you can expect Z after a few days.
I'm not trying to discourage your test. I'm trying to help you out by pointing out things that your test doesn't appear to be considering. If you'd like me to stop, I will do so - just say the word.
That's just it. This isn't really a test. This a basically a simple spread sheet that uses real numbers taken from actual players.
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Do you have actual examples of a specific roll at a specific position where training on Normal results in being able to hit the first cap 1-2 levels sooner?
no but using the data I have I could easily find some, for normal training. I've never seen a list of numbers laid out for intense training. Maybe that will be the next "test".
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I could possibly see this happening 1 level sooner, at most, and only in specific instances where 1 or 2 SP make the difference in being able to level up at level 3 or level 4 (this is a rare occurrence).
That "rare ocurrance" is what I am calling a magic number. For some players if they get thier initial roll high enough they could cap at least 1 level sooner, if they do focused training every day.
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
The part in an earlier post you made about assuming max XP is something I've thought about before but never spent much time on. When I was comparing build strategies I had to keep XP fixed across the strategies, otherwise the comparison would be bogus. For my own interest I ran the Intense vs Normal Comparison for a punter at 75% max XP, which results in a level 9 punter with 779 XP toward level 10. This run actually resulted in 2 additional SP for the Intense training player vs. the Normal training player. If you care you can view here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeUf1hD8Zve-dQ
Both finished with 80+% in their punting training bar, which will provide an additional 4 SP bonus when trained up during season 2.
The methodology is sound for a hypothetical experiment. What I am doing is taking 3 players with 3 different values of automatic progression (1, .67, .4) and showing what happens when normal training is used. While making this basic list I'm seeing trends, and getting ideas. I'm just passing on what I'm seeing.
For the long term, my basic premise is that by usuing normal training early certain players can hit thier cap at least 1 level sooner. Then they could switch attributes and hit that cap at least 1 level sooner. The switch again, and again as they see fit. Then after they've capped everything they want to cap, switch to intense training, and start collecting those free SPs from bonus tokens.
Given the fact that it takes 10 days to get 1 Free SP, then in theory if the player can make more than 1 SP by training on normal -- and then switch to intense training on or before Day 10 -- then they will have made a net profit.
This part of that greater expirement is just getting real data for comparison sake. Now in all fairness I didn't fully realize that is what I was doing when I started this. I was just tired of reading everyone else opinion on what at how to build as a player. I just wanted a data set to use to make my own decisions with instead of relying on some random jackhole who is spouting off what he "thinks" is the best thing to do, and may or may not have any kind of sound basis for that opinion. There are a lot of threads out there giving advice on how to build a player. There is a very small percentage of good threads out there, and it's really hard sometimes to get the good ones. Some players go so far as to spread misinformation so that they will be the ones with the advatage. The use realy neat looking charts and use big words to make it look and sound like they know what they are talking about.
That's why I wanted to do a simple list. If your attribute is X and you train on normal, you can expect Y. If you continue to train on normal, you can expect Z after a few days.






























