User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > My slow build strategy good?
Page:
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I'm not trying to discourage your test. I'm trying to help you out by pointing out things that your test doesn't appear to be considering. If you'd like me to stop, I will do so - just say the word.

That's just it. This isn't really a test. This a basically a simple spread sheet that uses real numbers taken from actual players.

Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Do you have actual examples of a specific roll at a specific position where training on Normal results in being able to hit the first cap 1-2 levels sooner?

no but using the data I have I could easily find some, for normal training. I've never seen a list of numbers laid out for intense training. Maybe that will be the next "test".

Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I could possibly see this happening 1 level sooner, at most, and only in specific instances where 1 or 2 SP make the difference in being able to level up at level 3 or level 4 (this is a rare occurrence).

That "rare ocurrance" is what I am calling a magic number. For some players if they get thier initial roll high enough they could cap at least 1 level sooner, if they do focused training every day.

Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
The part in an earlier post you made about assuming max XP is something I've thought about before but never spent much time on. When I was comparing build strategies I had to keep XP fixed across the strategies, otherwise the comparison would be bogus. For my own interest I ran the Intense vs Normal Comparison for a punter at 75% max XP, which results in a level 9 punter with 779 XP toward level 10. This run actually resulted in 2 additional SP for the Intense training player vs. the Normal training player. If you care you can view here:

http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeUf1hD8Zve-dQ

Both finished with 80+% in their punting training bar, which will provide an additional 4 SP bonus when trained up during season 2.


The methodology is sound for a hypothetical experiment. What I am doing is taking 3 players with 3 different values of automatic progression (1, .67, .4) and showing what happens when normal training is used. While making this basic list I'm seeing trends, and getting ideas. I'm just passing on what I'm seeing.

For the long term, my basic premise is that by usuing normal training early certain players can hit thier cap at least 1 level sooner. Then they could switch attributes and hit that cap at least 1 level sooner. The switch again, and again as they see fit. Then after they've capped everything they want to cap, switch to intense training, and start collecting those free SPs from bonus tokens.

Given the fact that it takes 10 days to get 1 Free SP, then in theory if the player can make more than 1 SP by training on normal -- and then switch to intense training on or before Day 10 -- then they will have made a net profit.

This part of that greater expirement is just getting real data for comparison sake. Now in all fairness I didn't fully realize that is what I was doing when I started this. I was just tired of reading everyone else opinion on what at how to build as a player. I just wanted a data set to use to make my own decisions with instead of relying on some random jackhole who is spouting off what he "thinks" is the best thing to do, and may or may not have any kind of sound basis for that opinion. There are a lot of threads out there giving advice on how to build a player. There is a very small percentage of good threads out there, and it's really hard sometimes to get the good ones. Some players go so far as to spread misinformation so that they will be the ones with the advatage. The use realy neat looking charts and use big words to make it look and sound like they know what they are talking about.

That's why I wanted to do a simple list. If your attribute is X and you train on normal, you can expect Y. If you continue to train on normal, you can expect Z after a few days.



 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes

Given the fact that it takes 10 days to get 1 Free SP, then in theory if the player can make more than 1 SP by training on normal -- and then switch to intense training on or before Day 10 -- then they will have made a net profit.


Yes, but this is an oversimplification.

Everything else equal, Intense Training w/ turning in Bonus Tokens provides more overall SPs than Normal Training - I assume you know this.

So, the only way Normal Training will beat Intense Training is if hitting the softcap X number of levels earlier provides more SPs from level bonus than the SP advantage of Intense Training. I think you'll be hard-pressed to find an example where this is the case.

Also, remember that capping one level earlier doesn't necessarily buy you anything. In some cases capping 2 levels earlier may not actually buy you anything from the level bonus (consider a CB who caps speed at 48.33 at level 4 vs capping speed at 48.99 @ level 6).

 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Originally posted by TJ Spikes


Given the fact that it takes 10 days to get 1 Free SP, then in theory if the player can make more than 1 SP by training on normal -- and then switch to intense training on or before Day 10 -- then they will have made a net profit.


Yes, but this is an oversimplification.

Everything else equal, Intense Training w/ turning in Bonus Tokens provides more overall SPs than Normal Training - I assume you know this.

So, the only way Normal Training will beat Intense Training is if hitting the softcap X number of levels earlier provides more SPs from level bonus than the SP advantage of Intense Training. I think you'll be hard-pressed to find an example where this is the case.

Also, remember that capping one level earlier doesn't necessarily buy you anything. In some cases capping 2 levels earlier may not actually buy you anything from the level bonus (consider a CB who caps speed at 48.33 at level 4 vs capping speed at 48.99 @ level 6).



again there are the obvious examples of the P, K and C. They get 1 attribute point per level for their primary attributes. that is effectively 1 SP each. Every time the player hits a cap sooner they save SPs. That's part of the reason why I chose 3 different positions. All have similar design philosophies, but their bonus attributes are different 1, .67, and .4 respectively.

and for the record, no I don't "know" that intense training will always net more SPs for the player. I assume it does just because it costs 3 times as much as normal training. In theory it should provide 3 times the benefit, however...
1) no one has ever made a list of attribute numbers and the amount of training gained
2) even if the training itself grants more SPs, capping attributes sooner also nets effective SPs and they may or may not outweigh the gains of training alone.
3) I have a hunch that judicious use of normal training could provide benefits to certain players at certain times... but again that is just a hunch

I'm not sure why you come across as so confrontational. I'm making a list (or spread sheet if you will) of attributes and training that's it. Any notes at the bottom are pure conjecture or personal observations or sometimes random babbling about taking over the world. It always sounds to me like you're trying to talk me out of doing this simple project or something.

I fully understand you spent a great deal of time developing your spread sheet, but I'm not trying to predict a player's growth over the course a season. All I am doing is stating that if your attribute is X and you train on normal you can expect Y gain. Any theories about magic numbers or extra SPs are just conjecture. I don't have enough data to say anything for sure. Maybe that will be the next project -- make the list of intense training values. If it turns out that normal training is pointless to do then so be it.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 23:09:31
 
LTearnhardt
offline
Link
 
can someone make a chart for me to slow build a HB? that would be helpful
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Honestly, TJ, I'm not trying to be confrontational. You were the one who initially started challenging my conclusions. I challenged those assertions on page 5 by pointing out specific responses of yours that were misrepresenting my data. Not one time did I respond to a post about your numbers, I solely responded to posts you directed at mine.

Things like this from page 5:

Originally posted by TJ Spikes
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma


Also, we'll have to agree to disagree on the normal vs intense training. The numbers I've run result in more overall SPs resulting from Intense training, which really is the goal of slow building.


well I know for a fact that for P, K and OC it most likely makes more sense to train on normal.

Normal train will probably result in hitting the cap a couple of levels sooner. Like My OC is set to hit it at L3 where as yours did it at 5. So that means for those 2 levels I'll be getting an extra point each. If I choose (haven't really decided yet) to go for the 60 cap, I could do it at L7 compared to yours doing it at L8. So by doing it one level sooner that's 2 points gained over yours--for a total of 4. That makes up for the 4 SP gained in a season with bonus tokens.


I tried to live and let live, and you came back at me with your "facts". When I called you on them you decided I was trying to challenge your data or what you were doing. I was and still am not. I'm defending my position on Normal vs. Intense, and trying to help keep "facts" separated from conjecture.

To address your above post, while Intense training does cost 3X as much per train you can only do it 40% as often. So the net additional cost for intense is 20%, not 300%; which is almost exactly how much more net SP you gain training on intense & turning in bonus tokens.

Speaking of, as proof suppose two players, both with str/blk at 21

In 10 days worth of normal training (no activity - 10 normal "trains"), you can get Str to ~24.62, blk 21 (yield ~362%)
In 10 days worth of intense training (4 intense "trains") you can get str to ~22.74, blk to ~22.74 + 1 SP (yield ~448%)

This is not conjecture. It is based on how Normal and Intense training actually works. Your actual numbers may be a few percent different due to randomness, but not by more than 5% or so either way.


Lastly, I'm done arguing about this and I'm sorry if I offended you. I will reiterate that I was not trying to keep you from working your numbers. I was simply responding to being called out.

Anyone who wishes to have more detail about how I come up with my numbers feel free to PM me. I will be happy to answer any specific questions, and I encourage you to figure out what's best for yourself, don't simply assume someone else knows what they're talking about.
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 17:26:29
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
sorry about the lack of daily update yesterday, i littlerally got poked in the eye with a piar of plyers. at any rate I'll be deleting these players and starting over with new ones. this time I'll do the same exact expirement only with intense training.

Right now I have a list of training from attributes at 16 all the way up to 24. I might keep one of these players around so I can expand that range... maybe 14 to 24 -- since that seems to be the normal range for player rolls on major attributes.

Then I'll put the two lists together side by side. From there, maybe I'll throw out another thread with some of my "magic number" theory.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Speaking of, as proof suppose two players, both with str/blk at 21

In 10 days worth of normal training (no activity - 10 normal "trains"), you can get Str to ~24.62, blk 21 (yield ~362%)
In 10 days worth of intense training (4 intense "trains") you can get str to ~22.74, blk to ~22.74 + 1 SP (yield ~448%)


again you are going outside of the scope of my current project. but here's the problems I have

1) You never gave any sort of citation for your spread sheet (or any of the numbers you throw out) and in no way explained where the numbers came from when you posted it in this thread. For all anyone knows it was a purely mathematical projection. -- What I am attempting to do is give everyone the tools to judge for themselves the credibility of your or anyone else's work on this subject, using real numbers that the players can easily verify for themselves.

2) You are using basic assumptions that just seem to be totally against what I'm trying to do. I fully realize that in your specific example above that intense training is the obvious winner. But I'm also not advocating that everyone always train every attribute on normal, which is the conclusion your example begs.

I'm thinking more like: a player has 21.67 Str, 21.67 block. He's L3 and has 3 training days before he hits L4. If he's 87% of the way complete with his Strength, could he push his strength up to 23.67, before hitting L4 so that when he does he'll be able to cap his Strength so that he'll be able to take advantage of the free Auto advancement points for his position. Will he be able to do it on intense? or should he go down to normal? will it do any good either way? will there be an advantage gained either way? This is what I'm talking about with magic numbers. This is why I want charts of attributes with their associated training gains.

The basic assumption is: yes intense traing is better for players to do. It costs more so it obviously should be. However the exception to that rule is that there may be times when a short stint of normal training, may provide benefits that outway the gains of the advanced training. This again gets back to the magic numbers thing to see when and how long those short stints are -- maybe 2 days, maybe 5, depending on the exact situation.
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
This thread has been very helpful so far. Thanks for the info.

Just curious though, lets say I want a WR that has 100 speed (with gear) and 2nd capped agility long term. Should I take speed to the 2nd or 3rd softcap before starting agility (training agility and some other attribute the entire time) or should I softcap both then continue with speed?

I'm hoping to be on a level 13 capped team in a season in a half, so I can't be a crap player then. I'm expecting to soft cap speed, then agil, then go back to speed but if I'd be better to stick to speed I'll go that route.

Thanks.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by satandole666
This thread has been very helpful so far. Thanks for the info.

Just curious though, lets say I want a WR that has 100 speed (with gear) and 2nd capped agility long term. Should I take speed to the 2nd or 3rd softcap before starting agility (training agility and some other attribute the entire time) or should I softcap both then continue with speed?

I'm hoping to be on a level 13 capped team in a season in a half, so I can't be a crap player then. I'm expecting to soft cap speed, then agil, then go back to speed but if I'd be better to stick to speed I'll go that route.

Thanks.


If you softcap Speed first, then go to agility, and move back to speed, you'll hit 100 easy.
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
Originally posted by satandole666

This thread has been very helpful so far. Thanks for the info.

Just curious though, lets say I want a WR that has 100 speed (with gear) and 2nd capped agility long term. Should I take speed to the 2nd or 3rd softcap before starting agility (training agility and some other attribute the entire time) or should I softcap both then continue with speed?

I'm hoping to be on a level 13 capped team in a season in a half, so I can't be a crap player then. I'm expecting to soft cap speed, then agil, then go back to speed but if I'd be better to stick to speed I'll go that route.

Thanks.


If you softcap Speed first, then go to agility, and move back to speed, you'll hit 100 easy.


Not sure if this is what you meant, but I'd try to never train an attribute that's had points put into it.
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
Nah, I was talking about training agility then entire time I pushed speed to the 2nd or 3rd cap. I think I've figured out a good routine for now.

Train Speed+Agil
Softcap Speed ASAP
Train Agil+Vision (no better combo)
Softcap Agil ASAP
Train Vision+Catching for a long while
2nd Cap Speed
Then either 3rd Cap speed or 2nd cap agil

At some point I'll need to drop some points in stamina to start but that'll probably be done when I boost. I could switch to agil/stam if I decide I can get away with stamina without SP cost. I'll figure out if I'm going to go balls out on speed depending on how he performs with 2nd cap speed 1st cap agil (I should be on a lvl 13 capped team by then).
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by satandole666
This thread has been very helpful so far. Thanks for the info.

Just curious though, lets say I want a WR that has 100 speed (with gear) and 2nd capped agility long term. Should I take speed to the 2nd or 3rd softcap before starting agility (training agility and some other attribute the entire time) or should I softcap both then continue with speed?

I'm hoping to be on a level 13 capped team in a season in a half, so I can't be a crap player then. I'm expecting to soft cap speed, then agil, then go back to speed but if I'd be better to stick to speed I'll go that route.

Thanks.


100 is a pretty lofty goal, depending on how much of your equipment you want to devote to Speed. If you get the Custom EQ at +6, and say L40 Equipment at +6 each, that could be a +30 to Speed. Which (of course) is only 70 points away from your goal. Given that the 3rd cap is at 68, it's pretty easy to get to 100 if you go that route and you could easily afford to cap agility. However, if you ever plan on getting some advanced equipment, that could cut into your +speed bonus. If you can only get say +20 Speed from equipment, then you might just want to go all Speed early on. And of course if you plan on hanging around long enough, the default answer is: it doesn't matter. By the 10 season mark, you could pretty much have whatever stats you want.



 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
Yeah...I realize 100 is a lot but I've watched some replays of a few receivers who have 100+ speed and I was very impressed with it. I probably won't touch AEQ for a long while (not until I have catching, vision, confidence soft capped) as I'd rather have the SPs. That and I didn't join up to item whore, heh. So yeah, I'll probably go to the 3rd soft cap and let items do the rest.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Ok, so I kept my OG so I can expand the normal training list. So I'll be posting those numbers first every day (hopefully). Then I rolled 3 new O-linemen for the Intense training lists.

Here they are

http://img171.imageshack.us/my.php?image=74651080gx0.jpg
Almost perfect for an OC roll, pretty good size too. I might end up keeping him just because. I won't even have to train Strength to cap it at L3 -- that is insane-o.

http://img171.imageshack.us/my.php?image=98190260ns6.jpg
A fairly decent roll for an OG. I probably could have done better, but he'll do for the purpose of the study.

http://img171.imageshack.us/my.php?image=37070521as5.jpg
Pretty good roll for an OT. Was kind of looking for a high Agility, and got the decent Strength as a bonus. He's a little small, but he'll do.

===

OG1 - Agi 10.75, 0% complete, 56% gain => Agi 10.75, 56% complete
------- Agi 10.75, 56% complete, 56% gain => Agi 11.75, 12% complete (2 days worth of training points)

===

OC - Block 20, 0% complete, 47% gain => Block 20, 47% complete
------ Agility 10, 0% complete, 69% gain => Agility 10, 69% complete

OG - Block 17, 0% complete, 53% gain => Block 17, 53% complete
------ Strength 18, 0% complete, 49% gain => Strength 18, 49% complete

OT - Block 12, 0% complete, 62% gain => Block 12, 62% complete
------ Strength 18, 0% complete, 50% gain => Strength 18, 50% complete


===

Ok, so that was the first batch of intense training. I just noticed that I have 2 players with the same strength, but I guess that's cool because we'll be able to see how many times they get different amounts of training in, and got 1 difference aready (a whopping 1%) so maybe that will give us some kind of idea on the margin of error for this data set. Also noticed that contract money is a bit random, and I never noticed that before. I've had players with $300, $350 and now $400 for daily salary. And lastly, my OT got kind of poor contract choices, there were no teams with empty starting slots for him. So his XP is probably going to be way off. However that might not be such a bad thing, because part of this data set is to track XP differences between the last set on normal training (with 14 Stam because of gear) and this set with just base 10 Stam.
Last edited Nov 20, 2008 21:14:59
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - 11.75, 12% complete, Actual gain 54% => Agi 11.75, 66% complete

===

one other drawback of Intense traing... bordom on the off days
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.