User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort, This Looks Like HorseCrap To Me
Page:
 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS
Originally posted by Kutzy

Im not necessarily saying its a bug, but looking for an exact cause to the exploit. Noone can actually fully explain that outside of the Devs. This is why certain things need to be looked at and explained. It looks really weird to have your dude running in circles until the WR catches the ball. Anytype of REAL explination would be better than 10 different guys giving 10 different opinions.


Listing potential causes of the problem is not giving different opinions, rather than exluding them as possible problems. It is known that low vision, confidence, etc. could be a cause of the problem. The player stating what those particular attributes are just helps to figure out where the problem lies. I'm sure that there have been more similar problems, so I do agree that an explanation from a Dev. would be very helpful.


But which one applies here? Which one applies to each situation? He has low speed vs. WR #1, Low Confidence vs. WR #2, and Low Kicking for WR #3? But yet every single one applies to the same exact "circle running" pattern by the CB? There are mismatches in every situation, but I doubt every mismatch produces the same result 6 or more times in a game.
 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whoshotjr
One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.



Hes going for the INT..I tell him to stop that shit but he can do what he wants..Its his team.. But now we are talking apples to oranges.
 
Swiftus
offline
Link
 
^^^ its like his head was turned the wrong way or something and by the time he turned back, it was all over.
 
Onyxgem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Onyxgem,

First, let me say that judging by the regular season game against Wasaga Beach Crash, I can see why this comes as a shock. In your regular season game, you shut them down 29-0. And held their WR's to 83 yards total.

So why 10 games later did they throw for 445 yards and 4 TD's?

Frankly I would say that it is a good and valid question.

I have been looking over the game tape for Clyde in this game in particular, but other games as well. I think I have come up with some factors that went into it.

In the first game, Wasaga Beach only threw to the right side(Clyde Armstrong's) a handfull of times, one of which was a 23 yard gain that looked quite similar to the playoff game plays you have posted.

The Wasaga Beach QB had the best game of his entire season in your playoff game, I think it is a safe bet that he boosted for the game.

In the playoff game it looks like Clyde had virtualy no safety support. The SS was either covering the TE or running under the coverage. Clyde was in single coverage even when he was supposed to have over the top coverage support.

In the plays you posted there were 2 where it looks like the reciever was covered and he just made a play on the ball. The other 3(and a few from other games I watched) Clyde was way off of the reciever just after the reciever made a cut. Is it possible that the recievers had an Agility advantage and could maintain their speed through the cut when Clyde couldn't? Or possibly as others had mentioned before Clyde got fooled by a very good head/pump fake combo?

Having said all that, I still share your puzzlement. In going from a regular season shutout to a blowout loss in the Playoffs, In going from Clyde being a virtual shutdown CB in the regular season to being a 4th string D-League CB in the playoffs... something has got to give.

Sure everyone can have an off game, but players who are historicaly among the best players on your team, and even in your league should not have swings this great in performace. Just my opinion.



Actually their QB had boosted well before this game...

But I understand what you are saying the rest of it, in all honestly the loss is now what I am even upset about, it is how it was pretty much the fault of one player who had been a shut down guy gets totally lit up for well over 350 yards passing...
 
HSKRCHMPS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS

Originally posted by Kutzy


Im not necessarily saying its a bug, but looking for an exact cause to the exploit. Noone can actually fully explain that outside of the Devs. This is why certain things need to be looked at and explained. It looks really weird to have your dude running in circles until the WR catches the ball. Anytype of REAL explination would be better than 10 different guys giving 10 different opinions.


Listing potential causes of the problem is not giving different opinions, rather than exluding them as possible problems. It is known that low vision, confidence, etc. could be a cause of the problem. The player stating what those particular attributes are just helps to figure out where the problem lies. I'm sure that there have been more similar problems, so I do agree that an explanation from a Dev. would be very helpful.


But which one applies here? Which one applies to each situation? He has low speed vs. WR #1, Low Confidence vs. WR #2, and Low Kicking for WR #3? But yet every single one applies to the same exact "circle running" pattern by the CB? There are mismatches in every situation, but I doubt every mismatch produces the same result 6 or more times in a game.

I see what you're saying, that it seems odd that multiple players are having this kind of game against him. My thinking was that if his player attributes were around where they should be, that would just make it possibly a little bit easier to figure out if this were a bug or a problem with his build. Maybe it's like somebody else said too, that he's trying to cover a WR with super high agility.
 
HSKRCHMPS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer
Originally posted by whoshotjr

One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.



Hes going for the INT..I tell him to stop that shit but he can do what he wants..Its his team.. But now we are talking apples to oranges.


I tell all of my players not to go for the pick, unless we are playing somebody we know we can beat. Too many big plays can happen. I thought it looked like he may have gone for a pick, but it was hard to tell whether it was that or a fake made by the WR or QB.
 
Onyxgem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS
Originally posted by Kutzy

Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS


Originally posted by Kutzy



Im not necessarily saying its a bug, but looking for an exact cause to the exploit. Noone can actually fully explain that outside of the Devs. This is why certain things need to be looked at and explained. It looks really weird to have your dude running in circles until the WR catches the ball. Anytype of REAL explination would be better than 10 different guys giving 10 different opinions.


Listing potential causes of the problem is not giving different opinions, rather than exluding them as possible problems. It is known that low vision, confidence, etc. could be a cause of the problem. The player stating what those particular attributes are just helps to figure out where the problem lies. I'm sure that there have been more similar problems, so I do agree that an explanation from a Dev. would be very helpful.


But which one applies here? Which one applies to each situation? He has low speed vs. WR #1, Low Confidence vs. WR #2, and Low Kicking for WR #3? But yet every single one applies to the same exact "circle running" pattern by the CB? There are mismatches in every situation, but I doubt every mismatch produces the same result 6 or more times in a game.


I see what you're saying, that it seems odd that multiple players are having this kind of game against him. My thinking was that if his player attributes were around where they should be, that would just make it possibly a little bit easier to figure out if this were a bug or a problem with his build. Maybe it's like somebody else said too, that he's trying to cover a WR with super high agility.

My speed is higher than my agi, my agi is around 60 speed well over 80...vison over 50....i don't just only have super high agi and no speed.
 
Onyxgem
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS
Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer

Originally posted by whoshotjr


One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.



Hes going for the INT..I tell him to stop that shit but he can do what he wants..Its his team.. But now we are talking apples to oranges.


I tell all of my players not to go for the pick, unless we are playing somebody we know we can beat. Too many big plays can happen. I thought it looked like he may have gone for a pick, but it was hard to tell whether it was that or a fake made by the WR or QB.


My guy only went for pick with help over the top except a couple cake games we had...
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS

I wish this were true, or at least that Bort would confirm it to be true. It would explain alot of different factors in the post season. However, Bort maintains that this is not true and that the sims work as the previous 16 games did. There is BS written all over that theory.

Agree with you their Kutzy! Everything seems to be nerfed in the playoffs! We have dominated teams in the regular season, but turn around and get our asses handed to us the first game of the playoffs.


I could have swore Bort mentioned the engine doesn't change, but "pressure" does?
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS
Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer

Originally posted by whoshotjr


One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.



Hes going for the INT..I tell him to stop that shit but he can do what he wants..Its his team.. But now we are talking apples to oranges.


I tell all of my players not to go for the pick, unless we are playing somebody we know we can beat. Too many big plays can happen. I thought it looked like he may have gone for a pick, but it was hard to tell whether it was that or a fake made by the WR or QB.


To be honest, that play seems to be a bitch to defend. I know I had a game earlier this year where my guy had 4 consecutive PDs on that play. On the 5th one he was in the same position, lost the roll and gave up a TD.
 
HSKRCHMPS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whoshotjr
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS

Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer


Originally posted by whoshotjr



One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.



Hes going for the INT..I tell him to stop that shit but he can do what he wants..Its his team.. But now we are talking apples to oranges.


I tell all of my players not to go for the pick, unless we are playing somebody we know we can beat. Too many big plays can happen. I thought it looked like he may have gone for a pick, but it was hard to tell whether it was that or a fake made by the WR or QB.


To be honest, that play seems to be a bitch to defend. I know I had a game earlier this year where my guy had 4 consecutive PDs on that play. On the 5th one he was in the same position, lost the roll and gave up a TD.


We've had the same happen to us. Koncorde, I know Bort said the sim engine is the same, but since I bought my team season 1, regular season games and playoff games tend to play out much differently!
 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS
Originally posted by whoshotjr

Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS


Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer



Originally posted by whoshotjr




One other thing it could be that your opponent benefited from the the extra "tick" to get rid of phantom incompletions. I didn't look through your whole regular season game, but noticed this in the first series:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154117&pbp_id=5037247 - Could have been a TD early on which may have changed the complexion of the game.



Hes going for the INT..I tell him to stop that shit but he can do what he wants..Its his team.. But now we are talking apples to oranges.


I tell all of my players not to go for the pick, unless we are playing somebody we know we can beat. Too many big plays can happen. I thought it looked like he may have gone for a pick, but it was hard to tell whether it was that or a fake made by the WR or QB.


To be honest, that play seems to be a bitch to defend. I know I had a game earlier this year where my guy had 4 consecutive PDs on that play. On the 5th one he was in the same position, lost the roll and gave up a TD.


We've had the same happen to us. Koncorde, I know Bort said the sim engine is the same, but since I bought my team season 1, regular season games and playoff games tend to play out much differently!


Most of the time I will lose the role in the 3rd. But get it back before the end of that quarter. Our first playoff game we lost the role in the middle of the 1st quarter. But got it back in the 2nd half..That was a strange game also.
 
Link
 
Here's your answer. Please disregard the random reasons given above.

1) Your Agility is 20-30 points below your speed. The ability to accelerate/decelerate and cut is governed by agility, and the faster you're going the more agility you need to be truly agile and mobile. The ratio of speed:agility (along with vision) is crucial for maintaining good coverage. Your ratio isn't too good.

2) The WRs on the plays look like they're playing very well, giving you a high mark to meet.

3) If the WRs have a speed:agility ratio closer to 1:1, you're going to have a difficult time covering them when they make a cut on their route. They're going to cut and your CB isn't going to be good enough to stick with him.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 15:22:24
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Here's your answer. Please disregard the random reasons given above.

1) Your Agility is 20-30 points below your speed. The ability to accelerate/decelerate and cut is governed by agility, and the faster you're going the more agility you need to be truly agile and mobile. The ratio of speed:agility (along with vision) is crucial for maintaining good coverage. Your ratio isn't too good.

2) The WRs on the plays look like they're playing very well, giving you a high mark to meet.

3) If the WRs have a speed:agility ratio closer to 1:1, you're going to have a difficult time covering them when they make a cut on their route. They're going to cut and your CB isn't going to be good enough to stick with him.


This is the correct answer. If the DC doesn't want his CBs to trade in Speed for Agility, then he needs to think of different schemes to defend the underneath quick cut routes.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Kutzy


Confidence at 50 will mean you lack in other aspects of your build.

While "low confidence" is an easy cop out, why did it never happen before this game?


Could just be on the wrong end of some bad luck. We have discussed the whole "snowballing" effect that happens sometimes with confidence. Maybe he was just lucky it didn't happen before (or unlucky as it might have exposed the flaw).


I am sure that the snowball effect had a bit to do with it, but if Clyde had a flaw in his build, shouldn't it have shown up on one of the 16 regular season games?



Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.