User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa


Exactly! There needs to be a 3rd HB slot.. the General "HB" Slot should be a basic DEPTH chart for RBS


It is...


There is an option for HB, HB1, HB2

If you use 3 HB's and want them to be in specialized situations you CANNOT have all 3 of them in specialized situation without only having 1 HB on your DEPTH CHART and 1 HB in each of the SPECIALIZED slots. In AI you have to choose HB, HB1, HB2 SO you will have to select an exact RB for every single situation in AI. There is no way to have all 3 of your RBs in the DEPTH CHART and also all 3 on SPECIALIZED slots

Thus needs a HB3
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 02:04:17
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa

There is an option for HB, HB1, HB2

If you use 3 HB's and want them to be in specialized situations you CANNOT have all 3 of them in specialized situation without only having 1 HB on your DEPTH CHART and 1 HB in each of the SPECIALIZED slots. In AI you have to choose HB, HB1, HB2 SO you will have to select an exact RB for every single situation in AI. There is no way to have all 3 of your RBs in the DEPTH CHART and also all 3 on SPECIALIZED slots


If you have 3 very specialized HB's, do you actually want them to be in the same depth chart and rotating?

You can have a speed HB, a receiving HB, and a power HB...what else do you want? You can theoretically make 3 specialized slots by making the general slot only one deep. However, WHY would you need 3 specialized slots, AND a general slot? Use the HB that fits the situation the best.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
I agree with Deathblade.
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa


There is an option for HB, HB1, HB2

If you use 3 HB's and want them to be in specialized situations you CANNOT have all 3 of them in specialized situation without only having 1 HB on your DEPTH CHART and 1 HB in each of the SPECIALIZED slots. In AI you have to choose HB, HB1, HB2 SO you will have to select an exact RB for every single situation in AI. There is no way to have all 3 of your RBs in the DEPTH CHART and also all 3 on SPECIALIZED slots


If you have 3 very specialized HB's, do you actually want them to be in the same depth chart and rotating?

You can have a speed HB, a receiving HB, and a power HB...what else do you want? You can theoretically make 3 specialized slots by making the general slot only one deep. However, WHY would you need 3 specialized slots, AND a general slot? Use the HB that fits the situation the best.


On the AI...

HB (Rotates out the 3 based on energy)
HB1- For plays you want hb1 to run
HB2- For plays you want hb2 to run
HB3- For plays you want hb3 to run
 
James Murphy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah
I agree with Deathblade.


 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
DB was absolutely right you don't need 3 specialized slots and a general slot. If you think otherwise you are out yo mind.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa



There is an option for HB, HB1, HB2

If you use 3 HB's and want them to be in specialized situations you CANNOT have all 3 of them in specialized situation without only having 1 HB on your DEPTH CHART and 1 HB in each of the SPECIALIZED slots. In AI you have to choose HB, HB1, HB2 SO you will have to select an exact RB for every single situation in AI. There is no way to have all 3 of your RBs in the DEPTH CHART and also all 3 on SPECIALIZED slots


If you have 3 very specialized HB's, do you actually want them to be in the same depth chart and rotating?

You can have a speed HB, a receiving HB, and a power HB...what else do you want? You can theoretically make 3 specialized slots by making the general slot only one deep. However, WHY would you need 3 specialized slots, AND a general slot? Use the HB that fits the situation the best.


On the AI...

HB (Rotates out the 3 based on energy)
HB1- For plays you want hb1 to run
HB2- For plays you want hb2 to run
HB3- For plays you want hb3 to run


You do realize that there's essentially no difference in the 3 existing slots, right? All 3 rotate according to energy settings, if you have multiple players in the slot.

If setting the HB on each output is too much for you, why do you want a 3rd slot? You already have the tools to do exactly what you're asking for.

I plan on using the slots for exactly what you're asking for, and it's obvious that it can be done with no problems.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa

On the AI...

HB (Rotates out the 3 based on energy)
HB1- For plays you want hb1 to run
HB2- For plays you want hb2 to run
HB3- For plays you want hb3 to run


If you need the 3 specialized spots...is there any situation where you will want them rotating based on energy? If there's three specialized slots, which there can be now, you have powerback covered for inside runs and short yardage, speed back for outside runs, and a passing back for passing plays.

Play them in their relevant situation? I mean, Bort can probably add it with a couple lines of code changed, but really, I don't see how it is needed, and the current set up can work just fine in pretty much any situation that I can think of.
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa


On the AI...

HB (Rotates out the 3 based on energy)
HB1- For plays you want hb1 to run
HB2- For plays you want hb2 to run
HB3- For plays you want hb3 to run


If you need the 3 specialized spots...is there any situation where you will want them rotating based on energy? If there's three specialized slots, which there can be now, you have powerback covered for inside runs and short yardage, speed back for outside runs, and a passing back for passing plays.

Play them in their relevant situation? I mean, Bort can probably add it with a couple lines of code changed, but really, I don't see how it is needed, and the current set up can work just fine in pretty much any situation that I can think of.


Yes I want them to rotate most of the time. But i also want the option to pick which of the 3 HBS i want in a situation. Right now there is no way to do it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
No 'Single Back Big' plays anymore Bort?


There was only 1 before, and I didn't get around to adding more to it, so I took it out for now. I plan to keep expanding the play selection, though, so it'll come back!
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Thanks. Apologies for interrupting the RB1-3 dispute. Carry on.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
DB is like god in this thread, he is infallible.
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
No he just doesnt realize what i want to use it for
 
James Murphy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah
DB is god


The hidden message imo. Yes god is in fact a vampire
 
Link
 
I agree now looking at the DC it is easy. You can divide 3 HB among the three different spots on the DC, or you could put everyone on your RB DC and then your Lightning guy at RB1 and Thunder RB2.

However, We definitely need a QB 1 slot. LEts say you run a 2 QB system and your recruit a Running QB as your third QB.

your Normal QB's will be in the QB depth chart, your Specialize running QB will be in the QB 1 slot. That way when you do a QB run play, you could specify QB1 and know your Running QB is getting the ball.

Conversely, you will also know that your 2 normal Pocket passer's (think Drew Bledsoe) will NOT Be running the play. Would also keep from people exploiting the QB1 slot by trying to put a FB or HB in to block on a QB sweep run.

Bort: Please consider putting a QB 1 slot, no need for 2 like the others, But certainly there is a need in a QB 1 slot.

Thanks
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.